We stumbled into this place for brunch one day. We were hungry and looking for breakfast-type options and the menu outside advertised all day brunch. The place was busy but we were taken to a table rather quickly. We sat near the bar, but close enough to the outside that overlooked Duval St. The table was a high-top table tha wobbled with all movement. HA! Chickens were very entertaining as they strutted around looking for dropped snacks. We had the Lox bagel with cream cheese. It was an interesting presentation as you have to assemble it yourself. All this is okay and it tasted good, just messy. Our daughter opted for the ceasar salad and she was satisfied with that. I had a bagel with cream cheese and a side of bacon. It was enough and we left satisfied. I'm not sure we would go there again, but it seemed to always be busy. Service was okay; nothing over the top, but adequate. read more

Bagatelle....I'm already missing you! We come here every trip to Key West- usually for happy hour. It's kind of a secret, and we love it. Happy hour is offered upstairs at the bar and is fantastic. The bar is small, but comfortable and classy. The espresso martini is the best one I've ever had. It's magic! Our server was the bartender and she made the perfect cocktail. She took our order fast and laughed when we said it wasn't our first rodeo. This was our first stop after getting off our plane so we were hungry and our order showed! We got the tuna, Brie, potstickers, and lobster Mac and cheese. We ate every bite!! I recommend this restaurant to everyone traveling to Key West. Whatever meal you come in for, breakfast, brunch, lunch, happy hour, or dinner- you are in for a great experience! read more

Bagatelle - Tuna, potstickers, Mac and cheese, Brie, espresso martini - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Had a nice brunch at Bagatelle while visiting Key West. Great service for our party of 7. Enjoyed a mango and peach mimosa, and the seafood omelette special. Others in our party had the biscuits and gravy, burger, avocado toast, breakfast tacos and cinnamon rolls. Everyone enjoyed their meal. The drawback was that at the end of the meal, we requested to split the check and the server informed us that she was not able to at that point. This is something I feel should've been communicated upfront (I even witnessed a server providing this info to another table). Recommend this restaurant, but be sure to inform server at time of seating to split check, if needed. read more

Bagatelle - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

We had an amazing meal at Bagatelle, at the perfect table on the second floor in the corner just overlooking Duval Street. The old house is a beautiful setting, though beware the small, narrow stairs if you're going up and down to your table. We were warned not to eat on the main level due to all the street noise. And with this place just across an alley from Hog's Breath, there are a ton of motorcycles that scream by during your dinner. Our server was great and very patient with us as we asked questions about the menu. I loved the lobster mac and cheese, though there weren't big chunks of lobster in it...just very small pieces mixed into the sauce. Still, it was very tasty. The crab cakes that my friend got also looked delicious and she was happy with them. I'd definitely go back on a future visit to Key West. read more

Went for my mother's birthday. Only thing good was the food. Mussels were great. Service wasn't great, it was raining and they put us on a wet table knowing we had a reservation. Expensive, and didn't tell us about a CC charge. read more

The food was amazing! Salad with blackened shrimp had incredible flavor. Risotta was addictive. Tuna and yudon noodles were so flavorful. Great service as well. read more

One of my favorites in key west love the building , the bar area outside. Food is awesome staff is great

Best crab cakes I've ever had and I live in Florida! The lobster mac and cheese and cherry mocktail werealso superb. Excellent !

Wonderful service. Food was fabulous. Excellent cocktails.Highly recommend Bagatelle. read more

We waited like 45 minutes for our food. Nobody is in here and I asked why is the wait so long and our waitress said because our food was a well done order all of a sudden it shows up and our food is cold. Also our waitress had such an attitude because I said please stop walking away we are not done ordering. If you're upset with your job I didn't do this to you . My chicken sandwich bun was cold breading on my chicken was soggy and fries were way over salted. read more

Sat at the bar and bartenders were great! Had the lobster Mac n Cheese which was phenomenal! Martinis were on point, we will be back!!

