Awesome for gluten free people! Cooked my pizza completely separately from the rest and used different tools!

We got two meals and it came out to around $24, and it was a lot of food. They have baked pasta now, which my husband got, and he said it was absolutely delicious. My vegan cheese pizza was really tasty. Their drink machine is the one with a ton of options, which is my favorite! read more

Your Pie - Vegan cheese pizza with chips and drink! - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

The business owner of this store is top notch! If her employee(s) make a mistake or say something wrong??? Let her know! She will go out of her way to correct the mistake! Very impressive and action oriented business owner. Thank You! I was taught the "Customer Is Always Right" I'm 75 and It's been a long time since we had someone care and get involved in making our contractors lunch A Great One! R&E read more

No greeting when we walked in, so I said "hello" just to be stared at in return. All the tables were filthy. Workers watched me clean my own table, despite being the only people in there besides one other couple. They weren't busy--now we know why. I'm pretty sure we were being discriminated against for wearing our masks, because the staff actually spoke and interacted with the other table completely different. Needless to say, no masks and no sanitizing were to be found here. We've enjoyed this place before, but we won't be back. Pizza looked sad too. read more

The staff is always friendly and the pizza is always delicious. They even go out of their way to look in the back if you want a different brownie than what they have set out. We appreciate the smiles, kindness, and attention to detail! read more

we really love this place but lately it has gone downhill . They haven't had sweet tea for a month , they claim it's because the brewer is broken . The lids and other untensils are in disarray . sadly this place to seems like it's going downhill .... hopefully the manager turns it back around . read more

Food was Excellent. Enjoyed the pizza large size ordered. Friendly service!! Eager to help with questions being first time there. Food was hot, in house cooling no frozen foods read more

I love our local Your Pie because everyone can get their own pizza just the way they like it. It is always fresh and delicious. I typically get the white pizza with chicken, spinach and onions. However, we went today because my son wanted pizza but I wanted something different. I decided to try a chicken bacon ranch panini. OMG. It was so good. The bacon was crispy, the bread was toasted just enough and the ingredients were so fresh. This might be my new go-to on Fleming Island for a good sandwich. Who knew? read more

Stopped by this location because I was in the area visiting and my friends were craving pizza, and coincidentally, it was March 14, or Pi Day. Consequently, all pizzas were $3.14, and the line was also super long. We waited about 30 minutes to place our orders and then seat ourselves. I'd say it was worth the wait, though, because the pizza was great, especially for the price. I'm not sure if I would have thought it was worth it if we had paid the full price on a normal day, since there isn't much that distinguishes Your Pie from other stylistically similar build-your-own pizza restaurants; in fact, I can think of some custom pizzerias that do it better, since I think Your Pie is a little bit skimpy with the toppings. In the end, though, the food was still yummy, and service was really quick and attentive, which is always plus. read more

Your Pie - Custom pizza! Pineapples, pepperoni, ham, and red peppers. Shredded mozzarella and parmesan cheese with marinara sauce on white dough. - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

I really love the concept. You get to choose one of their favorites or make your own. Every pizza is ten inches which trust me is plenty lol. They have the best gelato I've tastes in years and the pizzas exactly how I love. Thin gooey but not dripping toppings everywhere. Perfecto. I love the fact that they have those freestyle coke machines to where I can mix my drink or go old school with a coke. When the weathers nice they have a few tables outside to eat and I love that. Service is super quick I usually am done with the line and food in hand within about 5 -7 minutes if even that !(: the line crews I've dealt with are all super sweet and even though we both have to speak up to be heard its seriously an awesome place to come for parties or just to relax. Best pizza place in Fleming ! read more

