I used to love coming here, but the pricing has gotten completely out of hand. Charging $17 for a glass of prosecco is honestly ridiculous. I've been to high-end restaurants that don't even charge that much. The food is still good, but when your drink costs more than your meal, something is seriously off. It's disappointing because this used to be a go-to spot, but at these prices, it's just not worth it, especially when there's comparable spots nearby. read more

I have been to several location and I am sad to say the Exton location was disappointing. Very dirty especially the bar. This place needs a good dusting and cleaning. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

I had to lower because this place isn't keeping with the competition and it's way too pricey. Wings weren't good, my boyfriend couldn't eat them. We had a great server but the table next to us was ignored. The pizza was really good but there's a ton of great choices in the area these days. The chopped salad was great and big enough to share. I would be pretty happy with everything if it wasn't so expensive. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Chopped Salad - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

See all

Definately not 5 stars anymore. Last few visits have been progressively worse. Waited for 20 minutes beyond pickup time in a restaurant with 1 customer, one pizza got cold while waiting for the other. Whoever was working today doesn't know how to toss a pizza because the crust was flat and non-existent. To top it all off - the meatballs dont come with bread anymore, despite ordering it online and selecting it. You have to request it. Which if you're ordering online and selecting it, only to get home and realize its not there, is pretty misleading. Fixing your online menu would be a nice touch. Keeps getting more expensive the worse the experience gets. There's no shortage of good places to eat in Exton, think this one's past "well done." read more

Really good Italian food!!! Pizza can be a bit over cooked but that is the style for coal fired pizza. Service is great!! Ambiance is good but can be noisy during busy times. read more

Have been a regular for many years of ACFP between Exton and Wayne averaging multiple visits per week My visit today was disappointing While the food was enjoyable and no problems with service new ownership management continue to implement policy's that will discourage me from returning Of note I had multiple rewards that were denied because they allow only one to be used per visit So does that mean I have to play games and split the bill? Also , maybe it my imagination but the new bowls the salads are served in seem shallower. I could be wrong but portion seemed smaller than we are used to. read more

Prices are ridiculous. A plain pizza is $20; yeah sure whatever that's expensive but i'll bite my tongue. But then to charge me $5 for olives and mushrooms each, that's absurd. There is no way you put $10 worth of toppings on these pizzas. It's clear that the company is more interested in profits than delivering well-priced food. Also, this company charges more for orders on Uber, even when you say that you are going to pick up the order yourself. read more

Just skip this place. I ordered a pizza and salad yesterday to go and was a bit shocked at what I received. I understand most restaurants are skimping on ingredients but the pizza went too far. Barely any sauce cheese or toppings. So much so that the pizza was very dry. All of the greens in the salad were brown. They had to know this when they made the salad which to me, makes this intentional and not an accident. While I was waiting for the food, I only saw one server for the whole restaurant, running around like mad. Not cool. If Anthony's feels this is acceptable, they should go out of business instead of treating their customers and staff like crap. read more

We ordered two pizza's and an order of wings to go, ~$80. Both pizzas were burnt and the wings were dry. We did not discover this until we got home. No idea how they could have done this and thought it was OK. I have a photo of the pizza to prove it.......... read more

By far the best home made pasta fagioli. Taste just like my Italian grandmothers. Has a little kick to it too it's the real deal. I've tried it in so many places and they just do not compare. Thank you chef. It was amazing read more

We were in the extent mall area. I wanted to try a pizza place, and we have good reviews about this Anthony's location. So want to give it try , as we enter the restaurant. We were greeted and provided a seating. The ambiance of the restaurant is very nice they have a very good collection of wall hangings, which makes it so cool. The menu is well designed and was able to meet the vegetarian needs. we ordered garlic knots , eggplant, Margarita Pizza, and Fettuccine alfredo. The staff is friendly and was able to accommodate our needs. The garlic knots are very nicely portioned. We ordered 12, and we realized 6 might be sufficient enough. The taste was fantastic. The eggplant was probably one of the okay types of apps. It was not breaded, but it tasted okay. Margarita Pizza was fantastic and probably the best of all. A fettuccine alfredo tasted fantastic. However, the portion was very small. We enjoyed all the food a nice time out there at the restaurant we will definitely visit there again read more

See all

I can't comment on the ambiance of this restaurant, because we have only dined via DoorDash. What I can tell you is that we both love their pizza, which features a crispy and thin crust that would do any New York City pizzeria proud. We ordered a Margarita-mushroom topping that proved delicious. The one thing we did not find on their menu was a wild mushroom topping, which would have given them four and a half stars. Saving only the lack of wild mushrooms, their pizza quality is right up there with Osteria Ama on Street Road in West Chester. read more

You absolutely have to try the meatballs! We got them on our pizza and it was the star of the show, making Anthony's pizza our favorite local pizza place! read more

Entered Anthony's at 7:50p on a Sunday evening. Didn't expect it to be overly busy, but still surprised that the only patrons were 2 gentlemen at the bar...at least we'll get good service I thought. We were seated promptly and the server came over soon thereafter...good. Started off a bit downhill when she didn't know the rotating taps. Ok, I get it, probably not even old enough to drink but if expecting to be good at the job (and rewarded accordingly) it would behoove one to know the offerings. Upon returning from the bartender to inquire on the offerings, she rattled off a few by brand, neglecting to mention the particular name or type of beer from that brand. Second inquiry of the bartender and my selection was made. My wife wasn't so sure of a choice and decided to wait but upon sampling mine, agreed on the same, so ordered when we ordered food. During this time, another table had been sat so our server was now saddled with 2 tables. Apparently the beer had been ordered and poured by the bartender who, after 10 mins of it sitting on the bar counter, had to call out to the server and ask if she wanted to get that. We then witnessed the server stirring the beer with a straw so it would look like it had just been poured! With an almost empty place, we couldn't help but notice. Shortly thereafter I ordered another beer and, while it didn't sit for more than a few minutes, she still stirred it with a straw. She was highly embarrassed when I inquired about that and, while undoubtedly this young server was instructed to do this by someone else, but the place is supposed to be known for good food and good beer selection but that IS NOT how you serve a beer! Pizza and salad were both pretty good. read more

Italian sausage sandwich is delicious! Italian sausage sandwich is delicious! Italian sausage sandwich is delicious!!!!!!! Yum!

Been coming for years. Love their burnt pizza but this is ridiculous! Isn't worth the gas to take it back but we should get a refund! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza more than burned. Quite disappointed. - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

See all

Bartender Michaleigh is phenomenal! Great Drinks! Great atmosphere! I'll definitely be back.

We try to get to Anthony's every Wednesday with my family. Every week, we sit in Justine's section. We never met her prior to coming to Anthony's and she always treated us as family. She is a genuine person who is an amazing waitress. She remembers our order, always checks on us and makes sure we are good. read more

Very disappointed in the pizza I had today. Bland tasting and mushy consistency. I recently moved to the Exton area and still looking for a good pizza place. read more

I used to LOVE their roasted cauliflower pizza. Sadly, the pizza has been burnt the last 3 times I've ordered it. Three bad experiences in a row is enough to convince me to look elsewhere (sigh). read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Roasted Cauliflower 16" - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

Stopped in for a midday drink. Ordered the white sangria, it was well presented and extremely tasty. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Very delish white sangria. - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

Had to make a return to a specialty store in the same shopping center as this restaurant and so stopped in for dinner alone and sat at the bar. Ordered the 12 inch meatball and ricotta pizza which was $20.99. Pizza was good; service was fine although the bartender was not particularly friendly. This location is about 16 miles from my house so I might stop in again if I had to make another return to the same store. read more

See all

Went there for the 1st time last night. The Pizza is absolutely delicious as well as the caprese with prosciutto salad.

Pretty delicious uneven placement of pepperoni left one piece virtually without pepperoni. Ordering by phone was strange using an automated system. Bit food was good amd ready when expected. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Mike's hot honey pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

Food could be better. Only thing made on site is pizza,meatballs. Kitchen is very dirty. And not covered all day. Staff that have been there for 5+ years are rude to the costumers. There are better choices and much better quality of food and staff near. Poor management, poor pay, lack of team work. read more

Been to Anthony's a few times and haven't been disappointed yet. The coal fire pizza and the wings are delicious. We also got a garden salad this time which was amazing. I honestly never leave here dissatisfied read more

Went here for lunch with my kids. The weather was nice so they had their giant window doors open for the weather to come in. We ordered a Lg cheese pizza and a sm Cesar salad. The salad was able to feed four people to have as a side with their pizza. Their cheese had cheese all around with globs of sauce on top. Very good cheese! Love when the mozzarella has more of a salty taste when biting into! The waitress was very nice and on point when asking how everything was. The place had an old time New York feel. Over all a good place to check out when you're near by. read more

Anthony's pepperoni pizza may be my new favorite for pizza now that on Fridays. I always have gotten the eggplant pizza, which I love but I loved the pepperoni pie that I got for company this past Friday! read more

I like the new expanded menu. Sandwiches and pasta now available. Sausage was good. A little too much of a burned flavor for me. Will try the meatballs next time. Pizza is always good. read more

Little pricey, but very good . Friendly staff and very accommodating very good meatballs

Got the Caprese... it was pretty nasty. Dough was undercooked, tomatoes were cheap and watery and I gagged with every bite as they loaded it up with black pepper. I usually like black pepper but it was way too much. Would never order anything from here again. read more

These guys need to figure out what consistency means. I'm not referring to the food but their happy hour promotion.. The food is always good- no complaints. But they have wed happy hour special where they bring apps out for the bar patrons. No matter how many times I've asked, there is apparently no consensus exactly when happy hour starts. I've been told 5, 5:30, 6- WTF? Guys it's not that hard - if you want to promote then make it obvious what the hours are. If you don't, your business, your call. But your inconsistency means you will be left off the "regular" places list. I'm not going to guess what the happy hour flavor of the day is. Campeche? read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Exton, Pennsylvania

NOTHING in Pennsylvania comes close to New York Pizza, but to our delight, Anthony's comes close. Sadly the quality seems tarnished by my recent experience... though service still excels. I had an issue recently when I mentioned to my server that though I totally understand that the crust sometimes is burned (no problem) but the bottom of my pizza was burned black. Told they would remake it I waited for 10 or 15 minutes to then be presented with what looked EXACTLY like my first pizza. I never require perfection... but in my opinion - playing tricks with a customer is simply bad business. Do I know for a fact that they game me the same pizza NO - but it sure bothered me that it looked EXACTLY the same. read more

Stopped in for lunch on a Friday. It wasn't very busy so was seated right away. Pizzas were great... crispy crust that was evenly cooked and toppings were flavorful. Would go back here any time! read more

Capreze Pizza was amazing!, so was the Meatball/Onion Pizza. Spinach/Artichoke Dip & Wings were great. Service was excellen! The owner actually came out to see if we were enjoying our meal & if the food was good!! My Son got an email from Anthony's 2 days before our visit as it was his Birthday! His account came up in their system but it didn't show his Birthday. Our waiter, Owen, checked with his manager & my son was comped for his Birthday Pizza! Overall, it was a really great experience, from the service to the food. Would definitely recommend it to everyone! read more

I would usually give Anthony's 5 stars; however, my pick up order from tonight was totally wrong! I ordered a 12 inch pepperoni pizza and was charged for what I ordered. Unfortunately, I did not get a pepperoni pizza! Instead, I got a plain pizza. I could have eaten the garlic knots I also ordered; however, those weren't right either. I ordered them with no Romano cheese and asked for dipping sauce...they were loaded with cheese and I got no sauce. Feel like I totally wasted my money and won't be ordering from here any time soon! read more

I love Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza! I love their "well done" crust and yummy wings. We often takeout from Anthony's just because it's easier with our eight month old. My husband and I love their cauliflower pizza. They fry and bread the cauliflower first then top it on the pizza and bake. What's not to love about that?!? Anthony's has a good thing going and I hope they never change their recipe! read more

See all

Two words....cauliflower pizza!! It was crispy and absolutely delicious!!! We also tried another, but it wasn't as good. But, if the cauliflower pizza is all they've got....it's worth it!! read more

I had high expectations for the pizza and was disappointed. Their website offers delivery; however, I had to pick it up after an hour and a few drivers canceling the pickup. They don't use their own drivers, I guess this is the current age of outsourcing jobs. But by the time I got to the pizza it was over an hour and it was cold. Very disappointed, it tasted okay, but I was left highly disappointed. The wings were pretty good. Again cold, and they're not like regular wings. It's just wings cooked in their oven. Pretty tasty. But not the traditional Buffalo wings. But by the time I was able to pick them up they were already cold. Usually I will only write a review after 2 visits to a place. But I don't think it will make a two visit review. read more

Anthony's is still open during the COVID-19 pandemic! They are takeout/delivery only. They are also offering curbside pickup so you don't need to go inside if you don't want to. Their pizza here is always amazing. Tonight, my family and I had our usual (cauliflower pizza and tomato/basil/mozzarella pizza). Both were absolutely delicious! We have been cooking so much and it was nice to have our favorite pizza with no kitchen clean-up after. Please support this awesome business and order pizza from here! You won't regret it! read more