This was our first visit to Bagel Bros. I've been seeing this spot on Instagram and loved that it wasnt too far. The location is simple and it is street parking for those visiting for the first time. But their bagels were DELICIOUS; It had a nice crust but the inside was also soft and not too chewy. They have an array of bagels and spreads along with breakfast sandwiches. We got our bagel quickly and we were happy campers. Definitely will be back! For more, see @sipsandsizzles on Instagram read more

BagelBros&Co - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

I've just got couple of bagels and a cream cheese. Im a big bagel's lover and wanted to try a new place. This was a huge mistake. Saturday morning and I've got bagels that are definitely not baked this morning. Cream cheese smells and taste like pure sour cream. I understand that not every bagel place must be 5 out of 5 but if im getting something like this and being charge almost $2/bagel and over $2.4 for a bagel of the day you know that something isn't right. Also if you see that muffins are sell in the plastic bags you know freshness is not the key here which should be #1 of every bakery and deli place. Never again!!! read more

The best bagels in Ct. By Far. Cinnamon raisin excellent and blueberry Thankyou for all you do. Nancy Couture Hofmiller read more

Sometimes I finish eating, and I immediately think the Yelp rating for a place is too high or too low. Bagel Bros's rating is too low, and the biggest driver of that seems to be a surprising number of 1 Star reviews from people who didn't post any pics and who don't post many CT business reviews. In any event, during my visit, I saw a steady stream of enthusiastic customers, plenty of bagels and efficient and friendly service. My family enjoyed the bagels we've had so far. This includes an everything bagel with green onion cream cheese and a special cherry vanilla bagel with cherry almond cream cheese. These are New York Style Bagels that are denser and chewier than some of the popular CT Bagel Shops, which have very well executed bagel shaped bread that is softer. I enjoy that style as well, but the Bagel Bros. take is more traditional. The textures were good, the flavors were on point and the cherry almond cream cheese looked cool. 4.5 Stars. I would encourage readers to pay more attention to the recent reviews of Yelp Elite Members and other users who posted pics. Those reviews are more consistent with my experience. read more

See all

This place may be tiny but the bagels are mighty. Mighty good and mighty big. These are not for the meek. They are a bit firm on the outside and soft on the inside. Just how I like them. I stopped by and got a smoked salmon one with scallion cream cheese and a tomato on an everything bagel. The bagel was just right in terms of seasoning. Not too garlicky or oniony either. The smoked salmon was a generous portion and the tomato full of flavor. Overall huge and such a delight. Service was super quick and friendly. Wish they had a decaf coffee ready but the other coffee was quite good. Looking forward to coming back and trying an egg sandwich one day great find in an area that was lacking some good bagel choices. read more

This place just knows how to appropriately push the boundaries in terms of creatively crafting a breakfast bagel that you would never even think of; all of the sandwich items are so cohesive that even reading a description simply makes you want to leave with one more bagel than you intended on getting! I recommend the Shelton.. it's popular for a REASON (actually a couple reasons, sandwiched in between an everything bagel) Who thought of adding a hashbrown to the bagel sandwiches?! They need a raise! More of an in and out place, no seating inside! COFFEE BAR WAS GREATLY APPRECIATED!!! read more

See all

Upon entering we were immediately greeted, informed there were weekly specials and whenever we were ready to come up. This helps tremendously when trying to figure out who's waiting to order or pick up. The Top G was delicious and loved the Turkey bacon. Can't wait to try their cream cheese next. Inside it's an order and go, hopefully in the summer set out a few chairs and tables outside. It was super clean and a good selection of coffee. Smelled so good walking in! read more

BagelBros&Co - Love me some bagels! - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

