Best service Best Dinner locally Best Diner for miles!!! clean Diner ambiance!! Large portions with a HUGE MENU!! I'm not a local but if I was I'd eat here weekly !!! Great freakin brunch!!! Cheers!! read more

Athena Diner - Disco Fries - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

Came here, looking forward to a gyro, and my wife was in the mood for breakfast for dinner. My gyro was $19 and was a major disappointment. I'm used to seeing a huge pile of meat in a pita that contains yogurt sauce, feta and lots of assorted veggies. I received 3 small pieces of meat that looked, tasted and chewed like shoe leather. They were arranged on top of chopped iceberg lettuce, tomatoes and a stale pita. There were two slices of feta and a tiny plastic to-go container of tezyki on the side. The pita was so stale, it crumbled when I tried to fold it in half to make a sandwich. My wife's egg sandwich was very overdone and flattened into an unrecognizable shape. The service was friendly, but not attentive. Our drinks were not refilled and our server was nowhere to be seen after she dropped off the meals. Dining room and restroom were clean, and looked like they were recently remodeled. We ate the food because we were hungry, but don't plan on returning. read more

The food was delicious as I had remembered. My daughter had the turkey club and I had stuffed potato skins. I thought the price was a little high...... Certainly a bit higher than the last time I was there. All was good except our server was not great. Never a smile. Rather slow service. Not very welcoming. Where customer service is a huge part of the experience today was a disappointment. read more

Athena Diner - Potato skins with cheese and bacon - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

Never disappointed! From a fine greeting to fine service, food, dessert, we're never disappointed. Best local diner going in our opinion. And if you don't like something, speak up, they will accommodate. "Try it, you'll like it!" Phenomenal! TootsieT. read more

Very nice. Simple diner food, portions are big, food is good with no wait time. We generally get the out, would come back for sure. Hands down, great diner experience. read more

I have been to this location multiple times over many years. I recently stopped by en route to somewhere else figuring it was a safe bet. The place was clean (including restrooms) airy and light filled. We were seated immediately, and service was fast and attentive, just how it should be. The menu is quite large with many selections. We ordered breakfast, and while everything was fine, it was just that. I don't think anything is made in house (definitely not the corned beef hash as I asked). Fozen has browns. Basically dinner prices for cheap fast food. Plenty of parking in lot. read more

Athena Diner - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

Phenomenal. I'm not a huge fan of diners but this one was delish. We sat at the counter because we were in a rush. The food was fast and the service was great. Mary P. was our server and she was very attentive and enthusiastic (which was great for peak hours on a Saturday!). The chocolate chip pancake was cooked to perfection with a solid chocolate chip distribution (iykyk). The menu was extensive and the place is super clean and nice. Highly recommend giving it a go if you're in the area. read more

Athena Diner - Mozzarella and avocado omelet, with side of hash browns and rye toast. - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

The service, the food quality, variety, prices and ambiance cannot get better. They honestly never disappoint

In a word: don't. Lots of other great diners to try in the area. What does "hot meatloaf sandwich" mean to you? To me, it means a steaming open face sandwich covered in brown gravy. What I got was two slabs of cold, dry meatloaf, sitting on dried out wonder bread. Everything ice cold. When I asked, we were told "that's how it comes." It was inedible. When the server asked, we were basically met with shrugs. No one offered to back it out of the bill. Expect a lot more out of a $16 sandwich. It was also really hard to get a coffee refill, and it wasn't a peak time. Go somewhere else. read more

Athena Diner - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

My mom and I stopped in for breakfast around 11 on a Saturday morning. They were busy but were able to seat us, and we couldn't believe we were in and out in 45 minutes - it was great! Our waitress was friendly and attentive, and I also have to say this is one of the cleanest diners we've ever been to. Even the windows were sparkling! The strawberry shortcake pancakes were great, and usually I have difficulty finishing a stack of 3, but these were nice and light. My mom liked her eggs benny and hash browns, and the bacon was crispy and had a nice smoky flavor. A solid choice for breakfast on Washington Ave! We'll have to come back and try them for lunch/dinner. read more

See all

A huge menu and each item we've tried has been delicious. The service has been wonderful and spot on. Definitely highly recommend.

We went non for a late dinner and I got a tuna sandwich with spinach and onion. They used frozen spinach asked if I wanted grilled onions. She was very confused . The my cousin had a pot roast dinner . It was actually sliced roast beef from the deli out of mashed the gave me a baked potato the whole meal was returned. Maybe an off day. Would give it 1 more chance. Thanks Chris M read more

Been to this diner many times. It's your typical diner. The food is good, but I wouldn't say it's anything special. Service is always prompt, and it's very clean. read more

Athena Diner - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

After a day of travel, I was in the mood for diner comfort food, specifically a club sammich. I searched around for a club sammmich and Athena Diner popped up! I ordered a grilled chicken club with apple pie for dessert. It did not disappoint and cole slaw and fries that came with it also were delish. If you want yummy diner fare, check this place out! read more

Athena Diner - Grilled chicken club with fries! - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

The diner wasn't even busy but it took almost an hour to be waited on and for my food to arrive. When it did, it was cold so I sent it back and wound up waiting yet again. It wasn't even good. Not sure what's going on with this place. I gave it two stars because the waitress was apologetic. read more

This is a diner I have been to 30 times over the years but it's over now. The last 2 visits were terrible. Kids allowed to yell and swear. Wait staff was terrible. The good was horrible. The manager did try to offer $3 off my $60 meal. read more

Go to diner for breakfast lunch and dinner. Great service, good prices, and reasonable portions. Typical Greek diner fare. Breakfast wraps are great as are the club sandwiches. Points for a good coleslaw along with fries. read more

Athena Diner - Turkey Reuben. Thousand island on the side. - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

This trip to the Athena Diner was very nice. The ambiance was pretty good and the service was great. The only problem was that It took a while for food to get here, but It makes sense seeing it was a busy day and there were only like 3 waiters. I had Belgium Waffle and a side of bacon. All of the food was really good. Ive had a pretty good experience this dinner and I recommend it to anyone crossing by the area. read more

Very disappointed to be charged $10 for 2 tiny scoops of mashed potatoes to go. Still 3 stars, since I have enjoyed meals here, but felt taken advantage of when I stopped on the way home trying to save an hour of cooking. read more

Athena Diner - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

This place is awesome, Mary our server is one the best in here, if you ask for her when you come in she will take care of you 10 fold, the food is excellent and this place is always busy! read more

Stopped back in at Athena a year later and I must admit I was very disappointed. Being a Greek diner this time since it was evening I ordered the gyro platter. What came was some frozen gyro pre-sliced and heated on the grill, just three small strips, served with fries. Turned out the fries were the best thing the gyro was awful. Went back the next night and ordered the spinach pie, awful, frozen pie that was all dough and no filling. I had the Greek salad with the pie and that was without a doubt the best thing. The salad comes with grape leaves and an outstanding Greek dressing. As I say again this place is very expensive for a diner so you need to watch what you order. Next time I will just stick to steak and eggs. read more

Is it possible to give a diner 4 stars?...Yes, yes it is! This diner is one of the few left that is 24 hours, +1. The food menu is huge and the service is fast & friendly. Water is a given, as in immediately upon being seated. The whole place has recently been redone in nice blue tones, even the bathrooms. I love the chicken souvlaki, and that's my go to dish here. Fries are crisp, mozzarella sticks are yum, breakfasts are good, what more can you ask for at 2am? read more

See all

Ate here on a Sunday afternoon on the way home to NJ. It wasn't too far from the highway and we were able to gas up then stop for lunch. It wasn't too busy, so we didn't have to wait for a table. Inside of the diner looks like it was either newly renovated or just new in general. It was clean and still had the diner feel to it. So many different items on the menu, including breakfast served all day of course. I went for spaghetti and sauce. Nothing special, but it was delicious and not too big of a portion. Our server was nice and friendly. Best part is how they were kind enough to split the bill between the 4 of us. A lot of places won't do that, so I appreciate it. read more

Athena Diner - Front of menu. - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

In terms of serving sizes, you will get a bang for your buck without sacrificing too much quality. Of the times I have been here, the quality of food is usually good with some minor slips up here or there given time of night. Of course, that is inherent given that this place if one of the ONLY 24 hour places to eat that isn't a fast food chain driveway. I think the waitresses here get a bad rep on some reviews considering some of the clientele they have to deal with. I am a big proponent of actively treating your serving staff with empathy having been on both sides myself. At Athena, I have had people who were "New England tough" but will crack a joke with you should you be willing. The pragmatic parts of the service including correct orders, time from tabling tabling to order taking to serving to checkout, and taking requests WITHIN reason has been pretty solid. The only reason I don't give Athena anything more than 3 stars is, beyond what I have already said, the restaurant is nothing spectacular. It fits its function well as a 24 hour diner with solid food choices that are not particularly notable. I will continue to eat here as a solid choice and for late night sit-downs. read more

Went here on Saturday for an early dinner. I had the gyro which was not bad, pretty much average. I also got a chicken quesadilla to go, which was also good. The prices here seem pretty steep for diner fare. The service was good, looked like a clean place. The menu is huge and they serve breakfast all day. No problem parking and the location is very good, right off I-91. Nice experience other than the price issue. read more

We had a wonderful dinner at Athena Diner. The food was tasty and served as ordered, service was professional and prompt, and ambiance was good. The prices seemed a little high but that's how it is in this post-covid world. I would definitely return when I'm in the area. read more

Been to this place many times. It's your typical New England diner with the typical faire. This place never fails to hit the spot. This time we met up with an old friend of my wife from high school. She had the eggs. My wife just the grilled cheese and myself the salad. All good all tasty. This has been a cornerstone of my wife's life since her childhood. read more

See all

I'm going to start off with..... the service ABSOLUTELY SUCKED! First the burger and salad ordered took 20 minutes to arrive, I would be ok with that if the people who came in and ordered 15 minutes after us didn't get their food the same time as us. Second, the waitress had no personality and couldn't care less about us. Lastly, when the manager at the register asked us how everything was and we said "we've had better here" she just said "sorry" and didn't ask us why, then just walked away when she handed us the credit card slip. They made it obvious that they didn't care to have our business so we'll oblige by not going there anymore. BTW... this was Sunday @ 7pm so they weren't busy. read more

