Wooden Peel

Wow! The food here is amazing!…read more We showed up 15 minutes before closing, and instead of turning us away the owner was very polite and let us order AND dine in. The owner suggested their cheesy garlic bread and it was awesome. Loaded with a ton a cheese, soft, and hot. We ordered the 20" combination pizza and it was to die for! Fresh pizzeria sauce and hand tossed crust. If we are ever back in town we will definitely stop again.

I have previously left a great review a couple of years ago. Hadn't ordered from them for a while…read moredue to the very long wait times. Today, I decided that I wanted something different and had a drive until I was back in town, so it would be fine to have a longer wait time for pick up. I don't see why it takes 45 minutes to make a regular crust pizza with one topping, but at least they let you know ahead of time. My issue today was that I also ordered a sandwich. I picked up my food as the pizza was coming out of the oven, in which I had to wait on.. and the whole time my sandwich was setting there boxed up. It had been boxed up for quite some time. The sandwich was cold, and the pizza was bland and didn't have the extra sauce that I paid for. It's just very bland pizza. The crust is flavorless, and it seems like the cheese is too. The sandwich would have been good if it was hot and the oil hadn't soaked into the bread by the time my pizza was ready. Let me also add, that it's a pretty pricey pizza. So... high cost, long wait times, and meh flavor.

Cheesy garlic bread

20" combination

See all

Yum

Goodfella's Pizza

4.6(21 reviews)

47.3 mi

The pizza is amazing! Every time I come to Wabash I go to goodfellas and they never disappoint. The…read morestaff are nice. Will keep eating here forever.

The food was fantastic! The pizza, sticks and and poppers were all full of flavor, pipping hot and…read morethe order was ready on time. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the crust wasn't too much, but just right. Met the owner, super friendly and very customer focused. The inside was small but can easily seat a number of families. Overall, great location and pizzeria!

Inside Dinning area

A beautiful Goodfellas pizza!!

See all

Outside of Goodfellas business and vehicles.

Pizza Hut

3.7(9 reviews)

0.2 mi

Taco pizza ! Love this and you can't find it everywhere. So when I have a chance to stoop into…read moreBremen, I do. The staff was awesome too !

You would've gotten a five star if you would've actually put barbecue sauce on my barbecue wings…read moreand you gave me ranch when I didn't even ask for it but yeah you got my personal Pizza right and here's the picture to prove it

See all

JC's Coal Oven Pizza

4.6(74 reviews)

19.5 mi

Service was good, very friendly and kind servers…read more Garlic knots were reheated and not warmed all the way through, tepid inside and needed more color on the dough. Salads were good, the jalapeno ranch is tasty. Pizza was floppy and undercooked. "Roasted" onions on the pizza were only partially cooked and still tasted raw - not what we expected. Sausage and pepperoni were tasty but the pepperoni cups needed more time in the oven. The edges of the dough were cooked through but barely. Disappointed, coal fired pizza should be crispy with a touch of char. This pizza was already sliced and needed another 3-5 minutes in a hot oven.

Where do I even begin? Our server even called this place a dumpster fire! The only positives I can…read moresay is that the food is good but the service is horrendous. MANY patrons were MAD. We waited for over an hour to be seated (when the gal at the front said we'd be seated right away) then we waited for 2 hours for our food and when we get it, it's missing several ingredients...because they're out. Oh and the best part is when all the cooks left the kitchen and sat in a circle in the dining room for 15 or so minutes. The owner was also there...sitting at the bar with a drink. Why wasn't he helping bus tables, cook, GO TO THE STORE TO GET INGREDIENTS THEY RAN OUT OF??? This was during their busiest rush. What in the world???? Excuse was made that it's St. Joe's prom and all their employees are at the prom. Unreal! 1 star because food is decent but we will not return.

Dining area

Calzone

See all

Dragon's Milk

Bailey’s Pizza Parlor

5.0(1 review)

38.7 mi

Homemade goodness prepared in front of customers! All made fresh. Pizzas are very generously…read moretopped! Subs are amazing. Don't miss the Garlic Goodness sauce. Staff are very pleasant.

Food prep: clean and fast.

Covered Bridge Cheese Bread. Generously cheesy and yummy!

See all

Daily menu board. Updated with specials.

Bourbon Street Pizza

4.1(20 reviews)

12.1 mi

Food: Breadsticks are a MUST! So delicious. The pizza was great too... the large was only $1-2 more…read morethan the medium. Very reasonable cost for what you get! Plenty of options. Fountain drinks are self serve. Service: there were only 2 other tables dining inside and our 2 large pizzas and breadsticks were delivered within 20 min. You order at the counter, so you don't really have a server. They offer the plates, plasticware, and napkins by the drink fountain. All self serve. Employees were very friendly and accommodating to requests. Ambiance - the place was bigger on the inside than i thought. There were plenty of booths for dining. I would guess that maybe around 50 people could eat in there. Restaurant was well designed and clean. Saw the employees cleaning the tables regularly while i was there.

Poor service and even worse food quality. Everything was cold by the time it was delivered, bland…read moreflavor, and toppings were sparse.

Counter and kitchen where you order

Breadsticks, sausage pizza, taco pizza, cheese dipping sauce

See all

Inside of dining room

Danny's Pizza & Sports Bar

3.7(37 reviews)

24.9 mi

Fun place! Enjoy watching college football ND games there with great pizza!! Cold beer!!!read more

This place is terrible. pizza place with no working pizza oven . Placed 3 different orders of food…read morewaitresses came back we are out of this as well . Only thing available was the special which was not pizza . Italian sub , Philly sub must of been the only meat they had left in the freezer . Then waitress came back after we ordered more drinks said I need your dirty glasses we are out of clean ones . Comments made while ladies went to the restroom about go on in she didn't lock the door . What the hell they were 10 year old little girls in the bathroom. PUKE !!!!!!!

Danny's Pizza

See all

Chicago style pizza

Bourbon Street Pizza - Nappanee

4.0(31 reviews)

8.4 mi

Very solid pizza. They will do large deliveries, pretty consistent with not messing up orders. I…read morewish their cinnamon sticks were better, and their pizza isn't top-notch. Their breadsticks and cookies are very good though. They have a wide variety of pizza types and options to add any toppings you want and are quick with their deliveries. Eating at the restaurant is nice, too. They have free refills on their drinks, a TV which usually has sports on, and serve you at your table. If you're in Nappanee, this is the pizza place to go to.

Ordered to go. I was actually surprised in a good way with the pizzas we ordered. The hand tossed…read morecrust is the way to go. Quality sauce and plenty of toppings. Friend my staff on pick up.

Wings

See all

Bremen Vfw Post 8972

4.9(8 reviews)

1.2 mi

Ambience - It's a VFW hall. It has a bar and plenty of seating with a 1970's vibe as that was…read moreprobably the last time it was remodeled. Not a dig, but don't expect RUE152! Service is what it is. When they're busy, table service is reliant on VOLUNTEERS. They get tips, that's it. In this time good help is hard to find and volunteers must be incredibly hard to get. Give them a break and be patient. They're doing the best that they can. Once you order your food, it does show up quickly. Food is always hot, very tasty, generous portions and it's a bargain by todays standards. Since we discovered this place we have had several very good meals there, breakfast, lunch and dinner. We LOVE this place and hopefully we'll see you there for a beer and a burger...or maybe the fish fry?

Amazing food and great atmosphere! You don't have to be a member. Follow them on Facebook for daily…read morespecials.

See all

Gotta be a member

Barnstormers Pizza & More

4.6(54 reviews)

43.9 mi

ALL OF IT! The "Control Tower" had all the best ingredients, the staff and Don, the owner, very…read morefriendly, their restaurant is clean as a whistle. If you like aircraft and flying, you'll appreciate the surroundings. Just you try - to sneak out without a cheer and a thank you from the crew.... BETTER PIZZA THAN SILVER BEACH!

Overall a cute little spot! Would give it a 3.5 overall but the service won us over for a 4…read more Decided to stop into this place on a Wednesday evening. As a note.. this place is primarily a carry out spot. Luckily for us the staff was friendly and let our family push together some tables. We got a lot of stuff. Pasta, gluten free pizza, fries, the turkey ribs, a salad. Overall everything was just okay. The winner for me was the gluten free crust, we really liked it. Where they could improve: the salad, all the dressings were canned/bottled none of them were house made, turkey ribs were weird and the chicken tenders were gross. With how competitive food is I'd suggest this place take it up a notch and they could have a really good place with how good their customer service is!

Hanger Queen

See all

Cropduster Taco Pizza, always amazing!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Linda C.

