Renna's Pizza

250

108

236

29 days ago

The perfect place to grab a slice! I love a good pizza spot that sells by the slice. I went with the pepperoni, added some chili pepper flakes and Parmesan, and it was ready to be devoured. A solid slice with a really good crust. Simple, satisfying, and exactly what I was looking for. I'll definitely be back! Service was fast and friendly. And the vibe was just like any other pizza shop. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Crystal P.

0

1

0

6 days ago

The BEST white pizza I've EVER had! Everything from Rennas is always top notch! My favorite pizza!!!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jerry H.

73

523

2028

10 months ago

A perfect trip just me and my grandson eating pizza and me drinking beer. Of coruse, my grand had apple juice. We dropped Grandma to Panails to get her nails done. It was a 30 minute wait. We had to eat and run but the pizza taste just like the NY NJ metro area. The smell and bite of it all! Im writing this review and have been back already been back to taste a slice of heaven. Customer service was exceptional. I asked the counterperson to warm the pizza for my grandson since he does read more

Renna's Pizza - Me and my grandson - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Rachelle S.

22

132

172

1 year ago

Pizza is on the salty side, but this is the only pizza place the entire family agrees on! We always call in our orders because it's a busy place. Reminds me of an old school pizza place. Always busy yet chill. Family oriented. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Scott L.

34

199

573

2 years ago

Great little pizza spot. Love that you can grab pizza by the slice. They also have a nice little selection of beers. Nice break from the shipping :) read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Jennifer T.

9

83

238

1 year ago

We love Renna's pizza! We ordered pizza from their website and by the time we got there the pizza was ready to go! They lady at the counter took my name and came right back with my food and gave me plates and a bunch of condiments to go with the pizza. Definitely recommend Rennas for some affordable food tasting pizza. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Memee I.

11

94

417

1 year ago

I have been to this pizza spot because I love their slices of pizza meal but every time I come in here, there is always an associate or a staff member that has an attitude but today I had experience superb accommodating, friendly service from Latesha who works there that I thought was an owner. But if only everyone was trying to be just like her, this place would be a hit. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeremiah S.

8

76

118

1 year ago

Pizza is a little salty, but it's the only place the whole family agrees on. Busy spot, so we usually call ahead. Feels like an old-school pizza joint always bustling, casual, family-oriented. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Adrienne U.

0

2

0

3 months ago

Went for the first time today. my friend I grew up with in New Jersey said it was just like the pizza we grew up on! she was right! The lady at the counter was super friendly too! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diana F.

2

15

2

1 year ago

Service was great but the pizza was not great Been coming here for over a decade This visit was dissatisfying the taste was Not up to par. Recipe was not the same Sauce was not the same won't return read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julissa L.

1

13

9

7 months ago

We went here for our first time a couple days ago and the pizza was amazing. It was actual New York style pizza. Service was good. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Trong L.

40

12

16

2 years ago

I watch all of David Portnoy's pizza reviews on YouTube and have tried many of the popular local pizza spots in town. I have to say, for plain cheese, fresh out of the oven, this particular Renna's location makes the best in town 100% and is a must try, dine in. Get the entire pie! Great tasting sauce, perfect balance of sauce and cheese! Thin crispy crust read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alicia H.

266

661

3441

2 years ago

Consistently good pizza , decent price, convenient location in mandarin. Made my staff happy today- esp with the garlic knots read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Linda V.

Elite 26 All-Star

215

1137

6880

4 years ago

We have been coming to Renna's on and off for +20 years! Tonight we ordered two Caesar salads, a large pizza with two topping and a pitcher of beer, with tip $50 to eat in. The salad came out and to be honest...very disappointing, very yellow lettuce but crunchy croutons; maybe no body orders salads?!? The pizza came out and it was 8 slices; the crust was good but the toppings were sparse and on one maybe not at all?!? Regardless there were people coming and picking up orders and others eating in but it appeared to be slices not whole pies?!? read more

Renna's Pizza - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - Half and half.. the way you like it! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - It's been a long day! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - Prices have changed! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jose G.

