I used to feel this was a five star shop. I'm taking my ratings down to two stars. Why? First the prices. It now costs you $17 to get half a sub, fries and a small drink. And the small drink is not like a small from anywhere else. It's like an 8 ounce cup. Second the fries a salted and seasoned so heavily that you just can't eat them. I mean it is terrible. This place used to have the best fries. Not anymore. They are inedible. And this has happened to me twice now. Last time I was here it was the same way. I told them today if I spend $17 on food that it should be edible. I threw most of the fries away. I told them something must have changed with what they do as it's been terrible the last two times. Then one of the cooks told me to be nicer and not call anyone an idiot. I never used that term in my complaint. I said the food was inedible not that someone was an idiot. It's really sad as John when he was alive would never have said that to someone. I'm really not sure anymore when or if I will come back. So actually making this one star. They lost me as a customer. When I went back in from their patio to leave, I found the cook who claimed I called another guy an idiot and told him I said the "food was not edible" not that I called someone an idiot. He basically blew me off. Terrible service. The right answer would have been, "I am sorry. Let us make you some new fries." Nope they were unwilling to listen to a customer complaint. I shall not be returning to eat there again. Too expensive, bad food and bad service. read more

Sub sandwiches are delicious! Lots of variety to suit everyone. Sides are just as good. Would highly recommend!

A classic sub shop in McHenry County. All the locals know it. Check it out, you will not be disappointed. It's a unique place compared to the cookie cutter sub shops you see everywhere. read more

"Easily the best sub I have ever had!" is what I say each and every time I eat Algonquin Sub Shop. This time, I have a lot of new diet restrictions, so I had to build my own sub, and after my morning medication, I got a little overzealous with the ingredients when using the order online function. The crazy long list of ingredients came together just perfectly, just like all the subs on their extensive menu, and this was easily the best sub sandwich I've ever had in my 45 years on this planet. They did laugh at me a little when I picked up my crazy order, but I knew I deserved it, and appreciated their attempt to fit so many delicious ingredients onto a single sub. My one meal of the day before heading to the city for a Mara Volta concert, I did my body and soul right by stopping by ASS. The fries are also amazing. read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Veggie sub with pesto, goer cheese, spinach mushrooms tomatoes sprouts zucchini and bacon with vedalia onion vinaigrette and Dijon mustard - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Great place; unique and large variety of sandwiches. Been here seven or eight times on Saturdays. Consistently good food and always busy in there. I like how thy repeat my order to ensure accuracy. read more

I want to like this place but the quality varies. Today, my salad had about 70% brown, old avocado. 30% of it was edible. Algonquin Sub Shop is just okay. read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Brown avocado - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

The sandwiches are excellent always. Nothing bad to say as a regular customer. Don't change a thing!

The most unusual spectacular food but not a sandwich shop, gourmet sandwiches 2 dozen selections to choose from got to try them

This place has terrific sandwiches and subs. I wasn't sure about getting a salad at a sub shop, but their's are so good. Highly recommend this place. read more

Bottom line, I really like this place. The Al Capone is a triumph! A.S.S. Is never a disappointment. Keep up the great work! read more

Food is exceptional! Generous portions. Staff is very pleasant. Quality of food is great. Can't go wrong here

Normally a 4/5. Good food. Something happens to service after Covid. I went in today and waited 5 min before one of the 3 employees working acknowledged me. Once I was acknowledged I was rudely told it's 30/45 min for a sandwich. I mean no politeness or professionalism in any way. I guess this is what you get at a sandwich shop. Just not what they used to be. Also said they don't offer their wheat bread anymore. read more

Wanting to stop by for so many years, but today was the day. Spoke with ( long time employee) that this is my first time and listened to his recommendations. Went with their classic: Al Capone Sub! (Not even a surprise) must say it has its own personal style...Yum! Looking forward to stopping in again and trying their other Delicacies. This one place is a keeper! Mangia & Cheers! read more

See all

Fantastic subs! I wish I lived closer-this would be my favorite sub shop if it were closer yo home. Every time I've eaten here, the subs and soup have been delicious! read more

Local favorite! Best subs in the area (featured on Chicago's Best). The place is located right out of downtown Algonquin. It is a small place, but the food is so good! Never a sub I didn't like. My go-to's are the Al Capone and Chicken Diggs. The fries are great and the soups are good as well. This is a must-stop! read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Al Capone - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