Incredible food, views, and outstanding customer service. My fiancée and I had a very special night--we went to the keys to celebrate her birthday, during which time I proposed to her. Without being asked, they decorated the table and offered a complimentary glass of Prosecco. Multiple staff congratulated us and truly made this night special for us both. Thank you so much! We will be back! read more

Amazing experience, ask to sit outside on duval street side. The live music from hogs breath across the street is an added plus. Service was amazing, I can't remember our servers name but he was fantastic and professional. The food was delicious and full of quintessential Key West menu items. Beautiful restaurant as well, there is tons of charm. read more

I stopped in here twice in the same day. The first time was around brunch and I had the baked brie and the blueberry basil lemonade. The service at the bar was fast and friendly. The food was amazing! The second time I came in was for happy hour. I had the brussel sprouts and the pork toastada with a cucumber cooler. The brussel sprouts were cheesy and had little bacon crumbles. So good! The pork tostada was crunchy and flavorful. The perfect couple bites! The cucumber cooler was extremely refreshing. Would definitely recommend coming for HH. You can easily make a few plates your dinner. The staff and ambiance is so bright and friendly. read more

See all

Bagatelle was a great stop for breakfast on our trip to Key West. The vibes of the restaurant were all you could ask for. We were seated outside Christmas Day which was great for people watching. We ordered the cinnamon rolls and fruit platter to start. Delicious! Then we ordered the breakfast tacos and sampler (both were great). If your in Key west and looking for a great breakfast that isn't your typical tourist trap food, head over to Bagatelle. read more

See all

I have been going to Bagatelle for decades. Several husbands and numerous paramours were endured but Bagatelle never disappoints. Fresh fish that is mere hours out of the sea - delish! But save room for dessert. The last time I was there I had a brownie with vanilla ice cream. Sound boring? Au contraire. I dream about this brownie. I will marry the pastry chef. I wake up at 2 am craving this brownie. Who wants to meet me at Bagatelle? And there was an iguana hanging from the tree over the table. Fabulous. read more

Everything was excellent. Food, service & ambience. Highly recommend. It is expensive though, but worth it. read more

See all

Amazing meals! Refill water right away! Steps/stairs. No ramp. There are public parking across (fews) easy to walk across Fun seats to watch people walking pass Romantic. Cozy. Family gathering too. Will come back again! read more

See all

Whether it's brunch or dinner, Bagatelle is always on point. Sitting outside on the patio taking in the Sun, some great drinks and amazing food. Best Key Lime Pie in the city! read more

Bagatelle - Warm Brie - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Went on a Tuesday. Wonderful restaurant, grate staff, and super grateful for taking us last minute for dinner near their closing time. Our crew had the lobster mac and cheese, the ahi tuna poke, filet mignon, the bagatelle salad, the burrata. For drinks: strawberry - mint blast and blueberry-basil lemonade The ambiance was perfect - and the music across the street was a happy accident. Unintentionally we went to their sister restaurant the night before - 915. This is a fantastic restaurant group and can't wait to dine at their spots again. read more

Bagatelle - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We went to Bagatelle's for their Thanksgiving meal. There were 3 in our party and the ONLY hit I can give the restaurant was that after we were seated, about 10 minutes passed with no attention from a server. My wife flagged down a server (Edgar) who wasn't supposed to be ours but he said he'd take care of us until the assigned server got to us. Well, Edgar ended up as our server, checking in on us regularly but not enough to be a nuisance. The Thanksgiving meal was fabulous. Both the dark meat and the white meat were tender, juicy, and, oh so flavorful! We all truly enjoyed our time at Bagatelles and felt it was a wonderful way to spend a Thanksgiving afternoon with family. Great job to Edgar and the chefs for a truly memorable experience. read more

Beautiful interior tiling, beautiful blues. Food was good and service was quick. I also had a dirty martini which was tasty also very good ac inside. read more

Bagatelle - Beef carpaccio - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Ambience is great. Nice outdoor seating. Good service. Food was mid for the price. Hogfish was bland with a flavorless sauce. Chicken was ok. Lobster fettuccine and swordfish a little better. Def expect a lot better for the price. read more

