This is a small pizza shop in the five forks area of Simpsonville. They have a few tables to sit down and a small bar area to eat at. Their pizza is delicious. We tried a large pepperoni. We loved their cheese and sauce. It was a great NY style pizza. You order at the counter and they bring the pizza to your table. Thanks Anthony's for serving delicious NY style pizza in Upstate SC. We will be back for more! read more

This is a neighborhood gem. Lots of options for every type of person. Easy fast and really good read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

I really enjoyed the cheesesteak! It was takeout so I'm unable to comment on the ambiance. Staff were friendly.

Absolutely love the taste of their food. Low key, family-run restaurant for typical quick Italian pizza, wings, subs. Simple dining area (booths/tables) with service that is always friendly and prices that are decent. The online ordering is well done as well with live tracking/text updates. read more

Best pizza in the area! Even cauliflower pizza crust was amazing! The staff was very attentive and looked to make sure you had everything you need! The restaurant was clean and inviting. My family have gone back several times. read more

Stopped by Anthony's Pizzeria for a late lunch with my great niece. We ordered a medium pizza on a thin crust(1.79 extra for the thin crust) with pepperoni and ground beef. The medium pizza was a lot larger than some of the local chain pizza places( Papa Johns, Dominos and Romeos just to name a few). The crust though it was thin, wasn't the normal "cracker like crust", but it was thinner the their regular crust and it was tasty. The pizza was sliced into 8 pieces, we only ate 2 pieces each. The left over was for dinner. The only draw back was, the pizza did not taste as good reheated and the taste was off, I think it was from the to go box they use. That being said, it's always nice to spend time with family. read more

See all

I have to rate this restaurant honestly based on my experience. I ordered 2 slices (Sicilian style) around dinnertime. I asked for extra sauce and was told modifications couldn't be made. I was okay with that. I assumed the slices would taste hot and fresh (even if pre-made). They tasted old and lukewarm at best. The cheap price saved a 1 star, but if you offer slices for sale they need to be hot and fresh. The product I had was subpar. read more

Hands down the best pizza place around. The crust is perfect! Really enjoy the white pizzas too. Service is great!

I've heard a lot about this place so this was on my bucket list. Tucked at the end of a busy shopping center on a busy road. Lots of parking! I came here for lunch with a friend. The staff was super friendly and helpful. I got the lunch special-two slices of pizza and a drink. I added toppings to it. The pizza was crispy and chewy at the same time. Generous slices. I will definitely come here again! read more

See all

I ordered this off of Uber so I can't comment on the ambience. The pie was cooked pretty quick and everything was good in the delivery. We had the supreme and it was very good. I ordered it with extra sauce and mozzarella, which I don't think was necessary as it kind of overwhelmed the pizza. Next time I try this place, and I will, I think I'll go there and get the same pizza just stock no upgrades. read more

This place was really good back in the day but now the flavor has changed and we just can't justify an 80$ pizza order that is inferior to past products. read more

There is a place on Facebook called Greenville foodies, it recommended this pizzeria. Being quite skeptical about places we were not familiar about we thought we would try it last weekend.The pizza was really delicious, and also the salads we ordered. The owner an Italian gentleman came to our table and asked if the food was enjoyable, we assured him it was, his daughter was working there and she was very charming. Apparently the owner had operated a business for 31 years before relocating to S.C.The menu also advertised an assortment of pasta, and a few other items. I highly recommend this place. I would be a frequent customer, but unfortunately I live in California, and am just visiting my family here in Taylors. Greer S.C. read more

It is the best New York style pizza in all of the upstate. The food is great and the service is fantastic. My wife and I go there at least once a week. read more

First time trying this place. So I really didn't know what to expect. I ordered online. It said up to 25 minutes so I went around 15 minutes after I ordered in case. When I got to the counter the girl said it's only been 15 minutes since you ordered. (My bad some places are sooner) I said when should I come back and she said 10 minutes. So I left and came back after 10 . I sat another 3 minutes and my name was called. The wings were delicious. I got the hot wings to please the house. I got the Nashville? Hot on the side and it was hot but not like a buffalo flavor but still good. The kids devoured the cheese pizza and I liked it too. The spinach, feta, ham was my pick. It was very good not greasy; the crust was great. My only sadness was the flavor of the whole pizza was overpowered by the feta. I needed more sauce to balance. But I threw on some crushed peppers and it gave it that extra I needed. I would absolutely go back but dine in next time. read more

See all

This is the best pizza in Simpsonville! I go out of my way for Anthony's Pizza or ask my wife to swing by there! read more

Pizza is great, fresh and crispy without being too crunchy or over cooked. I love their choice of toppings

I've never gotten bad food or service here. If it's delivery, to go or sit down; the food and staff are always on point. As a midwestern transplant I've always sought out great prices for pizza and wings; and I do believe you cannot go wrong with this establishment. My children and I love the pizza, and I adore their hot wings. If we are nearby we take advantage of their fabulous lunch specials or we will get it delivered when a pizza craving is happening. The staff is always friendly and when I once ordered cookies for delivery, they sent cannolis with a sorry we don't have cookies note; which was even better. I appreciate this local and consistently stellar business read more

See all

Still the very best pizza around! The thin crust is our favorite, SO yummy, served piping hot, with sauce just spicy enough, plenty of cheese covering delicious ingredients. We always buy the extra large so we can take leftovers home. Apparently it's "under new..." but whatever it is the quality and service remain excellent. read more

See all

Always friendly, never screw up the order, food is legit... We always do take out so I can't speak objectively about ambiance, except that I've never been turned off by it. It's old school for sure, and this old geezer's okay with that;) read more

Went back to Anthony's for Pizza and Folks just as Good as the Last Time In. Pizza was Fresh and Hot with those Great Toppings!!! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Inside Dining!!! - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

Good pizza - friendly service. We always get it to go, so I can't speak to the atmosphere. Have only had their pizza which we look. Look forward to trying other menu items. read more

Wish I would had remembered to take a pic before we dug in. The pizza was delivered by Door Dash and it came hot and fresh. The pizza was excellent. Very much recommend! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Super NY Pizza and Italian Dishes some of the best we've had in the Upstate if not the best!!! Huge portions enough to really enjoy, Friendly staff! read more

This place is always delicious. They have daily specials and their pizzas and pasta dishes are extremely tasty. Prices are reasonable for the portion size. Good place for family dinner or to go orders. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Stuffed shells with added Italian sausage - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Ok pizza here in South Carolina has been hit and miss for sure. This place however is about as close to actual pizza as I think SC is capable of creating so this might be my new go to pizza shop. It would be a 3 star pizza in NY or NJ but elsewhere in the country it is 4 or 5 star. Place is reasonably priced and service was polite. It is next to a liquor store and doesn't look fancy so ya might have second thoughts walking up to the place but trust me, it is good NY style pizza. I cant say anything about the rest of the menu as all I had was the pizza read more

See all

First time trying Anthony's since Anthony sold the business. I was happy to see that the inside hasn't changed much. The iconic pizza crust that Anthony always used has been changed, its not bad it's missing that bite the chew and it has changed the flavor of the pizza itself. The antipasto salad was delicious and the Greek dressing was great. Overall not bad. I will be back. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

See all

Pizza was good. Fries were a must to order! Ranch dressing was amazing! Extremely clean restrooms. Friendly staff. Can order by the slice for the odd-ball of the group! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

Pizza was great - happy to have found a place that does good pizza by the slice. I'm a fan of traditional pepperoni and felt like authentic NY-style sliced pizza. I don't know if this is all the time, but when I went in they had a deal for 2 slices and a drink for around $7 (with tax). I waited for 5 minutes and took it to-go, and in case you're wondering it does travel well! I had it about 15 minutes later and it was still warm and tasty. They are on Bite Squad, so it's perfect if you're looking for a delivery pizza fix without having to order a whole pizza! One thing I would add is that they use styrofoam cups - let's try switching to a more eco-friendly container! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - 2 slices of pepperoni pizza to-go - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We did to go...pizza was great and definitely want to try more of the menu. We had the meat lovers and white pizza. Good crunch and chewiness on the crust. Food was ready when promised. read more

