Joey came right away and put in some extra effort to get me into my apartment and got the key out!! I could of been charged another $240 but because he put in the extra effort it was just the service fee and the lock out fee so total $140 saving me $100!! He was super nice and put me at ease in a difficult situation! Definitely reccomend! read more

After finding a burglar in my apartment one recent afternoon, I needed a new lock. (Yep, skipped all the juicy bits on that story, didn't I???) While the person who answered the phone at All-Star was a bit of a schmuck, Chris, the locksmith who came to my place within four hours (on a holiday weekend, no less), was great, and his assistant, Mike, was polite and quick. I appreciated the time Chris took to explain how the lock system I was getting worked, and he was up-front about what it would cost me - no hidden fees or "gotcha" tactics. He was straight-up and honest, and when you've found people in your house you didn't invite in, you appreciate that kind of honesty. Great service and the price is worth the peace of mind. read more

WARNING WARNING WARNING: THE WORST EXPERIENCE YOU WILL EVER HAVE!!!!!!!!! I called All Star locks based on a recommendation from Jay (Lockbusters) because they didn't service the Brooklyn area. What started out as quick fast process, turned into the worst experience ever!! After making the appointment to install a multi security lock on my new apartment door, Joey (the man who I believe manages the business) sent out a locksmith (and I use that term very loosely) name Chris to install the lock. After putting the lock on the door Chris "the locksmith" locked us both in the apartment with no way of getting out. Not sure what he did to the door but it no longer opened from the inside. He had to climb out the fire escape, go through the roof and open the door from the outside. I couldn't understand why a professional locksmith had to go through the roof to fix the problem if he was on the inside of the apartment WITH HIS TOOLS. After he opened the door, he attempted to fix the problem only for us to get locked in a 2nd time. I asked him what was the problem and Chris became very defensive saying the problem wasn't his fault (although my door was working fine before he got there). When I asked if he can just put the lock back on that was originally there he demanded I pay him $150 for his labor which is absurd since he was the person who created the problem. When I refused Chris took my entire door apart and stole some of the pieces to my lock to inconvenience me since he didn't get paid for ruining my door. I was stranded in my apartment for 3hrs until another locksmith came to rescue me. I called the company to speak with someone in charge, Chris had already called and told his side of the story so Joey didn't care to help or hear my side of the story. After we spoke I told him I was stuck in my house, he promised to call me back never did and when I called the next day several times he refused to take my calls. I will be taking legal action against them; Chris stole the parts to a $400 lock. PLEASE SAVE YOURSELF THE TROUBLE AND USE ANOTHER LOCKSMITH!!!!!! If you need one in Brooklyn M&D and in Manhattan S.O.S both are AMAZING read more

See all

Terrrrrrrrrrible customer service - I went to get a copy of my key, and after they "fixed" the original one, it didn't work. I just wanted an explanation - and the lady at the front desk starts getting angry with me and saying that it wasn't her fault. She said I'm mistaken if I say that the key doesn't work. I went back to my house to try the keys out again, and it still didn't work. I had to go BACK to the store, and the lady refuses to help me and change her attitude - so the manager comes out. He was nicer about it, but he still wasn't as friendly as I'd like. I will most likely never go back again. The key eventually worked - I mainly had a problem with the lady's attitude. She started getting feisty as soon as I asked about my key. For me, the customer service is just as important, if not more. If you're going to have a bad attitude working with me, then I don't want to return, no matter how good your services are. read more

Our apartment front door lock fell apart in my hands, almost literally. I found these guys on ServiceMagic.com. They were incredibly friendly and helpful on the phone, and came to my apartment within 10 minutes. The locksmith was very nice, showed me step-by step how he was repairing my lock, and explained why the last one we had had installed was so shoddy. The price was totally average, but worth it for the service. Highly recommended. read more

These guys did a great job changing the locks for an apartment. They were prompt (arrived a few minutes late but had called to say so.) They had good advice about what to do and installed the new locks quickly. They keyed as many as they could the same. They even put up with a cranky neighbor with style. You can go to their storefront to get additional keys afterward too. I'm keeping their business card. The only minor negative is that the locks were a little expensive, but I don't know anything about the pricing here. I got the pick-proof locks & they are higher. Everything seems expensive in NYC so what the heck. I recommend this business and thank Joey for solving my problems. read more

