This place was VERY busy for a Thursday morning. About a 35-40 min wait. The food was good and the strawberry mimosa was one of the best I have had! Chicken and waffles were very good. Also the banana pancakes were delicious!. Waitress was ok but very busy and took awhile to get her to take check. It's a good place but not sure I would wait that long again. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Chicken & Waffles - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

This was a great spot for a group for breakfast. The coffee was great and they were always available for refills! The hash brown Benedict were really different than any normal Benedict. The base was a hash brown which was so so tasty! The normal bend it was good but it tasted like the egg was premade, not like it was fresh. The country potato's did lack a little bit of flavor, wish it had a little more zest. The beignets were yummy and easy to share with a group! read more

See all

Food was amazing and the wait staff are very friendly. I would give it 5 stars but the door is broken and slammed shut about 100 times during or meal. read more

We came here for brunch around 11am on a weekday because my partner was craving home fries. Thankfully we found parking very easily and were seated immediately (we joined the Yelp waitlist). There's indoor and outdoor dining available, and the outdoor dining is covered so you'll be in the shade (great for a hot day, kind of chilly for a cooler day). We felt pretty safe (in terms of social distancing) but there are quite a lot of tables outdoors (and staff is not wearing masks as a heads up). I was looking forward to the beignets after reading the other reviews, but to be honest they really weren't that good! See pic for reference, but there was an overload of powdered sugar and our beignets came out lukewarm and were very crunch on the exterior. I did really like the ceramic mugs our hot beverages came in, and I liked how many options there were on the menu. The lobster Brie omelette was very unique and tasty. I also liked the hash brown eggs Benedict (another dish I don't usually see at brunch restaurants). The home fries were okay but nothing to write home about (no seasoning, just plain). read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Cheesy grits and hash brown eggs benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

This is by far our go-to breakfast place in the whole Sarasota area. We've never been disappointed. And our friend's that we've brought also raved. Great coffee. Excellent Bloody Mary's and the food is exceptional. We've tried many items. Our house is 20 minutes away and we'd rather drive past other restaurants to come here. The vibes and staff make the experience memorable! read more

The crowd was crazy (around 10:30 am on Sunday). The wait staff was visibly overwhelmed. Food was good, nothing extraordinary. Rather overpriced. But given the location, that's to be expected. Feel like 3.5 stars so giving 4. read more

Understaffed and poor operations. Unfortunately, my experience was way below expectations. Initially I was told a wait time of 45 minutes. I returned back in 45 minutes to be told there was 3 parties in front of my reservation. After another 30 minute wait I was told my reservation was near the bottom of the list. The initial wait time ended up being near 90 minutes! Once we were seated, we were welcomed by our waiter, Curtis, who was great. He was patient and doing the best he could with what he was working with. He deserves praise for the amount he was handling. However, after ordering, we had to wait another 30 minutes before our food arrived. When the food then arrived the portion and presentation was sub par. Disappointing after a 2+ hour wait for breakfast. Management was gracious enough to comp our food for the experience which we appreciated. The staff is in desperate need of help and communication between kitchen, wait staff, and host team needs to improve or they'll be more negative experiences coming. Until then, the staff will attempt to handle more than they should. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Hash-brown Benedict served from kitchen - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Lukewarm review based on lukewarm eggs and soggy bacon. Granted, I may have ordered poorly--I ordered the traditional breakfast with eggs over easy, bacon, home fries, English muffin. Bacon "baked" and not fried, so not crispy and with lots of thick fat veins present. Home fries were dry cubes, no spice except salt. Eggs not hot. Wife orders the crab cake Benedict without eggs, which didn't work out well for her as she had only one bite. I didn't try it. The bright spot was the complementary serving of warm crispy beignets served with a honey marmalade. You get that for free when it's your first time eating there. Next time, will go with pancakes or French toast which looked good on neighboring tables. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Traditional breakfast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Not what it used to be when I came here 10 years ago. Understaffed, slow service, cold coffee and underwhelming food. Omelettes were dry and stale (after waiting an hour), fruit previously frozen, overall taste was not enjoyable. Maybe new ownership?! Don't waste your time, literally. Not cheap either (~$200 for 9 people, including 4 kids) read more

One of our favorite breakfast places in Siesta Key! Always delicious! Mimosas are great too. The online waitlist is very convenient.

Short Staffed I Couldn't Eat My Eggs They came out Raw and Bacon tasted like Cooking Gas Save Your Money Go Somewhere Else

I recently visited Siesta Key after many years. I was so excited to go back for breakfast at the Broken Egg; it was one of my favorite breakfast places. The menu used to be extensive, food good, portions big, and service friendly. I can't say that any more. We waited an inordinately long time for our food order to be completed. Portions were small,coffee was lukewarm, and I am still waiting for my coffee to be refilled. The waitress was busy as the restaurant appeared to be understaffed. Next time I go to Siesta Key, Another Broken Egg won't be on my list for places to go for breakfast read more

Came here 3 times in one weekend and was impressed every time! Over the weekend i had every much everything lol, from Chicken n Waffles to Eggs Benedict to pancakes, beignets, fruit and mimosas. And i will say, this place is worth the 30-45 min wait for a table. Staff is friendly/normal experience but the food and drinks are tasty. (pictured below) My bf had the crab cake Benedict side of loaded grits, i had the black stone benedict with fruit and it's actually the good fruit, not that melon honey dew BS mix everywhere else gives you. Star of the show for me was yesterday, having chicken and waffles with their ranch, while my bf had the al pastor benedict. Can't wait to come here again. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - black Eggs Blackstone Benedict with Fruit side - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Food was attached to our hotel which made it extremely convenient!! They had it ready in under 10 minutes for pickup (for 4 people). Excellent service and great employees willing to help and get you taken care of quickly. read more

Great location, great food, great vibes! Wanted to do a quick breakfast in the village and ABEC did not disappoint. We were afraid that this would be a touristy spot, with a lot of postings on social media but lacked in real-life; we were pleasantly surprised! The food was really good; so many unique options, big portions and decent prices. I would def. come back here if I needed some good breakfast foods! read more

We had not tried this place before. My husband is usually looking for a more basic breakfast, and their menu is pretty fancy for his taste. But we both ordered the Supreme Omelet (sausage, bacon, onion, mushrooms, with cheddar on top). It was very good (and huge). The service was cheerful, and they checked on us frequently. Breakfast for two (omelettes, toast & coffee) was about $50. read more

Great service, nice ambiance, excellent food. Can't wait to go again. We had a party of 7, called an hour before we planned to eat to get on the waitlist, and they were able to seat us almost immediately upon arrival. read more

First time to this location and there was a line of people waiting. I checked in with the hostess and it was just me today so I got a great table on the patio. My waitress Isabella was very prompt and took my drink order as soon a I was seated. I tried the caramel cold brew. It had caramel drizzled on the rim of the glass and tasted pretty good. I wasn't sure what I wanted for breakfast since it was almost 11am but I ended up choosing the lemon blueberry goat cheese pancakes. It also came with a side of eggs and sausage. I haven't had sausage like this before. It was a bit olpeppery and was seasoned differently than most store brands. I liked it a lot. I was very pleased to know the pancakes were not stuffed and the toppings were just on the top. Little balls of goat cheese sprinkled along with zested lemon added to the flavor. The pancakes were very filling and I could not finish them. So much food for the $23 price without tip especially in a tourist location and very pleased overall. read more

See all

Reveal, another Broken Eggs in Sarasota. No parking space. Food's decent, not too different. Seating's often standard for beach-review hotels. Kind of pricey side, however fun. A lot of open spaces, great weather, at least for my visit. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

