This place is highly themed with fun-witch decor. It's cheerful, darkly colorful, and magical. There are plenty of ice cream flavors, and an incredibly friendly staff who will answer all your questions and do their best to make sure you have ice cream you'll love! There's a small bench inside, as well as a table with umbrella just outside the front door. It's located along a street packed with things to do and see, too. I'm definitely glad we found this place read more

See all

Witch Flavor is an adorably themed ice cream parlor in the main commercial district of Beaver. The witch decore is sooo much fun with black hats, cauldrons and a witch that flew into the pole outside. The business is open all year round and even sells soup in the colder months. I stopped in on a weekday in October for an afternoon treat and picked out a double scoop of Pumpkin Pie and Raspberry Cheesecake. Both ice creams were beautifully decadent and wonderfully sweet. read more

This place is great. My wife and I stopped in on a super hot Saturday afternoon, and we were not disappointed. They serve real hard-pack ice cream in tons of interesting flavors and options (multiple cones, bowls, etc.). It's super cute inside and we love the theme. It was clean, and the lady who waited on us was a sweetheart. A solid 5! read more

You can't visit Beaver without going to Witch Flavor! They have unique flavors that are sure to satisfy everyone! I got the Bee Sting, vanilla with hot honey. I couldn't get enough and wished I had gotten more scoops! The service was excellent and they were so patient waiting for me to find the perfect flavor. Very much the small town feel as patrons would come in knowing one another. I cannot wait to go back! The perfect treat! read more

Witch Flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Cute little place, lots of different flavors. I would stop.in again. Good portions also.

Best stop of the day! Cute little shop in downtown Beaver. Friendly staff who got us thru the process of ordering seamlessly. I got the toasted coconut and pecan... wow creamy goodness. I'd come here every day.... My love handles are safe from expansion tho. Family loved all their selections as well. The yellow brick dough looked absolutely amazing.... A definite must return read more

Witch Flavor - Yellow brick dough cone. Toasted coconut and butter pecan cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Many choices of hand-dipped hard ice cream here! I ate two scoops--one toasted coconut & one witches brew, which is a fudge delicious coffee ice cream. The staff was amazing, very knowledgeable of ice cream flavors, and took good care of us. I could tell customer service was a priority here. The ice cream was fresh and tasted great. Unique flavors. The decor was fun! There are also tables and chairs available outside. read more

Witch Flavor - Ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Best Ice cream shop in Beaver County! The staff is so nice and welcoming. They were also super nice to my pup and made her a pup cup. We always have a great experience here. We bring our family here every time they visit! read more

Witch Flavor - the front of the store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent hard scoop Hershey's ice cream! Multiple flavors and the nicest staff you will find perfectly in Beaver!

I've been trying to come here for almost a year now and it did not disappoint! The one and only thing most people know about me is I love all things spooky. My favorite holiday is Halloween and I even wore my Spooky dress to fit the theme. We traveled 2 hours on a Wednesday afternoon and I was surprised by the constant flow of people. We were there for roughly an hour sitting at the tables. We had a party of 6 and the employees were super nice and patient with our young kids. We all got ice cream, some in cups and others in cones. The two youngest kids got cotton candy and my niece picked cookies & crème and I think chocolate. My mom and I both got banana cream pie and peach. I don't typically order fruity ice cream, but it was so refreshing on a hot day. I wanted to take a pint home for Andrew since he had to work, but I forgot to bring a cooler of some sort! I was beyond disappointed, especially after tasting it. I also tried the Follow the Yellow Brick Dough and Honey Roasted Peanut Butter. I absolutely loved that they offer lactaid at the counter for those of us who don't let our intolerances stop us from having fun. I laughed a little too hard. I feel this should go without saying, but I adored all of the decor. The whole aesthetic is to die for and I wish I lived closer. Andrew said we will be back asap because he wants to try the Honey Roasted Peanut Butter. I must admit, it was borderline heavenly. I think he will love the Witches Brew as well since he is an avid coffee fanatic. We will be coming home with pints this time. read more

See all

The service was fine. The flavor I had was very unique: Bee sting, vanilla pudding ice cream with ribbons of hot honey, very interesting. It was good, but different. read more

The staff were twins. Friendly young men. Delicious ice cream and such an adorable store. I wish I could show you a pick of my ice cream but I ate it. read more

Witch Flavor - the front of a restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

If you find yourself in Beaver stop at Witch flavor. You can sit outside and enjoy a little ice cream. My daughter recommends the chocolate but my son downed the mint chocolate chip Fun town and great ice cream read more

This place has amazing ice cream and shakes! Beaver is a small town with few options but what they have is really good. read more

See all

This is a wonderful ice cream shop with a great variety of flavors unfortunately situated in the middle of beaver. It's often easy to forget to go there on the way to someplace else. read more

We love this little ice cream shop. The flavors are fantastic, the theming is magical and they even sell Lact-Aid pills for the dairy intolerant people like myself! Absolutely wonderful place to get some ice cream at! read more

A little place a couple doors down from Starbucks in town that serves some really good ice cream in different types of cones or in a dish to satisfy the tastebuds! read more

Not a huge selection of flavors but the choices are unique and delicious. Staff was very knowledgeable and happy to recommend some cool ice cream combinations. Highly recommend the Lemon Chillo! They're also open year-round with homemade soups in the cooler months. We'll be back soon. read more

Witch Flavor - Lemon chillo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

My Daughter JAIMIE loves!! This place !! Owners are great!! Love the town of Beaver. Great place. Warm feeling. read more

Witch Flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Holy Cannoli! The ice cream here is delicious. Perfect consistency, not too dense that eating it feels like a chore. Portion size is generous, considering the price. Cute little shop, and service is friendly. Will return for sure! read more

We found this little gem while coming out of one of our favorite restaurants. Let me just say if you havent been here you need to go. I'm not going to go into a long tirade of what we had and all that jazz, but the two things that came across that made me love this place besides the decor and quaintness, was the love you feel from the owner for what they do and the quality of the product they sell. This is some of the most delicious stuff you'll ever get anywhere. I felt valued, the icecream was on point and good luck trying to decide "witch flavor" to get! Awesome place! read more

Its an adorable quirky ice cream shop. We loved the aesthetic. It reminded me of Salem, MA. The ice cream was great. I will always stop here when traveling through the area. read more

ayden and boden, the twins, are great! amazing job at working together. they make that ice cream with a smile on their face and love in their heart! my dog LOVED her pup cup and my ice cream was great as well! will be returning! read more

Witch Flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Witch Flavor? is hands down the best ice cream shop around. It is owned by a fabulous, kind, sweet, genuine, bubbly, exceptionally fantastic woman. I guarantee the quality of your service will be a 5 out of 5. They offer a one of a kind atmosphere , with kid friendly music, pictures of customers , and 16 delicious flavors to browse over. The also offer weekly soups in the fall & winter months, custom made cakes and cookies / ice cream cookie sandwitches ! read more

Witch Flavor - Amazing Service. Comfortable & loving atmosphere ... And most important delicious ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Beaver, Pennsylvania

Note: As of this review, they only have a Facebook page... https://www.facebook.com/WitchFlavor Witch Flavor (love that name), has a system You walk up to the register, choose your flavor of ice cream, your receptacle (cones or dishes), pay, and your dilemma begins. You see, Witch Flavor uses Penn State Creamery ice cream, the most supernatural ice cream known to modern man. According to the owner of the parlor (and this was new info to us), the Creamery forbids the mixing of flavors, which is why you only get one flavor to a cone or dish (a dish gets you 4 scoops). However...you can get one sample of each of the Sweet 16 flavors... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihwxC58JdIc The standard vanilla was amazing enough to succumb to, but then there was the Pecan Praline... "Only the old folks order that for some reason," the owner told me. The pecans were large jewels studding an ivory landscape. I almost stopped at the Raspberry Sherbet, the owner insisting I try it before going any further. Arrestingly fruity and silken, I came to the realization that sherbet may have reached its zenith. Yet, I pressed on, trying another 6 or so flavors until deciding on a mystery flavor, a Witch Flavor. And bewitchingly chocolately it was, coming off as a Heavenly Hash having fallen willingly and hedonistically to Hell, exquisitely adulterated by fudge-coated almond clusters. I'm glad we asked the guy with the rock 'n roll hair at Philly Originals if there was an ice cream place to be found in the neighborhood. May Witch Flavor crush the nearby DQ with its Nittany-borne temptations. read more

After dinner in Beaver, my wife and I were enjoying a walk down the strip. We can never say no to ice cream, so when we saw "Witch Flavor?" it was a no brainer to walk in. The interior is colorful and we were greeted by a wonderful lady named Lisa! Lisa is one heck of a sales woman and made the whole experience wonderful. We sampled tons of flavors and even broke our "sharing rule" because it was all so good and Lisa convinced us to do it... or at least that's the story I'm sticking with. The ice cream was surprisingly delicious and might be right there with Brusters. I got an Oreo Mint and my wife a Coconut Chocolate. After reading the other reviews, it was a bit pricey, but Lisa made the experience so great - I might have even paid more that my $7 for two cones! read more

Witch Flavor was such a treat! It's a small place, but definitely worth a visit if you're in the area. The staff was really friendly and made great recommendations. I tried two flavors, salty caramel and cannoli. Both were delicious, but the cannoli ice cream was my favorite! It was smooth, creamy, and had a really delicate marscapone flavor with big chunks of crunch cannoli shell and chocolate. Did I mention the portion sizes are humongous? I will definitely be back! read more

The only reason that I am giving this place 4 as opposed to 5 stars is for the pricing. When you compare them to the other ice cream locations in the area they are much more expensive. This place rocks though, the Penn State Creamery ice is wonderful... my faviorte being the coffee flavor. The staffing here is really nice, and they even had the kids from the local elementry school come for a field trip. And they only charged them a dollar. This is another local place along Beaver County that everyone needs to continue to support even in the winter.... oh and in the winter they have homemade soups. read more

Like many of you, I love ice cream! That being said, Witch Flavor is one of my most favorite places to get ice cream. With a great location in downtown Beaver and access to outside seating, you'll surely love this place as well. They offer Penn State Creamery ice cream as well as their own other flavors. Bring cash and credit/debit cards. They don't accept credit cards for transactions under $10.00. However, it doesn't take long to get up to $10. This is why I rated Witch Flavor 4 star instead of 5 star because of the more expensive prices compared to competitors in the area. But, I do believe you are getting a better quality ice cream. read more

This is a super nice place! The staff is super friendly, social and efficient. The place is super clean and is always decorated for Halloween, which I think it's super neat. The ice cream was thick, flavorful and very tasty. It was also pretty cheap to. Overall, I'd recommend checking this place out! read more

I have had ice milk there twice both times it tasted like the freezer. Sorry I will not try the ice milk there a third time. I truly did not like the ice milk at all. Three adults and one child got cones the only one who thought the cone was ok was the child. Everyone else threw theirs away. And we typically love ice cream. However this tasted like ice milk. Blah read more

Great ice cream and friendly service. The pretzel cones are soooo good! It's in a great setting to walk around and eat your dessert after dinner. read more

This must be some sort of Witchcraft. Before visiting Witch Flavor, I thought I had eaten good ice cream, and I was wrong. Compared to the other folks who try to compete, there is no competition. Witch Flavor's ice cream is rich and dense. The kind that bends the spoon, with so much of the good stuff mixed in, you would think there must be some mistake. Witch Flavor should I start with? The Witch's cat's meow lies with their Witches Brew that makes for the perfect pick me up. And the Honey Roasted Peanut Butter is so scrumptious, it literally has to be the bees knees. With over a dozen different concotions to choose from, there is something for everyone and if you can't seem to find something on their menu that fits your bill, then go get yourself a Frosty. Witch Flavor is where you go to get real, awesome, sinfully tasty, ice cream. read more

Excellent customer service, delightful and delicious flavors, generous portions of ice cream servings (more like plentiful), as well they have the neatest decorative candies they add on which makes my scoop of ice cream that much more enjoyable. read more

This ice cream is delicious! I know other reviewers complain about pricing, but the quality is second-to-none. You can't mix flavors and they don't have sprinkles...this isn't that type of place! It's simple, delicious ice cream! It doesn't need more stuff on it. If you want to jazz it up, you can get a pretzel cone. :) read more

After doing some major pre-Christmas shopping down the street in Beaver, we walked back to our car which was parked right outside of Witch Flavor. I commented that it looked cute when we first pulled up, so when we put our bags in the car and it was still 'witching hour', we decided to stop in. The sign on the window says they serve Penn State Creamery ice cream.The witch theme is predominate, but there is an underlying Penn State theme. You first choose your cone, then you pay, then you can proceed to where the ice cream flavors. They have cake, sugar, waffle, bedazzled, and pretzel cones. Once you pay, you can move along to the flavors and sample any you would like. You can sample them all if you want! The girls behind the counter were super bubbly and helpful. I got Monster Mash in a pretzel cone. It's like a cookies and cream ice cream with caramel swirls. It was amazing with the salty pretzel cone. My mom got the pumpkin pie also in a pretzel cone, and she said it was great too. It does come at a price, but it's a treat we don't have all the time. It was also 1000x better than any corporate ice cream I've had. We left with two huge cones that were filled with oh-so-good ice cream, vowing to come back the next time we're in town. read more

Nice place with friendly staff. The ice cream is good but giving a choice of only about ten flavors. There are three down sides: one is that they wont let you mix flavors, second they don't offer any toppings, third its a bit tooo pricey for the amount you get. Sorry but you get twice the amount at Bruster's, Handell's and DQ with any topping you want. Keeping the aforementioned three downsides in mind, Witch Flavor will not be my first or second choice to visit when my family an I are craving for ice cream. read more

I had family in from out-of-state for the Labor Day weekend. After cheese steaks at Philly Originals We decided to grab some ice cream for dessert at Witch Flavor. My family and I had such a wonderful and fun experience here! The staff was friendly and generous with the ice cream samples. The shop has a fun and playful decor. The Penn State Creamery ice cream is by far the best we all have ever had! Not only did we enjoy our ice cream at the shop, we bought three quarts to take home! If you are ever in Beaver, PA, Witch Flavor should be on your "To-do list"! read more

Witch Flavor is a gem in downtown Beaver.......as others have said, it's more pricey than the other "chain" ice cream joints, but I'm willing to pay a bit more for the down home experience and flavor. I highly suggest the pretzel cone with one of the varieties of chocolate ice cream. BRAVO!!!! read more

Delicious ice cream! Love that I can get Penn State Creamery ice cream here in Beaver!