I called All Star today to fix an iffy bathroom doorknob, a loose deadbolt and a front doorknob that had completely fallen out of the door (real safe, I know!). Joey was prompt, fast, kind enough to explain what he was doing and what needed to be replaced, and just a generally super nice guy. I have no idea how much this sort of thing is "supposed" to cost - but honestly the price seemed fair for New York, and I'm happy to support a local guy doing good work. Highly recommended! read more

Thee only professional locksmith / hardware service i will use in Brooklyn. Prompt friendly skillful. Always dependable and reliable as i used them twice now. My go to guys. Thank you and thank you. Highly recommend. read more

I went to the store to purchase an item I needed to finish a lock installation I was doing myself. The important thing is, in the end I got what I needed and it worked like a charm. However, it wasn't easy to get the cylinder I needed. The women behind the counter fabricated issues I might have with the new piece and acted hesitant to sell me the cylinder in an effort to get me to hire one of the locksmiths. I know they can cost a fortune. I finally had to demand that they just sell it to me and stop discussing fake problems. I'd advise anyone who shops there to know exactly what you need, not ask any questions or start talking to the salespeople. They will just try to upsell you by inventing issues. read more

Quick and reasonable price. No complaints. I wish I hadn't had to ask them to put in the masks but whatever

Joey and his wife are great. Joey (owner) came to my new home to replace all of my locks in the fall. He was quick, efficient and his prices were fair. I have also gone to the storefront to make copies and they have a good little hardware selection. The key event happened several weeks later, when my 2 yr old son was locked in his bedroom mistakenly by an inside lock that was erroneously set in lock mode(fortunately he slept through it). I called Joey on a Saturday night. He sent me a locksmith right away. He even called to check in and make sure he arrived. His locksmith charged me well over the quote, so I called Joey, and he said "let me talk to him!" and suddenly the price dropped by $50. After the transaction, Joey called to make sure I was pleased. I was. That is amazing customer service, and for that i add the 5th star. read more

I stupidly locked myself out of my apartment 40 minutes before I was supposed to lead a meeting. I called up All Star and someone was over in less than 20 minutes! I was back inside with plenty of time to spare. They really saved me! read more

Christopher was polite, professional, thorough, quick, kind and reassuring. Got locked out and he arrived quickly and fixed the situation. Expensive; can probably find similar services in more affordable price range. Bonus points: Christopher was extremely appropriate in both his manner and distance - I could tell he was being mindful not to make me uncomfortable as a woman by herself with an unknown man, late at night. Was generally positive and funny and helped make the most out of a bad situation. Best believe it was appreciated - thank you Christopher! read more

I've lived in the neighborhood for years, and Allstar has always been polite, professional, courteous, and took care of the job at hand. I am grateful for their business here. read more

Shout out to All Star Locksmith. We've used them a couple of times to fix our lock and replace the electric strike latch and they've always been prompt and professional. This weekend, our lock was sticking again, but when the locksmith (didn't get his name) came around it appeared fine... so he didn't even charge the callout fee. That's customer service that keeps you coming back, and another reason to use a local store. All the stars for All Star! read more

Was locked inside of my apartment with another set of keys in the lock that no longer worked. Called and Joey came within 30 minutes and he was amazing, friendly, and efficient. Found All Star on Yelp and was really happy with the outcome! read more

Got locked out in the blizzard. Joey successfully gained entry without breaking the lock. Upon testing the lock we discovered that lock was defective so he did it over again (at no extra cost). fast, professional service. read more

These guys responded immediately at 1:30am when our apartment door lock was stuck. Very polite, helpful and reassuring. Extremely reasonable and fair rates. Don't hesitate to call these guys if you're locked out. read more

Joe is a saint of a man, he came in 5 min flat when 3 other locksmiths wouldn't even answer. Our apartment door was broken in to by robbers and we couldn't wait, so thank you so much joe! read more