10 years ago

Small towns with non-franchise pizza survive and thrive because the community loves them and are loyal customers. I love how Bill S. said you have to know how the Peel works. He is very correct. I've been eating at the Wooden Peel at least monthly for almost 40 years. You must memorize their phone number: 574-546-3233. And you MUST order your pizzas by phone, well in advance. Not open Monday nights. Thursday night begins the weekend and this is often the busiest night. This is NOT a fast-food restaurant. When I was in high school, there was a phone booth at the end of the block. After ball games, we would stop at the phone booth, call in our pizza order, and then avoid having to order inside. It is good pizza but, if you don't order ahead, what pizza is ever worth a two-hour wait? Back to the lessons on how it works. Call in your pizza order. Sandwiches are usually done quickly, so you can order them at the counter. Appetizers are quick but expensive. Pizzas and sandwiches are fair priced, but ordering 2 or 3 appetizers will double your bill. You can also choose cans of soft drinks or fountain drinks. And you only get one refill on the fountain drink. My favorite thing at the Peel, without a doubt, is the Stromboli sandwich with a side of pepperoncinis. I like to bite off the tip of the pepperoncini and drizzle the juice on the sandwich. Served with chips, you wait until the sandwich is finished then use your chips to scoop up the falling meat. Yummy. The pizzas are served HOT so local tradition suggests using a fork to pull up a corner of the cheese on a single slice, and let it cool that way. The cheese will go back into place after you let the heat escape. The thin crust is exceptional, although my husband (who grew up outside of Bremen) is not a fan. He does like the sandwiches. Finally, if you really want to make friends with the staff, then I suggest saying to them, "I know you're in a hurry but please be nice to me or I will tell Kathy." lol. (Kathy is the owner and will probably be the one taking your order.) Again, I don't think they're intentionally rude, they are just busy. That is all. read more

Sandy M.

13 years ago

Wooden Peel pizza is indeed the best there is! It's not true they don't accept credit cards, because they do!! There is a funny sign in there that says they "only take credit if you are at least 80 years ago and have parental consent"... or something to that effect. The service may be slower, but it's because every pizza is made fresh at the time it is ordered. Many, many people are happy to wait 2 hours for their pizza, as am I, especially on weekends! For something sassy, try the buffalo! It's the best!!! Sandwiches are great. read more

Russ R.

14 years ago

The stars say it all!!! Some will say it's the crust, some will say it's the sauce. I say it's everything! Maybe it's the water in Bremen? I don't know. But from my very first trip down from South Bend I haven't had pizza from anywhere else and don't care too. No matter how far you have to drive, it's definitely worth the trip! Oh yes, one other very important fact; It's a family owned business with some great people who just know how to treat their customers and make pizza too!!! I can't wait to get back down to Bremen!!! read more

Lisa F.

12 years ago

Small town pizzeria that serves a pizza like no other. Those of us raised here love the pizza and make it a regular weekly staple. My son who is in the army requests this pizza as his first meal when he is home. Occasionally there has been very lengthy waiting but that is a testament to the pizza that we all know and love. read more

Me C.

11 months ago

Best Stromboli sandwich I ever had in my life!!!!! Been away from the area for 14 years. Just moved back and I'm craving one!!!!!

Jeff M.

9 years ago

Awesome food and service wish it was opened 6 out of the 7 days but I understand needing days off! Highly recommended

Andrea S.

14 years ago

Slow service but usually worth the wait.

Wooden Peel - pizza - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Things to Do near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Coffee near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Restaurants near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Desserts near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Burgers near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Thrift Stores near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Breakfast near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Dinner near Wooden Peel

BEST of Bremen, Indiana Shopping near Wooden Peel

Best of Bremen

Things to do in Bremen

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Wooden Peel also viewed

Halls Kitchen

4.1

(9 reviews)

Food is consistently good, although some sandwiches could use a little more meat. Service is always…read morespeedy and pleasant. Ambiance at the Elkhart location is very nice. Rarely busy for eat in, but clean and spacious.

My wife and I are big fans of Halls Kitchen's pizza. Today, I decided to try their Turkey Club…read moresandwich. Their app showed the sandwich with stripes of bacon and tomato slices. It looked very appetizing. Unfortunately, when I opened the box, the sandwich looked nothing like the picture. The bacon was in bits that looked more like diced ham than bacon. The tomatoes were also diced instead of the full slices shown. Overall, both the taste and presentation was about average. As I was eating, I kept thinking the sandwich reminded me of what I would pick up at a gas station. The service was fast but a number of tables were dirty and no one came out to clean them while I was dining. Unfortunately. This visit was nothing special and what I received did not match what was advertised.

Massimo's Pizzeria

3.1

(38 reviews)

The Alfredo was fresh and ready and also for warning it is VERY HOT and the was delicious the…read morepepperoni pizza was one of the best pizza I had ever had I will be a returning customer

Pizza was terrible crust was like not prep correctly it tasted terrible and we got breadsticks and…read morethey didn't taste same as crust on pizza so I'm sure I should of just took it back but I won't comeback for that garbage

Marco's Pizza

3.2

(31 reviews)

Always have very friendly service here. They are usually busy when I go (Friday/weekend), but the…read morewait is never long. I've tried a few different pizzas, and they've all been good. The cheesy bread is my favorite.

Worker made me walk out in the cold on Super Bowl Sunday to make me prove to him I had a pizza bag,…read morewas just there an hour before, didn't ask to see bag. Clearly just being rude. Since you think making me cold when I got a back injury and I'm just trying to feed my family wouldn't come back to bite you. Butter people live bitter lives.

Pizza Bills

3.8

(19 reviews)

Service is always good!! Pizza was absolutely delicious! Lots of toppings and plenty of cheese!!…read morePizza Bills never disappoints!!

The food has been consistent since the 90s, which isn't a bad thing at all! Sadly since Covid the…read moredining room has stayed closed. Honestly I'd probably give them 5 starts if they'd just open that back up.

Venturi

4.5

(370 reviews)

Great food and service! Charming restaurant! I enjoyed a classic margharita pizza. It was…read morefantastic!

Made a point of ending my seven hour drive from Pittsburgh here at Venturi for their wonderful…read moreMargherita DOC. This pizza still bests the best of New Haven's aPizza offerings. This is a destination restaurant for anyone who seeks the best pizza.

Bourbon Street Pizza

3.5

(2 reviews)

I've had their pizza twice so far and absolutely love it. It's some of the best in the area. I…read moregave it 4 stars because the sauce that goes with their cheese bread instead the greatest. It's ok marinara but it's nothing to brag about. Their pizza is delicious! I've tried both their supreme and chicken bbq and loved them!

This place has amazing pizza and breadsticks. I have never eaten inside, we always order delivery…read moreor carry out. The only downside to this place is that their delivery service seems quite inadequate. I have had numerous deliveries take over an hour. Sometimes they have to turn away my business because of no available delivery. Overall the food is what matters and it is really good and fresh tasting.

Bourbon Street Pizza

4.3

(15 reviews)

Have you ever walked into a restaurant and immediately felt that comfortable feeling of being at…read morehome? The feeling of knowing that if you threw a dart at the menu anything you hit would be really, really good? That's the feeling I had when I walked into Bourbon Street Pizza. The high ceilings give the restaurant a really open yet cozy feel. The layout of the restaurant really flows. It's nicely appointed with CMA and other local history. There are no secrets at this place either folks. There are no walls or curtains to hide what's really going on in the kitchen. Everything is prepared right in full view. Oh...and the food....one word! GREAT! Really good food, prepared fast and served up at a really competitive price. And it's fast. You won't have to wait long for your pizza or pasta. Of course there are other choices for pizza. But, if you give Bourbon Street a try there may only be one choice. Give them a try.

I want to thank the team at Bourbon Street Pizza for helping me deliver a special Friday treat for…read moremy student and her dormmates at Culver Girls Academy! Ordering in advance was SUPER easy, prices were reasonable, the pizza was delivered right on time, and the students loved it!! You made it SO easy for me to do something special for my student and her friends from hundreds of miles away!

MJ's Pizza

4.5

(2 reviews)

MJ's pizza is now Urban Pizza. Great pizza and an excellent value. Our veggie pizza was packed…read morewith fresh veggies!

Talk about thick crust! Their bbq chicken pizza was amazing. We also ordered wings which were…read moregreat, we love that they're right by the baseball fields so we can enjoy them after a long day of sports. Wish there was somewhere to eat there inside but i understand a lot of restaurants don't do that since 2020. They're definitely worth a try!

Macri's Italian Kitchen

3.6

(102 reviews)