A Middletown staple for longer than most residents here been alive. The restaurant side is fantastic with a wide variety of hand-made pizzas, grinders, and other offerings. Don't know what to order? Try the chicken parmigiana grinder with peppers and cheese. Amazing! I have dreams about this sandwich when I am out of town. The bar areas is beautifully refinished with a pool table available and a TV in all directions. The bartenders are friendly and efficient. You can order food in the bar area without leaving your set. read more

The pizza is good and the aesthetic is nice. Then food is okay. The pizza crust is nice and the cups are nice red ones. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Coco cola nice red cup - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

Music bingo on Wednesdays is awesome! Especially when Michele hosts, I had a great time! Pizza, wings, and salad galore, delish!

Yo bro this food lit I would totes recommend to all the hip hipsters in America 10/10 kisses and hugs -Jahad read more

The stuffed shells were good but the meatballs were nothing special and not warm enough. The salad was hard to eat, too much for the bowl, and it was overdressed as well. The people were nice and the service was friendly. read more

Jerry's Pizza - The stuffed shells with a side of meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Our second time getting delivery from this place and (cus everyone deserves a second chance) again we are on a two hr wait (it's Tuesday)!!! Fortunately pizza was decent (buff chicken and meat lovers) but after two times of dinner being delivered at 945pm, when we order around 730, we will not be ordering from this place again! read more

When Jerry's pizza is properly cooked and eaten 10 minutes out of oven....and not re cooked upon arrival.....it's some of the best around. Tonight I waited too long and got an undercooked pizza and the cheese slid off and made me angry. 1/5 times the pizza is great....but the oven temp must be consistent.... I'm sick of this bs! Get your act together! Also a bottle of soda is 4.5$? Look....a pizza costs 2$ to make...I Paid 21$.... A reckoning is coming in the Middletown dining market.... When this pizza is perfect....it's amazing! All it takes is a system and quality control.... My family has pizza night once a week....Jerry's is out of my rotation from now on! Smh! Are you a bar? A market? A breakfast place? The whole empire is going to fall.....if the foundation has cracks! Get back to basics.....buts it's too late....now I can't count on you anymore! read more

This place has, without a doubt, the worst waitstaff in Middletown. 3 people "working" 30 customers and it took 35 minutes before anyone took our order. Sitting here listening to an awesome band and the waitstaff has paseed by our table numerous times, but don't bother asking if we need anything. Now there are about 60 people here, a waitstaff of 4, yet the service still is rotten. They need to hire competent workers. read more

The place was amazing and the food was spectacular. I was able to eat with the Terry Rizzenhouse as well, we shared good times, drinks and food as well. read more

I like this delivery pizza. We built our medium pizza with; ricotta, chicken, mozzarella garlic and tomato sauce. I like the crust: it was thin enough in the area with toppings and soft and crusty in the minimal crust area. It was an hour and fifteen mins for it to be delivered on a Sunday night. This is kind of long. $2 delivery fee which is cheaper than the "860 to go" option from other pizza delivery options of $4.99 delivery fee. I like them, they have decent pizza and a pretty good website. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Chicken, rigors, tomato sauce, garlic, mozzarella medium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Terrible tonight! 1 Hour 55 min for delivery, which wouldn't be bad if food was good, chick Caesar salads, 9.95 plus 5 bucks for chicken, no bigger then a 4 dollar Wendy's salad, and warm soggy lettuce! Pizza was barely warm!! Moms grinder soggy, anyway 58.00 for large cheese pizza, 2 salads, and A grinder! Wouldn't care if food was good! Done 2 weeks in a row read more

I ordered a grinder for pick up and when I arrived there was a customer waiting for his order inside WITHOUT a mask. There was a sign on the door that clearly states NO SHIRT NO MASK NO SERVICE. Staff as well as the owner were aware that this customer did not have a mask on. I immediately Questioned it and cancelled my order! Accepting this type of behavior once would lead one to believe it's something that can happen regularly. I was told that "he was only in there for a while & I made him stand over there" ( meaning in the corner near sodas that were on a rack). I love eating here but with co-vid19 now is not a time to be lenient with rules or regulations. Completely disappointed & hangry lol read more