I do not like writing such negative reviews, but my experience with this locksmith necessitates it. These swindlers set me back quite a bit. I've also confirmed from my super that they pulled the wool over my eyes and took advantage of my being locked out of my apartment alone. I would avoid them all costs. Full details below. I returned to my apartment at 11:45 PM to discover I was locked out--the person with my spare keys was also out of town. I called Allstar because it was the nearest locksmith and the reviews were pretty good. The person on the phone told me it would be $40 plus whatever the technician charged. I agreed. 30 minutes later the so-called "technician" showed up (some guy with a 213 area code--avoid this guy!) He told me he could try to pick the lock, and if that didn't work he'd replace it. He said the fee was $180 either way. I tried to protest but he wouldn't budge. Given how late it was, and that I needed to get into my apartment, I caved. He spent about two minutes picking the lock after which he said it was "too secure" to be picked and I had to have it drilled off. What could I do? After he drilled it off he tried to upsell me with another lock, this time I said no. He proceeded to continue to try and upsell me saying that my door wouldn't be secure for the night and if anything happens in the middle of the night I could call him. I paid as fast as I could to get him out of there. The next day my super confirmed that I had been totally ripped off--the lock was not "too secure." I had to get the lock replaced. A total waste. read more

I found out there was a spare key seconds before the serviceman was to do $400 worth of lock drilling and replacing (unclear if this included the service and preliminary lock picking fees). Still had to pay $100 ($125 if it wasn't in cash) for service ($45), and preliminary lock picking ($80). The man they sent to work on my lock told me "we're actually more expensive than a lot of the other lock smiths around." read more

The women who run the store are very nice. They have a good supply of general hardware considering that the store is so small. Their prices though are 50% higher than other areas in the neighborhood. Of course if you're in a hurry and desperate they probably have a lock for you and can make the keys. read more

Joey is a skilled and professional businessman who is passionate about his career. As a bystander, I saw a miscommunication happen... He addressed it immediately. I recommend you get quoted on all scenario options before having him come over. It will help avoid confusion when he completes his work. Thanks again, Joey. :) read more

I had horrible experiences here. Owner quoted me one price for job that was accurately described and then, with lock installed and my new keys in his hand, demanded more than twice what he originally quoted. Didn't even have a reasonable justification for it. Extortion, pure and simple. This was after a smaller bait-and-switch weeks earlier. Avoid this place. read more

Can't recommend this place enough! I was locked out of my apartment on a weekend and Joe arrived within 5 minutes--unheard of! He was so kind and was able to let me in quickly for a very reasonable price. Thank goodness for Allstar Locksmith! read more

They came to my apartment within 30 minutes of my call for a lock out. Al was friendly, quick, capable & very professional. I always appreciate people who are kind, and he certainly was. He gave me a new lock and taught me how to use it and how to get a less expensive fix if I'm ever locked out again. Great service. Thank you! read more

Great, fast service. Nice locksmith. Wish it was a little cheaper, but he did a great job.

I live in a brownstone and locked myself out of my apartment (but not my building) one morning last week. I started to panic - I've done this once already and called the landlord, but I was just too embarrassed to do it again. Luckily - Joseph from Allstar to the rescue! He came within 15 minutes, got my door open in a snap, and I believe only charged me for the service call. The reality is you NEVER want to need a locksmith, but you will - and then you should call Allstar! read more

After many hours of trying to fix my new door lock myself, around 8pm I locked myself and family INTO my apartment. It really was the most ridiculous of situations. I called All Star and David arrived within the hour (parking was hard to find which was cause for some of the delay). David figured out the problem, installed the new hardware, and explained the situation to us most professionally. He was knowledgeable, professional, and was able to laugh with us at the whole situation. I would recommend them to anyone. read more

I bought a defective product here and came to return it the next day. Their return policy states products could be returned within 7 days. They refused to let me return it and began fiercely yelling. This was a terrible experience but also is illegal in nyc! read more

I'm impressed. The door in my building wasn't working for anyone and I decided to call All Star. Although it was a Friday evening, they had someone come over pretty quickly. He had me text a picture of the lock in advance and acknowledged that this door may be tough fix. Upon arriving, this description quickly became the reality, but the locksmith attempted to work on the door for the next hour. By the end, he acknowledged that my high security electric door would need the help of a specialist in that area. He even suggested that I contact the manufacturing company. Though I expected to pay him something for his visit although the door was not fixed, he declined, provided advice on having the door fixed and told me to have a good evening. Good customer service includes acknowledging when alternative services need to be called in. All Star got it right. read more