See all

3.75 stars...so that rounds to 4 stars. Got a sneak peek of this new area concept where the pizzas are made to-order quickly in a gas oven, and are highly customizable (down to the dough - regular, wheat, and gluten-free), which is good news in that there's something for everyone. There are tons of fresh toppings available: roasted red peppers, corn, sun-dried tomatoes, jalapenos, broccoli, cilantro, dried cranberries, garlic (!), pecans, pineapple and beyond. Also on the menu are unique pizza dough bowl salads, paninis, gelato, sorbet, wine and beer (great assortment of both bottles and draft including local beer from Intuition Ale Works). High ceilings, ample seating (and a few tables outside), and lots of windows make for a laid back casual spot that's family-friendly. Our pizzas arrived quickly -- and were thin, crisp, flavorful and not greasy at all. We had a custom (bacon, tomato and pepperoni) on regular dough and The Hippie (sun-dried tomato pesto as the base, topped with fresh spinach, mushrooms, banana peppers, tofu, and low-fat mozzarella shreds), on wheat. We preferred the pizza to our italian panini. We also had caprese (spinach, fresh mozarella, tomato slices, basil, garlic and extra virgin olive oil) bread bowl salad but were too full to eat the actual bowl afterward. I tried the pistachio, salted caramel, and butterfinger gelato -- made with fresh milk instead of cream (and somehow 93% fat-free). The blood orange sorbet was a hit: sweet and tangy but not in an over-the-top sugary sweet sort of way. Granted we don't live near Your Pie, I think it'll be a welcome addition to the Fleming Island area and perfect for a group post soccer game or cheerleading practice. Two thumbs up! read more

See all

The personal pies are pretty decent, the pepperoni isn't great but the Bianca is really nice.

This is a nice addition to the chain restaurants offered in Fleming Island. I came here for an early dinner with my brother and mom since it was still relatively new & we wanted to check out something other than Mellow Mushroom. We were pleasantly surprised to see this cool concept of pizza making where each of us could order "your pie" just the way you like it! While not the most amazing pizza I've ever experienced (that would be Joe's in the West Village, NYC), it was good for Fleming Island without all the hassle of going to MM for the 1000th time. In addition, they offered a gelato dessert with your meal and carry some really great flavors. In fact, I pretty much tried them all. Ask for samples as they were more than happy to oblige me. Overall, it was a good meal at a reasonable price and a gelato for my sweet tooth just sent me over the top. 4 STARS read more

Pretty good pizza I have been many times I would recommend to anyone. I will go back

Pretty good food I've seen better but yeah real pizza and good service I recommend the ham cheese pizza

Crust is rolled out in front of you so dough is very fresh. They've perfected their crust and sauces. I been to a similar franchise that wasn't so as good and no matter what toppings I choose, the pizza couldn't beat Your Pie. That being said; the pizza is delicious! Their gelato is yummy as well. Staff is friendly. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars vs 5 is meat toppings isn't included, which can add up if you like meat like myself. The location in ATL has unlimited toppings including meats. read more

Your Pie - Love their pizza and gelato! Favorite pizza topping is the bacon. If you like garlic, that's good as well. - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

I'm not sure why anyone rated this place a whole star down based on the placed not having a proactive staff cleaning tables?! Get over yourself! Yelp is about food! To take away a star based on that means you are a #%^*, #endrant. this place was awesome I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza! The concept of making your own pizZa, is awesome. I bopped myself in thinking man why didn't I think of this. The ingredients are super fresh and the staff was witty! It's nice to deal with people who don't take themselves to serious! The pizza is made in a brick oven:) yummy yummy!! Go eat and enjoy!! read more

Your Pie - Spinach, chicken and tomato pesto, black olives BP onions and garlic. #awesomeness - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Yummy pizzas- very versatile & options for everyone, delicious crust & ingredients, cooked to perfection. Makes eating pizza feel less guilty with options like fresh mozzarella and fresh ingredients. I'll definitely be back. read more

Average. Staff is not friendly. Over priced. However they do offer gluten free crust & vegan cheese. Pizza isn't bad but overall I've had a lot better. read more

This place is incredible! If you like pizza and haven't been here yet then you're missing out. I've noticed a couple of previous reviewers compare to subway and they really hit the nail on the head. Your pizza is made right in front of you. First choose your dough, then sauce(s), your cheese(extra cheese is $1 each), unlimited veggie toppings, meat toppings do cost $1 each, then you're ready to go. Another really cool thing is if you have a problem with gluten, they have a gluten free dough(that I hear taste pretty good), they even will make your pizza in a separate area to ensure no cross contamination of gluten from the other pizza's. Oh and they have gelato, I haven't tried it yet but it looks really good. Make sure to get a "your pie" card. You have to activate it online after you ask for one, so if you're good with your phone and fast enough you might be able to get it working before you get to the register. Basically I believe it's for every $50 you spend, you get a $5 credit. This could take five trips or just a couple depending on how many pizzas, drinks, desserts you're buying. Still with it in my opinion, because once you've been once, you'll come back again and again and again. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

This place doesn't disappoint. They have great pizza's. The service is consistently good.

What's not to love about a place where you get to make all the choices on what goes on your pizza? And they're done in about 5 minutes. Fresh ingredients make for a yummy pizza. read more

Pretty disappointed today with Your Pie (again) today I chose Your Pie over mellow because of the $5 pizza sign outside. I ordered my pizza and my total was $10.15 for a single pizza. They charged me an additional $5 because I wanted double pepperoni. Unfortunately they had already placed the pizza in the oven and I was unable to have them change it. I would have been okay with the normal $1 up charge but I would have paid this much at Mellow for a MUCH better pizza. When I questioned the staff he was rude and rolled his eyes at me for questioning the $5 up charge for a single additional topping. I have had a few pretty bad experiences here and just simply won't be back ***** Update I am changing from 1 Star to 3 Stars because of the way the owner handled the situation as soon as she found out. She took time to discuss with me the problem and then made it correct and has advised me that she will better train her staff. My pizza did taste great! read more

Several times we have had a pleasant experience with great tasting food. Only complaint is that the tables/floor needs a good cleaning. Staff is well trained and quality of ingredients are top notch. read more

Looked for a different place for lunch with the grandkids today and my daughter. We were pleasantly surprised at the staff and the food. A great selection of pizza and toppings, paninis and pasta! The staff was spot on and extremely friendly. We will return! read more

Arrived on a Sunday afternoon in late December. Was not crowded our order was taken right away and didn't take Long to prepare. Everyone was friendly and courteous. Food was good read more

Wish one was near me. Pretty good for fast food pizza pie. Fresh and lots of topping. Price very great. read more

Your Pie - Inside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

best pizza in fleming island!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! mary and sister lauren are the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! love this place!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Seems like the owners have turned over the keys to the local high schoolers. Service is slow, food is slow, and a bit pricey for what you get. read more

* These young kids know what it takes to have outstanding customer service, in person, on the phone and whenever honestly! I love it! * the food is really yummy, great variety of the selection of the type of pizza you want to create for yourself *they have free WiFi and tv to watch sports on *a lot of times when I do go there, they have some kind of activity they get the community involved with. Games wise. *the prices is good, you pay for what you get, delicious customized pizza of your magical delight! ***** I'll be coming back again and again! read more

I found myself drawn to Your Pie. I simply love the fact that I can get a pie with the toppings I want. Two choices of crust, whole wheat or flour, I always get the wheat. I have gotten some with pesto sauce rather than red or white sauce and I have even got one with olive oil. You can order as many veggies as you want to top your pie at no extra cost. I normally get spinach, artichokes, sun dried tomatoes, mushrooms, green olives and some jalapenos. They even have vegan cheese which tastes awesome. They cook your pie to perfection every time with a nice crunchy crust. The customer service is outstanding and they have great patience with undecided patrons due to so many selections of toppings. They have a great crew working every time. I don't normally give out 4 stars or higher but this place deserves for stars in my opinion. No doubt I'll be back. read more