Ok. Usually the food is good here. Good pizza. And I have ordered from them a lot. But now for the 3rd time (not in a row) there has been an issue with my food so now it's time to post a review. I will not be ordering again either. As you can tell by my name, I'm Italian. Raised Italian. So I know authentic Italian food. But you definitely don't have to be Italian to know expired meat. I got a sausage grinder and the sausage was bad. It was rancid, EXPIRED. I called just to let them know. The other times they were apologetic and gave me credit so I wasn't going to ask for anything like that or even a refund. I just wanted them to know because like I said they're ok for the most part. Whoever the guy was that got on the phone completely denied that it's bad. He says they get it fresh daily. Yeah ok buddy. Obviously NOT. Totally dismissed what I said and basically was saying I'm a liar by saying all he said. Nasty attitude. And I work at a hospital so I hope other employees from my work see this. If it want for your attitude, I wouldn't have posted but you want to basically call your customer that's spent A LOT of money there over the years, a liar so here you go. Bravissimo imbecille vai all'inferno read more

Best cheese pizza in my life. Period. I've lived in CT,ME, and now California and nothing compares to the cheese pizza at Jerrys. I always make it a point to go there whenever I'm back east. Keep doing your thang!!!! read more

I've been jonesing for pizza for about a week, so when my boyfriend suggested we go to one of his old favorite pizza places, I jumped at the chance. I'm still jonesing for real pizza. What we got was a very thin crust that wouldn't support the weight of the toppings and was pale at the edges. We didn't order an overloaded pizza either, just sausage and peppers. The sausage was sliced wafer-thin and was flavorless. I'm not usually one to sprinkle crushed red pepper on my pizza, but I had to do something to give it some flavor. My boyfriend ended up adding grated Parmesan to his for the same reason. The bar next door, Matty's, evidently has the same owners as Jerry's. At 6 pm on a Sunday night, the bass from whatever "music" they were playing over there came thudding through the common wall, making our visit unpleasant. We're crossing this place off our list. read more

Now I order from Jerry's pizza A LOT. I grew up on it. But today has been the most unprofessional conduct I have ever seen. I know it takes a good hour, sometime 1.5 hours for a delivery to portland... fine. But dont have your delivery driver call us, ask what apartment number we are, then drive off without even knocking or trying!!! This put an EXTRA 15 minutes on delivery time and my food was just ABSOLUTELY soggy. I LOVE Jerry's pizza but I dont think I will ever order again. Only reason we kept the food was because my fiance and I both worked 12 hrs and didn't eat anything all day. DISGUSTING. read more

It's a terrible place to eat. Literally would rather walk down the road to McDonald's. There boneless chicken is either way over cooked or it gets you sick read more

One of our top 5!! Nothing over the top fancy, just food service and great food and awesome pizza!!!!

We moved to Middletown last summer and Jerry's quickly became our favorite pizza place! Thin crust and amazing sauce as well as consistent service. We always get take out from here and it's ready quickly. Love this place! read more

My husbands family is born and raised in the area. We typically frequent another pizza joint When we are in town but tonight they were closed so I gave Jerrys a try. Woman who answered the phone was friendly enough, nothing to write home about. There was lots of yelling in the background and she seemed distracted. I was told 25 min which I thought was very reasonable for a Friday evening. Upon my arrival about 30 minutes later, I could immediately see where the yelling is coming from. All cooks, waitstaff and counter people are clearly frustrated with each other and it shows. I stated my name and what I ordered. The man behind the counter turned around to a stack of par-baked pizzas, pulled one out and popped it in the oven. This was an immediate turn off, I was expecting fresh pizza!!! Once he boxed it up, I saw the box on the top of the oven was the other piece to my order (garlic bread). Sure enough I got home and the garlic bread was ice cold and the pizza tasted like left overs. I couldn't stomach either, my kids were so hungry they ate it anyway. Definitely not what I expected from a "hometown" family pizza resaurant. read more

I think it's time for Jerrys to clean their ovens. What happened? Like their oven had a layer of black soot on the bottom. Entire pizza had a burnt, nasty taste to it. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Consistency here is crap. One day it's good, the next it's undercooked and sloppy. Apparently they only care about customers when you've had a bad experience, and forget about it the next time you go back. Time for this conglomerate to eat a slice of humble pie and remember the people that built them up in this town. No wonder why Matty got out, if I was him I'd be angry too. read more

I have honestly never had anything bad here. I've ordered the salads, wings, grinders and pizza. All delicious. My favorite pizza is the pizza lasagna. Grinders are a great portion even the small. I love that they deliver quality food for such an affordable price. Always friendly service too. Definitely a must try for anyone that hasn't been here read more

This review is for a large Sicilian cheese pizza. Crust: Thick like a traditional sicilian style pizza. The pizza was obviously cooked in an old pan with a thick coating of built up oil. The crust tasted of rancid oil and pan funk. Great sicilian pizza is made on a well seasoned pan sure, but this pan needed to be washed and reseasoned. The after taste in my mouth right now is honestly making me want to retch. The sauce: Pinkish in color. Tastes like something between Prego and Spaghettio sauce with lots of extra salt added. No seasoning evident besides salt. No real tomato flavor. Salty pink stuff. The cheese: Translucent and sickly in appearance. Was barely melted. Very low quality, flavorless cheese. It looked and tasted like the cheese you might find on very cheap frozen pizza. Like the $1 frozen pizza. Altogether: Hands down, worst pizza I have ever had. I'm not that picky, I will eat any pizza I spent money on. I couldn't stomach more than one slice of this pizza. True, I may only have tried one menu item here, but that one item was so utterly terrible I will never bring myself to order anything from them again. read more