Went here to get keys made. Quick, east, and affordable. Nice staff. Good selections of tools including some Jorgensen clamps which surprised me! read more

I am very sad to read those negative reviews because I have lived near this store for close to 12 years now. I have shopped in the hardware store numerous times and never had a problem. I understand that the owners wife may have a English/Chinese barrier language problems, but most times she is knowledgeable and able to help with most problems. My son was locked out of the apartment while I was at work and I called and asked Joe to stop over and try to do as little damage as possible to open the door for him. He was there in a jiffy and opened the 2 locks and put them back together for me. He charged me a reasonable price and offered to make several copies at no extra cost so that I had spare keys in case this ever happened again. Now that is customer servive and a friendly neighborhood store. I also buy my terrace garden supplies in the hardware store. I would highly recommend Joe orChris or anyone from all Star Hardware, they are good hardworking gentlemen. And licensed lockesmiths too. read more

All Star Locksmith - AllSTar new logo. - Keys & Locksmiths Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Joey came to our apartment on less than a day's notice and installed a sweet deadbolt, then had copies of the keys made within a couple of hours back at his shop. We enjoyed great service, both at our apartment and at the store. read more

This is the WORST place. They will rip you off your money without a blink. I strongly suggest not to pay attention to the paid reviews on this site for this location, and save your money. They charged me $45 for coming over, another $70 for installing the simplest $20 cylinder. At least call another place to compare price before you order their service. do yourself a favor!! read more

Joe and his son are top-notch professionals. I was able to get a time I needed the day I called. They showed up right on time and were able to change my lock exactly the way I wanted. I emailed photos in advance and the fee was exactly what they quoted. The fact they are licensed, bonded and insured provides peace of mind, given all the fly-by-night locksmiths out there, and it's nice to be able to use a friendly, family-run business that has been in Park Slope for decades. Yes, I could have bought the lock itself on Amazon for less, but I prefer knowing that they can bring a lock that is guaranteed to work in the situation. Paying for a highly experienced pro pays off. read more

This is a review on their "residential lockouts" service only since I never visited the store. A few days ago I locked myself out, and found their number using yelp. An older dude with a beat up truck came to my apartment pretty quickly, opened and fixed the lock. That's where the 2 stars go. What left bad taste in my mouth was that person's communication and attitude. He never mentioned any quote in advance. Then basically asked me to pay. When I asked for his explanation on the quite big charge, he raised his voice and basically threatened to call police on me. It was basically the worst experience I have had with a business so far in New York. Fast? Sure. Professional, kind, friendly? Cannot be further from what I experienced. -1. read more

I was locked out of my apartment with my 2 year old son left alone inside. Joey from All Star got to my place in ten minutes and opened the door in less than a minute. He was like a neighbor coming over to help a desperate friend rather than a locksmith making money off my mishap. I called another place before All Star and they quoted my at $50 just for coming out and that was before labor and repair. I highly recommend All Star - they are the best. read more

If you value your money, do NOT use this company!!! I was told one price which of course was an estimate but then after learning that I owned the place and wasn't a renter, all of a sudden the prices changes and they tried to sell me stuff I didn't need. The basic items I eventually paid for because I needed locks asap cost about $450.00!!! This was a HUGE jump from the $300 I was initially quoted over the phone. Due to the circumstances in which I called them for their services, I felt I had to eat the cost but with Yelp, I can voice my displeasure and let other know to be caution of their poor service and scam type ploys to suck people of their money!! read more

Joey was a knowledgeable professional who quickly solved my problem. I was having problems with the mortise lock on my front door and expected that I would have to get a whole system. I sent Joey pictures via email and ended up taking the lock into Joey's shop and after giving the whole thing an examination, Joey discovered that whoever had installed the mortise lock had used the wrong spindle. He cut me the correct piece, oiled up the whole mortise lock, and gave me a tutorial on how to easily reinstall it. After about an hour and just about $60 bucks, my front door is totally functional and working like new. read more