These bagels were absolutely delicious! It is such a pleasure to have New York style bagels brought to Connecticut done right. The bagels had a nice crunch on the outside and were warm and fluffy on the inside. Their menu was quite large and had plenty of gourmet bagel sandwich options to choose from as well as cream cheese flavors. I cannot wait to go back and try more! My mom tried the classic bacon, egg, and cheese on a plain bagel and I opted for the Philly melt on the bagel of the day which was the scallion. Both sandwiches were delicious and overflowing with toppings. The meat on the Philly melt was juicy and so flavorful. I was in a food coma state of happiness after my last bite. read more

See all

Cute, pick-up and go place. Very friendly staff. I tried one of their seasonal bagel's: pumpkin french toast, toasted with plain cream cheese. It was delicious! Perfect crunchy outside dusted with cinnamon and sugar, with a soft center. I can see why people are raving, as they do actually taste like NYC style bagels. The only thing I wish they had was iced coffee to accompany my bagel. I ended up ordering a hot coffee as that is what they offer. I will happily return! read more

I stopped by this place not too long ago ad I was hungry and needed to eat something quick for breakfast, found this place on the road, stopped by and must say I was pleasantly surprised. The service was quick, the place was clean and nice inside. I got a simple bagel w cream cheese, and was not disappointed, bagels were on the huge side and they did not skimp on the cream cheese. Bagels were toasty on the outside and soft on the inside. I like the bagels that you can bite through and are not so solid that is like eating rubber. Can't have an opinion on other types of sandwiches, but for me, it did the job. read more

See all

Stopped by Shelton's newest bagel shop! The Bagel Bros offer a variety fresh and delicious NY style bagels and an assortment of spreads and cream cheeses to compliment. They also offer coffee, muffins, donuts, and catering. Each week they feature a creative specialty bagel. While there I indulged in their Hot Pastrami breakfast bagel sandwich. It came with hot Boars Head pastrami, fried egg, sautéed red onions, and cheese sandwiched between a hand rolled everything bagel. It was very good! I also got a raisin bagel and an onion bagel for my next breakfast...lol The employees were very nice and welcoming. The bagel shop is more of a quick meal on the run stop as there are no seats available. I definitely recommend stopping by! read more

See all

So this is my second experience with this establishment. Even better than the first. The clerk behind the counter knew their product and made some excellent recomendations for a dozen bagels I had to bring to a work event. The bagels are very good. Not a sit down place, order and go, read more

My mom and I stopped by to check out the newly opened Bagel Bros! We were very happy with our garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese and avocado melt. While we were waiting for our food, we decided to get a couple chocolate chip bagels and pastries but we couldn't resist after looking at them! The staff was friendly, and they balanced the volume of their orders well! I was glad that we lived only a few minutes away because we hadn't realized it was take-out only, but maybe when the weather gets warmer they'll have some tables set up outside. Definitely a great addition to Shelton! read more

See all

NY bagels are right here in Shelton, CT and are consistently delicious and the Best! The friendly service is amazing along with their selection of unique flavors and spotless environment. Try it and see for yourself! read more

BagelBros&Co - Everything, Plain and Onion Bagels! - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

The best bagel I've had in all of CT. It's doughy but crispy when toasted and there is a variety of bagel, cream cheese, and butter flavors. The staff is so kind and you're never waiting long, no matter what you get. I live across the street from a bagel place and I drive 20 minutes here because it's so much better. 5/5 read more

Great new addition to this part of Shelton! I love that they're open on a Sunday and Monday, especially as other establishments of this category are not. The Shelton is a great sandwich. The bacon is turkey bacon - nice touch. Great hefty schmear of cream cheese. Bagels are fluffy. Staff is friendly. Coffee is self serve Omar's off to the side - make it how you like it. No seats or tables inside, come in to grab your stuff and go. Place seems clean every time I stop by. Location is great for a quick stop in - plenty of parking. read more

BagelBros&Co - Turkey bacon with a nice schmear of veggie cream cheese on a cheddar bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

Had the Shelton. This was a very good breakfast sandwich. Can't wait to go back and try something new. read more