I have been here a couple of times and it has been fantastic both times. Today, we had pizza on our brains and this was the perfect place to quench the pepperoni thirst. The staff was friendly and polite. The place was clean and neat, but still had a little "hole in the wall" feel. I started with a cup of sweet tea. Perfectly sweetened, not over the top syrup, but plenty sweet for southern tea. Then to a nice side salad with ranch dressing. Pretty standard salad, but the dressing was great. Definitely mixed in house if not from scratch. We had a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. The crust was thin with a little crunch on the bottom. The mushrooms were fresh, not canned and the sauce had a very nice flavor. It was definitely not Ragu. The cheese was hot and stringy. When you took a bite, you had to be careful or all the cheese would come along for the ride. Had to bite carefully to break the cheese string. Overall great experience for a quick bite stop. We will take the long way home more often to stop by here. read more

The service was great and the food was even better. The daily specials are a great deal and go all day long. The food runner was very kind and attentive. Will definitely be back!! read more

Best NY style pizza in the upstate & amazing pasta fagioli soup. The service is fantastic

I tried Anthony's for the first time this weekend. I'm a native New Yorker so I'm very critical about pizza. I had two pepperoni slices and some chicken wings. Both very very good. So, why just 3 stars. Because I was very disappointed that the restaurant is taking absolutely no precautions to prevent the spread of the Corona virus. They have a lot of employees behind the counter all working close together with no masks on at all. There were about 30-40 customers in the restaurant and I was the only person in the place wearing a mask (not that they're responsible for their customers). But I have no confidence that there was any sanitization occurring of counter tops, table tops or any other surfaces other than normal cleaning. South Carolina just experienced a record weekend of new Coronavirus cases and deaths this weekend (still low compared to other states but high for SC). I think businesses like this that are pretending that the pandemic is over are doing the community a disservice. The pizza is really good but I won't be returning until they put precautions in place or until this pandemic has TRULY passed. read more

Visited Anthony's twice. First time was for some baked ziti and I think mozzarella sticks. It wasn't memorable. I was looking for some brick oven pizza and saw that Anthony's was highly recommended. Decided to try the supreme. It was alright, probably could've gotten the same quality for cheaper elsewhere. We did put it in the air fryer which made it better so maybe order well done if you like it crispier. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - 16" Large Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simpsonville, South Carolina

We ordered delivery from UE from this restaurant and were pleasantly surprised. Excellent salad (especially nice presentation) and pizza. Very good crust but needed a bit more sauce and to be cooked longer (very white). Good cheesecake but the cannoli filling was runny. Overall, we would definitely recommend Anthony's and hope to try dining in here soon. read more

Called in order for take out. Told it would be 20 minutes. Arrived at restaurant and told it would be 10 minutes. After 20 minutes. The order was ready. I received the order approximately 1 hour after I called in the order. Don't tell takeout customers 20 minutes if it is going to take 1 hour. The food was okay. Had baked ziti. I have had better. read more

Great pizza and wings!! Love the thin, authentic taste of the pizza and the wings are fantastic!! Never had anything bad here and the service was great!!!! read more

Received an incorrect pizza. Had toppings that we could not eat do to a severe allergy. Paid $55 for the food and we were offered a $10 credit. Ridiculous. Mistakes like this are unacceptable and dangerous. read more

Don't judge a book by its cover, Anthony's looks like any other strip mall pizzeria but that's where it ends, Anthony's is a top tier restaurant, I had read the other reviews and people raved about the place, honestly we were looking for a fine Italian restaurant it was Sunday, most were closed for Labor Day weekend now I am glad they were. The staff is excellent, friendly, not on cell phones, I think Mandy was our server but others came over to say hi, speaking of staff they had plenty, that tells me they are treated well. The restaurant is very clean and spacious, you can have a normal level conversation. Now the food and drink, great beer selection in a visible cooler so you can see all the brands, good wine selection, my lady asked for a sample of the Pinot Grigio and they accommodated her, she then got a glass of it. For dinner my lady got the chicken Gabriella, she couldn't believe the flavor, freshness and moistness, the angel hair pasta had olive oil and fresh garlic, outstanding. I ordered the sausage and mushroom pizza, thin crust, to die for! We will be returning every time we visit Greenville SC. we were there on 9/04/22 read more

This has become my new favorite pizza place in the Upstate. My wife like a good white pie and hasn't been able to find one until now. It has a butter garlic sauce, plenty of garlic, and mozzarella cheese. She adds ricotta and calls it heaven. Me, I get the meat extravaganza. Plenty of toppings and the sauce is fantastic. Both were ordered thin crust which is also amazing. We cannot get enough of Anthony's Pizza. We've even had it 4 days in a row. read more