10/19/24 (Updated Review) Stopped in for lunch. We ordered A Turkey BLT w/side salad and French Toast w/strawberries. Food continues to be very good. Service is always good here. Very old fashioned and homey atmosphere at the Millside Cafe. read more

See all

Nice people employed there. They were Very busy. It was a Saturday early afternoon. We sat at a countertop w stools so we didn't have to wait. It took some time for them to give us menus and take orders and bring food, but we were not in a rush. We both got the soup of the day. It was a delicious chicken broth with finely chopped carrots and celery. It was tasty and warmed us up since it was windy and chilly. read more

Millside Cafe - View of restaurant toward entrance door - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

Great cozy setting, great service, the owner is wonderful person. This place has it all. Highly recommend.

food was ok, was catching up with a friend and we weren't there long before the server asked us to wrap it up because two people were waiting for a table. I was still drinking my coffee. whatever happened to letting people enjoy themselves in a restaurant?? will not be going back. so unprofessional. people waiting is not a me problem since I'm also a customer, it's their problem. people can wait just like they do in any other restaurant. read more

I went for lunch with a new friend. We were greeted by one of the owners and seated at a clean quaint table. I ordered a Cubano with a salad. My friend ordered a Chicken salad. It was a perfect lunch spot. The breakfast menu looks delicious and is my next stop to try somewhere new. read more

This place has so much potential. I went last Sunday and the millside scramble was DIVINE. The food is great. The servers are so kind and attentive too. The managers/owners are INSANELY rude. Just from speaking to them I've gotten a bad vibe, but what I've heard from other patrons closes, makes it 1000% worse. Do us all a favor and boot the owners(keep everything else)! read more

Tried to make it for brunch and didn't realize it was so popular! It was about an hour wait. Even though we made it in late we were still able to get something off of the breakfast and lunch menu. The staff is friendly and helpful and the service was pretty quick. The food hit the spot. Everything had quality ingredients and was cooked and presented well. This is a great place if you're looking for familiar food, friendly service, and a quaint atmosphere! read more

See all

Serve warm food, ordered over easy eggs with sausage and fruit, plate came out and the food was as cold as the fruit, was not happy with my experience there. read more

Fresh, tasty ingredients, with a wonderful modern farmhouse environment for brunch and lunch. By 1pm on a Saturday, they had run out of their corn beef hash, so instead, I ordered the Millside Scramble (eggs with tomato, avocado, and cheese), which were so fluffy and delicious, I inhaled it and decided that I need to make this combo at home next time. Even the potatoes were perfectly cooked, with the edges slightly crispy and a nice herby seasoning. Servers were really attentive, refilling our drinks/coffee multiple times and checking in on us. If I can make it back to this area again, I'm coming back in the morning, so I don't miss out on the corn beef hash! read more

See all

another amazing breakfast stopped in on our way to get our Christmas tree. Myself and my wife both had the special suggested by our server and it was delicious, my eggs florentine was right on point with an amazing light and flavorful hollandaise sauce. My wife had the cannoli French toast, how can you go wrong? again the food was amazing along the great service with a special touch read more

Millside Cafe - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

Coffee is funky. We had a long drive home. I couldn't honestly risk the ride place. Sent the cup back same odd results. Spot is kinda cool though. Kudos on keeping the building in use.I had the hungry farmer loaded with breakfast meats and eggs. Like a western but mushy. Wife ordered the tuna. That was sans mayo, just an fyi. Wifey said it was good. Place could be much much better with some effort and attention. I must say the Wait staff was attentive and pleasant . I won't be returning on this one food, well food was eh..and way over priced. Menu was basic... I mean basic. Oh BTW... wifey gives the blueberry pie a solid 10 read more

Millside Cafe - Basic interior - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

We always stop in here on our way to Newark Airport or when we going out antiquing. The food is creative yet still comfort food. Delish always!!! A fav that we wish we had closer. I'd never have to cook. read more

Great food and atmosphere. Friendly service. I like to stop there when riding my bike on the Sussex Branch Trail right by it

Excellent breakfast slow pace comfortable seating and the wait staff are friends. Out of the way but worth the trip. I especially like the pancakes but have had other items on their menu. read more

Popped in here with friends after yoga on a Saturday morning. It's a very cute and cozy place. The menu hits all the usual breakfast specialties and a few twists. I stuck with an omelette which was good. A friend had eggs Benedict over pulled pork and loved it. Waffles looked great too. Their coffee cake is amazing. I bought an extra piece to take home. Service was prompt and friendly. If I lived around here this would be a regular go to spot. read more