180

335

4899

4 years ago

Amazing tasting New York Style pizza located in the heart of Mandarin. Conveniently located in a large and busy shopping plaza near the highway. Plenty of parking nearby. Also lots of seating space in the clean and comfy dining area. Kind and professional staff. Ordered a 12" vegetable pizza on my visit. Easily can be shared but luckily I did not for this solo visit. :) Nice fresh portions of vegetables, extra cheese and delicious buttery crust. Pizza was baked perfectly! See y'all soon for another tasty pie that I may not plan on sharing! read more

Renna's Pizza - 12" Vegetable pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - a hand holding a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

gabriela d.

0

1

1 year ago

Amazing pizza!! The owner was very very kind and the employees were helpful with ordering. Got my pizza in 5 minutes!! They have roomy seating so you aren't squished up against anyone which is a plus. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kiki P.

0

2

2 years ago

This used to be my favorite pizza place, not anymore! I ordered one slice of pizza with 3 topping for $3.49. The cashier charged me over $5.50. I asked her why she charged me so much. The menu clearly states "one slice of cheese pizza....add up to 3 toppings to make it your perfect slice". She gave a bogus answer that didn't make sense! What a shame. I ordered sausage, green pepper and onion. The green pepper was completely raw and the pizza was barely warm. I ordered the pizza while I was there and waited for it, so hadn't been sitting around. I brought it home and had to actually bake the one slice of pizza. read more

Renna's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - The nasty piece of pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Christos L.

Elite 24

5

82

130

3 years ago

Even though I've been in the neighborhood for a while now and in this plaza multiple times over the years, I had never tried the pizza from Renna's. The pizza was delicious and I was able to order half pepperoni and half specialty, which was great. I'm not a New Yorker but this is a very good pizza and it was delicious. I think I found my go-to neighborhood favorite pizza joint. The place is simple and feels like a hole-in-the-wall establishment, which is totally cool and charming. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Overall I had a great experience at Renna's. read more

Renna's Pizza - Half pepperoni and half Renna's special - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Julio H.

1014

1459

6795

4 years ago

Pretty good pizza here, everyone was happy with it as well as the garlic rolls. Unfortunately I forgot to snap a pic of the pizza because it took longer than usual to come out, and everyone was hungry! But it was pretty good. I guess I will keep coming back until I find my perfect pizza spot in Jax. read more

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 0

Love this 5

Oh no 0

Solana B.

0

81

0

2 years ago

It wasn't great, but it was pretty tasty. Pizza was a little soft on the bottom for me, but overall I liked it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tracie A.

0

4

0

2 years ago

I have NEVER had bad food here, until now! The pizza was delivered 40 minutes late. The restaurant called me looking for the delivery driver, because I didn't get the order he picked up. When the pizza got there, it was ice cold, hardly any cheese, it was a small, and I paid for a large!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Enrique A.

0

2

0

1 year ago

Good New York style pizza l like the Italian subs ,fast order filling ,good price will recommend

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa R.

0

4

2

2 years ago

I have been eating at Renna's, all the locations, for over 30 years. But I got a calzone tonight that was perfection. Look at it??!! Have you ever seen such a beautiful calzone? And it tasted just as wonderful as it looked. Calzone has always been good there - my favorite- but this one was just pretty too! I no longer live in Jax, but am so glad I stopped on my trip up tonight. Great service as well. read more

Renna's Pizza - Perfect calzone - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jacob J.

0

3

1

2 years ago

Lit. Cheap beer, great pizza, great service, comfy seats. Affordable and fast service. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Millie K.

0

1

0

1 year ago

If i could give 10 stars i would!! jack was a delight to speak with on the phone, very very friendly!!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Keith S.

27

10

1

2 years ago

It is with great sadness that I write this review, especially since I've given glowing reviews (on multiple local food review sites) previously. Everything has changed and it went completely downhill. Can only give 1 star because less is not an option. Pizza was always our family's favorite around town, but no longer. I know there are multiple locations around town - so hopefully the others haven't changed their pizza as well - but all other locations are even further away. Hope they turn it around at some point, but will absolutely be going elsewhere. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 2

Jen D.

Elite 21

9

106

148

3 years ago

I guess i always pass by Renna's but never tried it until today, it didn't disappoint! I saw a lot of people comes in and out for pick u orders. Daily's special include 2pizza slices (huge) and a drink for $8.50! Staff are friendly, clean restaurant and ambiance is a regular pizza shop (booths and tables) read more

Renna's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alicia D.

29

23

18

2 years ago

Food is always good no matter what you choose! Service is great and ambiance is a pizza joint period.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lynn P.

0

239

570

5 years ago

Ate here 2 days in a row. It is so good. Had a cosmo sandwich which has lettuce, tomato, ham, mozzarella, oil and vinegar on it. This bread was so fresh! I also had a 10" pizza with beef, banana peppers, and fresh garlic. This pizza had just the right amount of sauce. The crust is thin but still filling. You won't regret coming to this place. read more

Renna's Pizza - Beef, banana pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - Cosmo sub without onions - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Edward A.

424

925

5849

8 years ago

We grabbed a couple of pizzas tonight and Renna's never disappoints. We always get a cheese and our second pizza chosen was their meat lovers. They don't skimp on toppings and this particular pie also comes with extra cheese. Nice NY crust and flavorful sauce. If there was one critique it's that the ample toppings made the pizza a little on the salty side. Would we get this pizza again, definitely yes, but we may leave the bacon or ham off just to reduce some of the sodium. This location has been here almost 30 years and their pizza is always consistent. I like being able to also grab a slice or two when in a time pinch. I believe there are four total locations - all in the family - between the Westside and beaches. #supportlocal read more

Renna's Pizza - Medium meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - Large cheese with extra sauce - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 7

Oh no 0

Caitlyn C.

2

90

61

2 years ago

Still great as I remember from 10 years ago. We came and ordered in and our pizzas were great. A bit of a wait but a nice quiet chill atmosphere. I got a white pizza which has crush garlic on top that you could actually taste. Yum! My friend got a half cheese and half pepperoni which looked good just not as good as mine. Ha. The crust was really flavorful too. Will def be back. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bianca G.

Elite 24

159

95

402

4 years ago

I was craving pizza after donating blood and decided to check out this cute spot. I got the two slice and drink special. The food came out fast and was not overly greasy or too big to eat by myself. I think the sauce could use a little more seasoning but other than that it was good. I want to try some of the other menu options next time I am here The restaurant and bathroom are extremely clean. Great place to get a quick bite. The lady who was helping me was very kind. There is additional outside seating when the weather is good. read more

Renna's Pizza - Two slice special with a drink (added pepperoni and jalapeños for an added $2 charge) - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Renna's Pizza - Seating/front door - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Juvy D.

Elite 23

31

125

377

4 years ago

Been going to Renna's for YEARS at both OP and Mandarin location. The pizza has always been amazing. Just how I like it. It's my go to pizza place. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sianna V.

1

14

3

2 years ago

We love Renna's!!! The best dough, sauce, service, and the cutest vibe. It's a bit of a drive for us, but so worth it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Wm Kevin S.

Elite 21

72

115

132

5 years ago

We always forget Renna's is tucked behind Chipotle & Chili's, but we remembered today! We had a nice pie with pepperoni, mushroom, sausage and garlic. The sausage was very mild to the point of not really tasting it. There wasn't really enough sauce under the cheese, and yet it was a very satisfying pizza. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pepperoni sausage mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Gloria A.

0

3

1

2 years ago

The large pizza is now a medium pizza. Not big enough to feed a family of 4. Shrink flation should tell you this. Picasso's has a better pizza for the price read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nick D.

0

5

1

2 years ago

The food is really good. And the service is always great! I've only had pizza here which is really good. But I've heard the sandwiches are awesome. Looking forward to coming back read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Unit O.

1

68

5 years ago

This is the second renna's pizza that I went to, with the same punishment that I get. Whenever you order pepperoni and a regular slice, the pep slice is smaller than the cheese slice. Also why do they ring you up get your sodas give you everything before they even start to warm up the pizza? They should be warming up the pizza first. Then assisting you with ringing you up and everything so you don't have to wait. Very unefficient, this is another management issue. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ti M.

Elite 21

765

689

151

6 years ago

I took a Keto break after kayaking 4 miles. I needed...wanted to carb up. We were craving NY style pizza. We usually go for Napoli style from V. So this was to mix it up. We aren't native to JAX, so we didn't believe there was good NY style pizza. We were pleasantly surprised! I got a 16 inch cheese and 16 inch deluxe pizza. It was SOOO good!!!!!!! Oh my gosh, delicious! I do recommend this place. It has the nice thin slice with a crusty crust. It is our new go to! read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 1

Taylor H.

Elite 24

21

107

241

6 years ago

Went to Renna's for the first time today after hearing it was the best in Jax. I do think the pizza was good but I didn't think it was anything to write home about. The pizza was really greasy and limp. We had a meaty and a pepperoni. The garlic cheese bread was good but could have used more cheese. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 4

See more reviews

More info about Renna's Pizza

11111 San Jose Blvd
Ste 12
Jacksonville, FL 32223
Southside
Directions
(904) 292-2300
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.rennaspizza.com

Hours

What time does Renna's Pizza open?

Renna's Pizza opens at 10:30 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Renna's Pizza opens at 12:00 PM on Sunday.

What time does Renna's Pizza close?

Renna's Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Renna's Pizza closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu 10:30 AM - 9:00 PMFri-Sat 10:30 AM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Renna's Pizza take Bitcoin?

No, Renna's Pizza does not take Bitcoin.

Does Renna's Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Renna's Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Renna's Pizza have catering options?

Yes, Renna's Pizza does have catering options.

Does Renna's Pizza have a drive thru?

No, Renna's Pizza does not have a drive thru.

Does Renna's Pizza serve alcohol?

Yes, Renna's Pizza serves alcohol. Beer & Wine Only

Indoor Amenities

Does Renna's Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Renna's Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Renna's Pizza have bike parking?

No, Renna's Pizza does not have bike parking.

Does Renna's Pizza have outdoor seating?

Yes, Renna's Pizza has outdoor seating options.

Does Renna's Pizza have parking?

Yes, Renna's Pizza has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is Renna's Pizza wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Renna's Pizza is wheelchair accessible.

Does Renna's Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Renna's Pizza does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Renna’s Pizza is where friends and families gather for great food and good company. We make our dough fresh daily and craft every pizza the traditional New York way — thin, foldable, and full of flavor. From pizza by the slice to hot sandwiches and Italian dinners, there’s something for everyone. We’re proud to be a local favorite for lunch, dinner, and everything in between.

History

Established in 1976.

Renna’s Pizza began in 1976 when two brothers from Bari, Italy brought their family’s recipes to Jacksonville, Florida. After a stop in Brooklyn, they fell in love with Florida’s warm weather and opened their first location on Phillips Highway — introducing New York-style pizza and authentic Italian flavors to the First Coast. As Jacksonville grew, so did Renna’s Pizza. The Argyle Forest and Mandarin locations followed in the ’80s and ’90s, each serving the same hand-tossed pies and homemade dishes locals had come to love. In the 2000s, the next generation expanded to the Beaches, carrying on the family tradition. Nearly five decades later, Renna’s Pizza remains a true Jacksonville favorite — still family-owned, still dedicated to quality, and still serving the same recipes that started it all.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Carmines Pie House

4.4(1.2k reviews)

10.4 mi•Westside

Richard is great! Chicago style pizza is great!! The meat sauce and lasagna is delicious. Suggest…read morehigh protein options.

Everything ! From the server to the atmosphere to the food…read moreAnd omy the,desserts Can't go wrong

9.7 mi•Southbank, San Marco

Calzones

NY style pie The Frenchie

See all

New chairs and tables

V Pizza + Sidecar

4.4(1.1k reviews)

Im no stranger to V pizza. Been there plenty of times, multiple locations, they just make great…read morefood. I recently Visited during their 2026 pizza making competition (an annual event that i was not aware of prior to this visit). 4 pizza pros, 4 pizza rookies going head to head to see who can make the best pie. 2 rounds; 1st round was who can use the secret ingredient (chorizo) the best, 2nd round was a free for all to make the most creative pie they can imagine (Wagyu cheeseburger pizza and Chilli dog pozza to name a few). V sold wristbands that gave access to a buffet of everything made for the competition. I personally suggest the gold band (not sure if they change it every year, but it was gold this year) which came with a complimentary drink and all day happy hour from side car. As always, the food was fresh, hot and did not disappoint. Live dj, great staff and fun atmosphere made the entire visit a memorable event for the family. Combine that with awesome food, a wing eating competition, amazing drinks, and the fact that part of the proceeds went towards the v4v foundation made this an amazing experience, definitely one i will be looking forward to attending next year.

Great, casual spot to get pizza and drinks in San Marco. Order at the counter and seat yourself…read morewith a number. It is definitely reminiscent of a cafeteria but the food is great. It did seem quite pricey, I think I paid $42 for a pizza and a glass of wine. Additionally, we kept coughing bc there is some sort of pepper or smoke in the air.

MARGHERITA (V SIGNATURE) PIZZA - V Signature San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, bufala mozzarella, fresh basil.

The V Stromboli - crispy, cheesy goodness. If you don't tend to love the not so crispy nature of a neopolitan pizza - give this a try!

See all

CRYIN' HAWAIIAN WINGS -V marinated wings, V hawaiian sauce (think honey & calabrian pepper paste), fresh basil

Bala's Pizza

4.6(205 reviews)

9.1 mi•Southside

Excellent pizza Great ingredients…read more Very good service Try it they're across from the new big Publix

Delicious NY style pizza, they even offer Sicilian style and regular all by the slice. Excellent…read moretaste and good sized slices. Their garlic knots are delicious and not greasy. One of our go to's when in the mood for pizza.

10.2 mi•Brooklyn, Riverside

Pizza oven and ordering counter

Grab a glass of red wine and.. (･‿･) /ﾟ*:｡ﾟ let's dig in to a slice of crispy NY style #Margherita @ the neighborhood #Bala'sPizza

See all

Margherita DELICIOUS - January 2023

Rodrigo's Craft Pizza

4.7(108 reviews)

Finally tried this place a while back. It was really good! Crust was super thin with a nice blister…read moreon the bottom and the slices did not flop even when held straight out, not folded. Charred just right, too - not underdone at all and not burnt in the least. Goldilocks crust. Perfect amount of sauce that wasn't overly sweet or salty, the flavor of the quality tomatoes really shined through. Very tasty cheese and it wasn't piled on heavy-handedly, either. Alex, the owner/pizzaiolo came out and talked to us a good long while and he was the nicest guy ever. His kids were helping him run the joint that day and they were the best kids - like smart little adults! This place rocks and I think even in NYC it would be able to hold its own, admirably. Please keep it up, Rodrigo's!

Omg! The crust was so good! Crispy on the outside but medium soft on the inside... well balanced…read more They have a selection of Italian sodas and sparkling flavored waters. The Arugula Salad is really good, it has roasted pistachios in it. The back has a bar and next to it an outside patio.

Dining room

Sizzle Drizzle Pizza. Zesty and savory! *:｡ﾟ Highly (*‿*) recommend! *:｡ﾟ

See all

GEORGIE'S

Eleon Pizza & Pastry

4.4(95 reviews)

21.2 mi•Northside

Not only was the food absolutely delicious. The amount of sauce they put on the wings was perfect,…read moreand the chicken tenders and fries were good with every bite. The fries were warm and perfectly crispy and soft on the inside. The croissants were worth every single penny!! Both dessert croissants were stuffed with their appropriate fillings I am definitely going to come back and definitely recommend you try this place for yourself Also, the hospitality was very kind and above and beyond. I was greeted as soon as I walked in and felt very welcomed. The ambiance was welcoming and warm :)

As a first-timer, I wasn't quite sure what to expect with pizza and pastries. I've seen people line…read moreup at the door waiting to get in, and now I know why. The place is small with limited seating in a storefront but the ideas and flavors are huge! I ordered a small mixed vegetable pizza (minus the olives ) and a very inviting red velvet cupcake! When I saw my small pie, my eyes and mouth were so excited! The cheese was all that and they weren't stingy with the spinach, mushrooms, and mixed bell pepper chunks! It was delicious! The red velvet cupcake had a tempting cream cheese center that called my name, and I answered! It was not super sweet, a huge concern of mine, but just the right balance. I went in the late afternoon, so the cake, itself, was a little dry but the cream cheese center really helped it out. I will definitely be back for more on the menu!

Menu board

Strawberry Rollercoaster Shake

See all

This was mine. The mango banana milkshake. The coconut pineapple milkshake looked the same way.

Serafina’s Pizzeria

4.3(359 reviews)

6.4 mi•Southside

Great pizza Almost like being in Chicago…read more I know they are from NY BUT we will over look that.

Hubby and I tried Serafina's one evening for dinner. We drove over, ordered at the counter and…read moregrabbed a table inside. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza plus 2 slices of their margarita grandma pizza. The staff were friendly and we enjoyed the atmosphere. The line was long and consistent but it moved quickly. The pepperoni pizza was very, very greasy. I'm okay with some grease but this was way more than normal to the point my plate had a huge puddle of grease. I had to soak it up with napkins just to keep my plate usable. It also didn't have a whole lot of flavor which I was surprised by. I really liked the grandma slice and wished we ordered a whole pizza instead of just a couple slices. Not sure we would give them another try despite enjoying the grandma slices.

