This restaurant does get some live bands though probably would go somewhere else for pizza otherwise. The pizza is ok but there is definitely better in the area. It took us 90 minutes to get one pizza in house. They had bartenders trying to wait tables and my experience with that both as a customer and previous server is that these tables are left waiting way too long. Service was very intermittent and we would end up going to the bar the get drinks anyway. Venue is pretty loud with the band playing in such a small space, limited standing room if seats fill. There is a large parking lot for parking. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza (Large) - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Good pizza if you are in the Middletown area. I ordered a large cheese with bacon for pick up. I enjoyed the Pizza but I just wish they were a little quicker with the service . I was waiting for about 10 additional minutes for my pizza to be ready. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Pizza was good and bacon was crispy but it was greasy on the bottom, not sure if this was from the tin foil underneath it... I am also a crust person and I'll steal it off the next person's plate, but this is this first time I have never eaten the crust...kinda bummed read more

Jerry's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Purchased 2 slices from Jerry's food truck at Lyman Orchards today! Great food! Had pepperoni but they had options such as pesto, buffalo chicken, pepperoni and cheese. Also had fried dough balls for purchased and mozzarella sticks and steak and cheese sandwiches. Pizza came out quick, and was great and hot! Would definitely recommend! Prices for pepperoni was $7 per slice! They did take cash and cards. read more

(Last visited 3/31/2022.) Every Wednesday Jerry's hosts music bingo with a chance win all kinds of free prizes, so needless to say I've been here quite a few times not only for that, but for their delicious wings! Let's begin! Atmosphere/Appearance: This place is pretty much a dive. Lol. Not a bad dive. It doesn't present a risk of being killed or harmed in the parking lot, but once inside and you hang out for a minute, you'll understand. Lol. There is a private parking lot on the side of the building that Jerry's shares with a couple of other businesses. It's an elongated sort of restaurant with a drop ceiling, many TVs a slightly raised "stage", a pool table toward the back and a big bar rail on the right side. Like I mentioned, it's a dive, so it's loud in here. Service: I can't remember all of the servers names who took care of us, but I've never actually had an issue here. Things are fine, nothing like a fine dining restaurant, but it's all good. Food: I'm here for the wings! Throughout my numerous visits I've had their Bacon Ranch, Sweet 'N' Hot, Marinara Parmesan, Cinnamon Chipotle and Honey BBQ flavors. They're all very good, a decent size and full of flavor. Value: I feel like there's some sort of #WingWednesday special on the same Wednesday where there's music bingo, but I'm drawing a blank on what exactly is. Lol. Just trust me. In conclusion, this place is cool. I'm not gonna pull up on my own merit, but if some folks wanna get together to play some music bingo and get some wings, I'd be down! read more

See all

Best chicken cutlet grinder! Quickly served and don't get me started on the cookies they serve!

When Jerry's does things well, they're great. When they don't...you wish you went somewhere else instead. Consistency is a problem here. I've had one of the best pizzas of my life here, and many pizzas that I've had to go home and finish cooking or otherwise doctor up. When they make my chicken cutlet grinders as I order them, they're spectacular, but sometimes they're missing toppings and they never ever ever give extra pickles like I ask them to. At least when you dine in, you can ask them to fix it. They have live music at the bar a lot, it used to be called Matty's Next Door Sports Bar, but then Matty got ousted post divorce so now it's all just under the Jerry's umbrella (it was always connected inside). It's a good local spot to hang out and eat, I just wish it was a little more consistent. read more

See all

Everytime I go to Jerry's the pizza always reminds me as a kid when they were on Washington St by Caldor I would get a slice he was a kind man Jerry but the food is still amazing but I get 2 slices and 1 to go everyone should try it once read more

When my large order was cancelled at 7PM the night before the celebration of life for my mother by another place, Jerry's stepped up and saved the day! They had 20 large pizzas ready by 11:30 on Saturday and each one perfectly cooked and delicious. I am beyond grateful and recommend them highly. read more

They do exist!! The Thai peanut butter & jelly wings are not just a myth... they are a real thing! After trying to order them for what seemed like an eternity they finally had them! Omg they are PHENOMENAL! The the spicy peanut butter on a perfectly crispy wing coupled with jelly, life changing!!! Jerry's Bar is a fun place to go. They have live entertainment/events on most nights. My favorite is Music Bingo on Wednesday nights at 7. It's a night of singing and seat dancing over drinks and good food. If you win the prizes consist of free cheese pizza, well drinks, appetizers, wine or traditional wings. There is no charge to play. I am a fan of their calzones, salami grinders, & buffalo chicken salad - they make the best chicken cutlets!! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Thai peanut butter & jelly wings - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

I was placing an order for a chicken bacon ranch grinder. The Grumpy older blonde bar tender told me she knew what kind of grinder that I wanted. I got a burnt dry chicken cutlet grinder with overdone fries. Hungry so I ate the fries and half of the burnt dried out chicken cutlet. Worst ever. Bar tender stared through me when I said that I didn't want to take the second half of the grinder home. I was charged for a full grinder full price with no apology or concern. Food at Jerry's is not good most of the time. The beer is never Cold! People are putting ice cubes in their beer glasses. Keno machine gets shut off quarterly by the State of CT for non payments. Sad the owner doesn't run this place better. I won't be back to eat here soon. read more

Absolutely love this place!! Shannon is the best waitress. So attentive and friendly. We usually go on Wednesday for music bingo. It's something fun to do while hanging out with friends not to mention prizes when you win. Who doesn't want a free drink? All the food is delicious. Wings, pizza, fried pickles, sweet potato fries--all very good. Always served hot and we've never had to wait too long for the food read more

See all

Stopped in with some friends for a quick bite. Delicious cheese pizza! Adding some oregano, crushed red pepper and cheese to it made it that much better. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

I have been here several times for take out. Chicken wings, they are good wings. My favorite sauce is the Molasses Bourbon and the Old Bay dry rub. The wings are a nice size cooked perfectly. The blue cheese they serve with it is to die for! A lot of blue cheese and garlic in a creamy base. Only bad part about the wings are they are a little pricey, but to me, they are worth it. Grinders-My husband had the tuna, good solid tuna base. I wish they had more toppings like cherry peppers or banana peppers, but that is just me. If you do t want it toasted you have to let them know this. I think all off them come toasted, unless you specifically say don't toast. Desserts- I like their cookies. The peanut butter cup is my favorite. It's nice and large, my husband and I can split it and I am good with that and feel satisfied. The staff is always nice, busy and efficient. Again, I did not take a picture, because I scarfed my food down and it was an after thought. They have dine in, but I normally just pick up. From the area I pick up, it is clean. read more

Love music bingo night at Jerry's pizza. The staff is amazing always so friendly. Tonight we had the Hawaiian pizza and Buffalo wings. I was pleasantly surprise at how delicious the pizza was. The wing were a dry rub I typically prefer a sauce style wing but these were great. They have so many flavor options. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Music bingo - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Haven't ordered from Jerry's in a while. Unfortunately it was not good I used to really like their pizza. I ordered a small bacon pizza and the bottom was all burnt. Also ordered the Cajun shrimp skewers. There was very little Cajun if any at all and they were so overcooked they were hard to chew and just inedible. Not sure why they would let food go out like this. All went in the garbage. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Jerry's pizza is delicious! The crust is the perfect spot between thin and Sicilian. I like that you can get it by the slice at the resultant. Baked goods are also great! With cold beer on draft, you are all set. The staff in super nice as well. Great neighborly vibes. Deliveries are fast and hassle free. Just remember to order a cookie or two!! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Soooooo...the food is ok. The service is ok. It's not the closest place to me, so why do I keep going back? For the Music Bingo on Wednesday nights! They do have happy hour until 6, so if you can get there early to save a few bucks before music bingo at 7, that's even better! I've had some wings I enjoyed here, then have gone back a week or two later and they're bland or are supposed to be sauced yet come out looking like a dry rub. If it weren't for the entertainment, I wouldn't drive almost a half hour to eat here, that's what it boils down to. There are sweet potato wedges which I enjoy, though I always have to add salt and sometimes ketchup. I did order a pizza once and that was actually better than I expected it to be. It was the Blizzard Pizza with spinach and ricotta. But, when there are happy hour wings I generally stick to those, but they're just not consistent. I think they need more staff on nights they have entertainment, but maybe they just can't find anyone right now. If the food was great and the service was slow, I'd give that a pass right now as places are getting back into the swing of things post-pandemic. There is a pool table and touch-tunes available as well. And, I'm not sure what came out of the soap dispenser last Wednesday night in the ladies room. It was foam yet barely sudsed up, and smelled like rubbing alcohol. Did someone mistakenly put hand sanitizer in there that day? That would be my guess. I like to lather up and it just wasn't possible last week. If you're there for the entertainment and don't have super high expectations of the food? You'll have a great time! read more

See all

Great bar great food. The legendary Terry provided great service and even gave me a nice shoulder rub while I dined on my exquisite chicken parm. Will come back many times read more

We got a pizza and the food was delivered hot and is authentic. I'm looking forward to trying their grinders next time!

Good service delicious food... haven't been there in a long time. Will return great for lunch.

This place was great! We were celebrating some sweet kiddos birthdays at the trampoline park in the same plaza (also highly recommend..so fun!) and we came to Jerry's following our jumping for some pizza! They were super friendly and accommodating, the pizza was great (even my picky eater toddler enjoyed it!) and they let my friend bring in cupcakes for dessert and let the kids open their birthday presents there. It was so fun and comfortable - the perfect place for a pizza party. The next time we jump at the trampoline park, we will definitely come here for pizza after! read more

Food was great and Music bingo on Wednesday night is really fun! I was here last week for Nacho's and came back for more!

Oh my gosh I love this place so so so much! The ladies that work in there are nice and they have great service too. I've only tried the cheese pizza but honestly I think that's all I need to try. It's perfectly chewy, the crust is perfect, and the cheese and sauce is amazing. My family has been going here for around 40 years and it's always been phenomenal. Best pizza place ever! read more

Sat in the bar and waited 20 minutes for menus and never received them. Had to get up and ask for menus then it took another 25 minutes before someone came over and took our order. When the food finally came out it was lukewarm. Waited over 45 minutes for food after we ordered. Was not impressed at all. If it's your thing to be ignored and eat lukewarm food...then go for it. read more

Haven't been in Middletown in almost 20 years, Jerry's you did not disappoint, just as good as I remembered!! Whole family loved it

I should have looked at Yelp first. Sort the reviews by newest first and you'll see what I mean. My review is not about the food, because we didn't get any (more on that later). This review is about a restaurant that really needs to take a hard look at how they treat their customers. They should also consider canceling all forms of delivery. As the manager stated, she wished that they didn't offer delivery. Maybe they get enough foot traffic. Maybe if you go into the restaurant, they treat you better face to face. Both sides of my family have been ordering from Jerry's for decades. Never has anyone been treated the way that my husband was treated this past Friday. Jerry's isn't the cheapest in the area, but we decided to splurge ($65 - large pizza, small pizza, salad & 8 pc wings). We ordered via Slice. After placing the order, the app informed us that the order would be delivered in an hour and a half. It wasn't. We waited a few minutes and then called to check on the order. The woman that answered said that the guy left with our order a while ago and that it should be delivered any minute. After another 20 minutes and no pizza, we called again. This time the woman told us that the guy had just left 5 minutes ago and he was on his way. Fast forward 15 minutes and still no delivery. In this 15 minutes our son broke down in tears, because he was so hungry. I immediately got up and started to piece together some leftovers. At this point (over 2 hours later and past our son's bedtime) we had, had it. My husband called back to cancel the order. The woman told him that she was giving him a discount. He refused and asked for a refund twice. Without a word, she hung up on my husband. My family and I told my husband to call back and speak with the owner. When he called the next day, he spoke with the manager. We weren't looking for any compensation, just to voice our concern. Obviously, the staff is lacking customer service training. read more

I hope that Jerry's still does as well with their original offerings as they always did, but if you ever consider ordering their version of Sicilian Hamburg Pizza - a local tradition - don't waste your time or money. Incinerated crust, minimal hamburger in the sauce, and the sauce itself lacks the local "secret ingredient". I would have done better to throw away the pizza and eat the box... read more

The service was average. We ordered a pepperoni and a veggie pizza, the pepperoni one was ok, but the veggie was awful. It was bland, I had to put a lot of parmesan cheese to give it a bit of flavor, but it didn't help much. I've had many veggie pizzas in my lifetime, but this was the worse one yet. read more

I know the place is called "Jerry's Pizza" but listen, their wings are head and shoulders above any other wing I have had in CT. They aren't slimy. They aren't dry. They have ample breading and crunch while also being juicy. I live almost 30mins away from Jerry's and I drive all the way down there JUST to get their wings. 100% worth it. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

We had a great time at Jerry's Pizza. The band was terrific! The Fairfield Street Band. They had the place rocking. The pizza and wings were delicious too. Hope u have that band back again. read more

As always, food was delicious. Depending on how busy, it may take a bit to get your food but remember Good things come to those that wait!! read more

This place has been my favorite pizza place since I was a child. The cheese pizza is the most consistent pie of all time, the wings are a great size so worth the money (garlic parm), and I love the grinders especially chicken parm or hot salami with oil and vinegar. read more

I love this place but I hate when you pay for something and it doesn't end up in your bag even though you confirmed it was in there.

Jerry's isn't the best pizza in Ct. It's the best pizza in the world. i have never eaten a slice anyplace on on earth including Italy on par with the prefect slice of meatball and peperoni i get at Jerry's. always great service always someone warm and friendly behind the counter. just as it has been since the days on Washington Street. The wings are untouchable in flavor and quality and no one makes a Calzone as good as Carmella read more

Well first off they can't even get the order correct. Took a hour to get food. Didn't get the soda ordered and the tuna grinder that was ordered came toasted which is absolutely disgusting. I'll be going somewhere else. Jerry's pizza is dead to me read more

The wait is over finally enjoying a perfect night of sitting down and enjoying Jerry's Pizza. The pulled pork nachos went down too fast to take a picture but trust me you want to get it the next time you go! Carmela it's always a pleasure to come by! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Jerry's Special ABSOLUTELY delicious!! Couldn't take a picture of the perfectly made loaded pulled pork nachos they went down too fast! - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Haven't had food from Jerry's in years my son picked up take out and mine was awful. I had sausage and peppers grinder. I asked for sauce on side. Well I got what I asked for but the sausage had no flavor, if it was par boiled they drained flavor out. In fact the sausage itself did not look right or taste. I will say bread was good cause I threw out the sausage. read more

Oct 2019 UPDATE: went again last week... multiple wings had large feathers on them. It was gross. No flavors could make me go back. Such a shame. Only 2 stars bc our last experts great. July 2019 We ordered 66 wings from here for a party last night. Total was $64.00.....Chipotle bbq, bourbon molasses and garlic parm. They were a big hit! Bourbon was everyone's favorite. The garlic parm does leave much to be desired though. They were very dry and somewhat tasteless. We haven't had anything else from there so I can't comment on anything but the wings. read more

A Middletown staple for longer than most residents here been alive. The restaurant side is fantastic with a wide variety of hand-made pizzas, grinders, and other offerings. Don't know what to order? Try the chicken parmigiana grinder with peppers and cheese. Amazing! I have dreams about this sandwich when I am out of town. The bar areas is beautifully refinished with a pool table available and a TV in all directions. The bartenders are friendly and efficient. You can order food in the bar area without leaving your set. read more