Apizza Heaven has been on my radar for a while because of social media. Until recently, I didn't realize they're so close. I decided to try AH on a recent Friday Night. I think I ordered online for takeout and my order was ready within a reasonable time. I ordered a large chicken pesto specialty pizza and a small specialty pizza with standard pizza mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, and piped ricotta. I also ordered a penne all vodka and chicken cutlet. The crust on both pizzas was very good. Good char. A good mix of crispy and chewy. The chicken pesto pizza was terrific. It has chicken cutlet slices, pesto, cherry tomatoes, mozzarella and ricotta. Really every part of this pizza was great. Highly recommend. I ordered the 3 cheeses specialty pizza almost out of curiosity, because I've never seen anybody go all in on those cheeses like that. The good news is, that within that pizza, were the components of a very good pizza. The blend of these cheeses didn't completely work for me flavor-wise though. Also, these cheeses produced a bit too much grease. I'd order just the sauce and standard mozzarella next time and I bet it would be very good. The penna alla vodka was a chunky sauce version. The noticeable chunks were mostly onions. I'm used to more of a blended version. I respect that this dish has its own vibe, but I personally prefer a blended version. The sauce flavor was good. The chicken cutlet was very good. I bet they make a great chicken parm. Service was friendly and efficient. Apizza Heaven won't win any beauty contests. The inside is functional. There were a few tables. The outside could use some attention. There were a few random things around the general area. I definitely noticed them when I was walking in. I think people would have a better first impression if those details are taken care of. Overall, I'd rate my experience 4.25 Stars. But I could definitely see getting up to 4.5 or 4.75 on future visits. read more

See all

A year old gem hidden in a small neighborhood in Middletown, small dining area with a couple of tables but with a marvelous service and a busy delivery service. Max was exceptional, always smiling and attentive. (My daughters find.) She wanted to try a different pizza place. What kid doesn't like pizza right? And she is very particular with her cheese. First bite she approved immediately. Good wings, I would have preferred them less oily, and great mozzarella sticks . As a bonus we brought a large pie for home . read more

See all

Had lunch today at Apizza Heaven in Middletown. They opened in March of this year, but this place has clearly been living in Chris' head for a very long time before that, and it shows in every bite. The spot itself is small, clean, and unassuming, no flash, no gimmicks. Counter-style, quiet hum of ovens working, the smell of fermenting dough and bubbling sauce in the air. The kind of place where the pizza is supposed to do the talking... and boy, does it ever. I had: * A small plain cheese * A small secret menu pizza (ssshhhhh...) The plain cheese was everything you want in a pizza and then some. Built on a three-day fermented dough, that alone tells you the level of care here. Chris' standard is simple: If the dough isn't perfect, it doesn't get sold. Most people would never even know the difference, but that's not good enough for him. That's craftsmanship. The sauce was a perfect sweet-acid balance with that deep umami punch only great tomatoes deliver. The cheese? Bubbly, creamy, smooth. This pizza is an exercise in perfect simplicity, nothing to hide behind, nowhere to cheat. The crust brings a clean crunch and that subtle tang that only cold fermentation gives you. Now the secret menu vodka chicken pizza... Homemade vodka sauce. Homemade chicken cutlets. Dollops of fresh ricotta added post-bake. This thing was a full symphony: * Sweet * Acidic * Cool * Warm * Crunchy * Creamy Every note in tune. Nothing fighting for attention. Just harmony. And Chris? He is pure passion. Everything is made in-house, and you can taste that intention in every layer of the pie. No shortcuts. No autopilot. Just pride. My recommendation: Get down there. Try the pizza. Talk to Chris. You will not be disappointed read more

See all

Great pizza, friendly service, I will keep returning. Smaller place, I would say mainly takeout service. read more

See all

True Napoletano pizza of which New Haven pizza is a derivative, has a juicy chewy center that grows firmer and crispier the farther out you get/closer you get to the crust. Mondo is so sub par to me so I figured I'd try this because it has good albeit limited reviews. This was worse. Overcooked, hard, cracker like crust. Hardly any olive oil was used. Margarita wasn't a margarita. It's not supposed to have sliced tomatoes on it. It's supposed to have a simple, fresh, raw sauce, fresh mozz, lots of basil, glug of olive oil. This had a very oregano forward traditional sauce that tasted over seasoned and cooked. Pepperoni was somewhat better, but still altogether dry, overcooked, and totally lacking in proper, elevated, delectable flavor profiles. I'm not a Pepe's or Sally's stan. The best pizza I've had in this state is Zenelli's, also in New Haven. Their pizza is the closest I've had to the two Napoletano brother's I worked for in Brooklyn who owned and operated Luna Rossa which was the best pizza I've had outside of Italy. But it's 45 minutes away. Alas, the search for decent pizza in mid/northern CT continues, likely futilely. read more

Quite the tasty pie this place produces! Upon observation of both employees and product, it's obvious they take pride in what's served across the counter. read more

Apizza Heaven - Sausage and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

This place is great & everything I've tried here has been amazing..! My go-to's are the Chicken cutlet pizza, garlic knots & chicken wings. The owner is very nice & they always get the door for me on the way out which is appreciated. read more

Apizza Heaven - Chicken cutlet pie - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Decided to see what all the hype was about. Apizza Heaven is located in a residential/ industrial area off exit 21 on 91. Chris the owner takes pride in his new haven style pie. He makes everything from scratch. Now on to the pie. The crust has a nice crunch to it....it does soften a bit on the ride home but still has a nice crunch and it's sort of slightly airy at the same time. We had a pepperoni pie. The pepperoni had a nice spice to it. The cheese is a cheese blend that I think might have some cheddar in it from the flavor. It wasn't really a saucy pie so I would suggest if you are a sauce person you might want extra sauce. Sauce was very light. Think I could taste some basil to it. And the pizza wasn't floppy and could withstand the weight of the toppings. They were also generous with the pepperoni. 18" pie with 1 topping goes for around $20. Which is a good deal. I suggest you give them a try. I also heard they have some really good Garlic Parmesan Wings which I'll be back to try. read more

See all

The group was nice enough to show me the kitchen. The pizza was fantastic compared to others in the area. The people that served me were so open and kind. I'll post pics as soon as I can read more

Amazing pizza, so happy I went here!! The service was amazing and the people there were so kind. read more

We were in Middletown for a apt. We were thinking of going to new haven for a pizza.....FORGET ABOUT IT. Finally found the best pizza around. So happy we pulled Apizza Heaven up. The wings were awesome too. The owner aChtis was so pleasant. We will be back. We have been looking for years to find a great New Haven style pizza without going all the way down there. Highly recommend. A 10. Best ever. read more

Good pizza thin style and lots of topping options. I suggest trying one of their specialty pies. The service was excellent and this restaurant has a cozy atmosphere. The place can seat around 12 customers. Overall good experience read more

Very good pizza, small restaurant but the owner is very nice would definitely come back read more

Apizza Heaven - Half cheese half meatball - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

This is such a great place to eat, everything was cooked to perfection I swear!! My family and I had the julia and it was the perfect crust texture (didn't even bend when u picked it up) and the cheese was so gooey, and everything is SO fresh. ESPECIALLY the sauce, best sauce ever. They're a new restaurant and have a small space but it's 100% worth it! Their service was the best i've ever had tbh, my family and I had a great time talking to the owner. We even mentioned eggplant in our conversation which we didn't order and he made us some fresh for free, he was so generous! 10/10 would recommend! read more

We ordered around 6:30 on a Friday night: 6 honey bbq wings, 6 garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, a large cheese pizza and a tiramisu. The total came to just under $50 and it was ready in about 25 minutes as promised. The wings were delicious and crispy and the meat fell right off the bone - also the sauce wasn't TOO sweet, which I find is an issue sometimes with honey bbq (will definitely try the garlic parm next time). The garlic knots were twice the size of what I was expecting, and if I'm being critical - they could have used a little more garlic, but they were good nonetheless and came with a generous amount of marinara (enough for the knots and to dip the pizza crust). The mozzarella sticks were pretty standard but were cooked perfectly - crispy on the outside with gooey cheese on the inside. The pizza was the best we've found since moving to the area this past year: thin crust and cooked well done just the way we like it (if you don't like your pizza well done make sure to ask for it lightly cooked). The tiramisu I have yet to try, but it is made in house (as are all of the desserts) and looks very promising... will definitely be having that later. The ambiance is casual with a few tables. The restaurant is clean and all of the staff were very friendly and personable. 10/10 will be back. read more

AH knocks it out every time. Half pep and half chicken pesto was our latest. My wife and I downed our slices and raved about them. Chris is always so friendly and the shop, although small, is everything you want from a whole in the wall. Can't recommend AH enough! read more

the best wings and pizza i ever had! chris puts his heart into these pizzas best in Ct hands down

this place has amazing food and great service the owner is a great man and the food like I said was amazing