For full disclosure, taking away a star might not be fair given market conditions. I explain below. Two things stood out during this visit: the delicious food and excellent staff. Service is top notch, from the young maitre' d who was welcoming and referred to the bar menu as "happy drinks", to our server Dustin who took the time to thoroughly explain grits to me and was perfectly attentive without being intrusive. Entrée descriptions include calories which is bittersweet. I almost always order something other than what I REALLY wanted, but glad after the fact that I didn't inadvertently eat an entire day's worth of calories at one sitting. To be dietarily correct, I ordered the veggie omelette with grits. The omelette is filled with goat cheese (first time and YUM!), spinach and tomatoes. The grits came plain (their City Grits have bacon and other stuff.) and seasoned with the pepper sauce at each table. I liked them. Thanks for recommending, Dustin! An English muffin was also included. The husband ordered the salmon Benedict with potatoes, which he said was also very good. I thought the presentation was quite impressive. (See the photo below. Not a great shot because the husband has banned me from Yelping at the table; so I had to sneak a shot when he wasn't looking.) Based on all of this, the establishment gets 5 stars. If I could give four and three quarters, I would. Breakfast here is not cheap--it isn't anywhere around in Siesta Key, but $14 for basic eggs (2 with meat) just made me cringe. My veggie omelette was $15 and the husband's salmon bagel was nearly $20. Worth it for a special breakfast / brunch out, though. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Indoor/ outdoor seating - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Every single time we visit Siesta Key this place is a must. Beach access 2 to Siesta Key beach is right down the street so you can walk off breakfast & go for a relaxing beach day The food is always hot, nice presentation & sitting outside is a must! Waiters really seem to enjoy their jobs & very personable. Highly recommend the pitchers of Bloody Mary's they are fabulous! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Bloody Mary's to die for! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Great find in Siesta Key for breakfast/brunch. Just plan on a Long wait to get in, as this place is always super busy. We really enjoyed sitting outside and having mimosas and beignets to start off. We shared pancakes and an omelet and raved about how lucky we were to come across this place while checking out the island. We highly recommend!! read more

See all

This is a pretty popular chain restaurant - famously known for breakfast and always sporting a long wait outside the door. We hadn't ever actually had a chance to visit a location before and decided let's go for it. Luckily, you can join the Yelp waitlist before arriving - which saved us quite some time from standing in the hot Florida sun. We started off in 15th place and by the time we arrived we were 5th - make sure you do this otherwise you're waiting a good hour before eating. Once seated, our served greeted us and took drink orders. We opted for a pitcher of mimosa - which is well worth the price and delicious. We each got a different plate to eat, and truthfully, no one was really blown away by anything. We tried the crab cake Benedict (which was kind of cold and the flavors didn't blend as well as I thought it would), chicken and waffles (just some chicken tenders on top of waffles - I mean it was ok I guess), chilaquiles (which was my preferred bite), and some pancakes and beignets to share (mediocre at best). I'm not really sure what the hype is behind this place, but I guess I don't regret trying it although I definitely wouldn't willingly visit again. The food was meh, the servers were great. Not really worth the visit. read more

See all

I'd say this place is great for a quick stop in if everything in town is busy and you can't get into a restaurant for breakfast this would be a place to go. I was thinking about the food and while the food comes out quickly I'm not really sure it was up to what I like but that's just me. The coffee was good and the bloody Mary was on point so I'll give it a couple of stars for that and then the end of the way the place looks looks great. It's definitely a good place to stop in if you need to get a quick bite to eat. read more

Just left broken egg wow absolutely terrible quality of food. I ordered a cold brew that tasted like water with vanilla which they did not remove from the bill even though i told the waitress is watered down. I ordered the traditional breakfast eggs over medium i received over easy with still much of the white very loose... gross. My parents ordered the pancakes which were good but the scrambled eggs dry and pastey. How can you screw up a basic breakfast. I suggest the chef go to culinary school and learn the basics... never again. Good service isnt enough to maintain a restaurant step it up! read more

The food was amazing. We enjoyed the pancake so much last year, that this year we had breakfast there twice. On our second visit I wanted to try the Lemon Pound pancakes, unfortunately they were not available. Next time then. Get there early since it gets very busy. read more

See all

Great food, service not so much. We had the Cinnamon roll french toast with scrambled eggs and sausage as well as the crab cake Benedict with side of bacon. The french toast was DELICIOUS, Benedict was also really good, egg was poached perfectly. The cherry Mimosa kinda tasted like Robitussin, cold brew was ok. The sausage and bacon was to die for! The waiter placed our check on the table as soon as we started eating and kept walking past us to see if we had put down a card, we felt soo rushed even though it was not busy, I was going to get another drink but was forced to just pay. read more

See all

===== What are we doing, below.... ===== Review Next Section below === Another Broken Egg Cafe is our 16th entry in the Quest for great Eggs Benedict / Breakfast. Our quest for the top 3 breakfast spots in the Sarasota, Vamo, Osprey, Nokomis, Venice, North Port, Englewood corridor. Eggs Benedict w/Ham, Florentine, or specialty (seafood, veggies, corned beef/hash, or others) and hash browns/potatoes and grits are the sides. We will narrow it down to top 3 in a few weeks and re-visit them and win, place, & show those finalists. (we are getting a bit fatter, I am not sure how many more we can try out) The Breakfast Cottage Eggstraordinary Café BLVD Café Max's Table Willow's Café Toasted Mango Café Anita's Restaurant Blu Island Bistro Word of Mouth The Breakfast House Sun Garden Café Sunnyside Café Rosemary & Thyme Millie's Restaurant The Reserve Retreat Café Evergreen Another Broken Egg Cafe ================ REVIEW DOWN HERE ======================= Well dreading going into Siesta Key because the parking situation and ticketing potential is so predatory and unwelcoming, so pitiful. BUT early morning arrival after a trip to the airport sending daughter to college and a morning walk on the beach. Plenty of FREE and SAFE spots!!! Yippee!!!! Seated in a nice deck spot with a little view. VERY nice. Coffee was prompt and POWERFUL!! I was perspiring and a little jittery soon thereafter (I am a bit sensitive and should know better but I do it anyway) Service by James was awesome and never wanting and efficient! 10/10 I got the traditional Eggs Benedict w/ham and breakfast potatoes. These looked VERY nice. The eggs (there were three on this plate??) were almost perfect but slightly white snotty and undercooked (getting close to Sal Manila worrisome) ..a little bit disappointing and EASILY fixed of course. (gotta cook the snot out of those eggs to be perfect!) 7/10 The ham was one of the best egg benedict ham we have had. (my wife is really picky, does not like the sliced disk process ham, the lunchmeat sliced paper shreds etc.) This was a nice product, well grilled/cooked lightly brown in a few spots and hot as was the whole plate!!! 10/10 The muffin was also great product and well prepared and cooked. Lightly toasted/crisp and not soggy or mushy. 10/10 The Hollandaise Sauce? Where so many fail, this was one of the top sauces in the 16 restaurants! Very nice, smooth, spiced and flavored without overpowering. 10/10 so for the whole traditional ham eggs Benedict its a solid 9/10 The breakfast potatoes might have been a bagged reheated affair - perfect brown cubes of potato with rounded sides and edges. Arrived maybe 'room' (outdoor 80 degrees) temperature, soft and spongy and quite frankly I ate three or four cubes.....not worth the calories. I would prefer a cooked to order homemade product and of course served HOT. In hindsight I should have gone for the grits OR the "City Grits" with gouda cheese and etc. The potatoes 3/10 My wife went with the Shrimp Benedict on focaccia bread w/fruit cup. Her poached eggs were properly cooked which was fantastic!! 10/10 The bread on this was very good and sitting on top of it was a nice scallion, tomato, vegetable medley that was hot and cooked perfectly and all awesome fresh ingredients. 10/10 The shrimp however were sort of a canned or thawed frozen grey/bleached units and kinda off flavor not fishy but a contrasting taste? 5/10 So sadly had to notch down the overall since the namesake ingredient was not too good? 8/10 overall. The fruit cup while one might think a ho-hum addition (and most are one or two pieces like a melon and pineapple OR a chunk of honeydew and one of cantaloupe) but NOT HERE!!! This was a full featured fruit side, with watermelon, blackberries, mango, & strawberries. i.e. there was actually 'fruits" in the fruit cup!! 10/10 for the variety and the quality of this side!! Place is cute and clean, service top notch, the food was awesome with just a bit of attention to some cooking items and a few changes in ingredients (shrimp and potatoes) I think they MAY BE (not say for sure) in the top contenders for the breakfast finalist, but we will SURELY be back anyway because there is SOOO much on the menu we would like to try next time!!!!! read more

See all

Probably one of the better breakfast places I've had as went multiple times. Service was nice. Atmosphere is nice being able to eat outside or inside. The cinnamon roll French toast was AMAZING. The cookie dough waffles were also pretty great. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Cinnamon Roll French Toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

This place is delicious!!! Have been here more than once and have not been disappointed. Ordered the gingerbread rum holiday drink as well as the lemon goat cheese pancakes (sub strawberries for blueberries). Our server Ana (who was also the bartender) was excellent - she was super sweet, made sure we were happy and had such a positive energy. Would recommend either calling ahead or making a reservation as this place gets packed for breakfast, or trying them for lunch as they have yummy burgers and sandwiches. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

We took recommendations from our server and the food was fantastic. We got the shrimp and grits and lobster bennie. The spicy Bloody Mary's were also great! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Shrimp 'N Grits, Lobster Hash Benedict - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Patio is nice. That's it. Food was awful. Had the traditional two egg breakfast with scrambled eggs and I'm pretty sure the eggs came from powder in a box as they were grainy and utterly tasteless. My husband had a Southwest skillet, which should've been very flavorful and it was not. Never going back. many other wonderful breakfast places in Siesta Key try those instead. read more

Stacy was great. Good chicken and waffles! The spicy honey on the chicken was very solid. Waffle had a good combo of crisp outside and fluffy inside. Damn good coffee. And hot! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Hot coffee! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Met and exceed all expectations of our breakfast. Great coffee, the garnishment on the lemon zest & goat cheese pancakes were perfectly paired, the fruit was fresh, and a shrimp omelet with biscuits was praised as well. Service was great, always with a smile and sense of humor. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Customized coffee cup. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Wow!! Espectacular place, the food was amazingly delicious, servers are sooo nice. They made my vacations so much fun and delicious, whoever goes to siesta key must to go to have breakfast in this place read more

See all

Everything was absolutely delicious and incredibly fresh! Highly recommend the hueves ranchero. The chips were homemade and thick cut. The ranch in the fried chicken sandwich was finger licking good. My husband and daughter loved the bacon and home made sausages. Come hungry! Portions are decent sized so we ordered 3 and shared among 4 of us. read more

See all

This place is fantastic. VERY busy so be prepared to wait but well worth it. Really good fresh food. Nice outdoor patio. Lots and lots of brunch options - menu is really great. I had the smoked salmon bagel and it was so good - poached eggs done perfect - salmon was super fresh it was so good. Hubby had an omelette with sausage and veggies which he loved. We also got the biscuit beignets with orange marmalade YUM! Def going back. Love this place. For as busy as they were the service was really good. Loved the outdoor patio seating. They do offer an online waitlist option which is nice but you have 3 min to get to stand! read more

My friends and I decided to check this place out since it was very close to our hotel room. This was my first time visiting Another Broken Egg Café & My experience at this café was amazing from the time that we walked in to the food. Our waiter , Matthew M. made our experience so much better. He even brought us some free beignets ( very delish ) as a first time guest. He cracked a few jokes and made our table feel welcome and cared for. Because of Matthew , we had breakfast there twice during our trip. Once we ordered, our food was brought out quickly, especially surprising because they were slammed. ALL four orders were delicious, and very generous portions. I personally recommend this location to EVERYONE ! read more

See all

We have been coming to this restaurant for over 10 years consistently during our stays in March and October. We return year after year because of the people. The turnover of some of the staff has led to bad attitudes - mainly those in the host/hostess roles. It is very disappointing. We have tried to support this business post hurricane - and the poor attitudes have made that challenging. The food remains consistent and the service is good. However, first impressions are everything and they have a lot to learn. read more

What a great place to have breakfast in Siesta Keys. I had the supreme omelette with sausage, bacon, onions, mushrooms, jack cheese, chorizo, green onions and garlic butter. It was a great omelette. The service was great. Get on the Yelp waitlist before you go. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida