First time ordering from here since I was in the area and I'm always looking for authentic & Italian pizza! It was easy to call, order ahead, and pickup. The restaurant is small and with a standard theme, but it was neat and clean. The food was hot and fresh too. Right off the bat, I was excited to try the pizza. I'm tired of all the chain pizza places in the area, and Anthony's did not disappoint. The flavor was interesting, maybe an acquired taste with whatever ingredients they use, but I still enjoyed it! Especially the thin & crunchy crust, not doughy! The mozzarella sticks were also as expected. I have no complaints and would like to try an entree sometime. read more

Anthonys - Mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Greer, South Carolina

See all

Since my last review I have ordered take out from there several times. It has been consistently tasty pepperoni pizza. I also tried a slice of the Grandma pizza which i enjoyed. The Grandma pizza has Roma tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella cheese and olive oil. read more

A popular local spot in Greer that sells good pizza, but felt there could have been some improvements. I ordered an 18 inch pizza to get the big NY pizza taste. The pizza was good, but asides being slightly bigger, I felt it was not much different than your typical local pizza restaurants in the update. More specifically, the quality is not what several reviews are calling NY pizza. Single slices are available, but I felt that they were underwhelming. I ate my Sicilian slice not long after I received my order, but whether it was out there all day or not, it just tasted ok. Service is pretty good! It was a full house inside with multiple families with a lot of young children and the staff did a good job attending to everyone. My order took 20-25 minutes to felt, but I thought that was fine considering how busy it was. Overall, it's good pizza, just not "New York" pizza. I'd try it again in hopes that I'm wrong. read more

See all

Wonderful place. They get BUSY. Came here for lunch. Sicilian cheese slice was delicious. I also got their lunch shrimp scampi. Very generous portion and it tasted so fresh. So much better than other places. I came a second time and got different slices of pizza and they were all yummy. read more

See all

I follow many Facebook foodie pages and Anthony's is one of the top choices for a lot of pizza posts. The hype is there. The pizza was perfectly cooked, crispy, and flavorful. The [fresh] garlic knots were great, and the chicken parm plate was HUGE. Could easily feed two people and then some probably. While it's not a typical restaurant style, there is plenty seating available. You do place your order up at the counter. The service was great and we were attended politely. Definitely see why Anthony's is at the top of a lot of people's lists. read more

See all

By far the absolute best pizza in the area. We love the Sicilian pie and the regular large with meatball is no slouch, either. Consistently perfect, great sauce and they have no problem making half the pie as you request. Love this place! read more

I can't say enough good things about this place. From pizza to pastas to sandwiches it has all been great! Everyone in the store is also super friendly. My go to spot if I'm craving pizza! read more

We order mozzarella sticks, large pizza with pepperoni and sausage and spaghetti and meatballs. The Mozzarella stick had a good cheese pull; pizza has huge slices cooked to perceive my book and spaghetti was a hit for my 3yr old. The service is great and it's a quaint place to eat. read more

See all

Only open for a few months but very good food. I had the pizza and meatball sub and fries. New favorite spot. Didn't like having to use ketchup packets but at least they were Heinz. read more

Anthonys - Very good pizza. 7.4 - Pizza Near Me - Greer, South Carolina

See all

Very good pizzas! I moved back south after living in New Haven CT area. Pizza Capital of NE. I'm happy to report I finally found a pizzeria worthy of the honor of being called a Pizzeria! Service was great and timely for pickup! read more

Super Fresh salads, delicious thin crust, the best sauce, friendly staff and owner. We love that this is close to our home. They offer takeout but we prefer to eat there while food is at its piping hot best. read more

I have become a huge fan of Anthony's for their pizza!! This past Sunday, I called early to place an order for a pizza and 30 wings. I called around 3pm and asked for a pickup at 6pm (I did so in anticipation of it being busy because of the football games). I asked for the wings to be done extra crispy. The order wasn't ready on time and the wings were not crispy at all. I'll stick to ordering pizza from them though. I love the pepperoni pizza the best. read more

Genuine nyny style pizza, pasta, and service. They even sell slices. My new happy place. Being from nj, I am glad to have such a good Italian restaurant close by. It's not white tablecloth or anything but it's good and quick. read more

Hands down my favorite pizza. Thank you guys so much for dinner. The Anthony special is my go to. read more

Anthonys - Pizza Near Me - Greer, South Carolina

We got delivery of the 18" Emily's pizza (meat) today. (Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, & meatball). It's huge! Very good flavor, and delivery without a hitch. Will def order again. Also ordered tiramisu but haven't dug into that yet. read more

Good cheese, crust has great snap, and sauce ratio/flavor is on point. Very good ny style pizza

Great NY style pizza. Small local pizza shop here in Greer. Has indoor seating. Customer friendly staff. You can order delivery through the Slice app. Garlic rolls were good. The onion rings were a little on the well-done side but could be a one-off. I have gone back multiple times for the pizza. Plain cheese was perfect. The veggie pizza was delicious as well read more

This place is fantastic. Been here twice and it had been so refreshing getting a real NY style pizza

Just wow!!! It's like being in NY again. There is no reason why this place which by the way has only been open not that long, will out grow where they are located. The crisp, sauce, and taste is bada bing!!!!! read more

Where do I start I am from NY and this has to be the worst experience with pizza I have had in SC so far. My son would not even eat the food. It had so much salt you need a gallon of water to quench yourself. The sauce had no taste and the meat tasted cheap. I would skip this one ladies and gentlemen. read more

Bright spots are that the Pizza is pretty good as are the garlic knots. Sub Sandwiches are ok but very skimpy on sauce. Never get the eggplant dinner - virtually no eggplant and even less sauce. The meal was definitely not "ny" style. I'd go back for the pizza but won't try any other meals. read more

Seriously delicious pizza!! Anthony's NY Pizzeria has friendly staff & a great atmosphere. Looking forward to eating here often.

Amazing pizza. Will be back for sure. Everything was great. From the crust to the sauce and the cheese everything was balanced. The garlic knots were amazing as well. read more

Anthonys - Perfection - Pizza Near Me - Greer, South Carolina

See all

The staff were definitely NOT as sweet as their pizza sauce but it is VERY sweet tasting. Not a bad value for the size of their pizzas. There's a lot better pizza in this area. read more

Great tasting pizza and Greek salad. Very reasonable pricing. Friendly staff. Definitely will eat there again.