I tried Yesterday's Diner today and was pleasantly surprised. Two thumbs up! The restaurant is clean and quaint, with a charming atmosphere that jogs memories of fun diner days of the past when diners were all the rage. I ordered the chicken parmigiana "early bird" dinner before 6:00 pm for $18.95, which came with a soup or salad and dessert and coffee. I tried the chicken noodle soup--yum! It came with two fresh rolls. The entree was also impressive--a large portion that was delicious, cooked just right with a generous portion of spaghetti and marinara sauce. Dessert (rice pudding) was just okay, a bit bland, but the sprinkling of cinnamon brought some flavor to life. The coffee (black) was decent. The service was a bit slow considering there weren't many customers, but the staff members were accommodating and friendly. Here's my breakdown: Chicken noodle soup- 4/5 Chicken parmigiana - 4/5 Service - 3/5 Rice pudding- 2/5 Coffee - 3/5 Overall I would rate this diner 4/5 and like Arnold said, "I'll be back!" read more

Yesterday's Diner - Chicken parmigiana with spaghetti dinner entree. - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Today was a good day to visit Yesterday( the diner that is..). My dear friend Richie is a regular who loves this place and I can see why. The omelettes were great. The toast was hot with the soft melted butter. The fresh fruit side was bursting with flavor and juice. The coffee was hot and fresh and our fun and spunky server Edith kept our cups refilled. The food was out in a few minutes. It is really nice inside with some bright colors( photos) that absolutely livened up our day with the snow falling outside. The atmosphere was relaxed and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. Please note that there are just a few parking spots on the diner property but loads of parking on Jericho Tpke and the side street. This was a wonderful 5 star experience. Definitely be back. read more

See all

This diner used to be good, but that was "Yesterday". This morning I ordered 2 eggs over easy with bacon , home fries and toasted English. The bacon was as hard as a rock and tasted stale. like it was left over from 3 days ago. The home fires were so soggy they were more like mashed potatoes, and their coffee taste like it has been sitting in the pot for hours. Definitely not worth the $18.37 they charged me. They only thing positive is that the place is clean. But I'll take a little less clean with better food. I will not be coming here anymore. read more

The food and the service was great and so delicious. I ate everything. The waitress was great and friendly.

So cute! I'm usually not the biggest fan of diners but I really liked this one. The staff was so nice and the food was good! read more

Yesterday's Diner - Hungry man - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

We wanted a late breakfast after church and decided to give Yesterday's a try and we weren't disappointed. We were pleasantly greeted by both the man at the door who seated us promptly and by the waitress. My two soft scrambled eggs were perfectly done, the hash browns was a very big portion and delicious and my 4 strips of bacon could have been a tiny bit crispier but still good and more importantly not too salty. My brother's corned beef hash was just as good and he was very happy that they still had grits available. Our iced coffee and hot coffee were refilled promptly and we left very satisfied. Looking forward come back to try other items on their menu. read more

Food was great . Cute little diner, open late , but we walked and not one personal was around for like 5 minutes then it felt like we had to ask for service and everything we needed we had to get up to get it it was like no one wanted to work . Looked like it was just one Hispanic male and one Hispanic woman running the entire diner on a Friday night . read more

Your average dinner that's very reasonable. I came here for breakfast and they had everything from omlettes to pancakes to waffles and so on. The serving sizes are decent and the food is very average. This is your very typical long island diner. The service is very quick and attentive. The place itself is quite small and does get busy in the mornings on weekends, so just be aware. read more

See all

1 server...owner..does not help server...open today Christmas...ppl w no families ..are at diner...

We usually go to this Diner about once a month. We went a few days ago and were quite disappointed. The total bill for 4 people was almost $140.00 yet when we asked for extra cream cheese we were actually charged another $1.50 which seemed very petty. The service was not very good. It usually is much better. This was a different Wait Person. We had to ask for more coffee and our water glass was never refilled. Don't plan on returning for a while. read more

I stopped by because it was advertised as 24 hours. I waited for about 10 minutes, and although there were staff members present, no one came over to assist me. They were just talking among themselves. I ended up leaving. Very disappointing service. read more

Stopped in for a Christmas Day brunch. This is a nice, comfortable diner, with good & friendly service. Upon entering I was immediately shown an empty booth & given a menu. My server quickly appeared, taking my standard diner order, omelet with fries. I added a hot chocolate. My food was served pretty fast. I liked the way everything looked on the plate. The eggs were large, with plenty of hot fries. It all tasted very good. The hot chocolate was definitely hot, hotter than most places serve it nowadays. The only negative was the allegedly buttered toast. I was not given butter to add to the toast. I did see a couple of spots of butter on the toast, but it was mostly dry. More butter could have made this a 5 star review. All in all, a pretty decent experience. I will come here again. read more

Looking for a 24 hour diner this place was an option for me a few times. I do wish the quality of the food was better I do feel as if they give you just whatever at 5am. I've ordered omelettes each time and they were really well done eggs you know the eggs that you have to fork through not soft. They are pretty pricey if you are building your own omelette. Service is ok I did want to get my mother and omelette and turkey bacon to go and she did mention how they did give her a lot of turkey bacon. As I stated they are expensive that one meal just for my mother came up to about $27. read more

Came here for a quick bite to eat with my wife on a Wednesday night. They were not very busy since it was early and during the week. We received a warm welcome from our waiter, seated immediately. I order a Cheddar Cheeseburger Deluxe with fries and Onion Rings, a club soda with lemon and my wife ordered a Mushroom burger. Our food came out rather quickly. Our burgers were good, fries and onion rings were awesome, nice an crispy and all our food was hot. Dinner was filling so no desert. Our bill came to $25.00, not too bad for a quick bite. Overall the burgers were ok, fries and onion rings, great and our server was very polite, friendly and efficient. read more

Went with my boyfriend around 4-5am and it was pretty empty. Our waiter was very attentive and kind. I didn't actually eat, I wasn't feeling well but my partner enjoyed his burger. I did love the pictures of Marilyn Monroe and will return another day to have some food. read more

Best pancakes, sausage and eggs in the area. The sausage is crispy, plump and juicy. Pancakes have the distinct flavor reminiscent of IHOP that keeps you coming back for more. Service is excellent. Ricardo, Daisy and team are all super attentive and friendly. One of the least crowded places is a bonus, great food without the wait!! read more

Yesterday's Diner - Blueberry Pancakes - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I've been here a few times over the last few months and have always had a good experience. However, I was here this past weekend and extremely disappointed. I had ordered a pastrami melt but when I got it there was a lot of fat on the meat. I told the waitress that I didn't want it. She asked if I wanted something else so I decided upon a BLT. When the sandwich came, it only had three pieces of bacon on it. I started eating it and then I noticed that the tomato didn't look right. I opened the sandwich to see one of the tomatoes was cut leaving the core piece in it. Picture attached. I ate a piece of that core not knowing it. I feel the tomato was cut that way deliberately because I had returned my first order. So, instead of making their customer happy, they took their contempt out on me instead and then charged me $13 for three pieces of bacon. Great customer service! I will not be returning to this diner anymore and will not recommend it to friends, either. read more

Yesterday's Diner - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Fried Chicken and waffles were good! Overall.. your typical diner vibes and food. I wouldn't say it is out of the ordinary and extravagant. If I had to put it.. 6/10 for the food. read more

Yesterday diner is something I'll leave in the past. I will not return! Horrible service. I ordered a bacon cheese burger with avocado deluxe mozz on fries. Server brings me no cheese on fries after she repeated my order. She takes it back and brings it with American cheese after again she repeated the order. Asked for a cup of matzoh ball soup. Here is where the bs comes in not only was order wrong but now up charges me $8 for avocado initially when the charge for avocado on a burger is $4 the cup of soup is $3.95 and you charged me 7.95 and when I complained your manager who has no business being a manager changes it to $5.95 and says a cup of soup is $3.95 but motzah is $2 up charge. So here's the thing no mention on the menu of an up charge no mention from server either he had to change my bill so many times cause of their scamming. If you go here check your bill!!! There is a thing called truth in menu. This place epic failure read more

Yesterday's Diner - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

The food was as ordered. Jackie, our waitress, was excellent! And, though the diner was about 3/4 full, it was pleasantly peaceful. Don't understand the 3* rating! We'll be back! read more

Ordered myself some breakfast on mother's day since my hubs had to work and was not disappointed. Pretty good breakfast. Can't say much else since it was just take out/delivery. read more

Food choices are generous and delicious The Chilaquiles are delicious. also hungry man special also good. Services average. hours are weird. and the feel is good. Nice vibes overall. read more

Used to go every Sunday before Covid and loved the food and people who worked there. Went Sunday morning at 3:00 am. The pastrami was cut so thick, you could not eat it in the sandwich becauseit was hard. We had to take the pastrami out if the sandwich and use a fork and knife to eat it. The waitress realized that something was wrong so we ended up ordering a lamb gyro. The gyro was very greasy. So we ended up not eating it. The waitress was very sarcastic and we heard her talking smack about us in Spanish not liking the gyro. read more

Yesterday's Diner - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

This is one of those places I would give no stores to if I could. I took a friend there for a late lunch about 2 o'clock. There was maybe only one other occupied table in the place. We both ordered omelettes. Hers was maybe a farmers - vegetables with a tomato sauce poured over it - and home fries. Mine was onion, feta and spinach with a small amount of salad. It was typical diner food. Nothing fancy and basically flavorless. What prompted me to write this review was the bill. Including a 20% tip, the bill came to $40. I could have gone almost anywhere and gotten a much better lunch for a lot less money. Seriously....2 omelettes for $40.00??? read more

Extra expensive, for the most basic food. $2.00 to add onions to an omelette, they've gotta be nuts. I miss triple crown diner.

Ordered huevos rancheros and not very tasty, comes with no meat, had to ask for sour cream and hot sauce.