I've driven past the Algonquin Sub Shop many times, but never stopped in until today. Their menu is really great. With 20 to choose from, there is a sandwich for everyone. I ended up choosing #18 on multigrain bread. I don't know what I was expecting, but it definitely exceeded my expectations. The bread was super soft and fresh, the chicken was tender, juicy and well marinated with lots of flavor, the bacon was thick and good quality, the tomatoes were ripe and even the mayo/ranch combo was good - there was also lettuce, onions, avocado and cheese on the sandwich, which all worked perfectly together. The sandwich itself is piled high so prepare to have a very filling lunch. I could have stopped at the first half, but it was too good to save for later. My Mom ordered the #14 All American and she loved hers equally. She also commented on the fresh bread and quality ingredients. We can't wait to return and try some of their other sandwiches! read more

See all

This is our favorite sandwich place! Their sandwiches are all so good!! They also have the yummiest fries and their portions are huge!!! Love love!! read more

The food is fresh, tasty, and very good. The variety is really nice. The staff is friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend.

Came here a bit ago but forgot to review. We got a couple different sandwiches and soups including the Texas chili rub and the Mexican salsa soup. I wasn't blown away by anything but I thought they were tasty. This place seems to have a strong little following who love the food and I can see why. It feels like unique comfort food. If I am in the area again I would definitely stop by to see if they have anything new. read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Texas Chili Rub - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

Love this place ! Yummy took me a few times to find my sandwich but once I did gameover . Great fries !

Full size Turkey sub today, first timer. Weighed turkey on scale @ home. 3 oz of turkey exactly on a full size sub. Price: 10+ dollars. Will not ever go back. CRAP CRAP CRAP! I could easily open a sub shop next door and end that business.................. ....,............... ............no read more

I was looking for a nice lunch place while I was in Algonquin for the day and this place popped up Stopped here for lunch and was pleasantly surprised. Took a little long for the food to come out but once it did it was a great sandwich read more

Around noon today; my wife and I became first timers.Simply put- we were presented with 2 full and filling subs.This is definitely a sandwich shop we will be returning to. read more

Ugh. Where do I begin? I was so grossed out by the time we got our food I could hardly eat. I have zero clue why this place is rated so highly. It's filthy dirty in the kitchen! How does this place pass health inspection? The grease dripping from the vent fan with the originally white caulk turning black is enough to turn your stomach. The bathroom is so gross the door is completely sticky to the touch, it smells like pure musty mold. The whole sink area is filthy. Not to mention the toxic neon pink soap to wash your hands which leaves them smelling horrible and very chemical before consuming food. My 4 year old kept saying how gross it was in there. The lemonade was so nasty and tasted nothing like lemonade. The kids grilled cheese was on a bun that was flipped inside out so the crust was on the inside, it kept flopping open and was literally dripping with grease. The ketchup bottle was sooooo disgustingly dirty and coated in crud all along the top, it's clearly never cleaned. I ordered the grilled Italian veggie which they stuck on the grill next to a bunch of raw chicken and they just pushed the raw chicken juice away with their large spatula. It seemed the other man caught that happening and suddenly my veggies went to the back part of the kitchen and I could no longer see how my food was prepared. It came from the back kitchen not the front where all the other food was being prepared. We only ended up eating the fries and I threw the rest of the food away because I was so grossed out and fearful of food poisoning so I paid almost $18 for French fries.... No one had their long hair up in ponytails or hats. I can't imagine how many stray hairs end up in food. The woman throwing raw chicken on the grill in gloves never changed her gloves as she touched everything around the kitchen. I also saw her in the same gloves bringing the garbage outside 2x. Ask for a refund or run away. This place is a nightmare! read more

