We ate here today after meeting with the folks at the Legacy Castle about our son's wedding. We…read morefound this delightful restaurant right here on Yelp after I googled "Best Italian restaurants near the Legacy Castle." I made reservations, which we didn't actually need, but I like to play it safe when going to a new place. The service was friendly and the food was delicious. I got the chicken piccata with a half Caesar salad and both were marvelous. My husband got the Rotini with Sunday Sauce (although in our house we call it Sunday Gravy, LOL) and it was yummy. Our son's fiancee got pasta amatriciana and said it was ALMOST as good as what she'd eaten in Rome, and our son got the sausage pizza fra diavolo and LOVED the thin crispy crust. Great food and service - thank you! Not sure why the posted review says we're from San Francisco; we're actually from Allentown, PA.

I went here a couple of times and don't really like any of their food items on the menu. I only…read morecame here for the occasional event, but I would never order food here if given the choice. The pizza is stale. The service is great though and the waiters are really nice and understanding. The ambiance is nice and the decor is lovely and pretty, the aesthetics are definitely there.

Second go around wasn't as good as the first . The wings…read morewere just way to big and not crispy enough. Was kinda gross how big they are. We also had a mix up with the bartender serving us. Didn't order what we wanted but she made up for it by getting the right ones in and to us quickly. Still though off entire meal. We tried the xtra large pizza which was good. Not nearly enough toppings. It was too much for 3 people with apps. The Ceasar salad again was very bad. Shouldn't be on menu that's how not good it is. Overall love the place still and will be back.

Came here today with a friend, and we ordered the bar pie and the wings. Both were very good, and…read morethe waitresses were friendly, attentive, and provided excellent service. I also ordered the chicken sandwich, which was good, but I was disappointed that it didn't come with fries. Having to pay extra for fries with a sandwich feels a bit cheap. I also wasn't happy about the 4% surcharge for using a credit card. Those extra charges leave a bad impression and take away from an otherwise enjoyable meal. The food and service were solid, but my message to the owner is this: don't nickel-and-dime your customers. Including fries with a sandwich and avoiding credit card surcharges would go a long way toward creating a better overall experience.

Primo has been popular takeout spot among my friends and recently it has become my family's Friday…read morenight pizza spot. The pizza is always fresh and the sauce holds its own against other pizza places in the area. The real standout surprised me - the empanadas. I was a little skeptical about ordering empanadas from a pizza place but a friend recently raved to me about them. I decided to give them a try and ordered two of the spinach + feta and one ham + cheese. The dough was pillowy soft and contained the perfect amount of filling. Quick tip: they are not listed on the online menu and are inside a case next to the register. This is mostly a takeout spot but there is a fair amount of indoor seating. The parking lot is fairly small and is shared with a pool hall and Wayne Steakhouse. Staff is friendly and happy to help. Highly recommended ordering from Primo if you are in the Wayne/Pompton Lakes area. Plain Pie: 4/5 Spinach Empanada: 5/5 Ham and Cheese empanada: 5/5

Walked into this empty spot and soon realized why that was the case. The owner appears to be…read morehostile and not welcoming at all ! Had their chicken parm slice which was pretty good but the Sicilian slice was tasteless! The tables were sticky! A nope for me!

Love the basics! Great slide of plain cheese. There is a nice crust and nice thin dough. The…read morebuffalo chicken slice was also great. I've also tried their vodka chicken sub. I wish there was more sauce but overall it was delicious and the chicken tasted freshly made.

Stopped in for a quick slice and their options were plentiful. Service was quick. Chose the…read moreMargherita slice which was delicious. Crispy thin crust and their marinara is flavorful.

Great place with amazing pizza. Wish they still ran the storefront instead of just a road showread more

This place closed down, they only do the mobile pizza oven for parties and events. The brick and…read moremortar location is never opened. Just a heads up for anyone wanting to go there. Two stars for decent pizza, but Yelp listing needs to be updated.

I'm not a huge fan of NJ food but Anthony Franco's is one of my exceptions. When you walk in it…read morelooks like your typical pizza parlor with some seating off to the side, and there's a party room in the back. I was there for an event and got to sample their delicious food including eggplant rollatini, calamari, and more. And let's not forget the yummy tri-colored pizza - perfect in every way! The staff was attentive and I definitely recommend this pizza restaurant for more than just pizza.

