Best salad ever! The woman serving us was the sweetest person. [[HIGHLIGHT]]This photo from the bathroom mirror reflects the ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Cafe Serendipity - This restaurant has heart! - Delis Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

My wife & I were in the area having work done on her car. We came upon the cafe & decided to try it. We were greeted warmly & shown the days specials. I chose the tacos & they were delicious. When we're in the area again we'll be back. It was a wonderful experience. Great food & friendly staff. read more

Cafe Serendipity is conveniently located near Lowes in Newton, where there is a dearth of food options outside McDonalds and Burger King. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a clean, open space with a decent amount of seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The temperature is usually on the colder side, and I wouldn't say it is overly cozy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I've ordered here with some frequency over the last few years, usually when I am out running errands. I'd say the food quality is mediocre, and the prices have ballooned to levels I would say are prohibitive to the average consumer based on the amount of food you're getting. I ordered a grilled chicken wrap with mozzarella, balsamic, roasted red peppers, etc. the other day and was surprised that it was $17. For a smallish wrap, it's really too costly. The cafe throws in a bag of chips, but I've never asked for one. You can get a very similar (larger) sandwich at A&G Pizza in Branchville for $4 less. I'm not sure why the consumer would want to pay 30% more for less quality, outside of the fact that there are no other cafes or delis in the immediate area. The Hampton Diner, which is notorious for being expensive (but good quality) has a similar wrap called the California which is also somewhat expensive at $15, so I'd guess that's what Serendipity is basing its prices on. I realize all food prices are inflated right now, but Serendipity should be charging $12 max for its wraps, and based on the size, they're not far off what you're getting from Quick Check at half the price. At the cafeteria near my job, it's $8 for a wrap. I'll still check in from time to time at this cafe, but the prices are pushing me away. read more

The service was awesome, but the food was mediocre at best. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was clean & welcoming.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]

I get breakfast here often, love the pancakes and French toast! Deb is a great waitress!

Great local place for breakfast and lunch. I had the tuna melt, my husband had the chicken panini and my son had the Milton sandwich. All were very good. Great menu with reasonable pricing and many options: breakfast, wraps, sandwiches, salads. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Plenty of seating and during our visit a lot of people came to take out food as well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Restaurant was clean, service was prompt and friendly.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Will definitely return! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Food, service and ambiance was wonderful.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I went there for Valentine's Day and it did not disappoint. Highly recommended. read more

A friend and I came here after a bike ride, and Cafe Serendipity truly hit the spot. I got the Fat Pat breakfast sandwich, which had sausage, eggs, cheese, hash browns, jalapenos, onions, and salt/pepper/ketchup, and it was delicious. Although the sandwich sounds akin to a breakfast Fat Sandwich, I found the sandwich to be a good ratio/diversity of toppings that made it really feel like a balanced sandwich and a reasonable way to start the day compared to the classic Fat Sandwiches we see around our state that feel like a momentuous eating feat if you finish one--though to be fair I was coming off of a 20 mile bike ride so take my opinion with a grain of salt because I was starving. All of that is to say, this breakfast sandwich was one of the best I ever had in my life. The staff were so kind too. Overall, I can't wait to be back! read more

Cafe Serendipity - Fat Pat breakfast sandwich--life-changing! - Delis Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

My wife and I celebrated our Anniversary today and we were looking for a special place to start off our day with going out for breakfast, and found Cafe Serendipity on the internet. All of the other great reviews were right. This cafe actually exceeded our expectations and we were delighted in every way. My wife was pleased with the veggie omelet as was I with my old standby of bacon and eggs, which were done just the way I ordered and just the way I like them. The portions were generous and their coffee was perfect too. [[HIGHLIGHT]]When you first come in, the cafe immediately puts you in a relaxed mood with its quaint country decor and surroundings, and country music in the background.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The owner Nelson and our server Debbie were wonderful and friendly, and treated us like family, and the service was as prompt as could be. The prices were very reasonable and we enjoyed our breakfast very much, and hated to leave! If you are looking for a really memorable breakfast experience in Sussex County, then this is your place. BTW there are a lot of things on the menu for lunch too, so we'll stop by again for lunch as well. Without hesitation I give them 5 well-deserved stars and would give them more if I could. As the expression goes, this one is a gem. read more

Great local place for breakfast or lunch. Have a monthly networking meeting there and always enjoy our breakfast.

Excellent breakfast today. Western omelette with cheddar, potatoes, and toast. Veggies in the omelette were nice and crisp, and the potatoes had great texture and flavor. Coffee was very good too. This place is our new go-to for weekend breakfast. Food and service far superior to the two closest diners (you know which ones). And the prices are better, too! We've also had their bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches on a take-out basis. Very good. The eggs are not just scrambled as they are at other places, but cooked so the white and yolk are distinguishable and set just right. Break out of your old diner habit and give Cafe Serendipity a try. read more

I recommend this place to anyone who wants a quick bite to eat! Outstanding food every time I've been, plenty of variety. Friendly staff, and cute atmosphere! They have a little coffee station, plenty of beverages, and a freezer for ice pops. Check out the daily specials, they're awesome!!! read more

Cafe Serendipity - Taylor ham, egg, & cheese - Delis Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

See all

I wish that I could give more than one star, but I have to dispute any other reviews here. My wife and I stopped by somewhere around 6:20 and there was no one else in the place. My wife ordered two breakfast sandwiches, Taylor Ham, Egg on a roll with Ketchup and Taylor Ham, Cheese with Ketchup. She emphasized the order and made sure it was known. Well, maybe not enough coffee that day. Taylor Ham and Egg with Ketchup all good, but the Taylor Ham and Cheese with Ketchup had egg included. So, two pieces of Taylor ham with egg, (not wanted) and Ketchup. I took the eggs and half of the roll and fed them to the buzzards out the window. The other two halves were put together and I ate it because I was hungry. The rolls had to have been frozen, although probably from Anthony & Sons, the rolls were not fresh. I placed the other two halves together and ate what I had. Not good, and my wife's was not good either because we all know that you need a fresh roll. Also, if you do stop, do take out because their drinks are absurdly expensive. Sorry I could not say anything better. read more

Wouldn't say it's amazing but pretty good coffee and breakfast sandwiches. Probably the best breakfast sandwich in the area that I know of. Never had lunch from here but from what I've seen looks pretty good as well. Always see the same faces behind the counter and are always polite. Happy to have this place on the way during the usual Saturday morning Lowes/Depot run to grab something to get fueled up for a weekend warrior project. read more

I've come to love this place. They are still new and the shop is becoming a more cozy cafe, but the food has been consistently excellent from day one. The staff is friendly, the food is tasty and plentiful, and the prices are good... what more could you want? read more