#1 Al Capone #18 the Monterey (NO OFFENSE) I couldn't even imagine Algonquin having any restaurant worth stopping for-- all I've seen were franchises and chains. Then LO AND BEHOLD, my husband took a chance at this hidden gem. Husband calls me "want lunch?" I ask (since I can't make up my mind on the spot ever) "what town are you passing through?" He goes "Algonquin" I go "mmmm I don't know what's around there, forget it, I'll make something at home" (He texts me 5 min later) menu for Algonquin Sub Shop "You pick" My face ugh sandwiches.... I am so very picky about sandwiches. Husband and I get into FIGHTS about why I don't believe in overpriced-not-so-special-sandwiches .... and then I had a bite of #1- warm bread, tomato, Italian deli meats cheese perfect amount of each filling, dancing in my mouth with every chew .....just when I thought that was good.. I had the Monterey. O.M.G. If each topping was dancing to #1, this was an X-rated type of experience Oh and I friggin had chili cheese fries too- Not over salted, I tasted meat--'like real Ground beef perfectly seasoned- and not the overpowering combo Of seasonings..'you Know what I mean? That was a story in itself Guys, this place is THE place for the sandwich non-believers... they will not disappoint. Food must be good due largely in Part of happy chefs placing the ingredients perfectly together. Did I say perfect? Perfect sub shop. In Algonquin. read more

See all

This was my second visit, the first being many years ago and couldn't recall my experience? After hearing a friend who just moved to the area RAVE about this place I was excited to give it another try. I stopped in around lunch time and there was already a pretty good line started, and all the inside seating was occupied. I noticed the inside had been remodeled since my first visit and it seamed pleasant . A glance behind the counter , and I could the manager and the griller person preparing food, none of which were wearing hairnets or gloves. I placed my order for a sandwich and drink almost $14? Which was a little pricey, again second time here and couldn't remember what I had paid before. As I stood there for a few minutes it was very noticeable the process in which they receive and execute orders needed some work! The young employees struggled to keep up and stay on task and management failed at properly organizing and directing the staff. So, I told the girl behind the counter I would sit outside ? Eighty degrees and sunny..... why not? I sat outside on their fenced in patio about 10 mins goes Buy and my sandwich arrives, a little smaller than I expected for the premium price I just paid? Nonetheless I take the first bite. Bread was very good and the beef was hot and very tasty with the right amount of cheese. As I finished , I continued to glance around the patio which was very dirty, it appears they leave the table busing to the patrons? Imagine that? Food and napkins we're littered about. The building itself was in dire need of a power leash and coat of paint. The gutters sagged and we're starting to sprout small trees in side them. There was some type of exhaust vent on the roof , that looked like it had never been cleaned as it was caked with grease.) I cleared my table and headed to my car in the back lot, when I passed the garbage bin that absolutely horrified me! It was over the top and the worst invitation for rats I'd ever seen. This place May have good food, however there presentation and cleanliness is disgustingly inappropriate and should be addressed immediately! It was hard for me to imagine the areas where the food was prepared and how clean that was?? I will not eat hear again as I don't want to get sick, and Management should be ashamed of themselves , they're putting the public at risk and they're clearly missing the mark!!! Please do better , so I can come back! read more

See all

Most of the food here is good. The quality is there. The location sucks. Hard to get in/out. I remember seeing mold or mildew on the counter. I don't like it when I can't see my food being made in a place that looks run down. Suggestion to the owner; move to a nicer location. read more

I'm not a big sandwich person but love the sandwiches here. I love Jimmy the Greek and often have it as a salad. Today I tried the Where's Waldorf !!! Yummmmmm! It will be my new favorite! Melty Brie, sliced apples, sweet peppers, walnuts, with a delicious vinaigrette! Fabulous!! read more

Despite me ordering in person at the counter from the cashier, the last two times I've stopped here I've been told my order was for a later pick-up time when I inquire how much longer my single sub order would take. I'm not talking about a few minutes or being picky.. I'm talking about an amount of time that has passed where people who ordered after me were well into their meal or left with their food to go already, all while I'm still standing there waiting for my food that hadn't even been started yet. It gets a 2-star rating from me because the food is good, but I'll not be returning. Not sure what's going on over there with the ordering system/tickets/etc. read more

This place is outstanding and we can't wait to go again. I ordered the wrong sandwich but loved it anyway. See you soon!!

I went there a while ago because of the "good" reviews, and it was filthy dirty. As I was waiting for my order, I was doubting about eating it. I got my turkey sandwich, and it was just blant, I ended up throwing it out. If you want a good sub, just go to Jersey Mikes. At least they are very clean and you can see everything, and.... it's delicious. You know what you're getting. read more

Love love love this place! Phenomenal salads! My only complaint is the hours are limited.

