STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE. My husband went to this place on November 26, 2025 to sell some Morgan…read moredollars and a few pieces of gold jewelry. Before he went he called the person he usually deals with in LaGrange, NY and was quoted $30. each for his Morgan silver dollars. He previously cashed in some Morgan dollars with this dealer in LaGrange. He then called NY Gold and Silver and they quoted him $33. and change if he brought them in. The price of silver actually went up a bit overnight. He went in the next day and "Janet H." said the Morgan dollars were "worn" and "underweight". These Morgans were in better shape than the ones he had been cashing in at the LaGrange shop. My husband didn't realize until he got home that he was only paid $24.00 each for his Morgan Silver dollars. He could have gotten $30.00 each from the dealer in LaGrange. We emailed NY Gold and Silver in Carmel to explain the situation and to protest the price they paid him. We never heard a word back from them. I am still angry over this and also regret that I did not go with my husband when he cashed these coins in. I would have walked out rather than let them go for $ 6.00 EACH less than they were worth.....he cashed in 24 Morgans so he lost $144.00 on this deal. My husband is such a kind, trusting person and it is DISGUSTING that he was taken advantage of this way. DO NOT TRUST THESE PEOPLE, GET A SECOND OPINION.

I've never sold gold or silver before, but Janet at NY GOLD & SILVER put me at ease immediately…read morewith her kind but professional manner and obvious expertise. She explained what she was looking for and how she measured its worth, and gave me a fair price for the silver I brought in. She put no pressure on me to accept her price, which I really appreciated. I would definitely use this business in the future. I'd recommend making an appointment, and just to know before you go: if you are trying to sell whole pieces of jewelry with the stones intact, this is not the place for you. The gold and silver they buy is going to be melted down.

This is the 3rd time I sold old jewelry pieces, and Vic is incredibly a pleasure to work with. He's…read morevery informative about jewelry, and he gives you honest suggestions on what to keep and what to get rid of. He also gives you top dollar for your pieces, and he has also resized rings and polished jewelry for me at a reasonable, discounted price.

From the owner: Fine Italian jewelry. We buy, sell, trade all jewelry. Repair, clean, custom orders & custom…read morediamond settings. We buy gold, diamonds, platinum & silver. Come check out our jewelry store today!

I usally really only review restaurants..but I just had such a possitive experience, I had to…read morecomment. I brought some old coins and trinkets in to have them examined and appraised. I was treated very nicely..the gentleman ( who I take for the Owner ) was knowledgeable and professional...Moreover, even though the items I brought in were not very valuable at all, ( knowing they were once important to my late Father ), he treated the items with respect and dignity..that was very meaningful to me. I remember buying my wedding band here years ago and also remember them being great back then. In a small Mall that seems to be full of Jewelry stores and kiosks, I'd Highly recommend that you stop at Anthony's Jewelers before the others. Trust me!!

Had an awesome experience with Mark over at Anthony's Jewelers at the JV mall. Was able to get my…read morewatch band swapped out with a battery change and two rings cleaned no long waits! Highly recommend stopping by for all of your Jewelery needs.

Sacred Heart Gifts and Apparel is a total GEM of a local business. Definitely consider this store…read morewhen looking for gifts of faith. I have shopped here for small items and gifts for specific sacraments over the years; however, I recently made two separate trips--one time was just to browse and pick out things for myself and the second was to find small gifts for a couple of cousins' graduations, one high school and one college. Both times, the employees along with the owner could not have been more helpful! The variety of merchandise and vast range in prices makes it so easy to find a lovely and thoughtful gift with in any budget. For example, one can pick out a very thoughtful prayer card for as inexpensive as around $1.

Great store. Great staff. Patient and accommodating. Helped us find great First Communion gifts!read more

Having won a gift certificate from Zaltas Gallery of Fine Jewelers at an event some time ago, I…read moredecided to redeem it this month for a gift for my granddaughter who was graduating from High School. I so appreciated the courteous professional service from the staff in helping me choose something a teenager would love and treasure for many years. We agreed on a lovely sterling necklace which proved to be just the right present. I would like to extend my thanks to everyone at Zaltas and will always treasure the memory of this purchase. C.P.

I have bought several items from 3000 miles away aways sight unseen from…read more Kathy and Rebecca Zaltas of Zaltas Gallery. Offering many unique one of a kind items and great prices. They are very professional with perfect customer service. Don't hesitate, give them a try :)

Avoid Ralph at All Costs - Incompetent and Dishonest…read more I'm writing this from the courthouse where I've just filed a lawsuit against Ralph. That alone should tell you everything you need to know. I brought my father's watch to Ralph for a simple gasket replacement. It's a diving watch he wore while serving in the military, and I'm heading to Ukraine to serve myself--I wanted to wear the watch in his honor. I chose Ralph because of the many glowing reviews online. Big mistake. The first red flag was the overwhelming smell of marijuana in his shop. I dismissed it at the time, thinking maybe it helped him focus on delicate work. I couldn't have been more wrong. When I first brought the watch in, it was functioning well--just running about a minute slow each day. All I asked was for Ralph to replace two gaskets. We agreed on $200, which was all I could afford as I won't be working for the next six months during service in Ukraine. For such a basic job, it was a fair price. A day later, I called to ask if he could look into the cost of a new crystal. After not hearing back for a couple of days, I followed up--only to be told he had already replaced the crystal for $150 without my consent. When I told him I wouldn't have agreed to that, he flew into a rage, yelling about how he wasn't making enough on the job. It became clear to me he may have serious issues, possibly substance-related. When I finally went to pick up the watch, the bezel no longer turned. Ralph claimed I had damaged it myself, which I hadn't. Then I noticed the self-winding mechanism wasn't working. He insisted it was fine, despite clear evidence to the contrary. It was rubbing against the back plate. I stormed out taking my watch, but later returned, hoping he would take responsibility. After more yelling and resistance, he begrudgingly agreed to take another look. Weeks passed. My departure date for Ukraine got closer. Today, 2 days day before I leave, Ralph texts to say the watch is ready. I go in--and unbelievably, it's in worse condition than before. The winding mechanism is not working as it should. The bezel now turns, but it could easily be roomed with a thumbnail. I walked out refusing to pay. This time, he followed me outside, becoming aggressive. I told him I would see him in court. Later that day, I went to another, far more competent watch repair professional. He opened the case and immediately found the issue: the movement wasn't seated properly, and the retaining ring was missing. I know that was there when I gave it to him because I open the watch myself to see what gaskets were needed. Without it, the entire mechanism is unstable. If a replacement can be found, the watch might be salvageable. But it's an older model, and chances are slim. This isn't just a watch--it's a deeply sentimental piece of my family's history. And it's also quite valuable. Ralph, if you're reading this: You know exactly what happened. That retaining ring didn't vanish on its own. It's either still in your shop or you carelessly threw it away. I don't forget things like this, and I'm not letting it go. Ever. To anyone considering trusting him with something valuable: Don't. The reviews are misleading. My experience was a disaster, and now I'm left with a broken watch and a legal battle just days before leaving. Also, take a moment to read the negative reviews--those are the accurate ones. Many people have had experiences similar to mine. And look at his responses: full of excuses, never accountability. He clearly lacks the ability to take personal responsibility. Pathetic. Take a look at the photo I've attached. You can see at nine and 10 o'clock the space between the watch face and the case itself.

I dropped off my Panerai and Omega for polishing on Thursday and received a call on Monday that…read morethey were ready for pickup. Both watches were restored to mint condition-- the Omega had significant scratches and the Panerai had a ding, all of which were flawlessly repaired (check attached pictures). Excellent service at a reasonable price. Highly recommended.

Great business; helpful staff, wonderful showroom…read more I was trying to buy an engagement ring a few days before leaving for Europe. Tony and Louisa are such great people; they showed us several options, and made us reasonable offers. Come here and pick out something special!

Tony and Luisa were great in getting the right wedding bands for us. I got my fiancees' engagement…read morering there, and she couldn't have been more ecstatic about it. When it came time to get bands we went back to New Rochelle, and were not disappointed. My wife's wedding band needed to fit under her engagement ring, and I had a unique band design. Luisa worked with us to get the perfect rings at great prices. We both got compliments on them. Recommend them whole heartedly. (Photo is of our rings by our photographer).