11/14/2025 Always looking for great pizza. Found a great…read moreplace 'close' a few weeks ago, but didn't want to travel so far, so we ordered 'take out' from AF. I wonder about the 3.5 rating because we thought the pizza was just about as good as it gets. I ordered our pie 1/2 plain, 1/2 pepperoni... very thin and crispy... along with a side of mussels marinara. Ok, the mussels had a little sand (very little) but were plump with a very tasty marinara sauce. The pie was very thin and crispy as I had ordered. Really, a great pie that I would happily order again. Service, both on the phone ordering... and when picked up was very friendly. Might have to stop in and sit next time... It is a BYO.

The cheese slices definitely stood out! I was eating here and pretty much everyone came in after…read moreordered the cheese slices. My eggplant panini was okay.

I love their cheese slice! This is definitely my favorite slice in the area. I've had their vodka…read morechicken, bacon &chicken and plain Slice. I liked their chicken& bacon slice but nothing beats a good plain cheese slice. It's crispy and perfect thickness!

Pizza is really good with a lot of variety and the rest of the menu is excellent. We've never had a…read more"bad" meal there. It's a nice atmosphere however it can get very noisy on the weekends, but don't let that stop you from trying this restaurant.

ordered my pizzas online an hour before pickup and showed up right on time. I was told my order…read morewasn't ready yet. After waiting another 20 minutes, I finally asked what was going on--only to be told they had given my pizzas to someone else. That's when they finally started making my order. Mistakes happen, but what really disappointed me was the complete lack of customer service. No apology, no explanation, and not even an offer of a discount or anything to make it right. Needless to say, I will never be back. Absolutely unacceptable

Upon walking in i was greeted with a hello. As I was only getting two slices of pizza the gentleman…read moreand young man at the counter were welcoming. Smiles and all. As you enter you walk into a counter with some delicious looming pizza. I ordered two regular slices which they warmed up to a temperature that I love. Not very hot. The right amount of sauce and cheese. very good. Definitely would come back. There is a big dining room area to eat in. Tables and booths. plenty if seating. The dining area was a extremely clean and neat. It doesn't appear to be a new place, the booths seem to be very retro, but very clean. Nice place

Service here was horrible. I got a delivery order today (9/13) from Franks pizza for dinner through…read morethe slice app. I ordered around 7:30pm, wrote specific instructions on the app to call me when they arrive so they know to give the pizza to me. It's almost 8:30pm, almost an hour but I understand that it takes time to make the food so I don't think much of it. I didn't get any phone call but they rang the doorbell and my friend didn't know whether it was them or someone else because the app said it wasn't out for delivery yet. She opens the door and turns out it was the pizza and they forgot my 2 liter coke I ordered. I ran out of the apartment to look for them and to give them their cash tip but by the time I went outside they drove off. I was telling customer service I didn't receive the soda that I ordered almost an hour ago and they contacted the place to redeliver the soda to my place. Cool. Takes almost 30 minutes to deliver a 2 liter coke when at this point, it's 9pm, we're done with our food and the soda isnt necessary anymore and a refund is more suitable. The delivery driver finally comes and he hands me a soda and receipt and says that he expects a tip. First off, it's fucking rude to demand your customers a tip when you didn't even deliver my order correctly, didn't listen to delivery instructions I wrote down, and even took 30+ minutes to deliver some soda. After being obligated to give a tip, he decides to ask me how much I pay for rent. ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME??? I've never had such a horrible experience with getting food delivered to me, I just wanted to cry. I suggest you do any research before picking a place to order delivery.

The food was so good I might cry. The service was super nice and super kind. The ambiance was super…read morecool there was a lot of wine things. Boniello's is definitely a 8.7/5 because it was so good and so amazing and also was so good. I wish I could tell you because it was so good about the secret menu. Oh no I leaked it. Hee hee. Now it's no secret.

Got takeout last week and thought it was great! My favorite was the Italian sushi on the appetizer…read morespecial. I loved it! I ordered a Caesar Chicken Milanese and the cheese was melted on top of the Caesar salad which made it wilt and was not great. Next time I will ask to not melt the cheese because I think it would've been delicious if that wasn't done. Everything else was delicious and I will come back!