My wife and I went here to see a live show. We were seated completely out of view of the small stage. We saw friend's who were seated closer and asked the staff of we could sit at their table when they left. The hostess allowed us to move. Ten minutes later the owner demanded we move because he thought we had simply taken the table. After forcing us to move in a very aggressive manner, the owner then queried the staff and returned to our table away from the stage and grudgingly allowed us to return to our friends table. This owner literally expressed anger in this event and refused to listen to our explanation as to why we switched tables. My wife was shaken by the owners aggressive behavior and I was simply wondering how this man stays in business. We will never return. Food was average pizzeria fair. Sad the owner could not contain himself long enough to listen to a customer. He should have talked to the hostess first before aggressively approaching my wife and I. Avoid, there are much better brew pubs in the area. read more

Beer is home brewed. Bartender's are friendly. Dragon Fries are amazing. I like it here!

My wife and I have made this our "date night" spot with our little toddler as they have more than enough outdoor seating, delicious beers and pizzas that are better than competitors in the area. Similar to all restaurants during these unprecedented times, staffing is not easy to come by. With that said, it is impressive to see their general manager and owner hustling around to make things function as smoothly as possible. We will continue supporting this family business, and we can never manage to leave without a 4-pack to go - I guess that speaks to their quality! read more

I've been here a couple times. Pizza was good. Went last night and beer was watery and nachos disgusting with stale chips. Not going back. Too many other better places to have a good beer and delicious meal. read more

The scrapple burger was amazing but our waitress was very unfriendly and seemed like it was a hassle to serve us . Also acted like it was a hassle to split a bill between 2 couples ! Believe her name was Leigherin . She made it pretty unpleasant read more

Wings ok. Nachos bad. Beer wasn't the best but not the worst. At 2 pm we were the only people there. Our waiter was obviously stoned and took our order from 5 feet away. We had to wait a very long time to get our bill when we were finished. Our waiter kept swerving back and forth throughout the room. Don't waste your time or money. read more

The pizza has always been top-notch, but my favorite part of coming here is always the beer. They have had some super-delicious brews in a bunch of different styles. The bartender, I think his name is Pete, is a pleasure to talk to and has pointed us to some other great Delaware breweries since we're new to the area. This is probably my favorite spot in town. Keep up the killer work guys! read more

Worst happy hour I've ever been to in the state of Delaware. Not only was the bar service horrendous but the food was worse. How dose a bar mess up nachos? And early into the HH how dose the bar hag... oops sorry I mean bar maid forget our drink order two minutes after she walks off?! WTH! And has the nerve to have an attitude?! Throws us something that looks like nachos with some semblance of melted cheese. To top off the half- a$$ service I'm over charged... So do yourself a favor and go anyplace, but here. Jessops Tavern in old New Castle is nice. Ha! Even Trolly Tap House knows how to serve halfway decent nachos. read more

Such a great place all around. We go in here about every other week and have been very happy with the quality of the food, drinks, and service. Offering some salads and sandwiches that have been good, the pizza is really great. Everything on the menu is good, they could probably use some more fried appetizers, but they are much better than most bar food. They have a limited beer selection, but all of their homemade beer is unique and very drinkable. There are bar specials and live music nights with local artists, but it's a great place to just hang out to the jukebox. The staff has always been friendly and attentive, we have seen many at this point and always received fast service. They have a welcoming little spot at Pietros, and it's easily a favorite place for us to go. read more

Love the staff. Pizza, burgers, and cheesesteaks are where it's at. Love that there is live music most weekends. Great place to hang!

I have never written a bad review about any restaurant because if I don't like it I just won't return. However, with Argilla this was one of the first places I went to when I moved to Delaware. One of my husbands workers raved about it. We went and it was delicious! Some of the best pizza we have ever had. Fresh toppings, crust wasn't greasy but wasn't dry. It was awesome. I recommended it to everyone and we even went there for a birthday. The service was slow but the food made up for it. I liked the atmosphere of the place; sort of cool, down to earth vibe. However, my feelings have changed. The service got worse and worse too the point where, I believe, there was only one waiter working and some cooks in the kitchen. The last time we went, and probably final time unless some drastic things change, it was extremely slow. It was my family of four and another family of four and two people at the bar. I keep reassuring my husband that we will forget about the service once the food comes.....wrong. The nachos, which have always been my favorite, were disgusting. The chips were stale tasting and over cooked and instead of using fresh shredded cheese like they use too it was straight nacho cheese...like the stuff that comes out of a box. I am fine with nacho cheese...if I'm paying for $3 nachos at a little league game. Not $15 nachos that took 25 minutes to comes out. The veggies were surprisingly fresh but the cheese made everything soggy. Again, tried to reassure my husband that the pizza will make up for it. Wrong again. I ordered the arugula pizza which was my favorite pizza I ever had. Sun dried tomatoes, arugula topped on it, white sauce and fresh chunks of garlic, my favorite part. However when the pizza came out, no garlic. NO GARLIC. What's the point of getting a pizza with minimal ingredients because the taste it suppose to be delicious. Just tomatoes and arugula. To top it off when I was looking around the place trying to figure out how my once favorite pizza joint turned into the biggest waste of my money I spotted a Costco like package of 2 liters of coke. Not fountain soda; warm, sitting out 2 lifters. My husband and I came to the conclusion that they are running out of money and cutting back on things. With all that being said, and I feel quit ridiculous writing this extensive of a review when usually I just say "this food is gross, I'm not coming back", I won't be going back unless it goes back to how it was. And hopefully it will. I hope someone will appreciate the history of Pietros pizza and wants to bring fresh ingredients back and not cut back on the food. Also, the only reason I didn't give this a one star is because it says one star is "the worst thing you have ever eaten", so I gave it a two star "never recommend the place". The worst thing I have ever eaten is the supposedly nacho cheese that comes out of an MRE (meal ready to eat) that they give to soldiers when they is no cafeteria or chow hall around....this was a close second. read more