Never had any problems with this place , even though we come here literally every morning and have french toast and it's good amount for a great price. Comes with 3 slices of french toast and can come with a choice of bacon or sausage. Really neat and nice but wish the bathrooms weren't so small only two stalls and I had to wait because there was a lot of girl's in the bathroom( At least 4 people in line). On top of there's only one sink to wash you hands. So SMALL :(. However our waiter was amazing. Got water for us as soon as possible and didn't have to wait that much even thought it was little busy. Just wonder why they rush us like she got our drinks but 1 minute later she ask what were gonna eat. LIKE.... Overall, Pretty good for customer service. read more

As a woman from Jersey, I'm always interested in finding decent diners. I have been unlucky since moving but came across this one while visiting a friend. The meal was served exactly as ordered, without a too long wait and the service was friendly. There was a wide variety of desserts as well. The restaurant looked clean and tidy inside and out and I was super impressed with my whole experience even though I am a pretty fussy person. I am looking forward to my next meal there! read more

Absolutely incredible diner we found on a road trip. Fastest service ever, delicious breakfast all day, slices of pie or whole pies? Need I say more? So happy we went here! read more

Athena Diner - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

food was excellent however there was a lot of flys would recommend if you have a high tolerance for insects! LOL

Went for a late night breakfast and had to practically beg for a coffee. Ordered our food and proceeded to wait for no less than 45 minutes. When they served the table next to us who'd arrived well after us we got up and talked to the Manager. His response was to tell us to go to McDonald's. I had been there many times before and had great service but needless to say after being treated that way I will never go there again. read more

Came here recently two times. One for mother's day and surprisingly the service was fast on such a busy morning brunch. I got the crab cake eggs Benedict which is bold for me to get at a diner because I'm not expecting it to taste good. It was amazing. The crab cake had so much flavor and the sauce was properly made. My son had the kids pancakes and home fries. Very big portions. Second time I came with my son just for a quick dinner before soccer. I ordered a BLT and the bacon was crispy and the curly fries were crunchy. My son had the chicken fingers and fries and enjoyed them. read more

My favorite Diner!!!! Their phone was down yesterday due to utility issues- I am so glad they are back in!! Never a problem here. They will make anything and they make it delicious every time!! read more

Went here many times after and between hockey games. Looking for a diner - this is a great place with all the usually diner fare. They re-did the interior about a year ago; very nice. Service is good; lovely people. Not sure if it is family owned, and they seem like family. Good coffee, breakfast items, and sandwiches. You can't go wrong. Call ahead for a large group, they have helped us many times. read more

Had a business lunch here, and the place was clean and the staff were courteous. The meatloaf. Was okay but the accompanying beets and coffee fell short and I would consider them below the average. read more

Athena Diner - Ambiance - Diners Near Me - North Haven, Connecticut

See all

This the place for a solid diner dinner. It's not fancy, but if you like Greek diners, you'll feel at home here. Welcoming greeting just as you get in the door and fast prompt friendly service. Don't try anything too far from their forte -- stick with diner basics and Greek specials. Lots of dinner specials offered and breakfast all day. It was hard to choose from the big menu. My husband had their meatloaf. Comes with salad or soup. Choice of potato and veggie. He chose the mashed potatoes and the broccoli. Portion was quite large and came with brown gravy. The broccoli was a bit overcooked but he ate it anyway. I had their open faced turkey sans bread and chose mashed potatoes. This comes topped with yellow/chicken gravy and choice of vegetable. The waitress asked if I wanted cranberry sauce and brought over two little cups. Perfect if, like me, you like the jellied cranberry sauce out of the can. That's nostalgic for me so I loved it. We both got the salad to start (me with french(he with Russian dressing). There were 3 soup choices if preferred instead. Salad was large. No froufrou frisée here -- just good old American iceberg with a few small tomatoes, etc. and dressing. We left a lot on our plates, but still took a piece of coconut cream pie to go... read more

Completely updated, clean and busy on weekends. Staff friendly and knowledgeable. Food was standard diner fare, came out timely. Nice for brunch. read more

Athena is a standard diner - the food and the service is exactly what you would expect. You've got cracked vinyl on your chairs, dishes stained from thousands of washings, etc. Nothing special. HOWEVER -- I'm done. We had a party of 6 meeting at Athena last Saturday. One member of our party went 45 minutes early to put down our name. They told her there were 2 parties in front of her and to sit at the counter. She got some coffee and waited... apparently they meant for ALL SIX OF US to sit at the counter. The second girl showed up; they told the two of them that they weren't going to be able to accommodate a party of 6. More than once they checked back in and were told to go elsewhere. When the other 4 of us showed up a few minutes before the agreed-upon time, all of a sudden the staff went into a tizzy trying to find someplace to seat us. We told them "No thanks" and went to Adelphia Cafe down the street, where we were seated immediately and had much better food and better service. I know where I'm going from now on. Thanks but no thanks, Athena. read more