Had their broasted chicken basket and tenderloin sandwich. Both were fantastic. My order was ready within 15 min. This place is great for quick and flavorful food. I only wish I'd think of this place more often than I do. read more

Andy's Place - Chicken basket with potato wedges roll and butter - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

The chicken is amazing! Potato wedges were very crispy and tasty! Food was ready to go when I arrived! Very quaint little place!

Good handicap access. The decor is straight out of 1970, dont care about that. Place was clean. I had the sweet and sour chicken and my sister had 2 pc chicken dinner. We were the only dine in table although there were about half a dozen pickup orders. Our table was 6 feet from the counter but she set the soda cups on the counter and we had to retrieve them. Then when the styrofoam boxes arrived she also dropped them on the counter and we had to retrieve them too. There was a rack of silverware in sight but we each got only a plastic fork. The food quantity was adequate for the price. My sweet and sour chicken had a pink sauce which was neither sweet nor sour, it was just...there. My sister's chicken was ok but a bit dry. We each had "grecian" green beans which was nothing but canned green beans. We each also got a roll and a cold butter pat but only our plastic forks to split the rolls and apply the butter. Overall, filling enough and not too expensive but nothing to get excited about. The one unisex restroom was closed, nowhere to wash up before eating. read more

best fried chicken in the area!!!!!! Period. Phone in and ready in 10 minutes. Easy parking.

The Gyro was "meh". That is NOT tzatziki sauce my friends. I'm not sure what salad dressing it was, but it wasn't tzatziki. The ribs were not good. I think they were pre-boiled or something. The potato wedges were very, very good. The service was friendly and they are very fast at preparing your food. read more

This was my mom's go to spot, when she was hosting a gathering at home. Their chicken is very good. The owners are wonderful and friendly.

My Indiana friends and family insisted that we get off the farm and head to this favorite take out spot. I waited outside due to Covid concerns. It's a pretty plain Jane storefront with parking. I enjoyed the chicken wings and fries. Not the best thing I ever ate but a solo dos meal. I'll definitely sample more of the menu next family trip. I'm the meantime, be safe Granger/Elkhart - There was way too many defiantly massless! read more

Andy's Place - Understated front. - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

I have lived in Elkhart all my life and finally made a stop here for lunch. Definitely wasn't impressed. Hubby and I had gyro's. Mine was the chicken version. It was very bland and you could here them heating up the meat in the back in the MICROWAVE!!! It was gross and dry. Decor is out dated, but I didn't mind. It was a nice throw back . However, we will come back to try the chicken I have heard so much about. The location was clean. Staff/owner didn't seem to care that we were there. Hopefully, it goes better next time we are there. read more

See all

Food is good and prices are cheap. This restaurant is a true mom and pop shop. A Greek style restaurant with a host of options. The owners work the grill and the register. Seating is available if you want a truly private meal. If you would like to digress from big burger chains, this place is for you. read more

Andy's Place - Good food - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Awesome little hole in the wall specializing in broasted chicken. Sooooo much better than KFcrap. Tried the combo plate and a side of chili. Weird to only get one big fry but wasn't too concerned. Gyro was great too! Menu has chicken, fish, some Greek, and a little Chinese. Will be back for more! read more

See all

We love their chicken!!! Like the coleslaw. I don't really like the potato wedges. But the rest of my family like them. The chicken takes 20 minutes to cook, but worth every minute of the wait!! The couple is really nice! Someday we will try something else, maybe... read more

We hadn't been to Andy's for while, so we ordered some broasted chicken the other night. Oh my, we had forgotten how wonderful it is. Hot, juicy, crispy. Perfect! And the broasted potatoes are great as well. So today my wife wanted more Andy's for lunch. Mixing it up a little, we ordered fish dinner and a tenderloin sandwich and fried rice. Everything was excellent. If you haven't tried Andy's, do it today!! read more

Broasted chicken thighs, grease dripping off them. Dripping! Besides dripping grease, I have never had so much fat on my chicken thighs. Never again. If you stop in, make sure you DO NOT look at all the dead bugs and dust (and whatever) in the windowsills. read more

Best broasted chicken in Elkhart. Quick service. Tasty, and healthy food. Goodbye fried. They offer other great selections as well.

Bought chicken for dinner and found hair on every piece! Definitely not a clean place with poor hygiene.