Ashame the way this place has declined ! Would not recommend it anymore ! Slow service , wrong orders smaller portions management does not seem to care anymore ! Will never go back read more

Went in a Tuesday night. It wasn't crowded - we were quickly seated. Tried multiple beers which were all tasty. Ordered the sweet potato fries appetizer with honey & cinnamon- fries were crisp and the honey-cinnamon combo was not overly sweet. We also ordered the pork & peppers pizza- delicious with a crisp crust & perfect amount of toppings. read more

My husband and I really like Argilla. We've been a number of times and had good experiences, but after the last two visits we won't be returning. Both times, we arrived, were seated, and then were ignored for at least 15 minutes without so much as a "Sorry, I'll be with you in a minute." No water, no drinks, no ordering food. Last time we figured it was a fluke and stayed anyway. Tonight we saw it was a pattern and walked out to get our pizza elsewhere--but not before waiting another couple minutes being ignored at the host stand while trying to inform the staff that we were leaving. Get it together, Argilla. read more

Beer was great. Food terrible! Ordered a shrimp avocado BLT. Avocado was frozen, bacon cold and rancid, shrimp cold, and bread a hard toast! Server apologized and said she told the kitchen about it. When bill came, not even a discount was offered for the half of food eaten. No customer satisfaction is of their concern. Pizza may be good but other dishes, be open minded! read more

I brought a softball team here because I've been here on Friday and Saturday nights and it has been great in the past. Don't come on a Tuesday... one waitress in the entire place took 15 mins to seat us even though the place was empty. Waitress didn't know the specials..out of red bull... out of Jack daniels?? Out of all moonshine drinks? Food took 45 minutes and even then half the table ate while others waited another 15 minutes. Drinks came 30 plus minutes after we ordered them. The food was all good but the service was an absolute train wreck. Never coming back. read more

Great food, nice relaxed ambiance. Ok for family and for a few friends at the bar too. Staff is always fun, good people and never too crowded. read more

We have gone here several times through the years. Overall, we had enjoyed our visits. Things seem to have changed. The menu is new, and the foods are limited: pizza, burgers and salads. Gone are our favorite sandwiches. The pizza is still great, and the wonderful microbrewery is still there, but we noticed the worn tired tables and the crumbs on tables and the floor. We really did not enjoy the visit. read more

I've been a fan of this place since they just served pizza to-go at there old location. There food is great and with the addition of home-brewed craft beers, they are even better. I highly recommend this place. Great happy hour specials and very friendly bartenders. read more

Such a disappointing experience... The lack of any kind of decent service from staff and food was not there. Our server had not given us any notice after seating us that they had shut off the "flat top" after we arrived (this is a week day not even 9 pm yet), limiting out option to anything only deep fried or pizza (Kind of odd to run a kitchen like that, maybe just personal opinion)! Ordered our appetizers way ahead of time before we had given the rest of our order. So our entree (pizza) had made its way to the table before our appetizers (nachos and the raved about onion rings) which we had to ask our server about our apps, then she brings out our apps... Cold. Naturally the server blamed the kitchen ( okayyyyy ) We had our nachos taken back to reheat, they came back still cold in the center! Onion rings were just so bland that we didn't bother asking to salvage those. Pizza oven needs to be seriously cleaned, our pizza was covered on the bottom in this musky black film. Never have I seen that on the bottom of a pizza like that ever! Not a place I'd be willing to give a second chance. read more

My first time there, ordered the Crabby Nappa, which tasted like someone dumped canned NE clam chowder on pizza (pools of flavorless liquid sitting on the pizza) and added extremely bitter, overcooked broccoli rabe. Second time, ordered the Roman Margherita which was actually pretty good. Not amazing, but good. My second time there we also ordered the onion rings which were dynamite. Love the thick batter and basil aioli. Beer has been very good both times. Service was lackluster both times. All I have to say is....meh. (So helpful, I know) read more

