I have been coming here for so many years and the one word that always comes to mind is consistency. This place is by far the best Italian in the area. The Cesar Salad is a favorite along with the Medallions of Chicken. Service is always above par in the dining room and the bartenders are very attentive when sitting in the lounge area. Prices are very very reasonable and there's always plenty of food to take home if you cannot finish. Definitely a must try. read more

We made a return visit to Amici's last night and had a GREAT meal! They have a Tuesday Pasta Night which is all you can eat and you get to create your own meal from a choice of 5 sauces and 12 toppings! The dinner comes with a salad and delicious WARM bread! Also includes a nice choice of desserts. The staff was warm and friendly and the chefs at the cooking station made the whole experience a lot of fun! I definitely recommend it to everyone. read more

We moved out further east a couple years ago but decided to make the trip back to Amici tonight to visit one of our favorite Italian restaurants. I'm so glad we made the drive because it was even better than we had remembered. Both the service and the food are excellent, and we love the warm ambiance of the place. I had the lobster ravioli with asparagus and I have to say it was the best lobster ravioli I have ever had even compared to similar dishes at very high end restaurants. Our server Dawn and the rest of the wait staff were on top of everything. There are so many casual Italian restaurants to choose from on Long Island, but this is one that stands apart from the rest and at reasonable menu prices too. read more

Food was very bland, not very good, the decor is gross, looks like it needs a good cleaning or at least an update, actually I would call it a dump.We went because of a family obligation, if it wasn't for that I'd keep driving by. read more

I have been to Amici's frequently over the years and have never been disappointed . There is a full bar separate from the restaurant so the noise level is balanced. The restaurant itself is Rustic with a warm atmosphere. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Our server was attentive and pleasant. The food has always been delicious and reasonably priced. I recommend the Anti Pasta, clams casino, baked clams, as well as fried Calamari for appetizers.My favorite entree's are the Veal Marsala ,Eggplant Rollatini, and the Chicken Francese. .Amici's is a great place for a quiet dinner for two or a nice family dinner. read more

Been here a handful of times and have been satisfied. The place seems to do pretty good business, the parking lot always seems rather full. Happy with the quality of food just think its slightly overpriced. read more

Very delicious place for a Sunday lunch to meet with your boyfriend's parents. Everything was very delicious and it seemed like everyone enjoyed their meal. The only downside was as soon as the busboy cleared our plates, our server brought the bill and walked away. The resturant was pretty empty so its not as if they needed to turn our table. My bf's mom was the one who actually brought it up that we never got offered coffee or dessert and my bf's parents are after meal coffee people. So we just sat at the table for another 30 minutes talking anyway. read more

Had dinner last night at Amici's table of nine. Service was terrible. Four of the meals were returned mine was an appetizer of eggplant the sauce over the top was like salsa and it tasted terrible when the manager came over and had to return the plates he was quite rude. The manager than brought over two large plates of deserts very nice but at that point we were all very upset and just wanted to get out of there. I for one will never ever go back. read more

Large portions of standard northern Italian fare. The food is over priced and over salted in my opinion. Service is spotty-sometimes good, sometimes so so. For LI italian, you could do better but its not the worst place around if you are nearby. read more

I got the veal with prosciutto with mozzarella and tomato sauce. Let's just say I get a salty, soupy mess of a dish. The mozzarella wasn't even melted on top of the veal. Usually, this dish is served with sliced prosciutto over the veal with mozzarella on top of that. This dish was chunks of prosciutto all over the dish with veal and melted mozzarella not even layered on one another. I took maybe 2 bites, told both the busser and the server I did not like my dish. Was it taken off the bill you ask? No. Did they ask if i may want something else? No. Did we have to pay for it? Yes. Horrible customer service. I work in this industry and I would have taken that right of the check, asked if I could get them something else, and probably sent them home with a free dessert, just to try to get them to come back. 2 stars because everyone else liked their meals. Oh well, on to the next place. read more

This has been a favorite place of ours for years! Any opportunity I have to go out to dinner this is my first choice. Always guaranteed a delicious meal with great service. The seafood Chiara is always my go to dish. If its a date night or family nice this is the place to go. read more

Great spot for dinner or lunch the wraps are excellent the pizza is awesome they have some good deserts too all around good italian food

My husband and I did go back for the Tuesday pasta night. It was very good and the price is excellent! They have several different sauces and pastas to choose from. There are also a multitude of toppings and ingredients that you can add to the sauce to individualize your own meal. You can go back as many times as you want and use a different combination each time if you so choose. In addition to the pasta entrée you also receive a salad and a dessert. I was very pleasantly surprised by the pasta night offering and I would definitely go back to do this again. The only one complaint that I have is that I could not finish my second plate and was not allowed to take the leftover food home with me. While I suppose I can understand the reasoning for this, I am somebody who hates to see any food go to waste and I know what was left would be thrown away. I would definitely recommend going to Amici's for pasta night. read more

Love this place!!!!! Great management by Courtney, Cassie is awesome as are Michael, Omar, etc! The chefs do a great job too. Great seafood and pastas! Love the interior makeover! read more

This was our second time here, don't know what happened but the food was not good this time. The breaded calamari was tough. I ordered linguine with clam sauce. It was cold. I told the waitress, who by the way was very sweet, she took it back. It was definitely microwaved and the clams were tough and horrible, like rubber. Not a home run, the place is nice but the food unfortunately is not good at all. My husband had eggplant parm which was comparable to a pizza take out. Cheesecake was stale. Totally disappointing. read more

My first experience with Amici about a month ago was fabulous. Great Prix Fixe special. Every item our table ordered was outstanding and the service was prompt and friendly. Management stopped by more than once to make sure we were happy. We looked forward to our return visit a couple of nights ago. I'm sorry to say that this was a very different experience. I ordered the shrimp and asparagus for $19.99. It arrived as a huge bowl of spaghetti, *three* shrimp and I'd guess two asparagus spears chopped up. Essentially a $20 bowl of spaghetti. When my sister-in-law asked the server about it, she was informed "that's the standard portion." After some reluctance, the server agreed to let the management know we weren't pleased with this. And then nothing. No one stopped by the table to follow-up. Another person at our table with some dietary restrictions, requested a chicken breast and broccoli. The half-breast was tough and overcooked. The plate was overwhelmingly broccoli. She was charged $22. I was so disappointed by this that I've been motivated to post my first ever review here. I thought for sure we'd found a great neighborhood restaurant to enjoy again and again. I'd be hesitant to go back now- I feel as if it's a 50-50 chance I'll overpay for an underwhelming meal or get a great meal for a fair price. Quite frankly, I don't have the budget to waste. There are dozens of Italian restaurants in my area and I'll be spending my hard-earned money at one of them next time. read more

Last night I stopped at one of my favorite places Amici in Mt Sinai! It's never fails to satisfy my need for comfort food and with some of my favorites, and last night was no exception! You've got to try the chicken Marsala just delicious and a very generous portion! read more

We Used to eat here every week because we loved the food and ambiance. The on troubling factor was the owner. On more than one occasion she was rude to us.The last straw was when we bought our office staff there.After paying a hefty tab,the owner informed us that people had complained that we were too loud. We weren't speaking louder than any of the other patrons and when I expressed that though she told me that I might want to consider not returning. We never went back. read more

Went to Amici's with my peeps. Had a great time and great food. Service was excellent and the owner cared about how we felt about everything. We had the pasta night special and it was fun and the choices were very satisfying. Would absolutely recomment this restaurant to anyone. The bar was very friendly also and had great atmosphere. Think I will go eat in the bar with my husband next time. . Judith read more

We went with a group of 8 because we've always enjoyed this restaurant. We definitely did not enjoy it this time. The service was terrible. Two of the people said they thought their chicken was microwaved. My food was cold. It was embarrassing as I was the one to recommend and pick it for this special occasion. To top it off, they added a 22% tip as it was a large party. The waitress spent more time with her table of 2 than with us. She didn't pour the bottle of wine, reached right in front of me to put a plate down and was very inattentive. read more

After coming here for years we are done with this restaurant. Yes, it has always seemed a bit run down but this dinner was NOT acceptable. We came as a party of eight which means they automatically add 20% tip. We are good tippers but adding tip onto total with tax is underhanded. Lori D was NOT a pleasurable server - why should she bother knowing she was getting a nice tip one way or the other. She never came back for a second round of drinks or even to offer grated cheese after serving entrees. She stood at one end of table and took orders instead of approaching each person. I kept smelling mop water but place is carpeted - ugly too. It ended up it was our plastic menus, washed with filthy rag. UGH. A month ago we ate there and had a delicious roll and bread basket. This night was some strange light brown bread. Two people said the chicken tasted microwaved and two others were not happy at all. All 8 of us have lived on the Island for most of our lives (we're in our 60s) and no one will be returning. Sad since my wife's lunch with her friends the previous week was enjoyable so we moved or reservation to here from Caffe Amici's which is nearby us. There are plenty of Italian restaurants on this Island and this one seems doomed. For the owners: 0057 table 71 7:09 07/28/18 read more

There was a party of 12 (birthday) this past week-end...Entrees tasted good and plentiful...The soup of the day was..split pea soup with no other choices which I thought was ridiculous .What is split pea doing in what I thought was an upscale Italian restaurant ..I expected at the least minestrone or escarole soup....We had 2 servers..Each one never came back with an answer to a question that pertained to food...and one also seemed angry that you didn't want to ask another question for fear that you would get yelled at...This was my first experience here and my last.... read more

I have enjoyed their food before but the spaghetti with white clam sauce was a big disappointment. The clams were canned with no fresh clams on the half-shell on top and it did not have the briny taste of fresh clam juice. I could not detect any fresh parsley but the dried green specks tasted more like oregano than parsley. It was not worth the $17 plus that they charged. read more

The décor outside was similar to what was inside. Not appealing at all. The food was ok, nothing to write home about. The service was excellent though. read more