Millside Cafe - Lunch Menu - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

Have a wonderful breakfast at Millside! We sat outside on a beautiful day. Meal was delicious and staff were friendly and attentive! read more

See all

Cute little place in Lafayette. We sat outside. Very friendly waitstaff. We ordered salad with chicken, french toast and corn beef hash and 3 eggs/ sausage. Everything was delicious. We were very happy with our choices and would. recommend others trying it! read more

See all

Awesome breakfast and lunch spot!! Highly recommend!! Soup specials are a must. Great atmosphere. read more

Today i had the homemade corned beef hash. It's amazing!the hone fries were cooked to perfection brown n crispy. Unlike other diner food, not frozen.with 3 eggs cooked just the way I like. It's 5pm and in still full. The place is superbly unique. If you want a perfect country dining experience go here. The ambience is antique and authentic read more

I enjoyed everything about this bright cozy place. I had the sliced steak sandwich w/ a side Caesar salad which was more than memorable & will be hard not to order again. My friend ordered the Cubano sandwich which was also 10/10, nice tender pork & the bread it's served on is perfect. Service was friendly, clean, on point & welcoming. Great wait staff! Loved the coffee. Thank you! read more

Millside Cafe - Bright and cozy - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Went here for a quick bite to eat after antiquing that morning. Pretty easy to get a table even though the restaurant seemed to be fairly busy. We got the chicken salad sandwiches, the Cubano, the egg bowl, and some French toast to share. Everything was really good! Location is ideal and the waitstaff was all very kind. read more

Came here for a latish lunch when passing through the area. The location is wonderful next to antique shops and the river flowing through the area. It was easy to get a table and the food was pretty decent at least for the turkey wrap and chips I ordered. What was strange for eating more or less when people were leaving was that service became inattentive to the point where I wondered if we were invisible sitting nearly alone in the place. With the cash only policy for payment (I must have missed that coming in somewhere) that does not help either in my book. The bottom line for me is if I find myself in the area again I would likely give this place a pass. read more

Millside Cafe - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Great little place and a great little town. Food is fantastic and the staff is very nice as well.

I've been a great fan of the Millside Cafe for over 20 years, but recently something has changed. During this visit, orders took 40 minutes to begin arriving & were spread out over another 15 minutes, losing our hungry 7 year old. After ordering, our waitress announced that they had run out of salad & brioche. A number of extremely loud arguments lasting minutes could be heard from the kitchen. Wait staff seemed to be trying their best- serving copious refills of coffee - but there was no food being served to any customer. Usually, there was a wait list on weekends but in the last 2 visits, it was half full. New owner? New cook? Whatever the problem, I hope the Millside can soon straighten it out. read more

Did't take pictures because we were too hungry. I've been coming here since 2021 since they opennes up again after Covid. Quaint little restaurant and I've always liked their food until I came back this week for lunch. They rennovated the inside which is nicer than I remember it to be. We came in around 11:45am after 30 mins of wait which was fine since it's their busy time. When we sat down there were already lots of empty tables which meant breakfast rush was done. We ordered our food (steak sandwich and monte cristo). We had our coffee refilled 4 times before we got our food, which took about 40 mins! The food quality went down, we had it better, not sure if they changed cooks. The Monte Cristo was okay, they used to serve it with syrup and it supposed to come with hashbrowns but it came with fruits. We didn't have a chance of telling our waitress since we can't find her. The steak sandwich was just pieces of flank steak slapped in a bread with cheese then pressed. The meat was not even seasoned. Sweet potato fries was saggy and cold. The only thing that I enjoyed was the coffee. I am not sure if they changed management but that was our last visit to this place. read more

Not good , eggs over cooked , pancakes thin and tasteless. Unfortunate they closed . Thank goodness .

Food was delicious and service was attentive and professional. We will go back again soon!

I always enjoy stopping here on the way back home from camping. Their food is amazing and they have outdoor seating. read more

Millside Cafe - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

This is a cafe with a basic menu that opens early and closes early (6am-3pm). Their lunch menu consists mainly of sandwiches and wraps which are served with potato chips and a pickle (no fries because they don't have a deep fryer). The food wasn't bad, but it's not worth coming out of your way for. It's simple food designed to fill you up and send you on your way. I had a chicken Caesar wrap with bacon and it was fine though I didn't taste much in the way of dressing. Chicken was not overcooked. I can take or leave their apple pie a la mode. Decor was cute, whimsical, charming. Wait staff seemed to be frazzled and anxious - they don't have a POS system so all their checks are done by hand and with a calculator. They're also cash only. Sometimes old-timey is cool, sometimes it's just inefficient. read more

See all

After closing for a number of months the Millside is once again open under new ownership. They refurbished eatery is warm and welcoming. The menu is typical breakfast and lunch fare and priced reasonably. I recommend folks stop by when in the Lafayette area read more

Millside Cafe - the front of the restaurant - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

We've lived in and passed through Lafayette countless times in the last twenty years and never knew the Millside Cafe existed. Thankfully, Yelp is available. We tried it a few weeks ago and glad we did. The food was very good, and fresh. Service is a little slow but not a show stopper. Reminds you to dial it back and relax. We'll definitely go back. We're looking forward to exploring the antique shops as well. read more

Great country farm style and a wonderful breakfast... after wards you can shop at all the antique stores right next door....thanks we will be back! read more

A hidden gem. The atmosphere is old antique, farmer style. The food was great and the staff were friendly. read more

See all

On a crisp fall day in October on the way to Stokes Forest to collect and bottle fresh spring water, my lady friend and I stopped here for some lunch. The decor was charming country farmhouse complete with enameled metal tables, with a fantastic view of the roaring stream directly outside of this former mill, hence the name of this cafe. We started off with yellow split pea soup- was the perfect accompaniment to the weather, home made, tasty- perfect. Next up, I had an excellent turkey club on mutigrain bread served with corn relish on the side- fantastic with one exception- too much mayonaise- its always a good idea to let people add their own, some might even return their meal especially if served with this much mayo. My lady friend had a grilled veggie wrap that was pretty good too, I tried a bite. The place was so nice that on the way home, we stopped in again for tea, coffee and a lil slice of apple crumb pie heaven. I will be back. read more

Millside Cafe - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

Ashley was so rude, try helping costumers and maybe they would stay. Wouldn't "try" and eat here again.

This was our first visit since the re-opening after the change of ownership. The new hours are Thursday through Saturday, 7:30 am - 5:00 pm, and Sunday 8:30 am -4:30 pm. The new owners have relocated the rest room to the main floor, which I learned by walking down the stairs and into the newly expanded kitchen...oops. Decor is still rustic with a mish-mosh of different tables and chairs, but all the chairs are painted black and all the tables have natural wood tops with black legs. I'm a fan. We came for a late breakfast on a Friday. The service was friendly and the food was plentiful. JP had the veggie omelette with a side of bacon and I had the Millside Scramble. The bacon was cooked perfectly. He cleaned his plate, and I ate as much as I could...three eggs is too many for me. The scramble was interesting; the avocado was scrambled in with the eggs, and I thought it could have been added toward the end of the cooking process. Also, I needed to add salt and pepper. The home fries were perfectly cooked; I just had to add a dash of salt and pepper to make them perfect (for me). All in all, we'd eat there again. read more

Me and my girlfriend went to this restaurant and we saw that the ratings looked very good and the images looked very pretty...I did think that those photos are fake because usually at restaurants or fast food places they make them look pretty in the image then in real life...But they weren't kidding the food looked so beautiful...When me and my girl friend arrived, the food smelled delicious....I ordered the French toast and my gf had a veggie omelet....That French toast was the best French toast I ever had because it tasted so fresh from the whipped cream,berries, and toast...All the food I had was amazing and tasted so good ....I will definitely come back for even more food!!!!:) read more

Millside Cafe - French toast - American Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

We have bern wanting to stop by this place, so we went out of our way on a beautiful Sunday. It was busy so we waited quite a while for the server to arrive. She was very unfriendly did not smile or greet us appropriately or thank us. She didn't go over any specials. As we heard her go over specials with another table, they ordered the chicken salad which I asked her not to order it. If it had any dark meat in it, she was supposed to check, and I did notice that there was dark meat mixed in with the white meat it was very dry. The bread was good. However, my husband ordered the cheesesteak which was extremely tough and not tasty. The soup was good but cold probably will not stop by again. read more

The food was awful, I waited 1 hour, when I mentioned it the waitress told me there's other people waiting for their food too. I will never be back obviously the bill was 70$ for torture. read more

$37 dollars for breakfast is absurd!! That's $43 after tip. Got an omelette which was great, but my fiancé's pumpkin pancakes were bland and didn't even taste like pumpkin. So literally 2 pancakes and an omelette was $37?!? Not to mention the lady running the place was wack out of her mind! Will never be going back. read more