Calzone was amazing. Workers were kind and gave us extra sauce. The setting was a little like a back alley shop, but everyone knows those are the best. Come try for sure. read more

I was invited here by a friend and she raved at how good their veggie pizza was. I never had broccoli on a pizza so Aron's did not disappoint. All the ingredients were fresh and the business gave "mom and pop". The waitress was super sweet and they had several pickup orders while we dined it. The dining area can use a little renovating but I will say it doesn't take away from the authentic taste of the pizza. The food came out promptly and we even took pizza to go. I loved that they offered by the slice options and the menu has a little bit for everybody. Overall, it was a great experience and I will be back with new friends. read more

See all

Loved the crispy yet flaky crust of our Mediterranean pizza. We also ordered the white pizza. It was good but was missing some flavor, maybe garlic and oregano. The waitress was very pleasant and attentive. Definitely will go back to try more of the menu options. read more

Aron's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, great food! I enjoyed a pizza, salad, appetizers, and dessert. Everything was delicious. I can't wait to go back! read more

Went with the wife tonight food was amazing. Had garlic knots they were great and dipping sauce was really good and came out to the table hot. They have beer and wine!!! Also order pepperoni pizza also really good!!! Small dining area very quaint inside, wish music or something was playing but other than that it's was really nice and extremely clean! The young woman working the counter and taking orders was really nice and made the place even more welcoming! Food came out fast! Be careful pizza comes to the table super hot try your best to let it cool down. It will be tough because it looks and smells amazing read more

See all

Grabbed a carry out pie. The lady behind the counter was super nice on the phone and even when I got in the time she recommended to pick it up. The location is kinda small but it's seat yourself and the food I saw on the tables looked great. I was here just to grab a large pizza for the family. They showed me the pizza for my approval before taking off. The pizza was great as far a as flavor and and the toppings were evenly spread. I saw the guy making the pizza's behind the counter; he has passion in what he does. I'll be back to grab another slice. read more

I've had their pizza before which was delicious! I had the eggplant calzone from this time and it did not disappoint. Our sweet waitress was also very attentive. read more

This was my first visit to Aaron's. My grandson and I had gotten rained out at the zoo and decided to go see a movie. Both were hungry. I did a Yelp search for the best pizza in Orange Park and up came Aron's Pizza. We ordered a medium cheese pizza with light sauce and light(amount wise) pepperoni. Our server was very friendly and the restaurant was clean. The pizza came out perfectly fine with the cheese slightly brown just as I like it. The crust was flavorful, thin, crispy and chewy, as good as it gets! The sauce was very good as were the cheese( I would guess a nice blend of high quality Mozzarella and Provolone) and pepperoni. They do a good amount of business and the salads and entrees coming out of the kitchen looked great. We will definitely be back. Thank you Aron's! read more

Aron's Pizza - Pizza with light Pepperoni. Delicious! - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Aron's used to be really good. The pizza was top notch and the service was fast and friendly making this one of our weekly lunch stops. Over the past few weeks, the pizza has become very hit or miss, mostly taking on the characteristics of a saltine cracker. Not the foldable slices of the past. The service has also gone down since some staff changes. It's very slow, and some items are forgotten. Unfortunately these changes have dropped them off the lunch list. The inside is still charming with character, though it can get loud at times. I'm disappointed to be writing this, as I really liked this place. read more

I really enjoy Aron's Pizza. I have been going for a while now and am always pleased. Aron's is very unassuming from the outside. It kind of looks a little like an outpost or store, not a really yummy restaurant. I will say, over the years I have gotten the food delivered by Arons, by a third party and I have picked up. I have never actually eaten inside the restaurant and that is not for any particular reason, I just haven't happened to eat inside. The food is great. It has all of the basics of a pizza joint except they have really great pasta dishes, good bread and great salad. I personally love their chicken parmesan with their rosatta sauce (kind of like a vodka sauce) instead of marinara. It is great. The chicken is always nice and thin and has never had a piece of fat. The breading is great and it is covered in plenty of cheese. The eggplant parm is also good. We have also gotten the spaghetti and meat sauce and meatballs. Their pizza is also really great. The crust is soft yet thin and their toppings are great. The calzone is definitely enough for a meal. I love the cheese calzone most and even just their cheese pizza. Their good is simple and incredibly tasty. You can tell they take care in what they make. The servers are always nice and friendly. The restaurant looks clean inside and their delivery is great. I will continue visiting Aron's for as long as I live in the area because it truly is a really great community restaurant. There is plenty of parking on the side and behind the restaurant and there are about 15 tables inside as wells as some seating outside. Check out their daily specials if you are looking for a deal! read more

Aron's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Amazing pizza and great service. Never disappointed when we eat here The pieces can't be beat for the amount and quality of food read more

Not impressed with the food or service. The antipasto salad was less than expected for the price. The service was minimal. Definitely didn't expect to pay $3.99 for a 12 oz bottle of coke. Be sure if you're in a group to check that they did or didn't already include a tip in the check amount. They don't mention it. Not going back. read more

By far the most low quality I've even seen. cheap government type cheese and dough like a saltine cracker. took one bite and threw it in the garbage. was over 12$ for a four slice joke of a pizza. anyone who thinks this is good definitely has no idea what a New York pizza is read more

Aron's Pizza is...fine. I was craving a calzone of all things and my restaurant of choice was closed so I decided to give this place a shot. I ordered an eggplant and sausage calzone and an order (6) of garlic knots. The calzone was being pulled from the oven just as I arrived exactly 20 minutes later, right on cue for how long the girl on the phone said it would take. When I got home and opened the box, it was clear that it probably could have used a few more minutes as the outside was pretty pale. I dunno, maybe I should have ordered it well-done? The calzone tasted pretty good. The eggplant within was absolutely delicious, but I honestly detected zero sausage at all. I'm not even sure they put any in it. The marinara sauce accompanying both the calzone and the garlic knots was good; perfect thickness, and not too sweet. The garlic knots weren't terribly good. They were dry, a bit hard, and had little garlic flavor. They also came swimming in a pool of oil which made them unpleasant to eat, overall. Price-wise, I think Aron's is fine, and I'd probably try their calzone again but ask for it well-done. Based solely off of how delicious the eggplant was I have no doubt they offer some diamonds in the rough, but it might just take a little searching. read more

Aron's Pizza - Garlic knots. - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Stopped in this afternoon and none of the employees were wearing masks correctly. The cashier had hers under her nose, which is useless and neither of the other employees I saw had masks at all so I left. I hope I didn't catch COVID-19 during my brief interaction with these irresponsible people. read more

Aron's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Underwheming. Crust was crispy and tasty, the toppings were expensive and sparse. Barely could find the sausage, not much spinach (for the money) and the half-toppings were similarly underwhelming. Service was quite good, though prep was sloooow. Will discuss our possible return.... Ambience was notjing to write home about, but we were there for pizza; three stars, as I noted. read more

Food and service was great. Our waitress Veronica was AWESOME, she was very attentive, friendly and personable. We will be back.

Great food every time we come. I enjoy the pizza and the ham calzones. My hubs loves the chicken fettuccine Alfredo read more

Aron's Pizza - a plate of pasta and a fork - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Best pizza on the East Coast even better than New York. Pizza Chicago pizza beach them all immersed, eat at this great pizza parlor

I'll be honest, I don't have a lot to say but I'll give the highlights. Salad was lame, it sounded fancy but they used iceberg so it was a waste. Pizza was GREAT! Atmosphere was just okay and the servers were nice. They were bored because the place was dead. If I lived in this area, I'd order pizza to-go on a regular basis, but not go in there too much. read more