Went there because it said they had Philly cheesesteaks. nope, just a beef sandwich with provolone and the cheese was not even melted. Very spicy and soaked in beef juice. Very disappointed. Not Good. Stilol looking for a real Philly Cheesesteak. read more

This place is a small town Algonquin classic and favourite of locals. This place was seen on "Chicago's Best" and is very nostalgic. Opening almost 30 years ago, and closing just last summer. In summer of 2021 Algonquin sub shop was burned though the outside was fine the inside was burnt to a crisp. Their sandwich quality is also one of the best as well. Overall I rate this store 5/5 stars for the history, the feel, and finally the quality. read more

This place is a little gem with an extensive menu. There is something for everyone. My husband got the Al Capone, I had the Here's the Beef and my son had the Phili Cheese Steak. We also ordered a side of the potato salad. Let's start with the bread. I have a love affair with bread. This bread is so fresh, you can smell it when you walk in. It's soft and the crust is light, but still has a bit of that crunch when you bite into it. The horseradish sauce on my beef sandwich was just enough to add flavor, but not overpower the sandwich. The condiments were all crisp and fresh. They did not skimp on the meat in our sandwiches. My husband enjoyed his so much he barely spoke as he ate it. The potato salad was really flavorful. It is a small serving, but is less than a buck and a half and worth every penny. The sandwich portions are plentiful compared to the prices. I had the half size and I was glad I "shared" the potato salad with my husband because I could not have finished it otherwise. read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Here's the Beef - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

For over 15 years, this local guy has slugged it out against the giant sandwich chains, and by all accounts is winning....big time. On a mid Sunday afternoon, this place was jammed. With a long list of pre-customized sandwiches of all types, quality proteins, fresh-baked breads, and fresh vegetables make all the difference in the world. Salads, 1/2 pound fresh sirloin burgers, Red Hot Chicagodogs, and house-made soups round out the menu. Dirty brand chips, created by the late Ron Zapp in Grammercy, Louisiana are available, and beverages are by Coca-Cola. This place is a little spendier, and a little slower than the chains, but the wait and the dosh are worth with. The wait is made more pleasant by the demeanor and attractiveness of the woman behind the counter. I tried their best seller, the Al Capone, which is capacola, salami, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone and black olives. Most sandwiches are dressed with mayo, mustard, tomato, onion, pickle, lettuce, oregano and balsamic dressing. Upgrade to a multi-grain roll for 45 cents. The sandwich is easily in the top five of this type of roll that I have eaten anywhere in the world, anywhere. The burgers are outstanding. Big beefy flavor, with a little smoke undertone, and a slight char. Soft rolls. At 8 ounces, it's a monster, and at $6.49, it's a steal. Shoestring fries are crispy, salty, and delicious, with or without Chicago's favorite cheese sauce. Support local business. When you're in the area and you're jonesin' for a sandwich, think of Algonquin Sub Shop. Menu is online. Catering available, too. read more

I nearly rated this four stars because it's a little expensive and kinda a dive in appearance. The food is so good I just had to give it five stars. My son had a BLT and had them add ham, totally works. I ordered a sandwich with grilled chicken, seared in honey, garlic and BBQ sauce. After the thick cut bacon and the melted cheddar are added this was an amazing sandwich. The generous portion of fries are sprinkled with a seasoning salt that makes them irresistible. They have a huge selection of sandwiches, salads and of course hot dogs and burgers, but get one of the sandwiches, they're awesome! Make sure you go, you can't miss this place. read more

See all

got a number 19 no mushrooms. was too ther. the chef on deck looked to be a teenager but regardless asked if he could put more seasoning was very kind as he did so. Allison and Ava were great as well, they put me on to the apple cake which is amazing. first time was no let down will definitely be back for different subs and desserts read more

It's small, cute, homey and the menu is over whelming! This sub shop has been around for awhile now, and I just recently discovered it. They have several different veggie subs and all of them are amazing! My friends and I go there all the time, and we have never been disappointed. Subs, wraps, burgers, salads, soups, fries...the list goes on and on. One small downside all subs are $6-7. But, they are well worth it. Also, this little shop is located right off the Fox River bike trail. ENJOY! read more

Favorite sandwich shop by far! A customer of mine recommended it a few years ago and I've been coming ever since. Big menu full of the classics as well as some unique sandwiches. They're soups are to die for as well!!! read more

Algonquin Sub Shop - Al Capone - Sandwiches Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois