I was a big fan of Cafe 56, so when I saw that this spot was changing, I was downright devastated. My family used to love their salads and pretzel bagels just because they were that delicious and reasonably priced. With that in mind, the change to 56 kitchen is pretty major. Their salad selection is dramatically shaved down to under ten, and the vibe has definitely changed from a casual salad spot to a fancier dinner and drinks joint. Looking to try something new, I went for the love bird sandwich and a side salad. The chicken was nicely done and the brussels sprouts were an interesting and flavorful addition that I've never seen on a sandwich before! While it was very tasty, I think I understand why it's not been done. Paired with the "tomato jam" (a.k.a basically ketchup) and the moisture from the chicken, they made for one difficult to eat sandwich. I was fork-and-knifing it less than halfway through to keep them from sliding off the plate. Our server was impressively attentive - maybe even a little intrusive at points, but I'd definitely rather have someone who's there! He provided plenty of suggestions, kept the waters flowing, and even told us about the locally made art. The rest of the staff, though, were sort of awkwardly hanging around. I'm talking like seven people just standing in the corner watching us eat. I'm sure this will be resolved once the place picks up, but the waiter's station is very exposed. I felt a little under the microscope. I've never really been to a restaurant in its opening days, but I think 56 Kitchen can be something great once they settle in. It's a big step from a lunch spot to something more upscale and I think the area really needed something like this. Even despite my bias for the old spot and the few minor quirks in the service, I'd be more than willing to try it again. read more

56 Kitchen - new menu! - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

The food was great. 'Pewter Mug' salad was delicious. Reminded me of the original restaurant of that name. My family had the burger. The comment, unprompted, was it was the best she has had. Surprised from someone that's pretty quiet and tough to please. The service was good and ambience was fun. I'll definitely go back. read more

Went there with a friend on March 9th and I ordered the mozzarella balls which were good but very overly priced and my friend ordered a pizza that she said was delicious. I placed a to go order on March 13th for pick up. Ordered the Margaretta pizza and added sausage, and when I got it home the bottom we scorched black and not editable! And you couldn't find the sausage that they charged $2.00 for. So the bottom line is when you want pizza stick with your traditional pizza restaurant's that specialize and know how to make a pizza and don't waste $17.00 on something that is a waste of money! read more

Let me just say I had there chicken sandwiche let me tell u it was the best I ever had staff is really friendly

The food is amazing but Demetrious our waiter made the whole experience great. He was fun and went above and beyond. Go and ask to sit in his section. read more

BIG fans of 56 Kitchen! Food is always amazing, the service (VICTOR!) is the best. We always get the buffalo cauliflower wings, and usually one of the delicious salads. If you haven't been here, you should check it out. :) read more

Wow the service! My husband and I came in for an impromptu birthday dinner. We were greeted right away at the door by Ed. We asked to sit and bar and was introduced to Brad. My husband ordered a gin cocktail and I'm 5 months pregnant and so he made me a fresh squeezed lemonade first and a sparkling water orange zest second. I felt so special. We ordered the calamari app and the best thing was the sauce! If I could I would've licked the plate! When it came time to order entrees we spoke to the Sous Chef Shay and she recommended the pork chop special and the salmon cooked well for me. And they didn't disappoint! My husband ate everything except the bone and I ate everything except the lemon!! We even tipped the cooks to show our appreciation. Lastly for dessert I asked if they had a lemon cheesecake and they did! Every week they get different cheesecakes. It was so delicious All the staff was so accommodating to my needs. Made my husband have. A great birthday experience we definitely will be back Oh almost forgot we even ordered the white pizza Togo so delicious!! Thank you kitchen 56 read more

You cannot believe how great this food is prepared. From the salads and sandwiches to the entrees. Excellent! You must try this read more

56 Kitchen - This is the trout with couscous. Absolutely fabulous. This place is amazing. - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Every dish we got was amazing. The staff is so friendly too. Highly recommend the street corn! read more

56 Kitchen - Love Bird - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

This was my first visit. I was in the area to use the fitness center and some other businesses in the area. I was trying to decide what to have for dinner and stopped in here. The menu is extremely versital with something for everyone. I decided on a pizza with the waitresses suggestion. Ham with bacon. It is not on my diet plan but was really good. Service was slow at first but very good once they came to my table. I will probably come here again sometime when I am on this side of town. read more

56 Kitchen - Ham with bacon small pizza. - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Very nice food. Good taste and warm service. We ordered a pizza with special homemade meatball and a hamburger without cheese. Very Good. And nice French fry. read more

Kicking it up a notch. Food is outstanding and different to justify a tad higher pricing.

The people here care, and their food shows it. Their plates are a lot of food at a good price. Steak sandwich is great, and a lot of people like the brisket pizza. It has a strong chili flavor if you like that. read more

Warm welcome, attentive friendly wait staff and excellent food. The french salad and bone in pork chop with the peach salsa were outstanding. read more

It was my first time there. I love the atmosphere, food was awesome! Beer and wine list was good. What I was most impressed with was the cleanliness standards. The cleaning of tables and chairs between customers was above and beyond what I want to see to make me feel safe visiting their establishment. Definitely going to make it a regular go to! read more

Ordered take out the other night. It was super easy to do from their website. I ordered the Spesso pizza. I did not order it with the chili infused honey because I am not a honey fan. The other toppings (pepperoni, meatballs, and house made sausage) were absolutely delicious. The sauce was amazing too. My only knock on the pizza was that the dough was too thin near the center as the slices fell apart there. The taste definitely made up for that. My wife had the love bird grilled chicken sandwich. It came with Swiss cheese, tomato jam, fried brussel sprouts, and greens on a brioche bun. She loved the sandwich. She said the chicken was juicy and tender and the other ingredients were fresh. The sandwich came with fries and they were good. We also ordered the hummus which was amazing. We will definitely order again if not visit in person. read more

Amazing food and service. The new location is just as good as the original in Solon. Brad will make you any drink you want, but his drink menu is top notch. There is a small party room in the back, and roll up garage doors in the front. read more

I would normally give this place 5 stars but today is not it. If someone ask that the seafood and meat not touch, its a reason behind it. Tried the stuffed potato for the 1st time and it was not good. I finished it because i dont send food back. It was cold and felt as if it was thrown in the microwave before being served. The salads are getting smaller with each vist and the greens are becoming more white. 3 stars is because other visits have been a alot better..... read more

We had an 85th Birthday for my dad. There were 14 of us seated in our own room. The waiter Demetrius was amazing. He remembered everyone's name. The service was excellent and so was the food. read more

Our takeout was great! The tempura green beans were a little greasy but honestly still delicious. Fried food is tricky in a takeout situation anyways. My humble pie pizza was soooo good! I rarely order vegetarian pizza but this one packed a punch of flavor. You didn't miss the meat element. Next time I'm getting a cocktail to go, the list looked good. read more

This location is completely remodeled and has an extensive menu to meet the needs of everyone. Service was prompt and friendly. The vegan Mac and cheese was AMAZING!!!! I also ordered the tofu satay which came with a very rich and bold peanut sauce. They have a wide variety of spirits and beers on tap. read more

56 Kitchen - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

Very happy with the physical and menu transformation this restaurant has gone through. The interior is simple with an urban-style flair, with a nice little bar and in the warm weather, a roll-up front leading to a petite patio. This used to be a wonderful salad place, with soups, baked potato and such. The menu retains some salads, but has greatly expanded to include appetizers, pizza and assorted entrees. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive and the food is fresh and tasty. read more

Amazing salad. Original Pewter Mug salad is what I always get there. Everyone is super helpful. I always enjoy it. read more

Loved it when it was 56 salads. Now it's overpriced and not very good. Service and ambiance are fine.

My wife wanted to go, not my first choice, even though I had never been there before. I WILL BE BACK! Service was top notch. The salmon with the chichurri sauce was perfect. The salad was crisp and very fresh. Then came the cheese cake. The recommendation was that was outstanding and it was. I am glad my wife brought me in, now I will be back. read more

Food was good besides getting both our orders wrong. Service was horrible. Reason why our orders were wrong. Taking order, checking to see how our food was and receiving our check took forever. Needless to say no refills read more

Best burgers and fries I've ever had. Worth every calorie! We used it for takeout but I'll bet it's even better fresh off the grill.

Great little gem with consistently good food and better service. Look for Seaton to solve any problems you might run across. Also, the pizza is just fantastic. read more

Think back to the last time you ate a salad and examine how it made you feel. Great! Now, throw all of that away and try a salad from Cafe 56. What does it take to make a good salad? How about a great salad? Salads are odd. I can go to the store and buy the exact same ingredients that restaurants use to make their salads but mine never seem to turn out tasting the same. Its the difference between craving something, like CHOCOLATE, and just eating it because its healthy or you are on a diet. I really truly enjoy all of the wonderful flavor that Cafe 56 is able to pack into that bowl. Cafe 56 is great. For me its in an extremely convenient location; right near where I work. Yeah, sure, sometimes the wait is a bit long for a quick grab-n-go but they do make each and every salad right there in front of you. If you're picky about waiting, try ordering online. This location lets you pre-order and just pay and go! So far I have tried many different menu items. According to my yelp check-ins I have been here something like 25 times. Salads: -Millionaire (with chicken please!) -Napa Valley -Arizona Sun -Chicken Caesar -Beef Taco Salad -Fajita Chicken Taco Salad Other: -comfort bbq chicken sandwich on ciabatta Each one of these menu items has a unique, distinct, flavorful taste. You'll be sure to enjoy every bite with some left for later! These salads are quite large! Want to dine in? It can get busy in here during lunch hours. However, I have never been left without a spot should I want to sit and eat. Later in the day? No problem! They're open until a good hour and theyre usually quiet in the early evening. So what are you waiting for? Go try a Cafe 56 salad! They're each around $10 so you don't have much to lose. Fun tip: Try the tropical green tea. Its bananas (that's youngster for amazing). read more

56 Kitchen - Crispy Chicken Caesar - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

Our fave local place. We ordered from here 1x per week. I love the French kiss salad with grilled flank steak. The Spesso pizza is killer good. They are always so appreciative of our business. Really great owner, nice bar, great food! read more

The food was excellent and the service was great love the atmosphere and people in the restaurant will 100% come again.

The mug salad was bland and a poor representation of the original Pewter mug salad. The iceberg lettuce was on the butter side while the ham and Turkey lacked flavor. The salt pretzel served on the side was the star of the meal. read more

One of the place to eat in Cleveland. The food is amazing, the personnel is very friendly and caring, and the drinks are sophisticated and really good. I highly recommend if you like quality food and drinks at an affordable price. read more

Tonight was our first time trying 56 Kitchen. We ordered a couple salads for take out..I know boring, but my husband and I were both excited for the pretzel bagels the salads came with! I ordered the SOM salad and added grilled chicken and my husband ordered a wedge. He assume for $10 it would be a pretty hearty salad and opTed out of adding a protein. Well, his salad was pretty sad looking for $10. My salad was $14.50 since I added grilled chicken and also think that was overpriced for what I actually received. The piece of chicken was small and precooked/cold. I thought I'd be getting a fresh, hot piece of grilled chicken, but that was not the casee. Overall, my salad was good, but nothing special. The homemade ranch was really good, but pretzel bagels that we were so excited for were nothing to write home about either. Not sure we will try it again based on price vs. quality. Next time we will stick with winking lizard or mulligans for takeout salads much better bang for your buck (both quality and quantity)! read more

See all

Overall, I have had great experiences here. The salads and sandwiches are tasty, and they often have some great specials. The decor is so cute inside you forget you are in a restaurant in a strip mall in mayfield heights. We have gone back several times! The only item I did not like here was the peach marscapone dip. It was very odd. read more

My parents suggested we go there for my brother's birthday. There were 8 of us so we got to try everything. 95% of what we tried was very good, 5% not at all. Everything there is made from scratch, you can see the kitchen out in the open and you can taste that in the quality of the food. Crispy Brussels Sprouts - good, Heirloom Tomato and Burrata Carpaccio - excellent, Grilled Peach and Mascarpone Dip - the only hiccup of the night, not good at all, Sweet Corn and White Bean Chowder Soup - good. For main courses: 4 cheese bianco - I am not a good judge of pizza as I don't eat it but my niece said it was good, my son had a burger - he said it was excellent, very big portion, fried chicken - this portion is absolutely huge and my brother devoured it, he said it was excellent (I didn't try it personally), barramundi (from their specials menu) - very good, walleye - excellent, grilled prime sirloin - excellent, definitely a great value at $23. For dessert - their house made donuts holes and flourless chocolate torte - both excellent. At the end of the night, the owner (Israel) stopped by our table, asked us for the feedback, when we mentioned our experience with the dip (see above), they promptly removed it from the bill. Our server (and I apologize I don't remember the name) - was excellent, very friendly and attentive. So why 4 stars and not 5? The noise level was very loud (we came on Friday night), at some points we didn't hear each other and since restaurant was very busy our server was trying to be in too many places at the same time. But, great experience overall, great value for the money and my daughter even mentioned that she will consider this restaurant for her birthday with her friends (they have semi-private room in the back that wouldn't be as loud so could work out perfectly) read more

Love this place. The food is the best in the area and we always bring our friends here when they are in town. The service is beyond amazing and the food is delish! read more

We've been to this restaurant 5-6 times in the past year and we've never failed to have an outstanding meal! We've ordered the Pick It Dinner where you pick your protein, sauces and sides and ALL of them are excellent (we had a bigger group). We've also tried the sandwiches, salads and pizzas. No lie, it is all good. In addition, the barman (Creighton) is a master mixologist with amazing concoctions. He is also very friendly and gave us recommendations for drinks and dinner. The chef also asked us how we were doing and chit chatted with us for a minute. Overall, A+ experience. Do make sure to try it yourself. read more

Great food, Ceasar salad was amazing, mashed potaties were the best Ive ever had. Service very attentive. Would return again and again!

The plates are all awesome combinations! The sauces are so cravable and veggies are super fresh.