Bertolos is my go-to pizza place in Pelham! My fiance and I discovered Bertolos because they left a free pizza coupon at his apartment mailbox when he moved in. We tried it and it was delicious. Not only is the pizza good, but the pastas are to die for. The portions are very generous and the sauce is PERFECT. I love getting the sausage pizza- but I am going to try the meatballs next! I also love their salad. The prices are great and take out is so easy and quick. I will obviously be coming here again and often! read more

Zero atmosphere- AC was turned so low it felt like a meat locker. The employees were nice, the pizza tasted good, but the crust was so soft. Pizza was gooey at the center. The antipasti salad was good, lots of meat and veg. However, even after putting the leftovers in the oven- we had pizza soup. NY pizza- the crust should hold up- so this was not that. read more

We went on a busy Friday night. The service was quick and friendly. We ordered at the counter. The worker answered all my questions about the Hawaiian pizza. We decided on half pepperoni and half Hawaiian. It took a while to get to our table but they were pretty busy. The pizza was well cooked. The sauce was tasty. The Hawaiian side was a little soggy because of the vegetables and pineapples. The pepperoni side was good but not great. It was a pretty basic NY style pizza. We did enjoy it though. We will go back and try other toppings. I also got a garden salad with Italian dressing And crackers. I enjoyed the salad very much. read more

ordered a meat supreme and it had a few diced pieces of ham and a few crumbs of sausage. looked like a cheese pizza. Not worth the money.

The pizza here is the best I've found since moving here from Jersey 2 years ago. Always happy with the pizza here. Give it a try you won't be disappointed. read more

You need more sauce ! Dry spaghetti had garlic bread nothing to scoop up more sauce please

So I have not ordered from here in a while... And decided to give this a try again. Unfortunately my take out order....which was called in... And I did not check until I got home....so that is on me. However I ordered sundried tomatoes and they placed regular tomatoes....if you don't have them... Just tell me. Don't apply a substitute.... In addition.,.there was no basil... Pizza tasted ok...and that's a 3 star... Lousy customer service is a 1 star. I will take my own advice and check my orders. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Those are not sundried tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

Most NY-Authentic pie I've ever had! Classic mom & pop shop and the best pizza in Greenville, SC!

Spaghetti lunch special, large serving size!! Hot and fresh. This is my second time here, no prices listed on the menu board, someone needs to wipe tables down after guests leave, both times I've had to sit at a dirty table, that is my only complaint. Compliments...great food, service. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Spaghetti, salad garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

Food came out hot to the point had to wait until it cooled off before could eat!! Pizza was very good

Best Pizza I've ever had! Thank you Bertollos' on Pelham! You make it worth it every single time.

This place is delicious. We got two large pizzas. One was just cheese and the other was half and half. So good and classic. The crust was nice and chewy and not crispy and crunchy. Pizza didn't take long at all to pick up. I can't wait to come back for another pizza fix. read more

See all

Decent pizza, nothing better than we have in Seattle. Could use spicing up the sauce and adding more cheese at $24 for a medium pizza. Okay inside, looks like a sports card shot couple tvs, these dudes gotta get into action and raise above the bar!! read more

Best pizza in town!! Amazing customer service! Clean environment. Hardworking staff. read more

Pizza and pizza bites are great. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Strombolis are very large. I suggest sharing one.

Calling all my 80s babies!!! If you grew up eating pizza out and find tall red plastic cups with crushed ice and pop comforting you'll probably be a fan of Bertolo's. Sadly, no red cups or crushed ice buuuut the rest is a win. Great prices, delicious pizza & spaghetti for the littles (and the bigs) that's not over cooked and mushy. Add some sports TV in the background and ultra casual seating, sprinkle in a few questionable ceiling tiles and we're jn business. Highly recommend eating in since the pizza is best fresh but save yourself a weeknight meal and save your wallet!! Good service, clean tables and good food. read more

Really enjoyed the pizza flavor and thickness. Nice crunchy/doughy balance. Will be back!

10/10 definitely recommend. Went during lunch and the food and service was too notch amazing

It's been too long my friend. I missed you Bertolo's. I haven't been to Bertolo's in a few years. As Great as I remember. Why, why, why am I so stupid?.... Don't be stupid Go to Bertolo's. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - White Pie with ricotta, garlic, tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

It's top 2 in the area for pizza and my takeout favorite because it holds up better than sidewall if you can't eat right away. 2nd overall to sidewall for dine-in. They have messed up a few of my orders so be sure to check before you leave the parking lot. read more

First time trying Bertolo's and was not disappointed. Ordered a pepperoni, a sausage pepperoni and green olive, and a buffalo chicken pizza. All tasted great. Real happy with the Buffalo Chicken pizza. It was better than expected. Crust was nice and chewy and sauce was excellent. Definitely will be going back. read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Greenville. While I appreciate a fancy wood fired pizza, you can't go wrong with a small, hole-in-the-wall pizza place for weeknights or busy weekends. I usually get the pizza by the slice, and their garlic knots are AMAZING. Pizza/dipping sauce tastes homemade. My boyfriend loves the hot and cold subs as well! read more

Popped in for a slice. Service was a little backed up but the staff was very helpful and friendly. I really liked the pizza and salad was fresh! Very well priced read more

Everything about this place seems like it would be average, but when you experience it, it becomes above average. The food is good and worth the stop. The garlic knots are a must. Also,the pizza and Stromboli are above average and very good. I would go again if I lived in town. Great staff. Very friendly. read more

