Sewickley Confectionary sells treats such as ice creams, gelatos, sundaes, milkshakes, and slush puppies. They even sell Leona's lactose-free products. During my visit, the display cases contained ice cream flavors such as black raspberry, peanut butter, coconut, strawberry cheesecake, chocolate chip, coffee, mint chip, cookie dough, butter pecan, banana cream pie, moose tracks, etcetera. The employee promptly and politely scooped ice cream for my husband and me, and she accurately charged us. I had ordered a cup of caramel praline turtle ice cream, and my husband had ordered a hot fudge sundae. We rate these treats as 4 stars each. The servings were a good size, and we enjoyed the flavors. A small seating area was available with a table and chairs. This furniture was clean, and we appreciated the space to eat our treats inside the business. read more

See all

Best Ice cream and service around! Came here for a last minute hot five sundae, and honestly this was the best sundae I've ever had! I don't know what type of ice cream this is but it's amazing and fresh! A huge variety of flavors, I got a scoop of Cookie Monster drenched in decadent hot fudge! They also have gelato that looked amazing! On a side note, they have a freezer with beef and meats from a local farm, which is a huge plus if you want locally sourced proteins for dinner! I saw a couple of gluten free items from somewhere near by and also fresh English muffins that I would love to try. Stop down for some seriously good surprises ! read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

See all

I've never been to an ice cream place with different cone flavors before. Our group got M&M, chocolate chip, & pretzel. Delicious ice cream & great service. read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Entrance - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious ice cream, sherbet, gelato as well as farm fresh milk, butter, cheeses and other goodies. They offer local Delivery services as well. The ice cream parlor is a fun neighborhood shop with limited seating inside, more outside. Local teens behind the counter are always friendly and helpful. read more

Stopped in for a cool treat on a hot summer day. I ended up getting lemon sorbet which reminds me of frozen lemon. Lots of seating outside and numerous unique fun flavors loved my staff and customers alike. read more

See all

The cinnamon roll gelato is literally **the. best. thing. I. ever. ate.** I eat a low carb diet, and when I break it I seldom feel that it was worth it. But if I gain 5 lbs from this little cup of ambrosia, IDGAF! read more

Sewickley Confectionery - I ate it too fast to get a good pic - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

Wow, what a great ice cream shop! I tried several flavors, and they were equally as delicious. We ended up mixing two flavors, because we just couldn't decide on one! I love that they have Leona's ice cream sandwiches here, oh and even local milk cheese and eggs. I just had to get the eggs, and I'm sure you would have too! (How adorable is that) I would have loved to have seen a dairy free option, other than sorbet. read more

See all

You can't go wrong with the Confectionery. They have Perry's ice cream (my personal favorite!), gelato and a variety of local treats (including Brunton's chocolate milk) available all the time. There is both inside and outside seating. Stop by next time you're in Sewickley and looking for a yummy treat. read more

See all

This ice cream shop is a step back in time. I never miss an opportunity to grab ice cream and this place did not disappoint. When you first walk in, you're greeted with a gum ball machine and acouple old school carnival games. Fun! There is a small seating area inside and outside that you can enjoy if the weather is nice. They have several creative and fun hand scooped ice cream options, along with a separate gelato case. I opted for a tornado, which is their equivalent to a blizzard. They don't offer as many mix-ins, but my cookie dough ice cream with butterfinger and peanut butter sauce did the trick. Everyone in our group was pleased with the selections. So you think this place only sells ice cream? WRONG! They got cheese, milks, lettuces, frozen meats. All of the things you've ever wanted at an ice cream store, but could never get. Stop by if you're in town!! read more

See all

I stopped over here after lunch since I wanted to try their ice cream. I spoke to a very nice man behind the counter named Chris. They use Perry's premium ice cream for their various flavors. In addition, they sell Leona's ice cream sandwiches from Wilkinsburg and Italian gelato. I was free to sample whatever I wanted. The gelatos are made by the same people who make the ones for Mercurio's in Shadyside. Gelatos are a little more expensive than the regular ice cream but well worth it. Being a fan of dark chocolate I ordered one scoop of death by chocolate gelato which had chocolate chips in it. Chris gave me a cup with ice so I could fill it with water from their fountain to drink. This gelato was so good it was literally to die for! I asked about dairy free options and he told me that today they only had one ice cream and one gelato that were considered as such. They have only one table for seating since most people probably purchase it to go. In addition to the usual ice cream fare there is a case that sells dairy and cheese products as well as Sam Pelligrino, brown eggs, and bottled water. Free WiFi is available. Passcode given upon request. Chris told me that the Amish butter rounds come from a store west of this area and the glass milk gallons are by Bruten dairy. I have seen this brand when I visit certain grocery stores. Having purchased it one time prior I must say it is very good. Sewickley confectionery sits back a little bit from Beaver Ave and is next to a gas station which is next to Orr's fine jewelry. Metered street parking is available throughout the business district and it is an easy walk if you park in or around Broad St. This is a great place if you want a cool treat now that the weather is getting warmer and you happen to be in the Sewickley neighborhood. read more

See all

I'm sorry but this is not what I expected a hot fudge sundae to be. I questioned it and was told that they were out of whipped cream. That's obviously not the only problem with this. read more

Sewickley Confectionery - A "hot fudge sundae" ‍ - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

This won't be drawn out and an in-depth review. This is also my 100th Yelp review and was waiting for something super special. Well Sewickley Confectionery did it for me. Hands down some of the best darn ice cream I have ever had. I had the scoped Peanut Butter Pecan. Was so creamy and flavorful. The staff was super friendly and appreciative. read more

We get the Gelato when I come here, they also have ice cream too. We usually wait in line and it's usually out the door. The place is small with tables inside and outside. One time there was only one person working, maybe someone called off you never know. They don't have a restroom here. It's street parking and there's a parking lot area across the street. If they had a window for gelato only and a separate line for ice cream that would be helpful! I would come back for Gelato though and I might try the ice cream sometime! read more

Cute little ice cream shop in Sewickley. Lots of flavors to choose from. They have limited seating and small space inside. We went in the evening so I did not notice outside seating. When we walked in there were a few others inside so it was kind of crowded. Cute decor and good ice cream though. read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Lots of spoon art decorations, neat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

Everyone loved this place but me so perhaps I picked the wrong choice, dark chocolate lightning or something like that. The color was so deep that I was expecting something more decadent. If my husband liked mint (which was the lightening) I probably would have given it to him. I am also from the land of Graeter's and Jeni's so perhaps my standards were too high. Everyone else would have given their choice 5 stars but since this is my review, I am sticking with 3 stars. Friendly service. read more

This place rocks!! They always keep the flavors new and fresh and the employees are always very kind and pleasant! They also carry Leona's ice cream sandwiches! read more

What's not to like! Fresh and pure ice creams, yogurt, fresh milk, eggs and other goodies. I walk down and get my favorite ice cream cone. Great staff, friendly and nice. Can't go wrong!! read more

Love this place!!!!!! Great ice cream. Friendly staff. Quick service. Love that you can sit outside and eat your ice cream. I also love that they are open year round. One of my favorite stops while walking in Sewickley. I have created a lot of good memories with family while having an ice cream cone. read more

Never have a bad experience here, delicious ice cream and great service. No matter what you end up ordering you are sure to be satisfied. The location is ideal and even when there is a line out the door you'll never have to wait a long time. I would recommend this place to anyone looking for desert in the area read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

They have hard ice cream, gelato and a slushee machine. They sell Leona's ice cream sandwiches, Brunton's chocolate milk and some other miscellaneous things like cheese. read more

Best ice cream I've had in a long time! We had an ice cream cart Sewickley Confectionery l at work and the two girls serving were so kind. I had a scoop of the mint chip and a scoop of chocolate. Both flavors were incredible! Can't wait to stop by the shop and try other flavors. read more

This is a classic Sewickley establishment. It doesn't get as much traffic as Sincerely Yogurt, but it probably should. They offer sizeable ice creams (I got a kids cone and it was more than enough) and also have gelato. It's a small place, but they have outdoor seating. It's a little further out on the main street of Sewickley, but it's worth the trek to get some good ice cream. read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Rainbow sherbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

Little disappointed as my youngest child has a nut allergy and asked about using separate scooper to avoid any cross contamination and they did not have this available I we left and went elsewhere read more

Very yummy ice cream in a very cute street of stores. Today is a bit cold ans snow is expected so its not very bust. I imagine that is not the case on a warm summers night. read more

Sewickley Confectionery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sewickley, Pennsylvania

We always go with the girls we love it very good ice cream, nice employees,clean place . The girl love to go there. Good prices.

Sewickley Confectionary offers ice cream, gelato, and local butter and milk. Their ice cream is consistently excellent and you rarely (if ever) find one that has that slightly "off" taste ice cream gets when it sits in the freezer too long. The owner obviously takes pride in his business and strives to provide a quality product. The interior is small and I wish they provided more outdoor seating, but most customers end up wandering through the village of Sewickley while they eat so it really isn't much of a problem. During the school year they sell small fountain drinks for only 25 cents, but the prices go up as soon as school lets out for the year. read more

Great ice cream and they always have a nice variety of flavors. It's a cute place and pretty much what you'd expect for a basic ice cream shop. read more

I recently stopped in at the Confectionery-- a last minute decision instead of the usual fro-yo "buffet" at the trendy spot across the street. As I entered, I was greeted by smiling faces and was made to feel right at home. There was a large selection of hard scooped ice cream, but my focus quickly changed when I spotted the case of gelato. They had about 15 or so homemade gelatos so choose from, which made picking one nearly impossible. The friendly gentleman behind the counter offered several suggestions, followed by samples, all of which were absolutely delicious! I chose a Samoa gelato, which tasted JUST like the Girl Scout cookie! I was very pleased with my experience there.. The service was great.. The ice cream was wonderful and the prices weren't outrageous considering it IS Sewickley. I can't wait to go back!! Forget that fro-yo spot across the street--I found a new favorite spot for a sweet treat! read more

This is a cute little icecream shop located in the heart of Sewickley. They have a wide variety of hard ice cream and gellatos. My daughter's staple is chocolate ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. This little shop also has dog ice cream. read more

Had great classic sundaes! Perfect for a nice little birthday treat for my boyfriend. :)

Great local ice cream parlor. Wide variety of flavors and some very fun / unique flavors. All ages can enjoy the offerings of this ice cream joint. A popular place in the summer after baseball games or football games in the fall. Walkable from all the popular spots in the village. read more

Great place! Friendly staff, good selection of flavors and inexpensive. It's a couple blocks from my house so I'll often stop in right as I start driving somewhere to grab a fountain drink, cause they're just 25 cents there! As a whole, awesome place. read more

Ecellent staff. Plenty of great flavors.... ice cream and gellato. Chris is the best.

I have gone to the confectionary many times before and usually had ok service. The owner is a great guy. My reason for the single star is that I recently went in with my boyfriend one evening, maybe 9pm on a Sunday. As we walked in the door one of the girls working the counter screamed out at me scaring me to death;it was to warn me that the floors were wet, which though I appreciated, a simple yellow warning sign would have sufficed. The worst part of any transaction is when you feel like your presence is an annoyance. Seeing as how all the gelato was removed from its display, the floors clean, and all the toppings were removed it seemed as though they were ready to close with an hour still to go. We went to order and it seemed like everything we asked for they were "out of", I would much rather some one tell me that they already put the cherries in a cooler, or that they cleaned out the toppings containers already that's why we don't have nuts (which I have to say these guys when they have them, have the best). So we couldn't order sundaes because there wasn't any hot fudge, nuts, or cherries which was the main reason we wanted ice cream so badly. This is more a review on the service we received than it is on the ice cream because it is normally very good. So we then decided to get milkshakes. We were then told we couldn't get larges because they were out of large cups. Once we got our small milkshakes they were lousy. It was almost all milk, no ice cream the cups were covered in a sticky mess from the mixer cup they dump the milkshakes from, which was everywhere, squeezing out the top which wouldn't seat right. As we waited the two girls were in such a hurry to get us out of there each time a customer would come in behind us they would look at each other and roll their eyes. Anyways I would like to say regardless of our experience you should still give them a try if you get a tall, middle-aged man who is the owner you will walk out of there very happy. If it's a couple of high school girls an hour before closing time you might not get so lucky. read more