See all

The easiest way I could describe it is "take the way they make sandwiches at Subway and apply it to pizza". Everything is right out front for you to see. You pick the crust (bonus points for having a gluten free option, by the way), you pick the sauce, cheese, and toppings. You get to see them put it on your pizza. You can see them cook it as well. There's nothing hidden. No secrets. I know what I'm getting. The crust is thin and crispy. The traditional marinara sauce is perfectly spicy. So many places use a sweet marinara sauce that, in my opinion, ruins a pizza but not this place. The cheese is fresh and the ingredient choices are plentiful. It came out perfectly cooked and tasty. It also has a freestyle machine. From a purely philosophical standpoint, that's a perfect match. They're letting you customize your pizza in all kinds of ways, why not let you customize your drink as well? They also sell gelato which is a welcome addition to Fleming Island. I was getting tired of all the frozen yogurt places and, sometimes you just want something a little less healthy. There is a separate line and register for the gelato which, to me, shows some great forethought in planning. This way you don't have to wait in the big pizza line when you decide to go back for desert. I got some of the Tiramisu flavored and the wife got the mint chocolate chip and we both loved it. I was also impressed to see the owner of the place helping out everywhere he could. Between talking with guests to make sure they're doing ok, to helping bus tables, to helping cook, he was everywhere he was needed. When I see an owner jumping into the trenches like that, I can't help but feel a business is in good hands. read more

Such a cool idea! Chipotle and subway meet pizza! Pick wheat or white crust, sauce, then choose your toppings. Veggies are no charge unlimited, meats cost a little per item (adds up quickly). It bakes for maybe 5 minutes and they bring it to your table. They also have REALLY GOOD gelato - on Tuesdays or Thursday's they have a special with the gelato if I remember correctly (sorry can't remember which day specifically). You must try this place out - it's one of two locations and it started in Florida. Oh, and the pizza does taste good ;). Just don't spill your water on your lap like my wife did to me.... read more

When I heard a new concept restaurant was opening up in Fleming Island, being that it was an excuse for me to return to my roots, I jumped at the chance to go out and see what it was all about. If you haven't been out to that area in a few years, you will be surprised how its changed...for the good. Imagine if someone took a fast casual pizza place but gave you the option to custom make your pizza in a Subway, have it your way, style. Are you a gluten-free person? They have that as an option. Want a "ranchy marinara" sauce? Yep, they have that covered too (see what I did there? I'm here all day folks). Sun-Dried tomatoes, Carrots...yeah carrots, sweet corn, fresh cilantro...I could go on and on. Tons of options. You just walk down the line and point. And of course, they have a lot of cheese options. Originally, when I got in line, I was planning on just getting around 3 toppings. Yeah, that didn't happen. I was amazed at all the options. So, the 3 toppings thing didn't last. I loaded mine up with ranchy marinara, mozzarella, fresh cilantro, mushrooms, purple onions, grilled chicken, and then big pieces of fresh mozzarella (The pizza picture below is my wife's pizza, it's call "The Nat"). When you are done with making your choices, they throw it in an open flame oven right in front of you. You then pay and take your seat. They call your name out (mine was ready before I even sat down) and bring your delicious creation to you. I barely had time to check out the gelato. I will discuss this in a minute. They have lots of drink options. The Coca-Cola Freestyle will cover most of what you are looking for. They also had some local beers on tap, wine and I spotted some sangria. Back to the pizza. It was great. It was exactly what I was craving. I like the fact that each pizza is just for you. If you are like me and not everyone in the family likes the same things at the same time, this is a good way to make sure everyone can get what they want. After the round of pizza, I was determined to try out the gelato and sorbets. I got a sample of Blood Orange, Pistachio and Sea Salt Caramel. I'm a Blood Orange fan, it translated well. I think the Sea Salt Caramel missed the mark. Maybe that's because I have a high standard when it comes to Sea Salt Caramels : Sweet Pete's. My wife was a fan of the Mint Chocolate Chip. It was a good way to end the night. Extras: Check out the Caprese Salad in a Bread Bowl! I didn't see that until after I had ordered or I would have tried that out too. Next time...next time... The Good: - TONS of options for toppings - Everyone gets what they want - Local beer on tap - The owners are local - The employees seem to be all high schoolers but they were hustlin the whole time and were very courteous. Rare these days The Bad: - I live downtown and their only location is in Fleming Island :/ read more

See all

I am updating my review. Your Pie was my go-to pizza place in Fleming Island, however the last time I went the staff was incredibly rude and I don't love pizza enough to deal with it. read more

What a great place to order pizza. The service is always fast. Love the wings!! Ordered a Greek salad tonight and it was nicely made. You have a great team there keep cranking out the goods read more

It's no accident that Subway has become the world's largest single-brand restaurant chain. Its model works -- you see your meal created before your very eyes, to your exact specifications, in an efficient assembly line built for speed, and for a reasonable price. The folks behind Your Pie want to bring that globally successful model to the world of personal-style pizza. Their first Northeast Florida franchise opened in Fleming Island in March 2013, and after my experience there, it's obvious what they're serving is hot. Your Pie offers only personal-size pizzas (Mellow Mushroom is just down the street if you want to super-size things). You can opt for one of their 14 "favorites" with the ingredients all figured out for you, or go out on a limb and create your own. Then you choose from one of three crusts (white, whole-wheat or gluten-free) and top it with one of nine cheeses, eight sauces, 11 proteins and 25 veggies. It's great fun to mix and match as you mosey down the line, and here's hoping they find a way to store your combo preferences in some cloud one day, ready for cyber-recall. At the end of the line, they fire up the brick oven for up to four minutes at 550-600 degrees. And voila ... Your Pie. You'll also find panini sandwiches, bread bowl salads, 12 sorbet and gelato flavors and plenty of craft beers (what else would you expect from a concept established in Athens, Ga.?). They also sport the way-cool Coca-Cola Freestyle if your drink preferences are softer or you're bringing the kids. Pies range from $7 to $9, with paninis coming in at $8, salads at $7 (or $3 without the bread bowl) and the sweet treats starting at $2.45. And in kid-friendly suburbia, you'd better have something for the little ones. Kids' meals start at $5.75 and offer pizzas or paninis. You can't beat the freshness you get from a pizza constructed before your eyes. The crispness of the veggies, the newly melted cheese co-mingling with the sauce, the overly hot first bite triggering an impromptu dive into your beverage of choice. It's a wonderful choice for large families celebrating after the soccer game, a quick lunch break from the office, or catching up with friends over pizza and beer. The local franchisee promises more locations in the area over the next few years. The second location, in Jacksonville's Tapestry Park off Southside Blvd. and Gate Parkway, is currently under construction. Oh, did I mention that Subway does a pizza, too? After trying both, it's obvious that Jared's baby can't hold a candle (or a 600-degree brick oven for that matter) to Your Pie's pizza-centric ethos, and let's face it, cool factor. Dive in, and have your beverage of choice ready. read more

Honestly I love coming to this location the staff is super friendly and I love their reasonable prices compared to their good quality of food. I usually aim more towards getting a combo and Mary literally made me the perfect pan of pasta and she was really sweet. Would definitely recommend this place to others! read more

I went with three stars more as an attention getter for management than a critique of the pies. To be honest, the quality of the freshly baked, personal, customized pizzas was four star, at least. The concept of having "Subway" style ordering at a pizza place gives you one of those "Why didn't I think of that!" moments. It is simple, original and genius all at the same time. I deducted the one star because of the lackadaisical attitude of some of the staff and the fact that nobody seemed to be proactively cleaning off tables. We were in there this past Saturday afternoon, shortly after 4:00. This was our first visit. At the time, they were not busy. When we walked in, all of the booths still had items (empty cups, silverware, pizza pans, etc) on them. Some of the empty tables looked the same. The tables that didn't have items on them were still pretty messy with crumbs from prior diners. After ordering, my wife wiped off one of the tables with some napkins and gave me that "strike one" look. As we were waiting for our food, I kept looking around wondering when someone would clean off all of the remaining tables. Finally, a customer came in and requested to have a booth cleaned off. I figured that the worker would then proactively clean the rest of them too. Nope. He apologized to the customer, cleaned off the booth, then proceeded to go back to whatever he was doing before. What would he have done if they got busy? Clean each table as requested or depend on the customers to clean their own (as we did)? On the plus side, the lady who took our order was very helpful and friendly and the fire baked pies were excellent, with a decent char and a nice texture to the crust. If the pizzas were not so good, we would not be going back. Since they were, Your Pie deserves a second chance. read more

Awesomeness. We've been to a couple of other pizza joints and they just don't compare. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida