Met my family for lunch last Friday at 12:30, they provided us with a huge table and a dedicated…read morewaitress which was super nice. Place is easy in and out, very large inside and clean. Menu is traditional, plenty of options, I had the cheeseburger platter which was good. Price for a party of 10 was reasonable, everyone left with a full belly, and pleased with our experience thanks for the great meal and exceptional service.

We came here three times in a week during September 2021. I should have done a review then, and…read morewhen scrolling through my pics, was shocked I hadn't written anything. The food, the ambiance, the service - all were top-notch. I couldn't get enough of this thin crispy pizza that was beautifully topped and balanced for flavor. The wings - forget about it. Our service at the bar was everything you could ask for - friendliness, attention, and humor. This place for me was what my first trip to Syracuse was all about. I felt welcome everywhere I went and was blown away by the warmth of the people. I am so looking forward to my next trip.

My go to place when I'm craving Utica greens. They make them just like I want which is spicy but…read morenot with not a lot of moisture. Today was perfect as always!! I asked for some bread and butter and they brought out a nice hot loaf with garlic butter inside. It was very good. Utica greens were large portion so brought half home. For desert I got a ricotta cannoli and it was fresh and delicious. Service here is always good and I usually have the same waitress. If you want great Utica greens you must come here! Prices here are reasonable also. It's was 15.99 for large portion of greens, free bread and 3.50 for a cannoli.

Riggies are non authentic. Service was good. Not sure how a Utica place misses on a riggie but they…read moredid.

Recognized immediately upon entry and welcomed. Place has character and ambiance. She had the sub…read moreand I had the slice of pizza. Enjoyable!

The waitress was very nice, however the food wait was the worse. More than an HOUR for a sandwhich…read more They offered to refund in 1-2 weeks since we were under a time crunch. It was a large group but still.

I was in town to visit my wife's family in Auburn, NY. My father-in-law spoke highly of this pizza…read morespot so we had to try it. Papa Paulie's is a small establishment with long wait times. They have very limited hours of operation. It is advised to call ahead and expect your pizza to be ready 45-60 minutes, minimum. Service was great. The young lady that took my order was kind and courteous. The gentleman that took my payment was cool and efficient. The pizza is good. Very good. I do wish the pepperonis had more flavor. I also wish the pizza was less greasy. We ordered a large and it was about the size of a typical medium. The crust is thick and the edges are crisp. For Auburn, New York, it is a great spot to order from. I am happy that we were able to support a small business. My only real complaint is the extremely limited hours of operation. Coming from LA, most businesses are open 7 days a week from 10am-8 or 9pm.

The Absolute Best Pizza!!! Thank you for making the most…read moredelicious pizza in Cayuga County.

Was in here today and the staff was wonderful the pizza delicious. I was only in there for a pick…read moreup ordered and she made me feel so welcomed!

The service was poor, the food was overhyped and tasteless and there were only a couple of people…read moreeating and drinking at the bar. I don't know how this place stays in business. I would not go back here.

Went for a walk with a friend at Baltimore woods in Marcellus and was looking for a lunch place…read morenearby and chose here. The place is small and more of a takeout venue but he did have a couple of chairs to sit at the window ledge to eat. I wanted to try the calzone because it's been a long time since I had one and I was craving it. I was really hungry and chose the giant one knowing I would have leftovers. Boy did I have leftovers!!! The thing was HUGE!! The crust was crisp and the filling was substantial (I had sausage, peppers and onions with mozzarella and ricotta). The price was really fair for what I got, soda and giant calzone with extra toppings for $24.00. My friend got a chicken wrap and said that was excellent also. The owner waited on us and he was really friendly and has been in business here for 5 years. Give this place a try, you won't be sorry!

Always great food and excellent staff!! Many choices and all spot on. Very supportive of the…read morecommunity too. :)

I was recently in New York for an extended period of time...visiting my mom, family, friends. I…read morealways fly in and out of Syracuse bc 1) my brother lives in Cuse and can pick me up and 2) it's oddly cheaper (usually) than flying into Rochester. I have a sister in Rochester, but she always tells me to "uber it" I always feel the love when I wanna come home from her :-/ Anyway, this past trip, I flew up a little over a week ago and of course, out of Cuse. My brother wanted to treat me to a pizza and we couldn't decide where to go. I always prefer to try places people haven't been to yet. I like it to be a surprise for them as much it is for me. So we called several places. It was a Friday night, I flew out crazy early on Saturday. Naturally, pizza places on a Friday... always busy. Pizza places in a college town...even busier. Syracuse University keeps them busy as hell. Johnny Mac's. So I'm not sure how far or close it is to campus. It's a little bit of a drive from my brothers house. That turned out to be ok bc the wait was only 30 mins, maybe a little less tbh bc the pizza was SLIGHTLY cold when we picked it up. All the other places we called... hour and half for some, 2 hour wait for others. INSANE! For one pizza! Gurl, bye! So we went with this place. One of the best things for me was...my brother had never been. He took one bite and was like .... "It's so good!" Which made going here even better. And yes, the pizza was delicious. Even if slightly cold...it was still amazing and yeah..we have microwaves for a reason lol. The price was decent too. I wanna say $18 and change, if I remember correctly. Don't quote me on that. May have been slightly cheaper. Regardless, the pizza is fantastic and ya can't go wrong. If you've been, you know, if you haven't been, ya need to go. You won't be disappointed. It really is delicious. It's kinda of in a random spot, doesn't look like your typical pizza place, looks more like a little house lol, inside tho ... definitely pizza place vibes. I waited outside with my pup (saw the inside ...bc ya know, windows and stuff lol). It was in and out. Great place. Even tho I said I love to try new places, and I always do, I would absolutely have their pizza again. Wish I had something to say about the staff, but my brother was the one who dealt with them. Great place. I definitely recommend it. Thanks for reading, YelperMac'ers!!! Cheers!

Great pizza - perhaps some of the consistently best pizza I've had in Syracuse. The wings are…read moreequally good, and they let you buy them in 5s, useful if you have multiple people wanting different sauces, or if you just want a smaller order. Their delivery service is great, and seems to be in-house instead of through a third party. Only con is they're closed Mondays, but that's relatively normal, especially considering they're open Sunday. We really love this place, and hope they stick around for a long time to come.

Absolutely satisfied with service, food, atmosphere. A definite favorite dinner destination…read more Love the ambiance.

Best pizza around. Nothing better than a quick call and getting a cheap and delicious pizza.read more