Here's the thing, I didn't realize the cream cheese was Jalapeño cream cheese and it had bite. I ordered (I believe) the Sailor, lov, cream cheese and capers on a rainbow bagel toasted to perfection. After two bites of the too spicy bagel, I returned to the shoppe. Both the sandwich maker and the attendant at the register were pleasant and accommodating. They replaced the bagel with a milder scallion bacon cream cheese and the sandwich was both palatable and yummy. There is limited seating and no public restroom. Breakfast bagels are served before 3pm. Bonus tip: This store is a part of the "Too good to go" initiative. Toward the end of the day 1/2 dozen randomly bagged bagels in-store are $3.99. Nearby: Ample Hills, Grand Army Plaza read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Bagels tasted kind of dense and stale. The scallion cream cheese was pretty mid. Thought it was pretty expensive for the quality. Took a while to get my bagel because there was a long line. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered Olde as delivery, and it sounds like it would be faster than waiting at the actual brick and mortar. I got an everything with lox, and they were pretty generous with the filling, but the bagel had too much of a chew to it. Not a bad spot, especially if getting a loaded sandwich. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great little bagel shop. Very quick with your orders! Was with a group of friends who have been here before and loved it, so we made a point of stopping by before we headed back out of town! read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - ATW Lox Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Waste of time and money. Not only is it the laziest staff known to man, I decided to give this another try after two years and somehow the experience was worse than the first. Didn't think I could have two bad experiences with that much time between the two, but they defy the odds every step of the way. Go elsewhere, even if it's out the way. read more

Was in the neighborhood and saw a sign for za'atar bagels. So I had to come in. Seemed like a real local bagel joint. I wanted a dozen of the Za'atar but had to settle for 4. Next time I will get here earlier. Solid choices for bagels and sandwiches. Got home and had a Za'atar bagel which was excellent. Definitely coming back soon. read more

Surprised i havent reviewed this place yet?? Its my go to in my neighborhood and i have had many a bagel from here. Will an NY bagel ever compare to an NJ one.... That i cannot answer. But i am a huge fan of the spread of vegan cream cheeses they have and think the bagels themselves r fab, def the best in the nearby vicinity - and clearly i'm picky!!! Love my freak vegan sausage and vegan strawb cream cheese on a cin raisin bagel read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I went there and ordered a breakfast sandwich and told them twice no mayonnaise since I'm allergic. They put so much mayonnaise on it it looked like cream cheese. I drove 20 minutes back to eat it when I realized. I can't get back to return it because the West Indian day parade has everything closed so now I'm stuck with a 21 dollar mayonnaise bagel that's going in the garbage read more

This place should definitely be higher rated on Yelp. I wouldn't give it 5 stars because the bagel isn't one of the best in the city but it's still great! Very happy I came here and I'd definitely say it's one of the best in the prospect heights/park slope area. Got the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, cucumbers, and tomato and it really got the spot. Great chew on the bagel, perfect ratio of cream cheese, and very fresh. Not overpriced either. My partner got one of the breakfast sandwiches and also really liked it. Everyone who works there is also really friendly. Great drink (and random snack) selection too. Would definitely recommend! read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Still great bagels! But with fun cream cheeses...apple cinnamon...omg! With turkey bacon. I know a lil weird. Same good decaf coffee. Yes, I drink decaf and I'm just happy they have it. They still write your order down, but the biggest development is.... they take CARDS!!!! Years in the making. I know I'm a few mins late to the party, but I was exploring a few others spots. Today I had cash money and I was prepared to use it, but didn't have too. See ya around old friend! read more

ordered a scallion cream cheese bagel with light cream cheese but when i tell you there was next to no cream cheese on the bagel i'm not joking, it kinda feels like a prank... I know i asked for less but they really screwed the pouch, the bagel was literally dry!I will not be returning this place seems like a bagel pub rip off anyways read more

Ordered: Zaatar Bagel with Zaatar Cream Cheese (~$6) with tomato (75¢) and cucumber (75¢) - toasted & scooped out Aya's take: Being Middle Eastern, I was shocked that I had never heard of this place considering this is the Home of the Zaa'tar Bagel! They were pretty busy considering it was 11am on a Sunday but we were in & out in 15 minutes. The Zaatar Bagel was quite dry and you get that aromatic, earthy, and slightly woody flavor from the zaatar on top. For some reason, the Zaatar Cream Cheese had an essence of truffle. I didn't mind it since I'm a fan of this flavor profile but it just wasn't what I was expecting. The zaatar was definitely not very strong to taste; I would've liked more herbaceous, tartness (from sumac), and richness. The tomato & cucumber were a must as it added a fresh bite and crunchy texture to every bite. It was a good try but I would probably try something else next time. Stop by and support this local Palestinian-owned business! FYI, bring cash if you want to save the 3% surcharge on credit cards. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Zaatar Bagel with Zaatar Cream Cheese (~$6) with tomato (75¢) and cucumber (75¢) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The smells were amazing and promised great things! The bagels are large enough to share! The bagels were so fresh. Friendly service. Huge tea options. Only 1 table inside though. read more

love this place!! bagels are consistently delicious with tons of vegan options. staff is always so friendly and handles the weekend rush like pros! such a charming interior with lots of fun snacks and drinks to purchase as well. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If you are excited for the vegan option, don't be. I waited longer than the 3 people behind me for ... this. Ordered with ketchup, no ketchup. And they cut in half one small vegan sausage lol $11 I'd be embarrassed as a business to have this representing me, vegan option or not. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This has quickly become my go-to bagel spot in the neighborhood! The za'atar bagel with scallion lox cream cheese is super addicting. Quick service and lots of different bagel and spread options! read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Za'atar bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Zaatar Bagel w/Olive Cream Cheese is amazing. The flavor of the bagel paired nicely with the cream cheese. This was recommended by the gentleman who took our order and he didn't steer us wrong. I'd totally go back to see what other unique flavors they have and when in doubt, ask for a recommendation and be adventurous. You can tell this has been around awhile, the shop is quaint and you can see the age and history here. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I came around noon but apparently that was too late as they were all sold out of the za'atar bagels. Fortunately, there was za'atar cream cheese, and I absolutely fell in love with it. Initially I was leaning towards the black truffle cream cheese, but I asked the staff member taking my order which they would recommend and they immediately responded with za'atar. My sesame bagel with za'atar cream cheese came out $6 and it was worth ever penny. The sesame seeds had a nice toasted flavor and the bagel had an excellent deep brown color. The texture was not too denser and the inside was nice and springy. But that cream cheese, wow! It's nutty, it's rich, and the tang you usually get from the sumac is tempered by the cream cheese. In fact, it makes the cream cheese taste even cheesier and savorier, thanks to the marjoram and oregano. I will definitely be back to try their za'atar bagel and black truffle cream cheese too. But the za'atar cream cheese is definitely worth a trip over to Olde Brookyn Bagel Shoppe. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Sesame seed + za'atar cc ($6) - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Cute storefront with lots of items for purchase... like a bodega plus bagels. No seating at the store, but lots of tables nearby when open streets is ongoing. The bagels lacked a bit of something and were quite white. When toasted they we're burned. I'll save my bagel fix for the next stop. read more

See all

Second visit to this hectic bagel shoppe. The line is always long so don't pop in expecting a quick takeaway. The line to order wraps around a tall display shelf. So you are unable to see the menu until moments prior to ordering. Be prepared to decide very quickly! The shoppe offers many cream cheese beautifully displayed in mountainous dishes inside a cooler. Today was the Fort Greene sandwich served on toasted everything bagel and chive cream cheese. The avacado and turkey was plenty. Skimpy on lettuce cheese and tomato. My two friends receieved their individual sandwich in order of the ticket number, while I was skipped by five numbers. Finally the cashier called my ticket to clarify that I wanted the pepperjack cheese listed on the sandwich description. Mind you I didn't modify my order . So again I was resigned to waiting as my friends paced on the sidewalk. The service requires improvement. The sandwiches are on par compared to others in the neighborhood. Price point is high at $19 for a turkey sandwich. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Fort Greene on bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Got the vegan sausage egg and cheese and husband got the turkey panini with peppers. Both were awesome!! The staff was really nice, they get busy on weekends especially so the wait was kind of long. They have nice outdoor seating as well. read more

See all

AVOID. They are very slow. Orders not correct. $13 and 45 for the wrong order and their solution is to give a $2 refund in cash from the til. Save yourself the trouble and go elsewhere read more

Soft chewy bagel, flavorful spread, perfectly crispy bacon and quick friendly service. What's not to like? My order: ~$9 Everything bagel Siracha scallion garlic cc (special of the week and great!) Bacon, extra crispy read more

See all

Long line Saturday morning moved slowly but steadily. People working there seemed nice and were slammed so I feel for them. But bagel was just OK, maybe below average for a bagel place - doughy as if undercooked and not dense enough, a little bready. I think they must be making them too fast because they are so busy. read more

One of the best bagel shops in the area. Large menu. Be ready with what type of bagel you feel like. The service is quick and easy. And the cashier was friendly. Mr. F (Pastrami, fried egg, lettuce, red onion, and cream cheese on an everything bagel.) read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A nice bagel shop! Expect NYC prices, because you'll get them! We popped in for a coffee and bagel late AM. There are a lot of options with both bagel and toppings. The service was great! There's no indoor seating, but 2 long benches right outside, where we sat comfortably and enjoyed both the coffee (very good, by the way) and bagels. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm not sure why the reviews are so low for the bagel, it isn't that bad at all, and their signature Zataar bagel has some nice spices and flavors to it. They have many cream cheese flavors, and everything is generally good. They don't have seating, which can be an issue, but the place doubles as a Deli as there are options for other hot food options as well, coffee, and there are snacks you can buy as well. read more

Stopped by to get an everything bagel with hot honey pecan cc on a Tuesday afternoon around 430p on my way to prospect park. I probably should have asked for it to be toasted being that it's later in the day and the bagel wasn't as fresh as if I'd gotten it in the morning; but still very enjoyable. Service was quick, staff are friendly. Absolutely love the store logo-d parchment paper they use to wrap the bagel (it's in the little things!) Very generous cream cheese schmear. Would come back. read more

See all

A neighborhood fave. Reliably gold bagels and lots of yummy and fun choices of cream cheese etc.

A little surprised by the rating here on Yelp because I thought the bagel here was decently good! It's a bodega and bagel shop in one storefront. GET THE BLACK TRUFFLE CREAM CHEESE. First time that I had this type of cream cheese, and sure they're probably riding on the truffle trend, but I loved it. read more

I really liked the za'atar bagel here. I had it with scallion cream cheese and they deliver on DoorDash. However, I just don't go here much because it's cash only and I'm not going to go out of my way to find an ATM without a fee or use their $2 fee ATM for a bagel here with so many other spots around. I'm pretty sure studies show that businesses lose more money in business by not accepting cash than what they save in credit card fees - time to join the 21st century! read more

Food was excellent. Service was quick. Wished I got the zaatar bagel for my breakfast bagel but it's okay; everything was just as delicious. Went on the subway after picking up order and it stayed warm for a good 20 min in the wrapper/bag! read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've only ordered for delivery but these are the best bagels I've had in this area- still not my favorite but these are decent. I appreciate that they offer a few different flavors of cream cheese- including some very unique options like black truffle cc and bacon maple cc among various others. They also offer nice bagel sandwich options. Delivery has been fine, sometimes it can be slow on a busy morning. I'll continue to order delivery. 4/5 read more

Awesome place especially for the price. It's cash only but for less than $4 you can get great NY bagels and lox spread. The bagels are so soft and perfect with plenty of cream cheese spread. Loved this place so much! Ample outdoor seating when we went (3 patio tables and 2 next to the store). It's in good walking distance about 10min from the botanical garden so it was a great midday snack. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Salmon Lox Spread - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm sorry to say I didn't really like the bagel experience here. The place wasn't too busy when I went (I got lucky), ordered a sesame with lox spread, the bagel didn't really have any flavor to it (i know you're going, bagels and flavor, huh, but like, it's bread, we've all had great bread and bad bread, this wasn't good bread) and the cream cheese actually disgusting. I ate half my bagel thinking it was me, had a friend take a bite, and tossed the rest of the bagel out, as I didn't want to chance it with the cream cheese. read more

These bad reviews are actually absurd, although I do hope they keep the lines away. I almost never write reviews but when I saw this I had to. I've lived in 3 Manhattan neighborhoods and 2 Brooklyn neighborhoods over the past 11 years and these are the best bagels I've ever had (compared to Ess-a-bagel, Blackseed, Bagel Pub and many others). I take all my friends there. It can get busy, but the staff is always pleasant the prices are reasonable and the bagels are delicious and fresh. Great schmear options and sandwiches as well. read more

Great bagel, prompt and friendly service, and a really cute old-school decor vibe. Plus fresh squeezed OJ made the take out experience perfect. My everything with egg whites, turkey sausage, cheese and tomato was huge and delicious. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Just spent $16 on two ABC sandwiches with no egg. I guess I should have taken the menu literally, but I think it's pretty reasonable to have expected an egg on the sandwich. Listed under "breakfast sandwiches" is the ABC, "Avocado, bacon, cheese". Every single other bagel sandwich has egg. $8 for a bagel sandwich without egg is ridiculous. I'll spend my money somewhere else. read more

We originally wanted to get their zaatar bagel but they were out, so we went for the everything bagel with their cucumber dill cream cheese (4.5/5) a flavor I would never normally try. I was super pleasantly surprised with how refreshing and yummy it was. No frills, simple, delicious. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - Everything bagel with cucumber dill cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Not my first visit to this bagel shop but I really enjoyed the BLT sandwich which is pictured here in this review. You get to choose what kind of bread is used to make the sandwich and I chose whole wheat. I found the sandwich to be a nice balance of lettuce, tomato and just enough bacon bits and some mayo without there being too much of either. Quality over quantity! I have to knock off one star for this review because my first visit there was not to my liking. At the time, I tried their cream cheese bagel which one of my coworkers absolutely raved about. The bagel itself tasted fine and wasn't stale or mushy, but I did not like the copious amounts of cream cheese that were literally slathered on the two halves of the cut bagel to the point I wondered if the person who prepared the order had used half of a whole pint of cream cheese on it. Some people may enjoy eating that much cream cheese on their bagels. I am not one of them. I ended up wiping off whole layers of the cream cheese with several tissues until there was a thin but reasonable layer left on the bread. read more

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe - BLT sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York