We had a reservation for a party of 9. We were supposed to have it in the upstairs space but when we got there, they told us our table was given to another group because they arrived before us. We ordered the warmed Brie and cinnamon rolls, but both were brought out cold. They did end up bringing out an actually warmed Brie and warm cinnamon rolls. One person in our group ordered the fried chicken sandwich. It was well undercooked. They ended up remaking her food but she didn't get it until everyone was done eating. We were also supposed to have champagne but did not get it. Our server then brought out a pie for the mistakes. However when we received our bill, it was on there. She offered to give us the pie free or a 10% discount on our bill. We ended up speaking with a manager later in the day (who was not working at the time of our brunch) and he comped our whole meal, which was the best customer service we received the whole time. The food itself was good. We did enjoy the entrees once they were corrected. Due to the service, we would not return, at least in a large group. However, the food was tasty and worth trying. read more

See all

We enjoyed brunch on the porch. The food was amazing! The chickens joined us but when the rooster started calling, the staff kindly led him away. read more

Bagatelle - Breakfast burritos! Banana Fosters French toast and a peach mimosa - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Ate upstairs on balcony, music flowing from other bars nearby, server was great, 2 of us had swordfish served over roasted corn risotto which was done perfectly, and we picked at the key lime pie for dessert overall great experience read more

We were initially told the food was not worth the price here, but it really was. The service was great. The lobster Mac and cheese was exactly what I imagined it to be. We got the hogfish and yellow snapper chef special. 100 percent worth it. read more

We went for mother days brunch and were lucky to get a reservation with only a short notice. The location and ambience is really nice. We have visited a few times and usually it's very good. On this occasion the wife got the surf and turf Benedict at 36.00 and I got the burger which was 26 or 28 dollars. I ordered a medium rare burger but it came out well done and the wife ordered her filet portion of Benedict rare also came out well done. The fries with the burger come out in a small wire basket which is a nice touch but all my fries were small like one inch fragments kind of like the McDonald's fries in the bottom of the carton. Overall the food was kind of disappointing considering the price but it was really busy so we didn't complain and enjoyed the ambiance. read more

Located in a great spot. Open air seating allows you to soak in the fresh key west air. Service was prompt and friendly. The fried chicken sandwich was moist but lacked seasoning. Salt and the sauce helped slightly. The lobster Mac was pretty good and had enough cheese sauce with small pieces of lobster throughout. read more

See all

We were looking for a seafood place for dinner and this restaurant had an opening that worked with our timeline. We were seated immediately when we arrived. The restaurant is adorable. Located on Duval so it's close to shops and all sorts of things. Started with the lobster macaroni and cheese. Got the grouper entree, which was amazing. Ended with their key lime pie. Mile high meringue is right! Also the key lime martini is a must!!! read more

See all

Great food! If get to go there get the lobster mac and cheese during the evening happy hour, it's fantastic! I will admit that the breakfast happy hour, unfortunately is more than a bit underwhelming. read more

Purposefully wasting food. The hostesses, my waitress and the man who served my food were all lovely. The manager and "chef" should look for a new jobs. When the caviar service was sold out, I pivoted to a medium rare filet, for which the menu specifies the only included side was a cippolini onion. The steak was underdone and the onion was raw with a couple of char marks. The waitress acknowledged the steak was rare and had it quickly refired to bring up to temp. When the manager came over after the issue with the steak, I brought up the onion and he told me it's just a garnish and the chef can cook it however they want. I said I would happily discuss with the chef but he just so happened to not be in that evening. The onion is the only included side and to not cook it is literally just wasting an entire onion on every plate served. Why is this restaurant spending money on onions if they aren't going to be edible? read more

