The food was so good I might cry. The service was super nice and super kind. The ambiance was super cool there was a lot of wine things. Boniello's is definitely a 8.7/5 because it was so good and so amazing and also was so good. I wish I could tell you because it was so good about the secret menu. Oh no I leaked it. Hee hee. Now it's no secret. read more

Got takeout last week and thought it was great! My favorite was the Italian sushi on the appetizer special. I loved it! I ordered a Caesar Chicken Milanese and the cheese was melted on top of the Caesar salad which made it wilt and was not great. Next time I will ask to not melt the cheese because I think it would've been delicious if that wasn't done. Everything else was delicious and I will come back! read more

My wife had the 17$ soup/ salad/ or half sandwich, the mushroom soup was wonderful, the Caesar salad was very salty almost inedible, my meatball sandwich yummy and the tortellini in brodo was fantastic read more

First time dinning at Boniello's on Tuesday night. Recommended by friends who live nearby and made reservations for our group of 12. Located in a small strip mall close to I287 in Riverdale, NJ, it was easy to find and plenty of parking. The staff was great, our table was waiting for us when we arrived. It is BYOB, so the wine drinkers came prepared. All the food was very very good. No complaints, the stuffed flounder with rice and mixed vegetables was a generous potion (as were most of the others). Eggplant, veal, angel hair pasta, chicken parm, perfect! Very reasonable prices,too! Looking forward to another visit (oh look, pumpkin soup). read more

See all

I was in the area and decided to try Boniello's on a whim. I am so happy that I did! I have two words for you - Pizza. Cone. The pizza cone is neat. It is basically pizza dough with a sandwich inside. A big sandwich. It was well worth the $11 or so I paid. My pizza cone experience was not recent. And as I relive the meal it makes want to get back over here and have another. I do not live nearby and its a shame (although maybe a blessing for my waistline). Also the service was very good, waitress was friendly and on top of her stuff. Get over here and get your own cone! read more

Although my sausage sandwich was great, my Italian sandwich was a disappointment. Where's the meat? I know prices have gone up but I wanted more than a lettuce and tomato sandwich. read more

Nice outdoor seating and beautiful interior. Good service. Veal parmigiana was good and penne pasta with vodka sauce good. Disappointing meatballs as side. Probably best Italian food in area. read more

See all

Learned of this restaurant last year and wish I'd known about it sooner! Everything from the staff, ambiance, and food are top tier. The servers are always so pleasant and attentive and the food speaks for itself. I've been to the restaurant multiple times, ordered catering for holidays, and each time I've been to the restaurant I've been more than satisfied. The chicken saltimbocca is the best I've ever had and the portion was so big that I got three meals out of it! My go to app is the grilled peach salad with their homemade balsamic. So unique and delicious. Highly recommended! read more

See all

The food was delicious, as well as generous portions. Just make a rezzy in their website, quite easy! Anthony was our waiter. He recommended the special which was wonderful: Butternut squash sauce with pumpkin ravioli. Not our first time here, nor our last. Love giving business to neighbors! read more

Had some good reviews so us and another couple decided to try Boniello's - Hoping for a good Italian restaurant to frequent - Came during the week around 2PM - Only two other people in the restaurant - Ordered the meal - First - two salads - one without olives- 10 minutes later it came WITH olives Ordered hand battered Calamari (definitely NOT hand battered) Two Veal Parm (one with pasta and one without) And Cheese Ravioli We said that we wanted the Parm, Calamari and Ravioli to come out at the same time - IT DID NOT The Calamaric came out 10 minutes later and was WARM AND NOT HOT. 10 minutes later the Veal Parm came out - The pasta with the veal was warm and not hot and was watery 10 minutes later the Ravioli came out We asked why everything did not come out like we wanted The waiter said he was too busy working on delivery orders The food was good AND obviously the chef cared more about take out orders than the people in the restaurant. I CAN SEE WHY THE RESTAURANT WAS EMPTY !! AVOID THIS PLACE AND GO TO A RESTAURANT THAT CARES ABOUT THE PEOPLE THAT COME TO THE RESTAURANT !!! read more

Boniello's - CALAMARI CAME OUT WARM AND NOT HOT !! - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

I got the summer dinner to take to shore , it was excellent! Fed 6 with no problem, Chicken piccata was so delicious. I would definitely recommend!! read more

An amazing family owned Italian restaurant! Food is amazing, staff is super friendly and nice, food comes out fresh and always in a timely manner. Very clean place as well. Perfect place for any occasion. Highly recommended to anyone considering or just in the area! read more

My husband and I discovered this place on Resy. We've only gotten take out from here but we love it!! The Volpe sandwich is full of flavor! I love their chicken vodka sliders. One day we ordered the wrong sandwich and called them to see if we can switch the sandwich to something different and they were nice and accommodating to do that for us. read more

Great restaurant, service and food was exquisite. Newly renovated BYOBis even better for the wallet read more

Always a good experience even when crowded they go out of their way to ale the experience enjoyable

My favorite! Everything is so good here- pizza, pasta, seafood - cannot go wrong. We have even ordered a tray of chicken cutlets for guests. We sometimes just pick up a quart of vodka sauce to make for an easy weeknight meal. read more

First time eating there and it's wasn't crowded and busy. Staff was very accommodating and food was good. We had the fried calamari which was cooked well and included tentacles which was great! Mussels were sent back because too fishy but our server was fantastic about taking it off the bill. Eggplant rolatine was very good and perfect portion. read more

Delicious food that we always enjoy eating! Love the gnocchi pesto and the fact that the restaurant is BYOB. Staff are always very welcoming and kind! Great Italian restaurant read more

Boniello's - Gnocchi Pesto - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

Well as a long time Ringwood resident, the amount of decent food in this area is lacking. Enter DoorDash, which enables super busy people like us to order from well regarded restaurants within a certain distance. We tried Boniello's a few times, not in person admittedly. First time was great. Second and third were terrible. Tonight I feel the need to leave a review. Their sauces are great, so I get the clams. Nice size and well cooked but full of sand both times. Like crunching on sand. It's horrible. This time I got a refund from DoorDash. And quite frankly should have gotten a full refund. Included bread was stale (not the first time). Italian sushi is worse than store bought prosciutto roll ups. Cheap prosciutto and mozzarella. Not good. Salads are iffy. Both times my wife ordered a salad she said it was terrible. Escarole and bean soup, great taste, where's the beans and escarole? It was all potato. Cheap filler. Seafood salad was ok, except mussels are overcooked and those clams rear their head again, sandy. Poor clam prep. Must be lack of caring people in the kitchen. This place could be excellent...not sure we will try again anytime soon. read more

Not a fan my Mushroom soup was salty and my meatball parm was very sad no love what so ever DRY very minimal cheese no sauce and also salty ! Never again read more

Boniello's - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

I've been going to Boniello's for years and hesitate to give them a bad review. I order d a simple salad and soup for dinner. I ordered a quart of soup to have some for lunch the next day. I had to wait a few minutes to pick up my order but that's ok. I drove away and thought to stop and check my order. The soup was a pint and not a quart. Back to Boniello's it was. When I got there and took the soup out it wasn't even the correct one. I think I waited a good 10-15 mins for the correct soup. They did tell me to keep the pint which was nice. The kicker? I got home and there was no salad dressing. Plus the bread was horribly stale. I was really disappointed in the service. This isn't the first time it's happened when I have picked up food. read more

Here's the deal : this place doesn't need more love it's already difficult to get a table on weekends LOL. Loved the food. Huge portion!! Leftovers even better the next day. Love the cozy decor. Great spot don't pass it up !! read more

See all

I've had my eye on Boniello's for quite some time, and finally had the opportunity to stop in for lunch. Talk about a solid meal! We started with the garlic knots which had a nice crisp on the outside and were soft on the inside. My husband ordered a personal pie that nailed all the elements: perfect crust and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I had one of their salads from the specials menu that was topped with grilled shrimp, avocado and mango. All the ingredients were super fresh, although for $16 I wish there was 1 or 2 more shrimp. Service was great, the atmosphere is inviting and our experience was really enjoyable. We will be back! read more

Boniello's - Misto Salad from specials menu - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

Thought the food was fantastic. Love the decor of the place. It's wine cases it's adorable. Glad we made a reservation because it got packed quickly. The only thing that's keeping me from the 5 star is the service. The waitress didn't check on us at all unless waved down to the table. The zepollis are just mediocre. They're too cakey. But overall great and I will come back. read more

See all

Delicious food! Fantastic staff! The area is perfect and the ambiance is terrific. You can tell they put a lot of love and care into their beautiful space. I always look forward to ordering from Boniello's! read more

I love the Cesar salad here, and I'm not a salad person. I have had the Shrimp Rosa. It's delicious. The portions are generous. My daughters love the meatballs here. They are super generous with the butter in the cooking. read more

Food is awesome especially the homemade fettuccine. I have never had a bad experience. The staff is always helpful and professional

Been here a lot for takeout mostly for pizza and it's always been good. But today I saw they posted their chicken porpora on instagram and it looked so good we needed to have it. At at the restaurant for the first time and it was perfect. We started with the buffalo garlic knots and they were great. The chicken porpora was amazing. It was huge, the photos don't do it justice but we totally could've split it. The gnocchi was really good and the chicken was perfect. It's just a special but they really should add it to the menu permanently. Service was great and really fast. The vibe in this place is so cute, it's really clean and cozy. It was pricey but for how much food we got, it's totally justified. Will definitely be coming to eat here many more times! read more

See all

Ordered tonight because i wanted pumpkin ravioli. Not only were they not fresh but didn't have the right sauce even though it's says on menu "with pumpkin sauce" but the girl still asked what kind of sauce 2x‍came with a very greasy buttery salty brown butter sage sauce which i've had before but was not good never again read more

It was always great! I always loved everything I ordered there. Hope to revisit your restaurant soon! Service was very good! Decorated very cute & casual. Prices are not too high. Love that is BYOB. Can't say anymore. Enjoy! 4 star read more

I love boniellos!!!! Did a family reunion had it catered and the food is alll everyone keeps talking about!!!!! Their chicken Francese is my favorite!!!! Had spoken with Olivia who helped me figure out the catering for a family reunion. She was such a pleasure to work with! When picking up and dropping back off trays I spoke with Bianca and she was also a pleasure. When returning the trays my husband and I decided to get their vodka chicken sliders and rice balls and I was blown away!!!! Both were delicious!! Definitely recommend this place for their food and their catering!!!!! read more

Came here for a quick dinner on the weekend. Definitely make a reservation or else you'd have to be like me and come back for a table 2 hours later! I ordered the clam linguini and also the chicken vodka sliders. The plates were large enough to share and quite delicious! Just wished there were more clams in my pasta. Overall great experience! read more

Boniello's - Chicken Vodka Sliders - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

See all

Great Neighborhood restaurant for friends and family to meet. You have to try the mussels with red sauce medium or hot, the sauce is fantastic! Also, wonderful and friendly service!!! I will eat there every time I visit the area. read more

Last minute decision to go out and have Garlic Parmesan Wings (delicious) and a personal pie. We always enjoy our dinners at Boniellos! Best wishes Nick Epstein as you enter Seton Hall! read more

We really enjoyed the rice ball and the meat ball. The sauce that came with the meat ball was very good. Our toddler was tired so we had a few bites of everything else and then had to pack everything to go. The server was very quick and attentive to our need. The food was really good and the portion is big. We ate more pasta when we got home and really enjoy it. We left around 7 on a Thursday evening and the place was almost full, that says something about this place. Will definitely. read more

See all

Service is always great. I love getting the shrimp rosa it's my favorite dish. comes with a huge salad with antipasto like toppings. Make a reservation read more

Both food & service has gone downhill. Three of us stopped in for lunch the other day, and place was nearly empty. When I noticed TWO tables got their appetizers before we got ours, our server comes by and says, "It will be out soon". She didn't like the hungry looks we had. When the food finally arrived, my veal was underwhelming, tough and unseasoned. My lunch mates ordered fried food and a meatball sandwich, and noted they were unremarkable. Our server did stop by and asked if everything came out ok, however didn't bother to hear our answer. Really, she is lucky we tipped at all. This once fine establishment has succumbed to the woke mind virus that insists that EVERYTHING a woman does is to be praised, yet never held accountable, no matter what. I will truly miss this place, as no amount of virtue signaling will cover for sloppy delivery. read more

I really like Boniello's I think I just got the wrong thing last night. Ive been a few times and finally writing a review. Based on my previous experiences I'm comfortable giving 4 stars. Ambiance is nice. It is crowded always and loud but overall nice. Service has always been good. I think I had pasta and maybe chicken before which were both good. Last night I got the seafood platter special which had salmon, flounder, tuna and shrimp with rice and mixed vegetables. The salmon was bland. Flounder just looked gross and didn't taste like anything. Tuna was over cooked. Shrimp was good. Rice was good. Vegetables were under cooked. My boyfriend had the chicken piccata which was good and I ate some of his. My brother had the chicken parm which he liked and looked delicious. I really think I just picked the wrong dinner. For dessert we had a half dozen zeppoles, chocolate cake and affogato. The zeppoles are awesome and the affogato too. The chocolate cake was overly sweet and not great in my opinion. Will definitely return and pick a better dish. read more

Boniello's - Seafood Platter - Italian Near Me - Riverdale, New Jersey

Garlic knot vodka chicken sliders, squash ravioli, Ron and Sammi pie - service is getting a little bit iffy. This used to be our goto because of how great everything tastes and the service was spectacular. Now that they know they rock, service is getting a little cocky, please talk with staff and retrain, no amount of attitude is welcome in the service industry. read more

okay I went here last night and spent $150 on six different dishes and every single one of them was absolutely horrible. The soup tastes like dishwater, the salad croutons were untoasted white bread, the grilled peaches - LITERALLY WERE'NT - also the "Candied Walnuts - were just WALNUTS.... Thankfully they put the dressing on the side... because that was also surprisingly (because how do you scew up a balsamic vinnegarette) BAD... Francese Sauce was Goopy and solid... THE VEAL WAS DELICIOUS - If i ever have to go here again, i will stick to the Veal Parm.... Do you have a disgruntled chef working on tuesday nights? i cant complain enough....... read more