Serafina's wall

Margherita Pizza - April 6, 2024

See all

Mamas Pizza & Grill

3.8(365 reviews)

5.1 mi•Southside

This place was absolutely fantastic! We ordered the hot honey chicken wings and two pizzas -…read morepepperoni and white special. This the type of sh*t that make you go crazy. The chicken wings were perfectly breaded and fried - tasted homemade. The pizza crust was crisp and not overbearing. 10/10 recommend, so yummy!!! Service was also phenomenal, even when it got busy, Cidney made sure to take care of us (bringing refills, checking on us) while juggling other duties.

They don't honor mistakes that they make on GRUBHUB menu. I've been ordering from this place at…read moreleast 2-3 times a week for a while now and the owner would not make an exception. Outstanding customer service. I will be happy to take my $120-$180 a week to another local pizza place. You lost a loyal customer over $6.00 smart business move. Ciao

10.2 mi•Riverside, Brooklyn

Dining area

La Bonita Pizza

See all

Late lunch, early dinner...Start off with the fresh house salad...Rasberry vinaigrette dressing for the sweet people like me! :P

Biggie’s Pizza - 5 Points

4.0(178 reviews)

I live in 5 Points and live Biggie's is close by. The staff is always helpful. I love buying pizza…read moreby the slice. Such a great option!

Fun place for a late night slice! We actually were at another pizza restaurant but I knew my son…read morewouldn't eat their pizza (he is extremely picky and only likes maybe 2 other places)So I brought him over to Biggies to check out the big slices and he was hooked! He said it was a delicious cheese slice and would definitely come back for more! I would love to come back and try the grandmas-it looked divine!

Grandma

Meat me in NYC / Grandma

See all

Cheezus

Bronx House Pizza

4.5(135 reviews)

13.4 mi

Cool NY style subway decor with a nice red brick wall that is the backdrop for the bar. Love the…read moreopen concept kitchen. Ordered a basket of garlic knots togo that were ready in a few minutes for $10.00. Never been here before but was told by my neice and friend that the knots are a best seller. We had smash burgers from the place next door but wanted the knots as a side. They were so dang good.

I love their cauliflower crust pizza! It is crispy and very tasty…read more I do wish cauliflower pizzas would be bigger, but no matter where you go, it seems as if they are all on the small side for some reason. Their chicken parm sandwich is VERY good and I think that their bread (roll) it is on is so crispy and good. Being from NY it is hard to find comparable bread in Northeast Florida, so this is a special treat and chicken parm is good too.

Bar

Chicken Milanese

See all

Spaghetti and meatballs

Pizza Point

4.3(166 reviews)

7.7 mi•Southside

Pizza Point has an amazing calzone! I would have it delivered with some extra marinara sauce on the…read moreside... I love sauce! I would order their meat lover's calzone and add tomatoes. It was always

Due to my introduction to Indian pizza, I no longer want regular pizza!…read more Nothing fancy, just a nice little pizza place, when I was there, just a 1 woman show. I was greeted as soon as I walked in. You can sit where ever you like. I already knew what I wanted, but I still looked over the menu. I got the Paneer masala pizza 10 inch. The crust isn't thin, but it's not thick. If this is all you order, it's enough for 1 person. If you order a side, prepare to take leftovers home. The Pizza was really good, nice Indian flare. it's so nice to have something different. What a nice twist! Specially if your vegan, go try something besides cheese or veggie.

Chicken paneer masala pizza! Delish.

See all

Chicken tikka masala pizza

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Eric E.

0

18

1

6 years ago

Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg the calzone is so good! Omg Omg the calzone is so good! read more

Lizz B.

60

3

0

11 years ago

Best pizza in Jax I have never had a bad experience here the staff is wonderful and I recommend this place to everyone when they ask for a good pizza joint read more

Jan P.

0

14

11

10 years ago

We moved here from NYC and this is THE BEST we've had in Jacksonville so far. If you're looking for NYC style pizza this is the place to go.

Anna S.

114

3

0

9 years ago

Best pizza. I never have any bad service when I go there. Prices are great also. Never disappointed.

Debbie B.

27

197

655

18 years ago

I personally love their pizza because it reminds me of NY pizza; thin and tasty...that simple.

Indigo B.

0

153

160

4 years ago

Improvement noted all around! Great slice option.

Renna's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Restaurants near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Breakfast near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Desserts near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Coffee near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Dinner near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Parking near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Things to Do near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Burgers near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Shopping near Renna's Pizza

BEST of Jacksonville, Florida Movie Theatre near Renna's Pizza

People found Renna's Pizza by searching for…

Best of Jacksonville

Things to do in Jacksonville

Browse Brands

Renna's Pizza

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Renna's Pizza also viewed

Al's Pizza

3.1

(129 reviews)

I discovered Al's Pizza started at the corner of Beach & San Pablo but eventually opened up several…read moreother locations around town (Neptune Beach, Margaret Street, Ponte Vedra, and Philips Highway). I make sure to stop at the 3rd Street location in Neptune Beach whenever I'm out that way. I must admit, I've tried a few different types of pizza from there but always go back to the BLT Pizza! It's a tasty, unique treat that is only carried by Al's in this area. Now for the good part! The usual red sauce is subsituted for a mayo base, which perfectly mimics a real BLT sandwich! The toppings consist of mayo, bacon, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and red cabbage. The hand-tossed gourmet crust is frequently praised for being cooked to a perfect, toasty texture that handles the heavy toppings without getting soggy. Sounds like a weird combination but it totally works (don't knock it until you've tried it)! Over the years, it's gotten a little pricey. Current pricing for a 10" - $17; 14" - $25; 16" - $28. I typically stick with the 10", which is more than enough for me. There's ample indoor seating, and for those who like to sit outside - patio seating facing 3rd Street. Servers are friendly and accommodating; and the facilities and restrooms are clean so no complaints there. So if you're ever in the area of one of the five locations, be sure to stop in and try the BLT Pizza. You'll thank me later!

Was definitely not my favorite visit to Al's Pizza. We stopped in using a Clipp certificate. The…read morerestaurant itself was very clean, well organized, and inviting. Our waitress was friendly and accommodating, and we were able to sit wherever we preferred. She gave us plenty of time to look over the menu, and service overall was above average. We ordered two waters, a glass of wine, and a large 16-inch vegetable pizza, which was priced at $28 -- a bit on the higher side. Everything seemed fine until the pizza arrived. After a few bites, we both noticed an unusual taste. After some process of elimination, we realized it wasn't the sauce but the diced tomatoes on top. They tasted off, as if they may have been past their prime. Unfortunately, the quality of the food was subpar, even though the service was above par. Overall, I'd rate the experience a 2.5, but I'm giving it a 2 in hopes they improve.

Aron's Pizza

3.3

(96 reviews)

Calzone was amazing. Workers were kind and gave us extra sauce. The setting was a little like a…read moreback alley shop, but everyone knows those are the best. Come try for sure.

I was invited here by a friend and she raved at how good their veggie pizza was. I never had…read morebroccoli on a pizza so Aron's did not disappoint. All the ingredients were fresh and the business gave "mom and pop". The waitress was super sweet and they had several pickup orders while we dined it. The dining area can use a little renovating but I will say it doesn't take away from the authentic taste of the pizza. The food came out promptly and we even took pizza to go. I loved that they offered by the slice options and the menu has a little bit for everybody. Overall, it was a great experience and I will be back with new friends.

Marco's Pizza

3.2

(66 reviews)

Grabbed a to-go order last Saturday late afternoon and went back 15 minutes to pick up our order…read moreduring the walk-in, I should have called beforehand. Got the Chicken Dippers Boneless appetizer for $10.99 with Bleu Cheese as a dip, it was delicious and had a pretty good serving-though a little thick on the breading as I have noticed. Also ordered the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza-12 Slices to share with the rest of the family and we enjoyed it very much and happy to have tried it.

Been using Marcos since covid and enjoy the pizza and calzones. All food was as ordered and was…read morewell prepared.