Food is good. But don't touch their pens, or they'll Ruin $90 nails. Which I have to pay more money to fix. Never coming here again. And all the waitress said was "oh no". Didn't take accountability or even say sorry. She doesn't care. She's there for a paycheck and to talk nice. read more

The only place other than Uncle Charlie's on the Westside (I have been enjoying their pizza and meatball subs since 1977) that can make a proper Meatball Sub and being local to me Aaron's saves me a trip. And their pizza is a real treat too, best in Orange Park. read more

The veggie pizza is absolutely fantastic! Wasn't impressed with the calzone or the baked ziti or the fact that the business closed earlier than published time. Will definitely go again for the pizza! read more

Delicious!!! Pizza and calzones are what I've had thus far! Was in the way home, ordered for takeout to feed the family, everyone loved it!

Surprisingly good pizza! We got 1/2 Veggie & 1/2 Deluxe!! So good! However the 3nd time we ordered it didn't look the same and we expected it to look like the first time for $24 pizza. So she remade it and it didn't look any different less cheese and we got sick the next day. read more

Very quaint. Our server was nice. The pizza was delicious and the sauce was not thick and over powering. Very good meal. It's not an overly nice place on the eye, but the food and service great! I recommend checking it for anyone looking for a pizza that is not a franchise. read more

We reached out to this location while staying at the Hilton. Incredibly quick service, and reasonably priced. Driver made a quick courtesy call when he arrived. Extremely convenient. I have to admit this was some of the tastiest pizza I've encountered in recent memory. I cannot speak about the physical location because this was a delivery, but this seems like it would be a great local delivery option. I really can't do my traditional style of review on a single delivery, but I would go to Aron's again. read more

My family has eaten at Aaron's since the previous owner's However,lately the pizza has become very inconsistent. Sometimes very good and mostly not so good. The cheese tastes different sometimes and others like the old pizza that we had come to love. The crust is thick sometimes and others thin. You just never know what it's going to be like. Same with the sauce, I am only writing this because we truly love your restaurant. Btw, the service is great. Please do something so we will can continue to eat here for many years to come. Thank you! read more

This used to be delicious pizza. I don't know what happened but the pizza is awful now, and has been for months, but I kept going back hoping for better. The pizza must be pre-made with no sauce (or it's all dried up?), then the toppings are added. The pizza is hard, worse than a frozen pizza, and no longer has flavor. It's over cooked and crunchy. I never liked Pizza Hut's thin crust pizza but this is worse. I cannot figure out the mystery of the pizza having no sauce other than it being premade and the sauce was absorbed. I always have to ask for sauce on the side to dip it. I asked for extra sauce on the pizza and was told that it couldn't be done (which further supports my theory that the pizzas are pre-made frozen pizzas. Why else couldn't extra sauce, which would be "normal" sauce elsewhere, be added). I now understand why the restaurant has no pizza aromas in the air. I can heat up my own frozen pizza at home. I used to love coming here but won't be coming back unless maybe I try a sandwich or calzone, but the pizza is terrible. I kept coming back every week hoping it would improve. What sealed the deal was when my mushroom and ground beef slice was cold. The mushrooms and beef were cold from coming out of a refrigerator or freezer. The server replaced it, but the pizza wasn't good. I boxed it up to take with me. I posted a pic of it and you can clearly see how thin it is with no sauce and dried up cheese. I'll give it two stars because the server is really nice, (otherwise it would be one star) and it's not her fault that the pizza no longer is good. She deserves more stars than the actual food. read more

Aron's Pizza - Pizza with two toppings. Notice the side view how flat it is and no sauce. - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

