Great diner! Food was very fresh and good pickles and coleslaw (I think you can judge a diner on those alone). It was the perfect old school diner with good service. Plus bathrooms are clean and not run down like many diners these days. read more

Above-average diner fare, especially breakfast. I defy anyone to find a better Belgian waffle than Yetters'. Dinner is good, freshly-made diner classics piled high and deep. read more

This review is SUPER overdue, but so well deserved I needed to finally sit down and make a YELP account and actually write it! Back in 2016, I was a part of a production crew for a television series that was filming an episode in Lafayette and I was in charge of organizing craft services. We had a small film crew as well as talent and a construction crew that we needed to keep well fed on set for several days. I approached Yetter's Diner to ask if they would be interested in catering for us. The owner was super accommodating and incredibly helpful! He helped to curate a menu that offered wonderful variety, so that we were never served the same thing twice. The food was always delicious! We had a really wide variety of meals over the span of filming. Since it was so long ago, I don't remember every detail but I do know one day we had Italian, one day BBQ, one day a variety of Sandwiches, we also had breakfast catered at least once, among other options. Everyone was always so happy with their meals, and expressed how much they enjoyed the food every day after lunch. They were super impressed when I told them it was all coming from the same place, they thought I had brought in several different restaurants due to the variety. I specifically remember a ton of praise over the pulled pork on the BBQ day in particular. I am so sorry I have not gotten around to posting this review sooner, Yetters! But you guys were so amazing! Thank you again for catering for us! I highly, highly recommend checking out the diner if you are looking for a variety of tasty foods. read more

Classic looking NJ diner. Been meaning to stop as we drive by often but now never will because of that god awful new digital monster they call a sign. Extremely rude. When will people learn? read more

To many kids hanging out when you walk in. Must be friends of the waiters our waitresses. They just sit there on each others laps. You got to kind of step over them to get inside. Not to mention they make you feel unwanted by there gazes. I will skip Yetter's in the future read more

Solid, typical diner with a very good location and very nice waitresses.

I've been going to Yetter's since I was a little girl and it has never disappointed. It is your average diner serving all different kinds of foods and breakfast all day with a variety of desserts as well. Good location on RT 15 in Augusta and close to the fairgrounds, Sussex County Skyhawks, and Ideal Farms. Great for families and friendly waitresses! Good burgers as well! read more

Friendly staff, decent food, reasonable prices. Only gripe is the avocado in my Cobb salad was served frozen.

Always good food, quick service, and a friendly atmosphere.

When in the Ross's Corner Skylands area, this place is your top choice. Looks like a Jersey Diner and food does not disappoint. A must stop to get ya goin' on a fair day, or fuel up for those NJ outdoor adventures.... read more

Me and my family go all the time and it never gets boring every time we love it the food is great and the waiters are very nice.

Amazing food I live in California wish we had dinners this good out there.. dont trust the bad reviews

Yetter's diner, must rank as one off if not the worst diner in NJ a state proud of their diners, miserable staff, cold food, try the quick check next door it's far better and get a tank of gas with a smile. read more

We really enjoyed our dinner here. Friendly service and great food! We had a grilled cheese and a Philly cheese steak, and both were really good. The waffle fries and onion rings were also great. read more

I love Yetter's Diner. I have been a customer of theirs for over 50 years. I have never had a disappointing meal or experience. Food is great, diner is clean, staff is friendly. I also love the old diner charm. Try the rice pudding when you are there! read more

I've gone to Yetter's all my life (I've lived within walking distance for 47 years), but I'm done. The obnoxious digital sign is blinding, unnecessary, and an absolute blight. The quality of the food is definitely on a down slide. I looked forward to my straight up cheeseburger and fries--meat was visibly stuffed with fillers, cheese wasn't even close to melted, and fries were the starch-coated Sysco batter fries. I can't stand battered fries. And so, after 47, we part ways. Fortunately, the Victoria Diner in Branchville has A-rated classic American diner food (in addition to on-premises BBQ) and Chatterbox is always a good choice for local casual dining. read more

Awesome diner in a great spot! Happy staff, fast service and great food. I can vouch for breakfast and lunch here for sure.

I don't know what happened. Maybe it was the fact that the whole family ordered off the dinner menu, maybe it was the fact that grandma was acting moody, but the food wasn't good. The fish was memorable because it was dry, so very dry. And the chicken was greasy, floating in a little oil pool. It tasted like...well...old-people-food. Except that not even grandma was satisfied. The service was homey and our waitress was very nice, but that's not enough. read more

Yetters diner was ok. My food was alright I had the chicken fingers and French fries the service was good the food was alright for the price! read more

We stop here when we're in the area. Food and service is very good. They have the BEST cream of turkey soup. And we've always enjoyed good food here. However, the ladies room is atrocious! It's very small with two stalls when there should be only one in this amount of space. I would give Yetter's another star if the ladies room was decent. read more

A lot of local people eat there. The food is pretty good. The service is below average: waited for a long time to be seated and no one paid any attention to us. read more

Awesome food , I go every month and love the breakfast . My family and I look forward to it every month . I always get the country breakfast with French toast . Huge plate of food . read more