The pizza and service is average at best. I have tried other items but most are too salty or just not well prepared. The surprise is the lack of real excitement for the beer. I just had an Irish Red which was tasteless and quite boring. Then the decor is starting to show it's age. Sad that I have been in the area many years and this location has failed to excite since Slip Mahoney's. read more

Food is above average for the area and the beer is mediocre for what I suppose you could call a microbrewery. However the atmosphere is dark and dive bar"ish". But the actual place wreaked of a foul smell comparable to cat urine. Was not a pleasant experience. read more

Cool place. Really enjoyed the citizen pale ale and my dining companion raved about the Argilla Amber. One of the best local pizzas paired with quality craft beer. Definitely coming back. read more

My first visit and I'm blown away with the food and the craft brew. Just might be the best pizza I ever had and I'm Kinda a pizza snob......so good! read more

We went here yesterday at lunch to try a new place. I ordered a beer which was the best part of my meal....the beer was excellent. I had read a few reviews that talked about the French Onion soup, so my wife and I each ordered a bowl. It came out and looked delicious, but the broth had a strong vinegar smell. Not something I've ever had in a french onion soup....and...it's not good. We moved on and waited for the Margherita pizza to come out. We figured pizza would be safe...but that wasn't good either. It was soupy....hard to explain. Almost like they took hot sauce and partially melted cheese in it...then spread that onto the pizza. Then added some fresh mozzerela and basic on top. My wife and I both commented that we get better pizza from the slice places like Peace o Pizza or Margherita's on Main Street (and those pizzas have been sitting out for who knows how long). Don't plan on going back...unless it's just for beer. read more

I had a birthday lunch at Argilla, and it was great. We shared the margherita pizza and a white pizza, and both were delicious! I had a "Hopricana" beer - it was dark but not too heavy, with notes of orange. I really enjoyed my beer, and everyone else had great things to say about theirs. read more

I found the food to be absolutely delicious. I have been eating Pietro's pizza for years and am glad that the recipe is being carried on with this new establishment. After trying two beer samplers for which all were extremely unique and flavorful, I can say that their beer selection is on point.Service was great and the appetizer chicken quesadillas along with the cesar salad were perfect.I will defiantly be back. read more

Great house crafted beer, good food and friendly service.

Our first time here we had the pork pizza (has another name). It was amazing. The pork was well cooked and had a lite heat to it. The pizza was cooked perfectly and the crust was crispy and not greasy. The beer is good. They have at least 6 beers on tap. They are well done for the small brew pub that they are. The server was friendly and had great recommendations as well. Over all I would definitely come back. It's a great place in between Newark and Wilmington. read more

The pizza is alright but I've had considerably better in the area and it took forever (about 45-60 minutes from the time I ordered to when the pizza arrived) where several people I was with were several drinks in at that point. Providing you plan on staying for a while its not a bad place, but I'd much rather go elsewhere. read more

I love this place! The beer, food, and staff are all amazing. I got the buffalo chicken pizza and it was amazing. The staff makes you feel like you're family here. read more

Best fried pickles!! Dill spears sliced long-ways with thick, homemade breading and 3 dipping sauces!! So good! Pizza is decent also. Great beer selection and wonderful neighborhood staff. read more

Love their beers! Great selection of pizzas,burgers,and apps. The beer's always cold and the food is consistently on point. Join the mug club and earn points for cash off your bill and more beer for your buck. read more

Wow. wow. wow. Had two custom slices tonight and it was only $6.50. This place is heaven on earth if you love pizza good people and a good brew read more

Still can't find their way.......I ordered a pizza to go about a week ago and it was BURNT! How do you allow a burnt pizza to go out the door? I shouldn't have to check the pizza before leaving (especially for what you charge)! And the service is still mediocre, with the exception of Pete. He's the only one who's on his game. read more

I like this place quite a bit although it is a little pricey for pub food. I've been here a few times but haven't tried the pizza yet (can't wait - I hear it's terrific). The robanjero wings are frickin phenomenal & the brews are great! Fries? Good. Quesadilla? Good. Griiled chicken sandwich? Good. Everything is good or better! read more

Argilla is a great place- I've been a customer of theirs since Pietros pizza over 20 year's ago. It's great to see them succeed and evolve as a business. If you haven't been you def owe it to yourself to check it out. Support local businesses that keep things affordable and appreciate your business. Staff is super friendly and food is amazing. read more

Good stuff all around. I accidentally sat on the party end of a stool. It's okay because I had a plate of nachos to make me forget about my troubles. read more

Went for some snacks on Sunday evening - was pretty quiet and seemed to only be locals/regulars. The food here was overpriced and bland. Buffalo Chicken spring rolls were almost tasteless. Tacos were $4 each and literally only came with meat and onions - nothing else (lettuce, tomato, sour cream, sauce, nada.) Pizza looked decent but we only had appetizers. Beer was decent, but nothing to write home about. read more