We walked in 45+ mins till they closed and we were ordering to go, which may sound shitty but I at least tip really well. Anyways the 2 cracked out waitresses start with not acknowledging us, just looking at us and and then giving each other "the look" and then we asked if the kitchen was still open. They said "we close in 30 minutes", which I totally get it they don't want to cook more food but we were going to order something simple (pasta). So they said "oh we had a really long day, ugh it was so rough, I'm so tapped out I'm just ready to go", and they kept making comments so I said "OK we got the hint, we're leaving". I started walking towards the door and the girl says "oh you're just gonna walk away"? as if you weren't complaining the entire time we were looking at the menu. Don't go in at least 3 hours before and you'll have a great time! read more

Worst place you could to in OP. We had the wrong order and when asked to replace the owner screamed at us saying we ate half of it and then what to repace. There were racial comments on top of it. Food was not good at all. I never write a review but with this expereicnce being the worst I had to. The place is old and nasty to make it worse. read more

Don't bother ordering delivery. Alex was great in the phone. We waited 3 hours only to receive a message through Yelp that our order was canceled. Wasted time. We were at a hotel and starving. Horrible service read more

We have ordered from Aron's and usually are pleased. I had it delivered and of the three dinners ordered only one was good the shrimp fettuccine. It was up to the high standard we expect from Aron's. My meatball sub was all bread with the three meatballs cut in half. My daughter's chicken parmigiana the small piece chicken was burned!! So I don't mind paying a lot of money and then having it delivered but it will be the last time I order anything from Aron's which does make me sad. read more

Let start off by saying the pizza they serve is great and I don't have any complaints with that other than them maybe skipping out a little bit on the toppings. But the reason I am writing a review today is because I just paid for a 9$ platter of calamari and the amount given was laughable. Not at all matching what I paid for. Half way through writing this review I took another glance at the platter and dropped it from 3 stars to 2. UPDATE: just finished writing the first review and finally was able to take a bite of the most soggiest rubberband tasting thing in my life. This is the first review I have ever written in my life and I'm a very understanding person but this is HIGHLY unacceptable. The whole platter is going in the garbage. And now after tasting it I have to drop it down to a 1 star. read more

Aron's Pizza - 9$ calamari - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

UNDER COOKED AND GREASY! When called we were offered 2 free pizzas, so we could get more of the same. When we called, owner was not in the country. WE MISS ARON!!!! read more

Lived in Orange Park for 20 years now, recently decided to try Aron's Pizza. Immediately reminds you of a "hole in the wall" joint from NY. The smells...pure joy authentic HOME COOKED ITALIAN!! We pretty much go there once a week now. The pizza is perfect! Thin crust excellent sauce and GREAT toppings! Being from the Bronx; that's a big compliment! The sausage & peppers that he makes are THE BEST I've had since being up north! All of their entrees are delicious!! From the Fettuccini Alfredo, (with chicken or shrimp) to the Veal Scalopini! Their subs are FRESH, and the salads are better than most more formal restaurants. The staff is VERY friendly and so attentive! If you haven't tried Aron's Pizza you ARE missing out! Oh I and the Calzones!!!! OH MY GOD!! read more

The place has some of the best pizza I've had since moving to Florida, great staff all food was hot and fresh pizza by the slice which is great for on the go while at work definitely would recommend read more

Do not try to call in on a Friday evening for delivery. I was put on hold and then hung up on for the first attempt. I tried again about 10 minutes later. This time I was placed on hold until I finally hung up after five minutes. Another place is getting my order tonight. read more

Place was good. My husband got the all meat pizza and he couldn't stop talking about the crust and flavor. I got the lasagna which I felt had too much sauce but it worked perfect with the garlic bread. Our waiter was very attentive and the overall atmosphere was pleasant. Couple of regulars stopped in and that's always a plus. read more

Aron's Pizza - Meat pizza was good! I was surprised we had leftovers, but it didn't last long. - Italian Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Extremely tasty! Great pizza joint when you are burnt out on the typical Domino's/Pizza Hut/Papa John's triplets. This pizza's crust is crunchy, the sauce has a wonderful flavor, and the cheese is stringy! Absolutely delicious and what a pizza should be like. read more