One of the best restaurants for fine dining in Key West yet no pretentious attitudes here, just talented people creating delicious seafood dishes. We were lucky enough to to dine here on Easter weekend with our good friends who live here. You know you can always trust a restaurant when a local brings you. The restaurant sits right on Duval Street so we chose to sit outside to enjoy the beautiful spring weather and people watch. Our table was perfect and just far enough from the street noise. For starters we all had drinks. I selected a glass of French Viognier, my husband enjoyed a Margarita. We also shared a scrumptious Crab Cake filled with lump blue crab with a passion fruit vinaigrette. For entrees, I chose the Swordfish and husband chose the Tuna. The presentation of these dishes was on point and exquisite. The Swordfish was lightly blackened along with the black bean/corn risotto. Add the broccolini with the poblano cream sauce and this dish was pure perfection. Always a perk to be next to the sea when dining on fish. You know it's fresh! The Sesame crusted rare yellowfin tuna was served on a bed of chilled Udon noodles with edamame and a spicy peanut dressing. I couldn't take my eyes off this plate till I nabbed a bite. Again just incredibly tasty. Our friends enjoyed the Swordfish and the fish special of the evening. Unfortunately I was so caught up in my own meal that I failed to obtain the description of my friends dish. For dessert, we selected the Key Lime pie because when in Florida, this pie is a must. The pie itself was insanely good. My only negative was it had way too much merengue on top this just wasn't needed. The other dessert we ordered was an apple crunch was mediocre at best. Overall our dining experience was excellent. Service was terrific and the food was truly outstanding. I highly recommend dining here when in Key West. This is my 700th Yelp Review! read more

See all

Had a dinner that was fantastic so we went back for brunch the very next day. It didn't disappoint. It was so delicious and our waitress, Angela, didn't steer us wrong. The Watermelon/Lime cocktail was so yummy. Don't pass up the cinnamon buns! They were so light and fresh. Five stars all the way for Bagatelle!! read more

Bagatelle - Brunch Cocktails - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The ambience and location are perfect if you want to be in the middle of everything happening. We sat outside and the weather was perfect. Noise level is just right. The food was delicious! I had the Lobster Fettuccine and it blew my mind! The noodles are homemade with a delicious sauce, and you get two lobster tails on top, for a very reasonable price. The appetizers and drinks were delightful. The service was great as well. I definitely recommend! read more

Bagatelle - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

One of the best restaurants in Key West. I celebrated my birthday here and it was fabulous. From the food and drinks, everything was superb. I had the Lobster Tail Risotto and also shared a Filet Mignon. Presentaton was impressive. Lobster was cooked just right and the risotto was succulent. The steak was cooked to perfection and nice size too. I also loved the Lobster Mac. My gawwd. To die for. So if you're looking for good surf and turf, this place is a must right on Duval Street. Opt to sit outside if you like to people-watch or enjoy a beautiful night with your friends. Can't wait to go back again here. It's not super expensive. For the quality and great service, its very reasonable. read more

See all

Delicious brunch and immaculate vibes make up this spot in key west. With plenty of patio seating upstairs and downstairs, this place is a must for brunch. The crab cake Benedict was amazing, perfect crab cakes and the yummy hollandaise sauce. The burrata and heirloom tomato salad was refreshing. The fried French toast was an interesting take on the classic dish. While it was good I probably wouldn't get it again. The bloody Mary's and mimosas were awesome. Our server was attentive and kept asking to get another round of drinks and refill our waters. read more

See all

Awful service and food. So disappointing; food is overated, overpriced and overcooked. So many better resturant options in the area. Dont waste your time or money! read more

We had lunch here for 5 people. 2 of us ordered a sandwiches and the fries were ice cold. I asked our waitress to please bring some fresh hot fries. She can back about 15 min later with the same fries that were probably put under a heat lamp. Did she and the chef really think they fooled us? Our bill was $300+. In vacation locations they must figure they won't see us again so why bother doing their best. With so many restaurants to choose from, consider another if you want a great meal. The ambiance is nice so I will give them that much. read more

The brunch was AMAZING! The only thing that worries me is that there were chickens on table. I didn't mind them roaming around as they are entertaining but on the table was a bit much. read more