Cancel

Open app

Search

Your Pie

3.8 (53 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Salad, Italian
Open • 11:00 am - 9:30 pm

Order Your Pie Takeout or Delivery

Your Pie Photos

Business Info

YOUR PIE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Your Pie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Vegan gluten free supreme
Nicole K.

I love this location, mainly because there's free parking right out front (always a big deal!). The restaurant itself is small but cozy, located on the corner of a shopping strip in the Skidaway area, right next to Dollar Tree. You order at the counter, and I really appreciate that they have a separate prep area for food allergies. They also bake allergy-friendly pizzas on trays instead of directly on the oven surface, which helps avoid cross-contamination. They offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese, plus bottled beers and ciders (though no bar on site). Overall, the space is small but quaint, clean, and family-friendly, with staff who are both friendly and knowledgeable.

What a disappointing peach and prosciutto pizza! Their pizzas keep going down hill here.
Peggy S.

Not sure what's been going on here but the pizzas are going down hill. Your Pie is a go-to spot for me when I'm craving pizza, at least until my past several visits here. Each time the pizzas are under cooked and under topped. Most recently I got their seasonal peach and prosciutto pizza with added bacon. When I got it, I had to really look for most of the toppings. Unfortunately I was in a rush so I could not bring it up in house. Just check my comparison picture from their menu to what they served. I hope management does some trainings on quality control in this location.

Stopped by Your Pie for pizza tonight while in town visiting the family. We have been here a few times before and had no issues. Tonight was much different. It started out by following an employee at the restroom coming out as I was going in. Obviously she had been hitting the vape in there. Also, no paper towels so not sure how she got those hands clean. When we ordered my kids asked for a bit more cheese which we were told was $1 extra. More sauce - $1 extra - we haven't experience that at our hometown Your Pie so it was a surprise. My wife has an allergy so she has to be careful with most of the meats but her veggie pizza got some extra toppings from the meat guy without asking for them. It was from the chicken container but as you will see from the picture attached it could have been almost any kind of meat. I have never seen such a mess! They did remake hers without any problem which was appreciated. Hopefully this is an isolated incident and some improvements can be made to tighten up the ship at this location.

Pizza box with logo
Renee H.

Another Your Pie location in Savannah I love! I will dine in here, pick up to go, or mobile order here too. This location has plenty of parking thanks to the parking lot provided which is shared with other businesses/restaurants. It is located at the very end of the shopping center. Once you pass the dollar stores you will see the sign for Your Pie. I love all of the choices at Your Pie! There is truly something for everyone. If you have an allergy have no fear. They will make your pizza separately. Just let the pizza makers behind the counter know. There are gluten free, diary free, keto, & vegan options. They have white, wheat, gluten free, & cauliflower/cheese crust options. There are also chopped salads, breadsticks, & pastas. All of which are baked in the brick oven. Just choose from the multitude of toppings and it does not take long for your food to come out piping hot to you! Beer and wine, in limited options are available too. When you enter if you are placing an order turn directly to your left to join the line if there is one. They make everything to order. It is not a quick process. But they do move as swiftly as they can. It's worth the wait! If you are picking up an mobile order/order you placed online walk straight to the register. Let them know you are there yo pick up and your name and then walk out with your food! Generally I'll do mobile orders with their app most of the time to skip the line and wait time. If you are dining in there are high tops running the wall towards the front. In the back there are more tables with additional seating. The bathrooms are all the way to the back of the restaurant. They also have a fenced in outdoor area to sit as well. Last but not least, sign up for their rewards program! It is free to join. You can earn free drinks, food, or merchandise!

Cauliflower Crust (extra crispy)

Cauliflower Crust is not bad, all veggie ingredients are fresh. Pleasant vibes and friendly service.

Decor
Jamie W.

