Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Anthonys Orginal

    3.1 (53 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian, Salad
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Anthonys Orginal Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Anthonys Orginal

    Recommended Reviews - Anthonys Orginal

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Cheese Pizza Slice
    Miranda L.

    Everyone says it's hard to find good pizza in Florida, so we thought it was gonna be tough but we found it at the original Anthony's pizza in DeBary!!! The slices are perfectly cooked. Crispy, crunchy, cheesy and absolutely delectable We always sit outside, being from up north why wouldn't we but they've got seating inside too!! A local pizzeria feel inside we love it! Everyone who works there is incredibly friendly and helpful! if you're from up north and looking for an amazing slice down south this is the place to go!!

    Fettuccini
    Brian B.

    Great italian food friendly service clean dinning room. We started with garlic knots the doudh was soft nots of butter for my taste i could have gone for more garlic. They were good. The Caesar salad was cold crisp and flavorful. The veal parm was tender and the sauce was fresh and deleicious. The fettuccine was buttery and creamy. We took home canolie s they were were very good.

    Erik T.

    Save your money, ordered their "large" Stromboli for $18.99, its the size of a small,. Also got their pasta with meat sauce, virtually no sauce and tastes like store bought canned Hunts meat was barely existent and no seasoning/flavor, fried mushrooms were a soggy mush. Called the location after receiving it to make sure it wasn't a mix up, girl stated that is the "correct large". Would have been better to set $40 on fire.

    Could not eat here they had a reservation but 25 minutes still ok customers showed

    See all

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Consistently is a problem with this place. Sometimes good pizza, sometimes over cooked and salty, tonight is undercooked and doughy

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of John W.
    221
    279
    250

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of S S.
    30
    6
    1

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Anthonys Orginal

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 4,105 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nonna Maria's Pizzeria - Veal Marsala

    Nonna Maria's Pizzeria

    4.0(175 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    I have a new favorite Italian restaurant in the area AND they're open on Mondays!…read more We came in on Memorial Day which meant they were slow (apparently not a lot of pizza wanted on a grilling holiday?) but that was fine because we got a quiet restaurant and excellent service. I'm constantly chasing the flavors of my childhood Italian restaurant back home and I think I've found my closest match. First off, their pasta fagioli, absolute perfection. It's not just minestrone with pasta added in nor is it too tomatoey. It's the perfect level of veggies and pancetta and I ordered a bowl to go to have on hand as my "I'm sick" comfort food. The calamari was my only criticism, they serve it tossed in the marinara (and the spicy marinara isn't really spicy). That meant the crisp breading was soggy, but it was still well cooked and tasty - I'll just ask for sauce on the side from now on. House bread with herbed dipping oil - delightful outer crust and fluffy inside. My father had a caesar salad which was his only criticism - it came with a packet of Ken's brand dressing. For a place making most things from scratch, why they'd do commercial dressing let alone in a packet is beyond me. My father's veal marsala was cooked tender and the sauce wasn't overpoweringly marsala-y as many can be. My chicken francaise had the same level of meat tenderness and sauce balance and both came with perfectly cooked pasta. We had to judge on all levels of our go-to foods so we also ordered a slice of pepperoni which came with a sauce that wasn't too much nor too sweet and excellent cheese pull, thin but not cracker crunchy crust that has actual FLAVOR. Great ambiance, fun and attentive staff, and food near perfection - we have a new favorite!

    Our first experience here wasn't the greatest. Ordered some food to go, and our family was split so…read morehalf ordered Chinese and half pizza. We were told 40-45 minutes on the pizza and timed the Chinese order accordingly. We sat in the parking lot waiting for an additional 20 mins past the 45 minute time for picking up. The pizza was good, but a bit soggy, the bruschetta bread seemed stale so we ended up using my homemade sourdough, and then it had good flavor. Just overall not the best experience - we might give them another try, but to spend $50+ dollars with tip on a pizza and bruschetta and have it all be a bit disappointing makes it difficult to consider trying again.