I'm stunned to be giving such a low rating for this place. I had wanted to love it....the pic alone looks so damn tasty. Just goes to show...don't judge a pie by it's picture! LOL (really, Ron's pic looks very tasty!) Obviously some people have a taste for this kind of pizza. They have been in business for 40 yrs, so obviously they have a huge following.....Maybe we caught them on an off night? I thought from the pic that I would love it, thought I loved NY style (which I thought was really almost the same thing as Neapolitan)....but i guess i was wrong. I love so many kinds, altho thin and crispy in the middle with a nice fat crust (traditional Neapolitan) is my favorite for sure, but I like just about every kind of pizza.....or so I thought. Hubby was in this area today so he brought home what was supposed to be one small mozzarella to try it out, but he thought it looked so good, he got a medium cheese and a small pepperoni. I had a couple bites of 'roni and forced 1 slice of cheese. He's going to be eating the rest all week! This pizza is just plain chewy. and Plain! The Mozz did nothing to excite me, and the sauce had no real flavor either. Kind of sweet but acidic...but not in the least fresh tasting! The pepperoni was fine, but nothing to write home about. Not like Pepe's where it is so fresh and yummy that I want to pick it off the rest of the pie! LOL They say they make their dough fresh every day, i don't know how that is possible with it being soooooo chewy and hard to eat, My teeth are literally throbbing! What a tremendous disappointment. I did not eat anything all day, just in anticipation....Maybe my expectations were too high....or maybe your experience will be better than ours. If not, maybe you have more of an appetite for cardboard than we do......LOL read more

Om Nom nom nom nom nom!! Jerry's Pizza is seriously as good as it gets for me. I love pizza. LOVE IT! I seriously could live off of cold pizza as well. And getting a good pizza is like getting a good cup of coffee. When its good ITS GOOD. But when its sub par, it can really kill the mood. Or your day. But Jerry's oh man thank you for existing. I remember when I first moved to middletown and after painting my room my new roommate was like "Hungry? Like Pizza? I know the perfect place!" We ordered a clams casino pizza. Now usually I'm a bit wary about those but hoo baby this did not disappoint. So far I've gone with plain cheese, peppers and sausage, pepperoni. They just feel like they keep getting better! Also their subs are made with some WONDERFUL rolls... YUM! read more

The best fucking pizza in the world. I have been going here since I was 2 years old, and whenever I go visit my folks I always make a visit. I have eaten at numerous pizza places in NYC and Brooklyn, as well as New Haven, and this place kicks all of their asses. BOMB ASS FOOD. read more

Jerry's in the 90's was top notch, not so much now. Pizza will typically have a lake of grease on top. Be prepared for the cheese to slide right off like a marble on a ramp. Delivery: horrendous. Last time I ordered the food just straight up never arrived and they charged my card. I was able to get a refund, but I went hungry. I simply got my money back, nothing else. Typically it takes well over an hour for delivery if indeed it does come. read more

Anticipated delivery times are consistently off. Love the food but if you want to eat and you live within 2 miles don't expect your food in under two and a half hours read more

Great food but horrible customer service . The owners oldest son is very rude , he asked me " what's the problem now" when I asked for a waitress to be sent over after waiting 15 mins. When they took our order they were very rude and we watched our waitress go over and talk about us to a man at the bar .Their wings are amazing but their customer service to " non traditional customers" seem to always be an on going issue . read more

Recently, I moved to the other side of Middletown, and Jerry's became the closest pizza shop. I've gotten takeout a number of times since. Unfortunately, Jerry's is way too inconsistent, and nowadays we just tend to skip the pizza because of it. Their baked potato pie is fairly reliably good, so we will get that if we are really in the mood, but generally I just prefer not to give them my business because I never know what I'm going to get in terms of quality. Issues I generally have with their pies: 1) I don't know what they do, but half the time when we get our pizza home, the cheese has slid all over the place. I've never had this issue with any other take out pizza. 2). I've ordered pizza with toppings, and have gotten the stingiest amount of topping. Seriously, they should be ashamed. I ordered a mushroom pizza once, and had three mushrooms on my slice. If you hit them on a good day, you're in luck. If not, it's a total waste of money. read more