BagelBros&Co - Specials July 2023 - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Yummy bagels with a wide variety of styles and sandwich combo options. Staff is always friendly and super speedy. Only improvements could be more vegetarian sandwich options, iced coffees, and a place to sit and eat inside. Nonetheless my favorite bagels in the valley. I'm always willing to take the drive when I have that craving. read more

Okay. I grew up in the valley and now live about 20 minutes from the NY line. I've had the best and worst of all bagels. I made the 45 minute trip to give this place a try. DID NOT DISAPPOINT! I ordered a few things so my husband and I could try. The bagels are perfect..crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside and the flavors were on point. My bacon egg and cheese had so much bacon on it and the egg was cooked perfectly. The scallion cream cheese on the other bagel was also so yummy. It helps that the staff was super sweet and was offering me a whole bunch of suggestions on things to get because I told them I wanted to try it all. The only issue is now I'll want to drive 45 minutes for one of these bagels. Definitely giving top 10 places to get a bagel vibes. Best of luck guys! You're killing it! read more

BagelBros&Co - Bacon, egg, cheese, and Hashbrown on an egg everything bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

I really enjoyed my bagels here! They're big and fresh and chewy, all the things. Our breakfast sandwiches were really good. Other bagel places have a hella long line, this place got you in and out quick! I got some scallion cream cheese for home and some egg everything bagels. Parking is tricky but once we found a spot we walked to the town green and ate it on a bench, it was a lovely morning! Friendly counter service. Pricing on par with other bagel places. read more

Shelton just got a lot more tastier! Welcome to the Valley, Bagel Bros! You will be saving me a lot of time as I no longer have to import bagels in from the City. Everything is fresh and yummy. Also, get ready for a mind blower: Bagel Bros has an Egg/Everything Bagel! It is as incredible as you think. I got "The" Lox and there was a lot of lox on there, which I will never complain about. If you are looking for a great bagel store, this is your new place. YUM! read more

See all

Review for Saturday morning at 8:30am Unsure if the day I went was the opening weekend or not but definitely one of first. The bagel shop is a grab and go without seating. Service- like I mentioned this was a beginning weekend and they definitely seem to going through some growing pains. The girls at the counter were great with taking orders but the food delivery queue needs some tweaking. We waited a long time to get a bagel with cream cheese and when we got home the order was wrong :(. To be fair - Im guessing in a month or 2, these issues won't exist anymore. Food: our order was wrong but the bagels were very good. Hard on outside, soft inside and everything seasoning on both sides! Definitely will stop by again when things settle. read more

Awesome bagels and breakfast sandwiches! So glad we finally have a place like this in Shelton! read more

BagelBros&Co - Lox bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

As soon as you walk through the door you are greeted with smiles and a wonderful aroma. They have plenty of bagel and speciality sandwich options! This was our first time here and can't wait to come back! The staff are extremely welcoming! I ordered the chicken sausage, egg, and hash-brown on a garlic bagel. The sandwich was very filling and tasted great. The coffee was fresh and hot! So happy to have Bagel Bros open! read more

BagelBros&Co - Chicken sausage, hash brown, on garlic bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

Stopped in today got bagel with cream cheese not toasted. I expected the outside to be crispy hard crust so didn't get it toasted. No hardness to the outside and definitely not a New York bagel!! Grew up in nyc so I know my bagels. AM bagels has 100% over this place!!!! Not sure why everyone thinks these are like New York bagels? Must not know what a good bagel should be. One and done read more

The best breakfast sandwich in town. Bagels are a 7/10 but an egg sandwich on the bagel makes it fantastic. read more

BagelBros&Co - Double egg, Double cheese on an everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

