Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Your Pie Pizza

    3.5 (53 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza, Salad, Gelato
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Your Pie Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Your Pie Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Your Pie Pizza

    Recommended Reviews - Your Pie Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    a sliced pizza on a plate
    Alexander W.

    This used to be a great place ... definitely went downhill! The pizza was burnt, seriously burnt!

    Men's Restroom
    Ed D.

    Never again is all so can say. My wife and I stopped in this place last night and I'll let the photos tell the story with just one additional sentence. Cashier was not friendly, we were charged a dollar for a plastic cups of water, don't know when this place was last cleaned and good luck finding basil on my wife's slice of pizza... (I did give a modest tip hoping line staff would get something although it's a "pizza cafeteria line operation."

    Simple but delicious. Not too heavy and fresh.
    Angelica Y.

    They were so sweet! It was our first time and we dropped by for a quick lunch since hearing great things from friends. We had no idea what the concept was even after looking at the menu online. LOL. The employees were super patient with us and we could see their smiles even under their masks. When ordering we realized it was like a subway but for pizza. It was awesome! The pizza is literally rolled out and put together on front of you as you choose your toppings. How fresh! After ordering we sat, washed our hands, and the pizzas were delivered quickly. I love pizza and like I told my sister; I felt healthy eating this pizza!

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    I enjoy this brand and haven't had in in quite some time. I was excited to see one in the location that I was working in so I stopped by for lunch. The staff was friendly but the cashier did not greet us when we approached the register. She just started repeating our order before stating the total. The food came out promptly but we were missing the two salads that we ordered. We made the expeditor aware and asked that he make sure that they be bagged separately per our request when we ordered. They did not place all of our salad dressings in the bag so we had to request more. The temperature of the pizza could have been hotter. It was lukewarm. The Caesar side salad was decent but had several brown pieces of lettuce in it. Regarding the COVID-19 safety guidelines, it was good to see most team members wearing their face masks properly. I observed a Caucasian male team member with brown hair wearing his face mask below is nose with his mouth exposed. They had several tables marked off per social distancing, and had hand sanitizer available at the register.

    See all

    6 years ago

    Best pizza I have ever eaten. Goodbye Pizza Hut, Dominos, Papa Johns, and Little Ceasars. Little Ceasars pizza is a joke anyway.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    The food is great, the staff is so nice, and they are able to handle large parties with no problem! We love coming here with our Jeep gang

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Nice folks, good food as always. Now I am going to continue typing to meet the minimum character requirements.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of James S.
    1
    104
    48

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    1 hour 40 minute wait...get back in my car and NO marinara sauce for the cheese sticks‍

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M S.
    0
    3
    0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Your Pie Pizza

    Review Highlights - Your Pie Pizza

    I am in Winder once a year for family, and this spot is always our go-to.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 3,025 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Flour Water Salt Artisan Bakery and Cafe - Fresh pastries made daily, including delicious chocolate croissants

    Flour Water Salt Artisan Bakery and Cafe

    5.0(24 reviews)
    47.9 mi

    When we arrived there were several people waiting and talking to be what turned out to be a one man…read moreshow. There were several regulars that were popping in to get their fresh baked leaves of bread. The owner is a British man with a wonderful personality and accent. We ordered a plain ham sandwich which was hand sliced ham on fresh baked bread, and a Brie, Parma ham, and fig jam sandwich on fresh bread. This is not a fast food restaurant, it's one guy doing everything, and it's worth the wait. This may be the best sandwich I've ever eaten! Everything he does with food is intentional and the quality is second to none. The place is super clean, and you can tell he's glad that you're there to try his food. Some may think that his pricing is high, but rest assured the quality and taste outweigh the price. It's worth the money. He has assorted chips and a variety of cold drinks. My wife and I were visiting, but when we come back this will be the first lunch I eat. Collin (the owner) thanked us for coming. 5 stars all day long.

    FWS is a great lunch spot and I am happy Yelp suggested it to me. The owner - operator fellow…read moreexplained the entire menu to us when he found this was our first time visiting. The menu is extensive and is made up of various baked goods designed in the UK, France, and Italy (and maybe more). Megan had a chicken salad sandwich that had bacon, some fruit, and was on focaccia. Megan enjoyed it a lot. I had some butternut squash soup and a steak pie. Both were mighty tasty. I had a good laugh when the owner said to be sure to use all the gravy. LOL you dont know me, I will take two gravies! We had a few baked goods to go including a pasty, croissant, and a bear claw. These were good but as with all freshly made baked goods you need to eat soon, don't let it linger! Oh yeah, looking at my photos the reason that we went to FWS in the first place was to pick up some baguettes to make banh mi sandwiches, and those were great.

    Photos
    Flour Water Salt Artisan Bakery and Cafe - A relaxing, cool, space to enjoy lunch or a coffee and pastry

    A relaxing, cool, space to enjoy lunch or a coffee and pastry

    Flour Water Salt Artisan Bakery and Cafe
    Flour Water Salt Artisan Bakery and Cafe - Hand carved ham and Corned Beef for sandwiches

    See all

    Hand carved ham and Corned Beef for sandwiches

    Maepole

    Maepole

    4.6(154 reviews)
    20.2 mi

    During the last year of the five-and-a-half decades my mother lived in Athens, she survived a…read moreserious medical crisis and endured the sale of her longtime home and preparations for a move to my brother's city. A chaotic period, and when my brother and/or I were in town to help out with these exhausting and time-consuming tasks, finding quick, reasonably priced, somewhat healthy, and hopefully tasty food was challenging indeed. I unfortunately didn't discover Maepole until 2025, but it nicely ticked off those boxes. Maepole is basically a "fast casual," Southern-inflected "bowl" place, with a much heavier emphasis on the nutritious and fresh than is typical of traditional Southern cooking. You start with a base, just like at Chipotle or Cava--greens, sweet potatoes, or quinoa, etc.--and top with veggies or salads, and, if you prefer a protein, you can add chicken, pork, or tofu. Or you can just go full-on veggie plate. Top with a flavorful sauce; my favorites were the spicy avocado and lemon herb. My general impression of the food quality was that it wasn't quite at the five-star level some of the time--veggies weren't always cooked to perfection, for instance--but the general experience and value, as well as the bold flavors, argue for bumping this rating up to five stars. Plus, every time I think about Maepole, I sure wish my current city had an option like it.

    First time here and recommended by a colleague. I was a little concerned about dining out in Athens…read moreduring a busy Saturday afternoon but fortunately the N Chase location is perfectly tucked away, distant enough from the downtown area. I was 3rd in line and pleasantly surprised + pleased. Think Chipotle meets Chopt (the salad bar ). Fresh ingredients. LOTS of mix and match options OR preset menu items. And just as many drink options, including locally made kombucha. I ordered the winter salad and low country plates. With the exception of the turmeric ginger dressing (a little too zesty for me) and the hoppin John salad (hoppin John OR salad ... not both ) EVERYTHING was delicious. I enjoyed the salad way more than I thought I would. The spicy avocado dressing is YUMMY! The greens were cooked to perfection - another shocker. The edamame crunch, tofu and crunchies were just as delicious. I will visit the Atlanta location just to try the fritters! A wonderfully healthy and scrumptious delight !

    Photos
    Maepole
    Maepole - Quinoa + Super Greens base, Sesame Slaw + Bean Salad as sides, Tofu, & sriracha honey + turmeric ginger as dressings

    Quinoa + Super Greens base, Sesame Slaw + Bean Salad as sides, Tofu, & sriracha honey + turmeric ginger as dressings

    Maepole

    See all

    Salads by Martha

    Salads by Martha

    4.4(49 reviews)
    35.9 mi

    I came here on a whim as i was craving a salad for lunch. They have different options of salads…read more They are take out only. They also only offer curbside service. I called in my order, and it was ready 15 minutes later. She comes outside with the portable payment machine to your car. There is a number to call for your curbside service. The salad was delicious -- i got an extra dressing as it come sin a small condiment sauce cup. They write a bible scripture on the container. The chicken only comes grilled -- but the salad was filling. I would come back due to its proximity to work. As well as the fact that its not overly priced compared to the fast food restaurants near by.

    On my way to Zaxby's for lunch,  ironically to buy a salad, I saw the sign for "Salads by Martha"…read more Intrigued, I pulled into the shared parking lot and approached the restaurant.  A quick glance at the door/window revealed they were only accepting phone or curbside/intercom orders - no dine-in customers for the time being. There was already a line of cars waiting for their orders, and a friendly lady was bringing them out.  I placed my order with her, opting for the Southern Charm with a chicken breast instead of the chicken salad and no tomatoes. It turned out that the lady taking orders was Ms. McNeal, the mother of "Martha."  She was incredibly friendly, and my order was promptly delivered. The salad was very fresh and delicious. I have already been back a couple of times ordering from home and just driving over to pick up.  I definitely suggest everyone go support this local black owned business.

    Photos
    Salads by Martha
    Salads by Martha
    Salads by Martha

    See all

    Salata - Watery dressing, ruined my salad!

    Salata

    3.9(105 reviews)
    27.1 mi
    $$

    Ordered Door Dash from here for an office meeting. I definitely would order again. All of our…read moresalads were delicious and fresh. I had the steak and so many toppings lol. I have to make my salads make sense and this place had so many options it was easy. The next time I order I am going to try the crabmeat option. I have never had a crabmeat on a salad... Im trynna see what that hits like ;). Lol 4 starts just because the pita chips were not my speed...

    I brought my family here today for an out-of-town visit. As a fellow culinary professional, I hold…read morehigh standards for guest service, and my experience today was incredibly disappointing. My sister was ordering with her toddler, who is on the autism spectrum and struggles with verbal commands. While she was holding him, he reached toward the sneeze guard glass. Instead of a polite, professional request, the male manager approached my sister aggressively, yelling at her and threatening to remove our entire party. It was alarming to witness a manager raise his voice at a young mother and her child. When my mother asked another employee (Mahandra) if that individual was indeed the manager, she began to argue with us as well. While they claimed it is store policy to prohibit touching the glass, there is no justification for the aggressive, hostile manner in which this was handled. A simple, polite explanation would have immediately resolved the situation, as my sister would have gladly complied. Beyond this interaction, I had a previous experience at this location where their steak caused me food poisoning. Given the lack of basic hospitality and these recurring issues, I will not be returning to this specific location.

    Photos
    Salata - Modern tables with the food selection on the side.

    Modern tables with the food selection on the side.

    Salata - Build your own :-)

    Build your own :-)

    Salata

    See all

    Your Pie Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...