Pizza is great. Love the small nostalgic place. I look forward to this pizza when I am in the area.

Mainline has that hometown pizzeria vibe with friendly staff. Their cheesesteak pizza was the best I've ever had! The combination of tender steak, mix of cheeses, and deliciously caramelized onions was perfect. I loved that it had no peppers-- they typically make these pies at other pizzerias a bit soggy. A must-try! read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Cheesesteak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

Mainline pizza is the best....the pizza crust has a flavor that goes back in my memory 50 years ago to NYC...they used to say it had to do with the water from the Westchester County reservoirs... this guy has mastered that Great Taste...who knows maybe he brings his water in...they make the bread for the sandwiches with pizza dough...sandwiches are great.... read more

thin good crispy crust consistent every time - money. Muscles also very good. Boogers and poop dictionary soup because I love you

Review for plain pie only. Pretty much a basic football pizza. Thin-ish crust. Bland sauce. Standard cheese. Three stars for the pizza. Plus, an extra star for the old school pizzeria vibe and the guys who run the place. Middle of the road pizza. Wouldn't go out of my way but if I am in the area I may give it another try. read more

Food here is great but I had to remove 2 stars because the man I spoke to when I placed more order was extremely rude. I wasn't familiar with the sizes of pizza they offered so I had a couple of questions and he made it sound like I was conducting the Spanish inquisition. I just wanted to know the sizes they offered so I didn't under order! It loves such a bad taste in my mouth that I don't think I'll ever call there to order a pizza again. Maybe I'll order in store, but I not sure if I'll ever go back. There are plenty of pizza places around here that don't treat you like the enemy. read more

My go to pizza spot Does not ever disappoint If you're looking for a local pizza place that hits every time it's Mainline! It truly think it's one of the best in the area! Definitely give it a try! read more

Old school pizzeria, exactly what you expect in Jersey!! Great selection, whether you stick with a plain pie, classic pepperoni, or disco fries specialty pie, it will be a 10 out of 10 every time!!! read more

Highly recommend the chicken vodka parm! It's so delish. All the other food we got was so goood too. read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Highly recommend the Chicken Vodka Parm!! This place is delish, my new pizzeria to order from. - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

Consistency! Dom and the team consistently make sure that you're getting the best pizza! Small quaint place to get in and get out or have a quick slice. They offer a regular style crust, but also a thin style, which is phenomenal. Never have an issue about the cheese or the quality of the products ingredients going into the pizza and being able to tell on the final product. Keep going! read more

I have frequented Mainline Pizza for the past 15 years. Me and my 3 works friends usually go once a week and find their pizza average and just get a few slices. Today, Sunday, we went to eat at the restaurant across the street from Mainline. That establishment is trying to stay open during Covid and has put outdoor seating in their parking lot. Because there is limited parking we parked across the street at Mainline. Mainline is CLOSED on Sundays so we figured it would not be a big deal but we received a threat of getting our car towed on our windshield. I'm not sure if YELP will post this review or not but I think they should because it speaks to the character and community feel of this establishment. We try to support all places in town especially during Covid because they ask us to support our small businesses. We'll Mainline Pizza just lost our support. I find this notice extremely petty considering their pizza place wasn't even open at the time I parked there. Any place that threatens to TOW MY CAR is a place that I will NEVER eat at again. You lost my business and I will now eat at all the other 10 pizza places that are in the area that you compete with. read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Parking lot - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

I've been a pizza semi-snob in this general area for a while and thought I would finally give Mainline a try. This is a deli-sized 2-man operation that's been in business for 40 years so I had to see what was what. My go-to's are Pizza Terminal (Verona), Dough (Wayne) and Gino's (Belleville). Montclair pizza is a chapter for another day. First off, there's not a gazillion employees behind the counter like Forte's or Rusillo's or Pizza One. This is not a restaurant, it's a pickup spot. It took me 5 busy phone calls to get through bc on Mon/Tue they have a $12 plain pie special, so it's a beehive. There's plenty of parking. The guys were nice to deal with, no attitude and no-frills. It's not knock your socks off amazeballs pizza but it's better than your typical chain-franchise delivery. It's standard, but solid. I would rate pie Quality about 3.75 stars, but I give them 4 bc they can keep costs down after 40 years and still hold fort, so they know their biz. Hats off to that. When I got home, I sautéed some mushrooms and roasted jalapeños for my toppings, reheated my slices in a Breville and drizzled some Truffle hot sauce - now we're talking. Does it reheat well? Kinda - I wasn't disappointed. For $12 you can't beat it. Can't speak to their toppings or sandwiches as of yet but go & see what you think. read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Plain pie is a great value and tastier than you'd expect - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

John S., so here is a guy that parks in someone else's parking spot and get Butt hurt because he got a letter asking him not to park illegally. I always read the other reviews to see what other people think. This place makes a solid sandwich and good pizza. My favorite is the grilled chicken and the occasionally cutlet. read more

Crispy pizza, cooked well done. Cheese and sauce lacked flavor. There was no option to add salt to my slice while at the counter so as is, overall it was a well cooked average edible NJ slice. The pizza won't offend most ppl as most NJ pizza is gloppy undercooked doughy and horrible. I wouldn't travel here for a slice but if I were going to Rita's Ice down the road from here and starving I would grab a slice provided there was a salt shaker lying around. read more

Excellent local pizzeria. We've ordered the plain and white pizza and it's cooked well done just how we prefer. Would suggest mozzarella Styx and chicken fingers, too. read more

I honestly think this place has one of the best pizzas in the area - also the buffalo chicken pie is the best I ever had!!!. Always on point and the sandwiches are great too. read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Chicken cutlet sandwich! Banging! Always on point - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

We just moved to the area and were looking for pizza. Our friends recommended Mainline and they were right. Mainline's pizza is delicious and we highly recommend it read more

Not sure how this place has 4 stars. Pizza was average at best and it was not cooked long enough at all

I just recently moved into the area and found Mainline Pizza simply by driving by. Stopped in grabbed a cold sub and what can I say, except, to the say the staff is attentive and the food delicious. Terrific sub sandwiches, prepared well and their bread is amazing. Great job to the owner and staff, it is a great place for take out for sure. I am now a regular and the Monday Tuesday special is a nice extra to an already great business. read more

Classic spot for New York style pizza. The owner is a machine just cranking them out. Really nice guy too. I love the retro diner look of the place as well. Having their own parking lot is another huge plus on Main Street. I don't ever have to be worried about being run over trying to pickup takeout. read more

Had no intention of coming here and just stumbled upon it. One of the best slices I've had in a while. Super nice staff!!!!

Awesome pizza and this place is close enough for me to walk to! Highly recommend the Philly Cheese Steak pizza!

Been going to Mainline since I was a child. The place hasn't changed much in the years from a physical standpoint, but the pizza has. The inside of this place is extremely basic and I wouldn't recommend eating inside. It's pretty much takeout only, with the exception of 3-4 tables inside. If you prefer pizza that has more sauce than cheese, this is your place. The pizza isn't very cheesy. It is very standard in taste. Not above average, but not half bad either. They have specials on Monday-Tuesday where plain pizzas are 9.99. Sandwiches are also discounted. It does get very busy here pretty much everyday of the week, as this seems to be a favorite among locals. The wait for pizza can sometimes be upwards of 30-45 minutes. Note - They do not deliver. read more

I have been going to here for years. The pizza is out of this world. They make so crispy that it seems to melt in your mouth. When I am not in a pizza mood, I always grab a nice sub sandwich. The price is right, they have specials on Mondays and Tuesday on their large sandwiches and pizzas. read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Best Pizza and Sanwich in town - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

Best pizza in NJ. I moved across the country 16 years ago and every time I come home to visit I drop in for two slices of cheese and corner of Sicilian...and one more slice to go. It's the best and EXACTLY the same every year I have it. read more

My favorite local pizza place! Where else can you get a large pie and a large hot sandwich (we get a delicious chicken parm one) for $15 bucks on a Monday or Tuesday? They get swamped on these nights so make sure to order about 45 minutes in advance. read more

The pizza was cook perfectly and it wasnt to greasy and the crust was golden brown the only problem is it is a little pricey

Will have to downgrade my review as Main Line Pizza will never get my business via phone. They do not accept calls from blocked numbers which is annoying in a day and age where land lines are no longer necessary and company phones are forced to only show up as blocked. Luckily their competitors down the road accept phone calls from blocked numbers. read more

I have only ordered from here one time. I heard they had disco fries pizza and I had to try it. It was delicious however I would order it a little bit well done next time. I look forward to trying some other items on their menu read more

Mainline Pizzeria - Disco fries pizza - Pizza Near Me - Little Falls, New Jersey

I ordered two pies one plain and one with peperoni and mushrooms. The pizza isn't bad, but the second pie wasn't completely baked and we had to finish baking it in the over. Not really a fan of having to fix the pizza so it's edible... This place also does not deliver. read more

Just started going to this pizzeria and it is amazing. The buffalo chicken pizza is great and has a such an amazing flavor to it. 10/10 recommend trying. read more

I stopped in here one Tuesday evening to take advantage of their $9.99 large plain cheese pizza deal. I called ahead to order and they told me the pizza would be 20-25 minutes, so I did a few other things in the meantime. I also told them I'd like my pizza well done. When I arrived, the gentlemen behind the counter were very friendly and the one guy showed me my pizza before putting it in the box so I could see if it was well done enough. The pizza was cooked perfectly and was piping hot. My boyfriend and I both had a couple of slices each and we enjoyed it. I'd definitely return to pick up another pizza from Mainline because it's a great value for a fresh, tasty pizza. read more

My family go to! Theeeee Best according to a very picking boy!!!! Pizza and hero's are our favs here.

This is the best quick pick up pizza in town! Classic pizza made fresh to order with great topping selection and yummy sauce. I'm also really picky about my cheese, often finding it too thick or greasy and their's was just right! Their prices are cheap and they have drinks to pick up too (do you know how rare it is to find cherry pepsi?!). They have a few barstools and small booths to sit at while you're waiting but the place is cramped so don't plan to hang out with the whole family. read more

I've been going here a long time, pizza is very good, price is good. The sandwiches aren't the best. Call ahead especially on Monday and Tuesday. They get really busy read more

One of my coworkers turned me onto this place last year and we haven't stopped going since so let me put you guys onto one of favorite places to eat lunch. We went drove past this place for years and never stopped in until one of coworkers kept raving about it and eating it constantly so we finally all went to grab lunch. First time we went we quickly realized they had specials on Monday and Tuesday's that you really can't beat...6$ 12" subs and a lot of variety or a large pie for 10$ so I tried the chicken parm, huge sandwich for 6$! I got this a few times then started branching out and tried a slice and a meatball parm, also good. Now things are getting interesting so I normally don't try cheesesteaks from random places because I'm usually let down as they not "philly" at all or skimpy or well..just not good..I was surprised, not only was the cheesesteak great but a good size too, no complaints also tried their fries with it, perfect. All the food and owner is great. I will warn you it does get super crowded at lunch and seating is very limited, it's a shoebox inside..I recommend take out or if you're eating in try it weds-sat to have a better chance at a seat! read more

Best pizza in North Jersey in my opinion. I moved up north almost 10 years ago from South Jersey and was always disappointed with the pizza. About 5 years ago we moved to Little Falls and found this gem! It's tiny, but the pizza and other menu items are great! The Italian Hot Dog is pure awesome. And the guys that work there are so nice! Love this place! read more

Its and old school pizzaria- you go in, grab a few Slices and a soda and thats it. Its a tasty sauce, the guys working the counter are nice and friendly. 8 bucks for 2 special slices and a Snapple for lunc was pretty good for me! read more

the pizza is average. go to sunray; much better pizza. the marsala sauce is great. i find their marinara sauce to be slightly acidic at times. a hit or miss. i would rather have them be a hit all the time. not consistent but good luck. read more

Good pizza but their hours seem a little weird? I have stopped by a few times when they were scheduled to be open only to find that they are closed. Staff is always nice when I do stop in so that is a huge plus. read more