Haven't order from this place in a long time and now I remember why. 6/29/18 at about 5:45 I place an online order and pay online. (This should be easy, right?)according to the website my order will be ready in 30 minutes. I arrive in about 40 minutes. Walk into a tiny carry out area and behind the counter are 3 teens and not one says hi or how can I help you etc. one is on the phone and 2 are talking amongst themselves. After about 5 minutes of me just standing there I finally say "hey I ordered and paid for my pizza online I just need to get it" the one girl says "I'm sorry only 1 computer works you'll need to wait for her to get off the phone" okay so I wait. Finally young girl with purple pony tail says okay let me grab ur pizza. She walks in the back looks around and proceeds to fold napkins! I stand in a hot carry out area waiting for my pizza. Needless to say I waited and waited for her to wander and fold and finally received my pizza. Good help is truly hard to find. Dumb kids with poor people skills shouldn't deal with the public. I won't be ordering again! read more

I got an XL sausage for 25 bucks. It was pretty good. They browned the top slightly. Which I like. But the sauce is just a little to sweet for me. I don't know why they have to put so much sugar in it? Carry-out is the way to go here. read more

After taking down all the christmas stuff I had a taste for some za. I have not had Aurelio's is a while and thought it was a good idea. I need to quit having ideas. It was ok. The sausage was a bit salty and the sauce was ok. The pizza was not how I remembered it was just ok. One thing for certain is it is better for carry out than dine in here. read more

Trying to find our "go to" local pizza place. Tried Aurelio's on Wolf the other night. Ordered 1 large sausage and 1 large cheese for pickup. Pizzas were ready when I got there about 5 minutes early. Parking lot not very easy to use. Cheese pizza was really good, but not to wild about their sausage. It tasted over cooked and like it was cooked in bacon fat or something. Just had an odd taste to the sausage. Crust was good. Unfortunately can't look past the sausage since that is our standard order. Sorry, but Aurelio's will not be our "go-to" pizza joint. read more

Should have known when the delivery guy gave us the wrong pizza it would be a disaster. Ordered an extra thick Italian beef and giardiniera and appetizers. The pizza was awful all the topping piled in the middle nothing within 2 inches of the edge. The beef was falvorless looked like it was from arby's. $50 worth of garbage I've learned a lesson only go to homewood read more

Take out only. DO NOT EAT IN. Eating in gets 1 star. The service is awful. They only appear to have one waitress for the whole damn place! But the pizza is my favorite but I always get it to go! read more

What can I say what can I say? Best pizza around! Never disappointed when coming here! Staff is a joy to be around and make your visit that much more special! Food is always tasting great just like the original in Homewood. Jay the owner makes sure to take care of his guests like family! Lastly the remodel looks amazing and I look forward to coming back in town and getting my favorite pizza in Chicagoland area! read more

Call me crazy, but Wolf has the best pie! Older ovens? I don't know, but the flavor vs. other locations is hands down, the best! Check them out, you'll see! consistency, as well, love their consistency. read more

We had the number 22.....sausage cheese peppers mushrooms onions, fiesta size, and Alfredo cheese and spinach medium. Good pies just like I remember them in Homewood back in the late 70s.... read more

I do not like this location as much as the Frankfort one. It seems dingy and kind of sad. I would rather drive out of my way to go to the Frankfort location than eat here. The food is amazing as always, however. read more

Great pizza and Italian food! Also who knew a pizza place could make a great cheeseburger! This location is highly recommended by me!

I've eaten Aurelio's pizza since 1967, and pizza from this store for 20 years when I am in town to visit my mom. I ate there last night and it apparently has new management/ownership. The pizza recipe has changed...it's not the same Aurelio's pizza. The pizza is okay; it's just not an Aurelio's pizza. read more

Ordered a sausage and green pepper pizza for pick up since it not too far from my house. I've always enjoyed there pizzas since my kids were little. The pizza itself was amazing, which is to be expected. The only reason why I gave it 4 Stars because I had to wait an additional 15 minutes for my pizza to get done. I understand that places get busy, but if I'm willing to come and pick up the pizza then the place should give me the right time. Just a minor complaint, but the meal was worth it. read more

Thank you Jay........My order for a family size Aurelio's Cobb Salad was a very last minute thing...we decided to meet with friends and I agreed to bring a salad. The salad was beautifully presented and delicious, the amount of ingredients was over the top and they also agreed to give me two salad dressing instead on one. We have stopped in and had your pizza and we are never disappointed. read more

When I moved to Chicago I basically only ate deep dish for the first 2 months and then I came here to visit my boyfriend's family and they wanted to come to Aurelio's. I was surprised because they are such deep dish eaters as well. The pizza here is amazing though and has such flavor and the thin crust is still so filling because it is so flavorful! read more

Seventy minute wait for pickup when they said 25 minutes. It's awkward waiting in the tiny waiting area.

Great atmosphere to be for a great Pizza in the Chicago land area. Everything about this location is good! Highly recommend to those that are looking for a good place to sit down to enjoy a pizza that has been around for awhile! read more

I have been frequenting this particular Aurelio's for over 5 years now, and last night, they blew it! First, let me say that the girls who work there are great, very nice, very helpful, no complaints with them at all. Pizza is decent, generally not over/under cooked....but last night, the owner/manager made the worst mistake he could have - he ignored his customer base! My husband and I sat at a regular table, with pull out chairs, (they have 2 seat bench style, and regular tables). The chairs are so old, that the wooden seat piece had separated from the metal frame. When I sat down, and attempted to adjust the chair closer to the table, the seat and frame separated, and my finger smashed in between the two pieces, and a sharp piece of metal punctured my fingernail and fingertip. (Really glad I recently had a tetanus shot) Although the wait staff was extremely helpful, and brought me ice for my finger, the business owner did not come out from the back to apologize. To add insult to my injury (pun intended), the owner told one of the girls just to put the chair in the back party room, against the back wall. This chair should be taken off the restaurant floor, and either repaired properly, or replaced. I am not sure if the owner/manager thought that I was just looking for a free hand out, but if I attach pictures here of my finger, you would throw up while reading this! Not pretty, I will probably lose my nail - and all I wanted was a freaking apology...not free food, not a discount....AN APOLOGY!!! Take care of your restaurant, in turn, you take care of the people that come to your restaurant...which keeps them coming, and ultimately, makes you richer....I had no idea that human decency had completely left the planet. This is a sad day indeed. read more

Aurelio's IS pizza. Perhaps I'm biased because I grew up in the south suburbs, and down here, Aurelio's is #1. I'm not even a big pizza person, but I LOVE Aurelio's, and you will too. My favorite is their stuffed pizza with spinach. This is the best pizza you will ever have in your life :) read more

Great pizza, great salads nice bar to wait at while your take out is being prepared. Never had a bad anything but if I did, I would speak to the management before posting something negatives. read more

Started going to Aurelius pizzas on Ridge Rd in Homewood in 1974 when they only had 8 tables and loved the pizza and salad. Something changed the taste about 2 years ago and no matter where I buy their pizza in the area it doesn't have any good flavor anymore. This was my final try to get a good Aurelious pizza. Not the original flavor and close to frozen pizza quality. read more

Aurelios has redeemed themselves, we have had carry out at least three times since last review, every time was outstanding. They are back.

Pizza was just like I remember from Homewood. Service good, friendly! So nice to have the Aurelio's I remember close to home!

Pizza good. Salad old and uninteresting. Service indifferent, Server disappeared for 15 minutes and when I commented that my drink glass had been empty for that long, server didn't seem to care. Place needs an overhaul or they won't last. read more

When I went there two weeks ago it was my first time in ten years...No the last time was my sister's soccor thing in elementary school...and there is a good reason why I aint gone back...PLACE STINKS!! Thats it...it stinks! oooohh Left 4 dead 2...I will describe the pizza I got in great detail. Normally...........most pizza places, their deep dish and stuffed pizzas are their BEST pizzas. Aurelio's their stuff is hopefullly the worse cause if there is something worse than that...it is NOT edible....its sooo bad....it was burnt on the bottom...dough tasted like **** and the sauce tasted like spagetios. is there water in there?...gold dust....HOW many games you downloading...? Elder Scrolls?.....im spent. read more

I absolutely love there pizza! Jay and Jeremy are the best always friendly great staff and great food. The new Aurelios beer is fantastic! I always get a sausage and mushroom pizza which never disappoints. I would recommend going here to everyone if you love a great family run atmosphere! read more