    Photos
    Nonna Maria's Pizzeria
    Nonna Maria's Pizzeria - Garlic Knots

    Garlic Knots

    Nonna Maria's Pizzeria - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Blue Springs Brewing- Riverwalk Pizzeria & Brew Pub - Meat lovers Pizza

    Blue Springs Brewing- Riverwalk Pizzeria & Brew Pub

    4.1(228 reviews)
    4.1 mi
    $$

    Been coming here for a bit now, and the biggest thing I love here is the consistency! The pizza is…read moreby a long shot and IMO the best in the area. Very good happy hour deals and runs from 2-7 and half price apps. Love to hit up this place after a long day of work. They have a good variety of craft beer. But also make cocktails. Brad and the team behind the bar are absolutely amazing. They are efficient, professional and so friendly. The glass never hits empty! If you've wondered why it's full, pass on by! If it's empty, stop by even sooner!

    We were visiting the manatees and grabbed a beer from the snack shop at Blue Springs when we became…read moresmitten with the logo of the beer they were serving. Learned about where the beer could be found and after we visited the hundreds of sea cows we were off to find the brewery. Super sweet staff, great pizza, and really great beer! We both got tasters (honestly we were swayed to get he flight because the boarding is swerved on us manatee shaped lol) and we ended up LOVING the cactus sour. So much so that we took a growler home. And tank tops. And stickers. And koozies LOL Very much looking forward to going back and sitting on their patio which appears to be quite inviting! You could tell thee were lots of locals and regulars there between the different seating areas of low tips, high tops, and oodles of bar space. One star removed though because - y'all, your beer and food is too good for you to NOT take the extra step and make your own ranch dressing.

    Photos
    Blue Springs Brewing- Riverwalk Pizzeria & Brew Pub - Bar area

    Bar area

    Blue Springs Brewing- Riverwalk Pizzeria & Brew Pub - Hawaiian pizza

    Hawaiian pizza

    Blue Springs Brewing- Riverwalk Pizzeria & Brew Pub

    See all

    La Strega Bistro

    La Strega Bistro

    4.4(138 reviews)
    0.3 mi

    The wood fire pizza with prosciutto is the best! All staff…read moreare always so happy, inviting. We love taking out and dinning in. Every time is always enjoyable. Even when we are waiting for takeout the chef brings out new tasty items to sample. Just love this place and the family atmosphere feel.

    I really wanted to like this establishment as the name and the menu seemed very appealing. They…read morehave a great selection of Italian items on the menu and the name of the items would lead you to believe that it's truly amazing. Authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant itself is disappointing. You feel like you're walking into a Mediterranean restaurant and it's very casual in the atmosphere and decorations. I dined with a group of individuals and we all felt the same about the food in that it had zero depth of flavor or in the case of the broccolini and the chicken marsala, they both had a distinct sour flavor. We all asked for Parmesan cheese, which is not served as a part of the meal, you do need to ask for it. And we all needed salt. The service was another disappointment. Although they were nice and friendly, they were not attentive in just a little things were left off. When we raise concerns about the soreness of the food, they said that that's the way it was supposed to be. Overall, the price would lead you to believe that this is an upscale restaurant and the experience is very downscale

    Photos
    La Strega Bistro  - Wine

    Wine

    La Strega Bistro  - Tiramisu

    Tiramisu

    La Strega Bistro

    See all

    Big Love Pie - Hand made everything...