So I ordered 2 sandwiches today, I had assumed the sandwiches came with eggs but they do not, the bagels on the left side of the menu don't come with eggs, the sandwiches on the right do.. so when I got home I was like where TF are the eggs lol.. they are pretty expensive, so the chicken sausage, cheese on a bagel was $7 and the Philly steak, cheese on a bagel was 7... the regular breakfast sandwiches (right side menu) are $9.50 w/o tax. You don't get a lot of meat on the sandwiches which was disappointing especially when you're paying $10 for a breakfast sandwich. The service was good, the girl was nice. There is no ambiance, I think it was an old pizza place before, it's a just a small room with no tables or chairs, cannot eat inside. Over all I will not be going back, sadly. read more

This bagel shop is super cute inside, no tables, but plenty of standing room. I got the shelton on an everything bagel. The bagel was crunchy and soft the inside was soft and ingredients were so fresh. The people are super friendly. The service was amazing and fast. read more

BagelBros&Co - The Shelton on an everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Went for breakfast for the family. They said they don't take orders over the phone and I should come in to the shop. Went to the shop and they had no bagels left except for 1 jalapeño cheddar bagel left at 10:40 am on a Sunday morning and they are open until 1pm. Wish they would have told me that over the phone. The menu looks amazing but the fact that I was told to come into the shop and when I arrived 10 minutes later, they were out, may prevent me from coming back. Hope it was just a fluke and this isn't a reoccurring theme. read more

These have to be the best bagels I've ever had! Better than any NYC bagel. The everything bagel was so delicious with a hearty amount of flavor , perfect crunch on the outside and doughy in the middle, and large in size. I almost couldn't finish one bagel because it was so filling. The customer service was great too! Said hello upon entry and thank you to me several times for shopping with them. read more

Great flavorful bagels! Salted bagels - yummy! Blueberry bagels were robust and one of the best blueberry bagels ! read more

They're mid and the coffee is like going to a gas station. Not that very clean or put together. Not much service.

Can I say the BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE!! Walked inside and the front girl remembered my name -made me feel extra special knowing that they cared about their customers! The bagels taste excellent and they have an amazing variety to choose from! I took a scallion cream cheese spread togo and my husband loved it!! I will definitely be coming back and recommend others to give them a try. read more

BagelBros&Co - Store front - Bagels Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

Great flavors to choose from. Each bagel is so flavorful and the breakfast sandwiches are top notch. The staff is always friendly and the food is always good. read more

Huge bagels. Not as tasty as Bagel King, but close. One I had was crusty outside and perfect inside. Best jalapeño spread around. Not made with cheese. A little pricey. Help does not understand English too well, but very friendly. read more

Always good when I go! Staff are friendly and bagels are great. It's always clean too.

It's close to home, we've given it a try a few times. Unfortunately, it's just not for me. The everything bagels seem to be overcooked with burnt "everything" topping, some of bagels sort of just don't have a taste, and while I do wish they would offer regular bacon in addition to the Turkey bacon I probably wouldn't get an egg sandwich here again, there's always a strange oily flavor. Maybe it's what they use on the grill but it seems like the bagel is soaked in it when we order egg sandwiches and it's really not a great taste. I love that they use real egg but our last sandwiches (& final visit) had very large chunks of egg shell: it was a week day morning, no one else in the shop, no reason to rush. The shells make me feel like the people handling the food are a little too careless. It looks like they've got a lot of very good reviews so clearly people do like them but there are a lot of very good places in the area for people to choose from, I think it they want to last in that location, they need to make some improvements. I wish them well. read more

This place is a great addition to Shelton! Fantastic bagels AND the people that work there provide exceptional service. Stop in for a quick breakfast next time you're zipping down Howe Ave! read more

(made an account just to write this review) 10/10 the BEST bagels I've ever had, and great prices it's like $3.50 for a quick breakfast super friendly staff as well, my favorite place to go for a morning snack! read more

Stop in to check out the new place what a disappointment ordered a bacon egg cheese and large coffee $13.00 over priced and bacon is only turkey dry and chewy almost like jerky why would they not have regular bacon and not tell us it's only turkey Never again read more