After eating lots of seafood on our trip to Savannah we decided to get a pizza for our last night. After reading several reviews on Yelp & Google we decided to try Your Pie. It feels a lot like "Blaze" but it was clear that they have higher quality ingredients. We had salads & pizza. The salads were fresh & crunchy. The pizza was not bad - it needed a few more minutes in the oven & to be turned, so that it would be crispy. Because it was undercooked & not turned some of the pieces were slightly doughy. The kids who work here weren't rude - but definitely not well prepared to work with the public. Not personable or friendly. Overall it was kinda "meh" .... Not bad ... not amazing. But just okay.

10" cheese pizza with banana peppers and green peppers
Caroline V.

The vibe of the restaurnt was very chill and the service was amazing! The pizza was great for 2 people and was plenty to share. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza had the perfect combination of cheese and sauce.

Jackie S.

I came here twice and still loving the pizzas. I ordered for takeout and my order was ready in a short period of time. We got the Nat Pizza, the Lineage Pizza, and a custom pizza with chicken, spinach, mushroom, bell peppers and onions. I haven't tried the pasta yet but I am sure it is delicious. I almost tried the gelato so I will save that for next time.

Marley G.

Can't say enough good things about this concept and this location, in particular. The staff is courteous, helpful, friendly, offer great suggestions, and always thank us for coming in. If you've never been, it's a great experience. You come in, choose your dough (white, wheat, gluten free), followed by your sauce and toppings. This is where you can go crazy and have some fun. I like to get ranchy-marinara or Alfredo with cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, spinach, beef, bacon, basil, and garlic. Take advantage of the meal deal and try their a-maz-ing gelato. Several flavors to choose from and they'll let you do taste tests before settling. They've recently redone the place and it looks great. Plenty of seating, very clean, lots of choices, fix your own beverage, and a nice outside porch. Definitely put this on your list of regular stops on Savannah.

Scott B.

My wife and I were out in the "Sandfly" area the other day and went to Your Pie for lunch. It's located in a little strip shopping center at the intersection of Skidaway Rd. & Ferguson. I'm not usually a fan of quick-cooked very thin pizzas, but this was excellent. You pay a single price and select all the toppings you want. They also have a gluten-free crust and make a distinction as to whether it's just a dietary preference or if needs to be baked separately for Celiacs. And they also have vegan mozzarella and plant-based meats for those who are abstaining from animal products. As an added bonus, they have a variety of draft and bottled craft beers available. They even have a very good gluten-free beer from Spain (Estrella Daura Damm). Definitely not something we were expecting basically out in the middle of nowhere.

Lineage with ranch on the side
Autumn K.

This is my favorite local pizza shop! Always nice and crispy and they have the best ranch!

Build your own!
Allie C.

We are new to Savannah and saw this place and stopped. Glad we did because we had a great experience. Staff was nice and it's like "Blaze Pizza", you build your own and they have gelato!!!! We would definitely come back!

See all

6 years ago

Very decent pizza Cold environment. It's a McDonald's of the over priced pizza industry.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Great pizza and salad. Fresh and done in front of your eyes. Centrally located in Savannah. Parking areas very close.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of P J.
0
10
1

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lynn H.
19
44
15

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Guy D.
0
10
0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of A Z.
0
16
0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Your Pie

Review Highlights - Your Pie

“We recently made a weekend trip to Savannah with a Dogfish Head beer sampling at this Your Pie location being a focus reason for the haul.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,010 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Saint Bibiana - Fazzoletti with gluten-free noodles

Saint Bibiana

4.2(144 reviews)
5.7 mi

Wake early for morning photos at Forsyth then walk across the street to St. Bibiana for breakfast…read more The dot has a pickup spot super close so, afterwards, hitch a free ride air conditioned ride to view the rest of the city! If we could afford to stay at this boutique hotel, we would! Breakfast gave us the opportunity to appreciate the beauty of the dining area, each order a sweet or savory item and share, and imagine what staying here would be like. Service was amazing with lots of other local recommendations for dining (which we took and were spot-on). Food was delicious with every bite. It's a beautiful spot. Working in the funeral industry myself, it was also neat to know it used to be a funeral home.

