Large place, lots of seating. Menu is large. I am always hesitant eating at small town places…read morewondering what's fresh. I have to say the quality of this food is really really good! I had the buffalo chicken wrap and it was large and perfectly cooked! Baked potato soup was great. Side salad was just ok. Iceberg lettuce (yuck) tomatoes and cucumbers. Just bagged lettuce nothing to write home about. My dad had the boom boom shrimp and loved it! Not little shrimp but big meaty shrimp!! My mom had a pattty melt and loved it too! Hope everyone takes advantage of this gem!

We love their food. The only complaint I have is you can't order for breakfast just one egg. I am…read morenot a big eater. I was told they don't Sell just one egg. I want 1 egg, toast side of bacon. So then I have to order 2 eggs. Then I get my meal and there are 3 eggs. Then I over heard one of the staff say they might have to raise prices due to cost of eggs. Well I got 3 eggs and could only eat 1. how wasteful that is? maybe if they would let you order what you want they wouldn't have to raise prices.

Took our son-in-law to experience Rentown. He raved about his corn beef hash and bread pudding! I…read morehad my usual fried mush, so tasty. Services good as usual. We waited about 15 minutes to be seated on a Friday.

Crowded and slow to get to table however good was good once it arrived! I did not favor the…read morebiscuits because it was like squares of cake! No sourdough bread just wheat white! It was breakfast time Place had nice gifts to sell Average rating

Great experience! Need a place for dinner for 75 hungry campers! This is the place. Everything…read morewas delicious from the homemade bread to the pies and OH that strawberry dessert! Great hosts, friendly servers, relaxing atmosphere, and great food! Highly recommend no matter your group size.

Dining at Yoder's Homestyle Cooking was the most amazing memorable experience I have ever had. The…read morefood was delicious especially the poppyseed chicken. The service was spot on and the ambiance was exactly what you expect at an Amish Home. I can't wait to visit again.

I recently visited One Eyed Jacks, and I couldn't have been more impressed. The food was absolutely…read moreamazing--everything was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. You can really tell they take pride in what they serve. The service was just as outstanding. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was right without being overbearing. It created a really welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere. Overall, this was a great experience from start to finish. If you're in Winamac and looking for a place with excellent food and top-notch service, I highly recommend giving One Eyed Jacks a try.

I would normally get the tenderloin bites. I wasn't very hungry so I got a cup of delicious tomato…read moresoup and the smash burger which is smaller version of their regular burger. It was really good. My husband got the potato soup and chili. Unfortunately he could still taste the flour and the potatoes were undercooked. He didn't care for the chili. We've been here before so I'll give them another try.

Service: very friendly servers, they get the food out quick, never had a mistake with food, quick…read moreto refill drinks, I always tip 20+% Food: especially for the price, amazing food. They have a very cheap steak that tastes good! Not THE best steak I've had, but for the price it's amazing. I've heard that their pizza is solid as well, but I think their sandwiches are their most popular. Ambiance: They have several TVs with sports games on constantly, really cool design on the outdoor seating and it feels like you're eating at a hunters hideaway. They have a bar section as well, but I've never eaten there. I have walked through and it's looked very nice.

We were driving from IL to IN to see family and decided to stop for lunch. We sat in the bar area…read moreat a high top. Our waitress took our drink order and checked on us a few times before we decided to order. Two of us wanted the breaded tenderloin sandwich. Which the waitress informed us the didn't have any. Why couldn't she mention that 1/2 hour ago. I ended up ordering the grilled chicken breast sandwich. I was disappointed with the chicken breast, it was very thin. It tasted ok, but would have been nice to have more meat. We did enjoy the beef poutine. I would recommend this restaurant. It was clean and big enough for larger parties. They have the bar area, the dinner room and also a inclosed patio in the back.

Short wait on a Thursday evening. Our server was kind and very busy doing her best to give great…read moreservice. The food was large portion and amazing. The chicken burrito was stuffed and so large I took one half home. The pot roast sandwich was by far the tenderest meat and oozed with cheese. Steak taco came in a set of 2 with rice. The inside was clean and tidy.

We came here for dinner over the 4th of July weekend and were surprised that there wasn't a wait!…read moreThe interior is decorated with taxidermy animals. Our kid got a kick out of it. We ordered the whitefish, which was really good, very buttery and generous portion size. The ribs were fairly tender but salty. The coleslaw was nice and I liked the potato salad the best (compared to the fries or red potato side options). My husband and was very interested in the walleye, but we wanted to mix it up. It was nice to share a little meat and fish. Our toddler ate up all the kids mac and cheese. And the blueberry fruit pie with ice cream was a fun way to end the meal - not too sweet. Service was friendly and attentive and the food came out quickly. Definitely a solid place.

This place is amazing! it feels like I'm right at home. the servers are so friendly, the food is…read moreamazing, the building is beautiful and the peanut butter is awesome! every server left me with a smile. I couldn't stop eating the food, and now I feel very full, but it was so worth it. thank you all!

This was the best dinner I have ever had. The peanut butter and jelly they served was to die for…read more the chicken and steak were so good, and the mashed potatoes were nothing short of perfection. I recommend to anyone that wants to have a cozy dinner that is perfect. The service was the best service I ever had considering, extremely friendly and kind.

Another visit to Castaways!…read more 9.9 out of 10 Very clean and welcoming restaurant, great customer service, amazing menu choices, food delivered quickly, very generous portions, very good tasting food and super reasonable prices. I highly recommend! Chief

We were driving from Indiana to Illinois and was looking for a place for lunch. We were looking…read moreforward to this restaurant because of the great reviews on here and the euro restaurant that we wanted to go to was only drive-through. The prices are great and the servers are top-notch and super friendly but the food and cleanliness was below my expectation. My son's soup came with a spoon that had food still stuck to it. They were happy to get us another clean spoon. When I was eating my burger, I felt something very hard inside and found some piece of maybe a tip of a vegetable or something else that had must've fallen into the patty mix. Overall, the burger looked and smelled good, but really didn't have a lot of flavoring. This again is my experience others may have a different experience.

Really cool little bar/music venue. Got to catch Mick Kolassa playing the blues here…read more Nice tile floors and ambience. The specialty pizzas were really surprisingly good. Never thought of Brussels sprouts on a pizza, but they got it to work! Loved it! The only thing - grab a wooden chair if you're a size 14 or over - those metal ones just do not fit our behinds. Great place - I'll come back for sure!

Super cool place we stopped at on the way through. Limited rally good menu, a couple sandwiches,…read moregood pizza, nice specials. I'll take a short, fresh menu over lots of lousy food any day! Friendly staff showed us the theater while we were here.

Food is good and reasonably priced with very good waitresses! Even though it's a bar , you can…read morestill sit on the restaurant side where the whole family can eat away from the bar area

They have the BEST Tenderloin Sandwich by far. The staff and customers will welcome you like you…read moreare family. Definitely a must.