Overall, the benefit of this hotel is its location. It's central to everything. Boston is an incredibly walkable city, and having a home base in the heart of it is worth something. So from a cost-to-location perspective, it's worth a few extra ducats to be in the center.
I'll break down everything else.
I'll start with the Staff/Service (4.5 Stars):
The people are lovely. Kind, friendly, and will work to accommodate you as best they can - more on this later. There is a valet who is quick and with 10-15 minutes advance notice will have your car front and center. That being said there is a parking garage right next door. But if you want that service, it's there.
The Room (3):
While our room was the biggest hotel room I've ever been in, it is dated and dark. Lots of muted colors and rich wood tones and silly furniture. The lighting is dark, but thankfully there are huge windows (at least in our room). When the shades are pulled back it lets tons of light in. The drawback is that's when you can see the datedness of everything.
The room had a fireplace - which was romantic. It keeps the room in a warm glow. It should be noted that it had a little bit of a mind of its own. I get the sense that it was battling the thermostat for control of the room. Ultimately the thermostat won out.
The sitting area is fine. Though again the furniture felt very 90's. And in general the hotel feels that way. The hotel TV station was running footage that felt extremely dated and most of the channels on the TV were in SD.
The View (3):
It's in the center of a city so unless you're actually on the park, the views are of buildings. But we could see the old state house down the block. Generally, I wouldn't complain, it just wasn't anything to write home about. We weren't expecting much. Just don't get excited that you'll get a view in any room in the house that's super meaningful.
The Bathroom (3):
The shower is really nice (5 Stars). Heavy rain shower, like being in a waterfall. I loved it. The sink and the pipes squeal. So, open all the way.
The Sleep (4, but see the next section):
The bed is comfortable, and inviting. The sheets, a hair rough. But generally we were quite comfortable, and getting into bed we quickly fell asleep.
The Night (2):
Terrible. This is really where you have to weigh your options. We stayed a Friday and a Saturday night. Both nights starting at about 3-4 AM we had garbage trucks. Actually that's an understatement. We had what sounded like garbage trucks being tossed into a wood chipper. And then tossed down a flight of metal stairs. It was not good. At all. Follow that up with cars "cruising" Beacon street. To be fair to the XV, there is little they can do about this. And when I had foam ear plugs in, I was able to muscle through. I have to imagine that the back of the building would have significantly less of that, so given the earlier "view" discussion, I would opt for that. But buyer beware.
I did go down to the lobby the next morning to discuss the night before. The staff was apologetic, but clear that there wasn't much they would/could do. I was hoping that the next night would be better. It wasn't. I know they can't control the cars, but to not offer some concession was a little odd to me.
I've stayed at other hotels on and around The Common and while the searing hot metal twisting that happened was unique to my experience at the XV, the racing cars and motorcycles wasn't . Whether it's the Four Seasons or the Boston Park Plaza or the hotel formerly known as The Taj, I guess that area is a cruising zone where people live their lives a quarter-mile at a time.
The Lobby (3):
Also small, dark, dated. Needs a sprucing.
Other amenities:
We didn't use the restaurant, but it was jumpin' and seems like a solid place to eat.
We *did* use the free car service. Which was great. The driver was engaging and friendly. The ride was smooth. They will take you from the hotel, anywhere in the city, up to 2 miles (which is basically the whole city).
The Price:
We paid a lot. It was a holiday weekend and the Boston Marathon. So disproportionately high. But overall for our experience, way too high.
All in all, I would not stay here again. The friendly staff, notwithstanding, and the room size being what it was, when you pay a premium at a hotel, location can't be the only amenity that you're paying for. Sleep counts.
Recommendations for the hotel:
1) Speed bump/Stop sign in front of the hotel. I would work with the city to create that. It would make that area less of turn around point for cruising.
2) City Windows. I don't get the sense that people open hotel windows all that much. Seems like a solution like City Windows would really cut down on the sound issue.
3) Updating the AV/Electrical - The speaker system and stereo in the room is nice, but everything feels like it needs updating. The light switches feel flimsy.
4) Brighten and update the look.
Hope this helps. read more