We were able to get a reservation for 8pm. We used the valet service to park our car. The…read morerestaurant was gorgeously lit up. The hostess greeted us at the door and checked us in. There isn't a good place to stand at the entryway as people walk in, but we were able to maneuver around the doorway as more people walked in. They led us to our seat, which was sadly in a walk through space. I get that you need to utilize every space possible to seat people, but it was disappointing that it felt very much like an overflow seating area. I thought I was over thinking this, but another table said it felt like punishment to be seated in this particular space when every other space was so gorgeous. Our server greeted us quickly, but didnt really give us the full 1st timer overview? Again, I thought it was me thinking to much into it, but then heard another server give the full 1st timer overview and felt cheated out of the experience. They took our drink order and then disappeared for quite a long time. They finally returned and took our order, but then we really didnt see the server again until it was time to consider dessert? In fact, we had to ask the people bringing out our food for more water. Again, really felt like this particular space was just an after thought... The food was amazing. We ordered a half dozen oysters to start. The mignonette was so good. We then had the Caesar salad. We enjoyed the mushroom toast. We did not enjoy the cavatelli pasta dish as much, it was ok. The steak was delicious with the bone broth and butter. Unfortunately, only part of the steak was actually medium rare, the other part was over cooked. We had no room for dessert. I did see videos of a person walking around with a bread basket, but we did not see it. Might be seasonal? I was expecting better service and better seating given the price point. Maybe you need to get in early for 5 star servic? Maybe you need ask for a reservation in a specific room?

Photos
Saint Bibiana - Dining area

Dining area

Saint Bibiana - Bistecca Florentina

Bistecca Florentina

Saint Bibiana - We were seated in special window room for our special occasion (my birthday). It was beautiful!

See all

We were seated in special window room for our special occasion (my birthday). It was beautiful!

Bella's Italian Cafe - Baked ziti with sausage

Bella's Italian Cafe

4.0(316 reviews)
3.9 mi
•$$

We had a great dinner at Bella Napoli Italians Bistro. There were several items in the menu to make…read moreanyone happy- pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and pasta. Our sever was very kind and attentive, and other staff members were too. We got there right when it opened, and were seated immediately. But seating filled quickly! Reservations are required for parties more than six. I ordered the shrimp scampi and my husband ordered the baked ziti with sewer sausage. The scampi comes with a side of angel hair, which was interesting. If I'm to ever order that again in the future, I might put the shrimp scampi over the pasta, and not the other way around. The garlic oil how everywhere! The wine menu is great, more than just the typical options. The dessert options were great too. We ordered tiramisu and it was delish. The total price was pretty comparable with other places in the area, but I don't think what we ordered was worth the price - but it is savannah! We'd definitely go back and try more. The inside is decorated beautifully.

We were visiting Savannah and decided to give Bella's a try…read more Hostess was friendly We loved the bread service. My husband had chicken parm with ziti on the side. The ziti side was the perfect amount. Too many places give a huge side of pasta with a small main to make it look like a large servicing. The chicken parm was thick and wasn't hidden under pasta, which my husband appreciated. I had pizza. It was good. It definitely seemed bigger than 10 inches but I loved the thicker crust. I did find their sauce on the sweet side but it was good. Service was lukewarm. She wasn't bad, but wasn't great either. We would return the next time we are in Savannah.

Photos
Bella's Italian Cafe - Daily Special

Daily Special

Bella's Italian Cafe - Tomato soup

Tomato soup

Bella's Italian Cafe - Normal sized side of penna pasta

See all

Normal sized side of penna pasta

Garibaldi's Cafe - Crispy Diamond Scored Flounder

Garibaldi's Cafe

4.0(722 reviews)
6.6 mi
•$$$

Had a business dinner at this restaurant there was no valet parking so we had to find a parking lot…read moreabout a block away. Ambience was perfect for a business dinner. Food was very good. Service was excellent.

We used to love Garibaldi's so much, as we would drive 3 hours from Columbia SC to Savannah GA, and…read moreback just to enjoy the scored flounder. So, after moving to GA recently, we decided to go back for my birthday. We enjoyed the atmosphere of the old Italian look of this place. We could not have asked for a better table location as we were all the way in the back and tucked away in the corner, very private and romantic. The only issue is the circular coach seating was worn out, and I knew with bad back I might in for an uncomfortable night. The service itself was professional, but not very friendly. While most staff members seemed to smile and appeared to be enjoying themselves, our waiter acted like he did not want to be there. As for the food, it just did not measure up to the past, as there was 1 great dish, 1 OK dish, 1 not so good and 1 just bad. We started out strong with Denver Lamb Ribs with a sweet Ginger soy sauce glaze. Easily the best rib dish we ever had. We debated on our next dish between the Lobster Cocktail or Stone Crab Claw and unfortunately went for the Crab as it had years since we had some. We both agreed the Crab meat did not seem fresh as it was mushy and the sauce lacked the tang of a traditional Stone Crab sauce. We both ordered the Crispy Scored Flounder as that is the reason we came here in the 1st place. The dish is a Flounder, that is scored on both sides into easy chunks to eat, with and Apricot Shallot Sauce. Overall, it was an OK dish, but not as good as either of us remembered as it could have used more sauce on top of the fish. We finished up with a poorly executed Bourbon Pecan pie. This dish looked (see picture) and tasted not much different than a Little Debbie pie you buy in boxes of 10 at the grocery store. This small round piece of pie had zero Bourbon sauce or flavor whatsoever. The dish seemed so out of place both looking and tasting, that I went to see what others posted on yelp, and what we were served didn't even come close to previous dinners experiences. Not a great way to end my birthday dinner.

Photos
Garibaldi's Cafe
Garibaldi's Cafe - Almond Berry Basket! Oh my goodness!!!

Almond Berry Basket! Oh my goodness!!!

Garibaldi's Cafe - Table setting

See all

Table setting

The Olde Pink House - Shelf and portrait. 9/8/2026

The Olde Pink House

4.3(7k reviews)
6.5 mi
•$$$

I had dinner there on September 12th in the bar area. The food was great and I meet a women named…read moreCindy and her friend Sam. We had a nice conversion and I walked her to her car but I didn't ask for her number and I regret that She was traveling from FL to OH to see her son and grandkids. If anyone knows her I would love to be able to contact her

If you are visiting Savannah, The Olde Pink House is a must! 18th century mansion that has endured…read morefires, the War of 1812 and the Civil War which included being a Union HQ! The historic mansion was built for James Haversham, Jr in 1771 and completed in 1789. It has gone through several major restorations throughout its history. We were fortunate to get a reservation for lunch. Our server, Jessica was so welcoming and informative with not just the menu but the basic history of the house. Food was fantastic! The Southern Fried Chicken with gravy over mashed potatoes is incredible. Hubby had the crab bisque, crab cakes with a side of mac and cheese. He also chose key Lime pie for dessert. I tasted and yum! If you visit The Olde Pink House, do not leave without your self guided tour! There are dining rooms upstairs in addition to the main level and their famous Tavern in the basement level. Interested in ghost stories here? They got 'em. Jessica, our server described the Tavern as "creepy " Favorable yelp average with over 6.9K reviews. Go ahead, bucket list this place. :)

Photos
The Olde Pink House - Upstairs ballroom seating - there's an elevator . . . ask, if you don't like stairs

Upstairs ballroom seating - there's an elevator . . . ask, if you don't like stairs

The Olde Pink House - The main dining room we were sitting in upstairs before it got crowded

The main dining room we were sitting in upstairs before it got crowded

The Olde Pink House - Dining area

See all

Dining area

Your Pie - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...