I've been passing this restaurant for years, commenting that we have to stop because the parking lot is always full, A very good sign. My husband and I finally stopped in last night, Tuesday, "All You Can Eat Pasta Night." From the time we walked in, we were greeted and got wonderful, friendly service. We were immediately brought a basket of assorted,warm breads and dipping sauces. Very nice garden salad, with enough blue cheese dressing. We both had the pasta bar. Amazing sauce (Scolara?), as well as a la vodka, Alfredo, marinara, and oil & garlic. I can't remember all the add in ingredients you can choose between, but there were very good little meatballs, ground sausage, shrimp, roasted peppers, mushrooms, broccolini--much more. The pasta bar chefs were friendly and very helpful. For dessert, (included), we had banana Nutella bread pudding, and NY style cheesecake. Both wonderful. The noise level was a bit high, but it was the sound of people having fun, not annoying. I came home happy, and stuffed beyond belief. read more

The food is always delicious and the menu varied. The employees are the best. I have never patronized a restaurant that was so willing to accommodate almost any request regarding food preparation and substitutions. I always have a great experience at Amici's. read more

Have been coming here for years, food is always amazing! Look forward to returning. Would recommend to anyone who likes good Italian food!

My family and I decided to eat here after a long Sunday afternoon. We had a gift certificate that we won and figured we would try it. I liked the atmosphere, you can dress up or casually (as we were) and still feel comfortable. The service was good and the food so-so. My real complaint is that my daughter has a peanut allergy and apparently EVERYTHING they make is made with peanuts...right down to the olive oil that is on the table. This I find out after my daughter used some as butter on her bread (luckily all was ok). After ordering app's I asked the waitress to see if the calamari is made with peanut oil, she came back and said "yes", so we told our daughter she can't have any...10 mins later a manager came out and said "Everything we make is made with peanuts or peanut oil". I could not believe that with the number of peanut allergies children have today that they do not display the fact that ALL meals are made with peanuts...it's not even on the menu. I do have to say they offered to make my daughter a meal from scratch not using any nuts, which we ok'd because we already began eating and drinking when we were informed of this peanut infested restaurant. I will not eat there again and I already began informing parents of children with allergies and anyone who may know someone with nut allergies. read more

Been eating at this restaurant for the past 3 years. It was pretty good three years ago, but I think it has gone downhill recently. Had lunch there about 2 weeks ago and I felt like they skimped on the ingredients to reduce cost. The head lettuce salad was mediocre and the chicken parmisian was tough and chewy, and was drowned in tomato sauce. The only portion of the meal that was OK was the side dish of spaghetti with marinara. read more

It has to be said that the staff are lovely, you couldn't ask for nicer people. Pasta night is always an attraction for my kids, which offers salad, a pasta station then dessert. Tonight's experience had to shared, the caesar salad is among the worst caesar salads I've tasted, lacking in caesar dressing, over salted (unusual for a salad). Previously I've had their house salad, its not unusual to get butchered looking bruised lettuce. So, onto the pasta station, I decided on garlic, oil and spaghetti - surely couldn't go wrong with that!? Well, the garlic and oil was more like watery garlic powder sauce with a minimal amount of garlic (and oil!!). Dessert were fine. I really have given these guys a chance, its just terrible value for money. Maybe its just pasta night? read more

This has been one of my favorite restaurants for years. The staff is always great and the food is delicious. I always leave with leftovers which I love! read more

Amici now has a Tuesday night mix and match pasta night. Can't be beat!!! You create your own dish. The selection of sauces, pastas and toppings make it a real food experience not to be missed. Freshly cooked right in front of you! I love this option! You have got to try it.... read more

I went to Amici's because of a recommendation of a co-worker. I don't know if I did something to upset them or if it was because they haven't gone in a while and the restaurant took a wrong turn. She raved about the service but ours was very impersonal and my party and I felt as if they'd rather be somewhere else. The food was good for some but not for others. Maybe it was an off day, but I won't be going back to be sure. read more

very overpriced !! and they skimp out on the expensive ingredients like shrimp even though they charge you an arm and a leg.. almost all the 5 star reviews on here are from family members trying to make the place seem great. read more

The food is very good. The Seafood Chiara is a must have, but the service, at times is lacking. But for the most part, the dining experience is enjoyable. read more

The last time I ate at this restaurant was in the 90's and I wasn't impressed then. I figured it has been in business for so long and the parking lot is always packed. So, last night me and my husband went there for dinner and it was absolutely disgusting. Chef Ramsey needs to tear this place apart. For the two of us it was almost $100. The restaurants appearance needs major overhauling. Our waitress was very unpleasant to top it off. My husband ordered a special that had shrimp, veal, and chicken over pasta and I ordered Broccoli Rabe with Grilled Chicken. My dish was approximately $20 with two pieces of chicken that were paper thin that I wouldn't feed this to my dog! The menu is entirely TOO big and this in itself says al ot. Usually fine dining has a small condensed menu with exquisite cuisine. Honestly the diner has better food than this restaurant. I am very surprised to see so many people like their food. Maybe it was an off night but I would never go there again. read more