Ordered the Pastrami omelet. Unfortunately it was all gristle, low-quality meat. That pastrami was tough and difficult to chew. This used to be a good little diner, but not anymore. read more

Their cheese quesadilla was delicious It's what I always ordered from here. And their service is good.

Mainly depends on the staff at the time. Went again for brunch recently, and they didn't offer me utensils or refilled my tea when they offered. My order had sides and wasn't brought out until I asked again. Took l 10 minutes to bring it despite going into the kitchen many times and did the same again before refilling my tea. read more

I stopped by there the other day on the way home from the casino. I've been there before and was pleased. Our experience the other day was fantastic. Everyone working there were happy and pleasant. We ordered our food and it's was delicious and the portions were huge. We had enough for the following days dinner. Our waitress, I think her name was Edith, was the best I've encountered in years! She couldn't do enough for us! I left a 30% tip, and I don't usually believe in tipping, lol. I can't wait to return. The specials were around $16. Mom and my girlfriend were similarly impressed! read more

Food was really good, and the server Victor was a sweetheart. would recommend to a friend, and the decor was sick!

Very friendly people as soon as I walked into the door you feel like your home, inside the decor is pleasant your typical Long Island diner, a little nostalgia field, from the 50s into the 60s, Ricky the waiter was fantastic, all the meals were fresh delicious great portions reasonable prices plenty of parking, stop by you won't regret it, and judging by the customers you see people that are coming in many repeat customers from the neighborhood that keep coming read more

See all

I'll keep it short and sweet: This place used to be a great diner. Lately, they have done something with their pricing and it has now become one big scam ! Example : 2 short stack orders of banana walnut pancakes. 1 side of bacon 1 coffee 1 tea Total: $37 before tip Avoid this place at all costs! Go to the Floral Park Diner instead. It's almost half the price for the exact same meal. read more

They're called Yesterday's because that's when your food was cooked. Place is clean and staff is friendly. Our waitress was a pleasure but unfortunately the food is horrible. I ordered a chicken salad wrap. It came with coleslaw. But zoom in to both. The coleslaw looks like they used a blender. Same with the chicken salad. Extremely mushy. Did you guys use a blender to mix it? It had no flavor and the consistency of mashed potatoes. One star is for cleanliness, the other for the waitress. read more

Yesterday's Diner - a plate of rice and a sandwich - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Decided to try this diner the other day and it was pretty good. I ordered pancakes deluxe (chocolate chip pancake substitution) with home fries ($4.95) on the side. It totaled out to about 21 with tax. The meal came with 2 eggs, sausage, 2 strips of bacon, and ham. I thought the meat and eggs were delicious. The pancakes were good but not the best I ever had. If I am paying about $2 for chocolate chips on my pancake, I want a significant amount of chocolate chips. The size of the pancakes were very big and perfectly rounded (maybe a little too perfect for my liking) but I was very content with the portion of my meal. My friends also ordered breakfast and enjoyed their meal. My friend had toast as one of the main parts of her meal but didn't receive it until after she finished everything. They kept saying "it's coming" but then after asking another time they said they burnt it the first time. Waiters were very friendly and looked so happy to be there which was nice to see. Also if you check in, you get a 10% discount if you spend $15 or more. I would come here again. I enjoyed my food here, but maybe I'd try something different next time. read more

See all

Hate having to write negative reviews but its the only way these owners will learn they cant just run roughshod over the public Drove up at 7am and the place was deserted that should have been a sign Ordered basic beeakfast of 2 eggs potatoes and toast was asked if i wanted juice and coffee and declined Thats the breakfast special Got the check and paid for it but was charged the breakfast special price $ 4 more than it was for non special i hope the owner reads this review please dont spend my 4 bucks all in one place I will never be back and will never take down the review On to the food Eggs and toast nicely prepared home fries absolutely tasteless zero flavor If you go here be prepared to watch your wallet SO DISAPPOINTING BE WARNED read more

I serve at a diner in New Jersey, So I know how a diner should operate... And boy was this diner great! My server was so welcoming and friendly. Service was really fast and the food tasted amazing. Im not often in this area, but I defiantly want to come back. read more

See all

staff is very friendly and service is fast . just ate breakfast here and i would suggest the diner switch to real loose shredded hash browns and also sausage links with skin linings. read more

Clean restaurant, great location, friendly staff and delicious food. Came to visit for a non pleasurable trip but definitely will be returning to enjoy and try different dishes. Gotta love a good diner! read more

Yesterday's Diner - Salad Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

I asked for pepper and egg on a roll. The sandwich was made with 2 eggs and some cut up raw peppers. I was charged $6 for the sandwich plus $2 for the extra egg and $2.00 for the pepper. A glass of ginger ale and the bill came to almost $16.00 plus tip $2.00. No pickle. No Cole slaw. Nothing. $18.00 for a lousy sandwich. Who ever heard of pepper and egg with raw peppers? Prices are outrageous. Not going back there anytime soon. The waitress was very unfriendly until she brought the bill which is the reason for the small tip. read more