Go there and get soup. I had the chicken and rice and loved it. This is a nice diner. I like it better than Sparta and Jefferson. Tonight I liked the waffle fries that someone else mentioned here. Staff and customers are very country but that's where it is. Haven't eaten breakfast there but plan to. read more

This is a Diner. No surprises. Diner food, Diner prices, Diner service. It's all good. What more can you say. I believe it's the best Diner in the area. And Carol is the best waitress in the area. read more

I've been here several times in the last 20 yrs or so. Today I had eggs & bacon. I have to say that the bacon was absolutely gross. It wasn't cooked all the way. It was stuck together & the couple of pieces which were seemingly edible didn't have any flavor at all. The woman who rung us up seemed angry or maybe just didn't want to be there. You used to be good. What happened ? read more

Reasonable Sunday morning crowd; ok prices and service...just watch seating ...don't let them put you near table with lots of kids...very noisy read more

Good diner with Good food. At the diner we had a couple of Gyro platters and the Chili Cheese potato skins. Both were excellent. For the gyros, they provide grape leaves, French fries, a greek salad(loaded with feta. AWESOME!), and a Gyro. There is quite a bit of meat on the Gyro and the type of meat is what I come to expect from a diner so it is pretty good. In addition, the chili cheese potato skins were great. They were cooked perfectly and used Real cheese vs. cheese whiz. They had great flavor and the chili had a little bit of a kick to it which was nice. I plan on going back in the future to try some of their other food. read more

It is an adequate diner with good food and good waitstaff. It is not trying to be something it is not. Of note, they have a smoker to provide an interest variety of food. The do not have a liquor license. If you are looking for a diner, give it a try. read more

Fantastic diner! If you want someplace with good taste, pleasant atmosphere, and friendly staff, please go here. The prices are very fair and the selection is wide. All in all, this is my go to place for a nice meal out with a high success rate! read more

I had been going to this diner for years, so I was really disappointed in my recent visit. We had sat down and ordered, waited almost an hour for our appetizer alone. It wasn't until we actually got the appetizer that we were told that one of the cooks didn't show up. The appetizers were ok at best, uneasoned if anything. The main course was only ok as well. Everything was unseasoned, the coleslaw was extremely sweet, the pickle tasted like pure salt water, and the fries were mushy. It was disappointing at best. At least the waitress comped our drinks in apology. read more

Eggs over medium and crispy bacon. Both horribly well done. Couldn't eat them. Worse food in my four day trip

Service is horrible. Waited 20 minutes for a waitress to take our drink orders. I tried to order food through her but we had yet another waitress for that. Maybe 1-2 other people were in the diner at the time and 3 waitresses were just sitting around, looking at us. The food wasn't anything fantastic. The first time I came here I ordered a steak and they brought me out a formed loaf of ground beef, that was truly, utterly terrible. Should not have even bothered again. The math on our bill was also added wrong. read more

Went to esters diner for breakfast on August 1, 2014 at 10 am. we order off the breakfast menu. i request toast with butter on the side the coffee was old/burned . i asked the water for butter she said just weigh and back after 15 minutes the butter . Upon requesting a second cup of coffee it tasted good. the food was poor quality and warn . i will never stop here again. read more

Worst breakfast ever...ordered egg white omelet with veggies. Omelet undercooked and greasy. Not again.

The food here was excellent. It seemed a little sketchy at first because the place and the menus are old and outdated.

We went here for lunch looking for some good diner food and were completely disappointed. The meatloaf sandwich I ordered resembled something from a dog food can. It clearly lacked any seasoning. Meatloaf was dry but with enough ketchup it was edible. The burger my husband ordered as medium rare came out well done and broken. The pulled pork on it had a very strange taste and it was quickly removed. While we were struggling with our own meals the man behind us had to send back his eggplant because it was too hard to chew. The only ok part of the meal was the chicken soup which I highly suspect came from a can. Service was good. I felt for the waitresses who seemed to have to take the fall for the kitchen's short comings. Hopefully in the future this diner can do everyone a favor and find the salt and pepper! read more

Classic NJ diner food...good, but nothing special if you're from north Jersey...the average wait staff when we went was 73 years old, so be patient...if it's a weekday, go down the street to the Chatterbox instead, it's a better atmosphere and more of a unique experience...don't get the brownie from the counter...It tasted like a wood chip with frosting on it. read more

Excellent food, good prices, great variety of dishes. The service was fabulous. This is a nice place to enjoy a meal, very clean. I would definitely come again. read more

ill give you one star for the drink since it was the only thing on the menu that had any flavor ...this place is in desperate need of robert irvine from restaurant impossible to come in and change this dump .not to mention the service completly sucked..the owner had the nerve after everything being completly inetible and tasteless to say he could only knock 2.00 off the bill ..!!!!!p.s. keep the 2.00 you will need it to file chapter 11 for this dump! read more

Went with my family this afternoon. My mother ordered the buffalo burger. The meat was bad (literally -- you could smell and taste that it was meat that had gone bad). So we asked for it to be returned and replaced with a salad. They actually charged us for the salad. No apology. Went to the cashier. No one asked how our meal was. I told her someone might want to check the buffalo meat supply. No reply. It's a shame because we've been going there for years. Not anymore. Any restaurant can make a mistake or serve something bad. But for goodness sake, do right by the customer and don't charge them for a salad they really didn't want in the first place. read more