Just had the absolute best wings at Jerry's Sweet Chili and teriyaki Crispy, full of flavor Cooked perfect! read more

For well over half a century, Jerry's has been a family-owned Middletown treasure. Their white clam pizza is justifiably famous, and their red sauce pizzas are the best tasting non-New Haven style pizza (that is, not thin crust) anywhere. Carmela, Anthony and the rest of the family are just wonderful, and Megan, who waits tables over the lunch hour, makes everyone feel at home. Parking is easy and plentiful, and their kitchen supplies the food for the sports bar, Matty's, next door. Delivery is efficient and courteous. Other comfort foods like buffalo wings and baked manicotti are top notch. read more

When I moved to Connecticut when I was 4, this was the first meal in our new house. That was an undisclosed amount of years ago. And it is still a favorite. And I have lived in Brooklyn and New Haven. I love that they offer a full menu from the bar next door and will gladly fulfill any requests if they can. It feels like home here. :) The food is delicious and the pizza....so good. Their Siciliana is the best ever. read more

We recently tried Jerry's Pizza's wings for the 1st time on our latest visit for our monthly car club meeting. (We changed our location a few months ago because one of the guys has Celiac Disease and they have a good selection of things he can eat here.) We ordered two plates of 24 and a salad for our gluten free friend. I don't often have wings, but I definitely wouldn't hesitate to have them again! With so many flavors it was hard to decide. We ended up trying the Bourbon and the mild wings (for the old guys in my car club). They came out fresh and hot with plenty of meat on the bone, just the right amount of breading and perfectly spiced. They are a little like Hooters, but not overly breaded. Everyone loved them! We also had their pizza which is really good. We had the Loaded Baked Potato, Buffalo Chicken, a White Pizza with extra garlic and for our gluten free friend Pasta Primavera (he said it was fantastic and I can't believe he at the whole plate!). I never thought I would like broccoli in the loaded baked potato pizza, but it really worked. Everyone loved the pizzas. They said they liked how the pizza is just the right thickness. We will be back! read more

stopped by with some friends, wary of the new location. The inside definitely doesn't look right. Gone are the grease stained walls and the harsh neon lights and run down looking everything, peeling laminated news articles. fancy new wallpaper depicting pizza, seafood, pasta, all so cheesy. Young people behind the counter. 15 minutes later, SHEER MOUTH BLISS. place hasn't changed a bit. awesome. BYOB, currently read more

We were in Middleton CT for a football game against Wesleyan University. We hosted a post game tailgate to feed our players and parents following the game. We ordered from Jerry's Pizza based on feedback via yelp and other food blogs. We were not disappointed. The wings and wraps both Buffalo Chx/ Bbq Chx were delicious! We ordered a variety of pizzas and they were ALL yummy. The favorites were the white shrimp, and the buffalo Chx pizza. Best of All our delivery came exactly at the time requested so the food was hot and ready to serve. Carmela, who handles all the catering was so helpful and professional. She asked all the right questions about amount of people we were feeding in relation to the order. They even provided sturdy plates so the team could pile on the tailgate food! Thanks for helping to make our tailgate a success! read more

I eat at Jerry's several times a month and each time I go in I am never disappointed. The aroma hits you as soon as you walk in the door - immediately you feel at home. The staff is very friendly and very hard working. They keep the restaurant clean and comfortable. And the food?... The food is phenomenal. I love the pizza and have been fond of it for years. I really enjoy the Jerry's Special (Pepperoni, sausage, peppers onions and mushrooms). Every bite is overloaded with toppings. The Buffalo Chicken is spicy but not so spicy you can't finish it :) The Sicilian with Mozzarella is another one of my favorites. You'll never finish a Calzone sitting there - you'll have some leftover for another meal :) And where grinders are concerned - same thing. A small may be a good size, but get the large because you'll regret it if you don't. I'm partial to the turkey grinder, hot with roasted peppers and every time I get it, its better than the last one. The tuna grinders and eggplant grinders - also great choices. And add toppings to them, don't be shy, they probably have twenty to choose from. Thank you Jerry's for being a part of our town. We need good businesses like you. You've fed us all these years and are a great asset to our community. I will always be a big fan. read more

I work in restaurant business so trying to be empathetic but damn. Third time the food has been wrong. This time I was charged for an item I did not receive too. The wraps were soaking wet. It looked like someone dropped water in the containers before putting the food in. I don't even understand how they get that soggy and wet. Upsetting. read more

I really love this place! Between being treated like family and having plenty of food options for my healthier eating habits. Their salads and veggie burger are great. When I'm on a cheat day I usually get their wings in either hot chili or sweet bourbon. AWESOME. Anthony read more