See all

This is family run pizza restaurant that has it's roots way back with Two Guys Pizza from the old Greenville Mall. The original Two Guys was opened by an Italian immigrant Piero Bertolo and the recipe and name carries on today at Bertolo's. This is a NY style pizza with the thin crust and zesty Italian tomato sauce. Typical of the style, the thin crust can be flimsy, which is why New Yorker's fold their pizza. This location also has a birthday party option for kids to make their own pizza and learn how to do that. Most of the time, we call ahead and do take out orders, there is no delivery. Recently, we decided to eat in. Rick, the owner (or one of them) and his family were there running things. They are very friendly. I've never had a bad pizza experience here and it is our "go to" pizza choice. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Other than pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

See all

This has been our go-to local Italian eatery for the better part of two decades now. I've probably tried everything on the menu, with their Italian or Meatball subs being my favs, like the ones shown in my pic. It's not really the best Italian joint around, but then again, it's not trying to be. Prices are more than reasonable and their service is always stellar. The real plus is that I don't ever think I've had a bad experience in the dozens upon dozens of times we've dined here. Pizza is NY style and unpretentious. Spaghetti and Ziti dishes are always fresh and hot, Calzones are massive and can feed two, garlic knots are always hot and buttery. Antipasto salads are also a great alternative if you're in the mood for something other than pasta and/or carbs. Enjoy! read more

See all

Good service. Pizza was decent. It's good to pick up one if you're in the area and you're wanting a pizza not from the chains. Dough was fluffy and chewy. I like most types of dough so no issue there. Sauce was ok and the cheese ok. Nothing really stood out in the flavors. I will go back and try the knots and pasta and prob order a cheese again. Friendly place. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

This is place where you must order at the counter - they'll give you your cups to self-fill at the drink station and then they'll bring the food to you when done. The food is excellent but they have flimsy plastic utensils. OK, so those people that love the New York Style pizza eat it with their hands, but there are those that like to use utensils, too. And there are plenty of other items offered that a sturdier set of utensils would be nice. While we were there, one of the workers ate a salad on her break - she had metal utensils! How about for the other patrons, too. read more

Good pizza Slices are very big and tasty they offer good lunch specials can fill up fast at lunch deffinatly worth a try read more

The pizza was hot and delicious!! The salad was fresh and green. Service was excellent. Jammin Joe read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

Aaaaah-mazing! I asked the locals where I could find a good pizza place, and I am ok with a hole-in-the-wall as long as it's the best. I was not disappointed. There was a long line in the afternoon during the week so I do suggest you call ahead if you are hungry or short on time. I took a bite and fell in love. I will be back. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

Ordered a large cheese. Gave us a small cheese and argued about it. Gave us another small cheese. Horrible service. Been coming here since mid 2000s and service has been awful. Will be taking our business elsewhere. read more

For New York Style Pizza in South Carolina, this was pretty darn good. The dough here was absolutely amazing and their standard 16" pizza was the perfect thickness, sauce level and cheese amount. I haven't had pizza any place else in Greenville, but this was pretty darn good. I also recommend the Sicilian Pizza (really thick crust, not deep dish chicago style, just really doughy.) It was really good and this dough just had a great flavor and texture. Two things made this a great experience. 1) Red Pepper Flakes, Parmesan, Garlic and Oregano at the table... not every day do you see that... 2) 5 guys ate like kings for $40. Others had different versions of the hot sandwiches and they all looked good, especially the steak and peppers sandwich. Check it out if you are anywhere around Pelham Rd. read more

Bertolo's Pizza - Front of Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, South Carolina

Great pizza, friendly service are just the start. The garlic knots are where it's at.

Great tasting pizza and friendly staff. Out of all the places we have tried for pizza they by far have the most authentic tasting sauce.

Bertolo's is the ONLY place that we order from, and there's a reason for that: the people here (quite obviously) give a damn; the cheese that they use is very high quality; the marinara sauce is homemade; the cold cuts are good. The portions are good, and prices fair. The people working the counter are nice. Too many Italian restaurants in Greenville skimp. They skimp on the quality of the cheese they use (it's flavorless and too oily); the food is greasy, etc. Bertolo's is none of these things, and the quality of the food they serve is not an accident. So...although Bertolo's isn't NYC/Philly/Boston style Italian food, Bertolo's is very delicious food, well prepared, by people who are friendly. For those reasons Bertolo's gets our business. And...even though the pizza isn't crispy on the outside (they need to ditch the pizza screens or get hotter ovens), it is the best tasting around. read more

This really is a good and delicious place if you want pizza and that with wholesome ingredients and fast service. I tend to being particular when it comes to pizza and I have never been dissatisfied or disappointed in their pizza. read more

My favorite pizza place. I drive 30 minutes or more to get it. We have lived in the area for 7 years and have tried a lot of places. Bertolo's is consistently delicious. Just enough crust and topping ratio. To be honest I have only had the pizza Maybe some day I'll try other menu items but for now I'll stick with the pizza read more

What a great family run pizza joint. Place was full with many carry out orders as I waited for my food. Very homey feel to this place. The cashier was soooo friendly and smiled and made me feel so welcomed (I was just in town for business and felt like I had been here many times). I decided on the manicotti and a slice of cheese pizza. Price was very reasonable, a little cheap for dinner actually. Portions were nice. The manicotti was good. A lot of flavor in The cheese pizza And the crust was just the right Crispy. The Pizza crust was A thin crust style and was really really tasty. I'll be back before I leave This town And if you're in the mood for pizza I would recommend this place highly. read more

Great pizza, awesome sauce, and staff is so friendly. Wings are delish too!!! Has become a staple for great pizza and wings. Do have one critique- we ordered a mushroom pepperoni pizza and were sad to see the mushrooma were canned. Although there are lots of great pizza places in Greenville I still say everyone should check them out if you are on this side of town. read more