    Big Love Pie

    4.0(4 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $$

    The food truck experience can be fun, and deliver a lot of variety. But never quite so much…read morescenery since you're staring at, well, a boxy truck. Not so with Big Love Pie. Sure it's portable, and sure it shows up at locations convenient to entertainment, just like food trucks. But it's an open trailer with a massive, gorgeous wood-fired pizza oven that's immediately visually appealing. A big part of the fun is watching them precisely control the wood temperature, smoke amount and flow, and tend to the fresh pizza you're about to enjoy. First you'll watch your home-made dough hand-stretched and hand tossed, then topped with items that vary by the visit. The whole process is entertaining and definitely whets the 'tite. And the result... wow! What an amazing crust! Your pie is about 12-ish inches in diameter with the outer 3/4" to 1" left mostly untopped, and for a good reason -- that crust alone might be your favorite part. It's thin, it's crispy, it's chewy, and it's almost flaky, put not quite pastry. It holds up and doesn't crumble, so you can pick up a slice of it just like it's a piece of New York pizza and fold it to hold in one hand. Not that those toppings will disappoint you. There are always a couple of staples, like plain cheese -- a creamy-good mozzarella -- which you can get in a zippy but light tomato or a white bianca sauce. And of course pepperoni in either sauce. They had goat's cheese and I got the impression that's something they offer most or all nights. The special toppings vary, and can be as simple as maple-chicken sausage with basil, or my fave, their super-thick, meaty bacon, diced flavorful tomatoes, topped with arugula. A squirt of balsamic sauce is a staple drizzle option, and perfect with this bacon-tomato number. Oh, and they'll make about anything you want... as long as they have the ingredients there. Owners Tom & Tracy are talkative, so I hung around to watch the process, and learned how much care goes into it -- how they've perfected the recipes. They even bring in special water for the dough so the minerals and pH deliver the right consistency that makes it marvelous. Their yeast is classified secret. The wood used requires a certain amount of seasoning times, and until now i never realized things like flame-rollover (affected by shape of the oven -- they've chosen an igloo configuration) and differences in temperature from oven floor matter so very much in how a pizza bakes. Their igloo-shaped oven is a heavy, concrete and mastik, tiled monster. Not sure any food truck can replicate the size and openness. The owners made it themselves after extensive study about what they theorized would distribute heat and flame ideally. The crust tells me they sure got it right. Some random but useful notes: They're not always at Central28. On Fridays and Saturdays they're currently at Celery City Brewing in Sanford. Beverages are just limited to canned sodas. Sometimes they will fold over that wood-fired dough into a sandwich style -- their salami, which I sampled, is well-chosen and doesn't rely on too much salt. They also have Crucially, there is a limited amount of dough and when they run out all you can do is watch the coals glow and wish you got there earlier. Still a nice view. I really enjoy watching that oven... simple things amuse me perhaps. Finally, I got the impression that the owners weren't yet sure what they have on their hands here -- they seem to have a lot of opportunities but it's clear from many things they do (limited amount per night) they want to keep things special -- they're perfectly with making fewer but better pizzas. That feeling came out in everything they said. So it's a "Craft-Style" Wood-Fired Pizza. It's truly "artesanal," an oft-misused word which should mean small, handmade batches that are never quite uniform, and totally original to the artist. It goes well with your Craft-Brewed Beer from whatever place they're parked outside of. Pricing (menu photo) is so well within reason it's not even a thought. A pizza can fill two light appetites or well-satisfy a hungry solo. I stupidly told them it was too cheap for this level of quality...(Then clamped my mouth shut. I hope that doesn't cost me on my next visit!) The downsides are kinda obvious: limitations on the portable (food truckish) style. I'll mention 'em: There's only a place to sit in the establishments they're near -- they have no tables. They have a VERY limited menu. You'll get wood-fired pizza or sandwiches. Salads or sides are infrequent. They're in different places different nights, so you hafta know where they'll be, but I think they're now posting location and menu specials nightly on Facebook (@biglovepie) which is easy to check. And no, there's no alcohol -- that's the point...these folks do the food right outside where you get your beer. Big Love Pie does one great thing, and does it better than anybody else I've tasted, maybe ever.

    Wow what a pleasant surprise for a pizza on wheels. Amazing wood fired Pizza !! Just wow a must try.read more

    Photos
    Big Love Pie - Tom hand forms and tosses every crust.

    Tom hand forms and tosses every crust.

    Big Love Pie - Fun to watch them roll over the flame at night...

    Fun to watch them roll over the flame at night...

    Big Love Pie - Tom of Tom and Tracy, propietors of Big Love Pie.

    See all

    Tom of Tom and Tracy, propietors of Big Love Pie.

    Anthonys Orginal - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...