Dolce's Pizza

3.6

(86 reviews)

Great Cozy Atmosphere with an extensive menu for any hunger for Italian cuisine with the…read morefriendliest staff and the Fastest Service. I started with the Fresh Made in House Baked Breaded Cheese Ravioli with a fresh Marinara which was vibrant and delicious My Entree, The Penne Alla Vodka was one of their Specials of the day with fresh baked Focaccia Bread and I couldn't decide on Dessert between the Cannoli or the Tiramisu, so I tried both and took the rest home. This Hidden Gem somehow has eluded me, but I won't let my Yelp friends let this place be missed. So if You're near the Mandarin area of Jacksonville Florida and looking for a new place to take your loved one, sweetheart or hell just treat yourself, stop in Tues through Sunday and Grab Lunch or Dinner, and tell them Big Rich Sent Me!!

The food was no better than MCDonalds. very disappointing…read more Over 50.00 for takeout for 3 people. We ordered to subs and fettuccine with chicken. The subs look like they were on longer hot dog rolls. With very little meat inside them. The fettuccine looked as it was frozen and than warmed up. Very disappointing !! I would not recommend as you will be very disappointed. Maybe a pizza would have been better!!!!

Vitos Pizzeria

3.9

(125 reviews)

We are from Massachusetts and really couldn't find a pizza that could compare until we tried Vito's…read morepizza. Along with the great atmosphere and clean dining area we found Vito's pizza to be the best pizza around. The employees are so friendly and helpful. Greeting us at the door with a smile.

I'm a NY boy and was Jonesing for some NY style gas oven pizza a while back so I stopped by Vito's…read morein Orange Park for the first time. And while nobody outside of NY (except me! ) can match how good it's done up there, this place comes VERY close! They're nice in there and you can't beat the price either. I got the lunch special which is two one-topping slices and a drink for $5 and with that, they let you add another one-topping slice for just a buck which I did. Special runs up to 4 PM. I got one slice tomato, one ricotta and one sausage and for six bucks even, it really hit the spot. Nothing fancy, just good old regular gas oven pie. I swore I'd be back whenever I was craving the pie of my youth but was too lazy to make it myself. And I have been - many a time! Go here. It's the best gas oven NY-style pie I've had outside the NYC Metro area.

Five Star Pizza

3.7

(92 reviews)

The price to pizza ratio was great. This pie costed $19, 2 topping XL. (A special) Gotta get it…read morewell done to make it crispy. It was ready quickly and tasty. I do wish they had flavored crust or added more cheese without asking. I will eat here again!

I really wanted to give this Five Star Pizza location a fair chance, but unfortunately this was a…read morevery disappointing experience. We ordered an extra-large meat pizza and garlic chicken through DoorDash for $50.70. For an extra-large meat pizza, there was surprisingly very little meat or toppings. The sauce was dry, and the crust had huge puffy air pockets across the top. I have pictures showing exactly how the pizza arrived. The garlic chicken was even worse for me. It was extremely greasy and so salty that I literally had to spit out the bite I took. We simply could not enjoy the food we paid for. What bothered me even more was what happened when I tried to resolve the issue directly. I called the restaurant at approximately 9:55 AM on August 19 and spoke with the manager. I explained the problems with the order and was genuinely trying to give the restaurant an opportunity to make things right. The manager would not give me his name and laughed during our conversation. I found that incredibly dismissive. Restaurants have bad nights. Mistakes happen, and I understand that. What makes the difference is how a business treats a customer when that customer respectfully brings a legitimate problem to their attention. I wasn't asking for anything unreasonable. I paid $50.70, had photographs and a receipt, and simply wanted the problem addressed. Instead, I left the conversation feeling like my complaint wasn't taken seriously. I have since had to pursue the matter through DoorDash and other appropriate complaint channels because I was unable to resolve it directly with the restaurant. I hope the owners or whoever is responsible for this location sees this--not just because I want my money refunded, but because customers deserve to be treated respectfully when something goes wrong.

Pizza Dynamo

3.5

(49 reviews)

Came here for the first time and ordered the Spicy Pie. It was definitely spicy, but instead of…read morehaving a balanced flavor, it mostly tasted like heat and lacked other seasonings. I also wasn't a fan of the crust--it was too hard for my liking. That said, I'll probably come back and try a different pizza since it was my first visit and I'd like to see what else they have to offer.

Did not even order pizza because of how dried out, stale, and overcooked they looked. Visited last…read moreSaturday at 6:30pm, one would think that is a normal time to expect fresh pizza, esp with a hopping bar next door. When my husband mentioned to the pizza dynamo employee that she should replace the pizzas on display she just laughed. Incredibly disappointed.

Your Pie

4.2

(153 reviews)