Are you seeking a hip, trendy or posh place to dine? Do you have a strong preference for restaurants with an optimal location, and amenities? Well Andy's is the wrong restarant for you, but if you're in search for delicious food (especially fried chicken) you've come to a great place!!! Andy's is definitely the epitome of a no-frills, mom and pop restarant, with the emphasis being on NO-FRILLS. The entire appearance of this restarant is extremely basic, dated and could really use a makeover. Yet Andy's is a fairly popular well respected restarant in the area, and is known for their Broasted chicken, which is very popular. Strangely, unlike other restaurants that are designated into a category, I'm not sure what type of restarant a person would classify Andy's as being? They serve a random variety of food, ranging from classic All-American style, to Greek, and Chinese. One Greek menu option they serve that not all Greek/Mediterranean restaurants serve is Spanakopita, which sounded good, but I decided to order their prized Broasted chicken. When my chicken meal arrived, my entire meal was piping hot, and I could tell my food came straight out of the fryer!!!! This was a very good sign. I love restaurants like this that make food fresh to order. When I tasted my food especially my chicken it was delicious. Crispy, fried texture on the outside and juicy, tender, delicious chicken meat on the inside. Just the way fried chicken should be. My overall meal was great. The rating I'd give this place based on the food alone is a solid 5. However, since I dined in and atmosphere does factor into a person's enjoyment of their food, due to the appearance and atmosphere of the restarant I have to subtract a star. On the positive side, regardless of the restaurant's appearance and atmosphere their food speaks for itself, and not only do I recommend Andy's I'd also return. I just don't recommend dining in. read more

My wife and daughter wanted Burger King but being fairly new to the area I suggested this place. I ordered the regular gyro which was dry and portion very small and wife ordered chicken gyro which was like rubber. Chicken strips and fry were sub par. I'm wondering if this place is known strictly for the boasted chicken. The lady wasn't very friendly either. I wouldn't waste my money unless it's the boasted chicken your going for. read more

I love the owners! They are always so nice and friendly! Been eating there since I was little and their broasted chicken is awesome!!! Sometimes we get a lot just to have leftovers because it is so yummy. They also have little chocolates and other small snacks that I believe they make themselves and they are delicious! read more

Not good!!! gyro meat was like it was left over from 2 months ago! Bought a tea out of cooler and it was 9 months out of date. Picked up a new menu and immediately through it out!! Will not be back. And this was their second chance, I had some of their famous chicken several months ago only to find a long black hair in the breading! Nope! read more

Holy time warp! Walking into this place had me wondering what business was like when it originally opened. The checkered flooring, orange booths and neon light fixture on the wall, old style shake machine and freezer was all very neat and made me contemplate another era. I appreciate the fact they kept it original and kept it up well. The food was actually pretty good and the woman at the counter was very nice. I ordered the fish platter with fries and green beans and was happy that it all tasted so clean and was cooked well. Not greasy at all! We tried this restaurant by chance and will definitely be going back! read more

Food was excellent. Agree with the previous review on the wings and house special. Decor is blah. old. outdated BUT clean. This restaurant has been around since I grew up in the area. They must be doing something right. read more

Andy's Place - Catered potatoes - American Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

Being new to Elkhart wanted to try somewhere new. Waste of time and money. Gyro plate was small and the meat was dry. Chicken was good but then found a bug in the dinner roll and lost our appetites! Politely asked for our money back and the lady was very rude. read more

Great fish and chicken. The service is also very good. You do not come here for the atmosphere because there is none. However, the food is so good you don't care. Carry out also available. read more

We heard about this place and thought we'd try it. I got the wings and my wife had the chicken gyro. Not too impressed. Would like to try the fish sometime but won't be back for a while read more

i will not go back i ask the lady was the fish she had was catfish or etc. when she told me the type of fish i told her i couldn't eat it nor have it and i didn't want it but i still wanted the burger meal she still charged my card for the fish meal.the fish and fries wasn't worth it the cole slaw that came with the meal it was bland. my husband had the burger combo and he didn't like it didn't have a taste to it. read more

Best boasted chicken ever! Nice people own the place. Quick, friendly, delicious!!! Call in carry out... Ready when you get there..

Got carry-out chicken (24 pc). It was delicious 2 days in a row. Even warmed up it was still juicy. I hadn't been to Andys for 25 years. The owners seem like great folks. I will return and I do recommend the chicken read more

Don't go here if you are hungry. I got the chicken gyro for $7 with tax. The Styrofoam container weighed more than the sandwich. It only had 4 very thin slices of chicken. I also asked for a small cup of ice and was told that it cost fifty cents extra. I would have been better off getting two 0.99 cent cheese burgers from McDonald's. The sandwich was not anything I would ever order again maybe for 0.99. I'm sure it only cost them 0.50 to make the sandwich. read more

Wow, small mom and pop restaurant. Dated interior but that's not what I came here for. Best Broasted chicken in town. Wings were amazing. Gyro was flavorful. House plate keeps me coming back for more! read more