My wife and I enjoy trying new pizza spots, so we decided to check out Wicked Peel in Riverton. Even though various tables were open, the hostess seated us right next to the swinging kitchen door and just a few steps from the bathroom - easily the least desirable table in the restaurant. We wouldn't have minded if the place were full, but it felt like an odd choice given the empty seating. When our pizza arrived, it was noticeably overcooked and burnt, and the flavors were average at best. For the price point, there are definitely better options in the valley. On the positive side, our server did notice the pizzas were burnt and sent us home with two replacement pizzas to make up for the issue, which we appreciated. Still, based on this experience, we're unlikely to return. read more

The pizza was delicious. The service was great and just a really beautiful view too from the dining area.

Wow! What had I been waiting for to try this pizza?! So much time wasted trying to find "that" pizza that brings you that eye closing pleasure I'd been trying so hard to find Amd it's literally right next door! Ugh. I ordered for a food delivery service so I this review is just about this delicious pizza. It arrived in a cardboard box with the Jack in the middle to keep the box off this treasure. I got my usual tester ingredients: red sauce, pepperoni, pineapple (do not judge me), jalapeños, GREEN OLIVES (rare find). I know I've said this multiple times before but THIS the BEST pizza I've had since moving to Utah 3 years ago. My pizza quest is over. This is the perfect thin crust with a boatload of ingredients. It is balanced with flavors, texture, ingredients and Mmmmappeal. I am in love. Thank you Wicked Peel! read more

See all

Pros: fresh made meatballs on the sub. Very cheesy. Good dressings. Cons: pizza was pretty bland, salad had all canned ingredients on top. Wouldn't come back, glad we tried. read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Meatball Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

See all

Pizza great, cheese sticks amazing, canzone yummy, and service was great! Lots of young people working that were very attentive and nice...kind of surprising. Would absolutely come back. read more

I love this place! It's still the best pizza I've had in Utah. The Betty is one of our favorites. The desert pizza is out of this world. They have some of my favorite beers on Tap. Locally owned business is a plus. read more

We came in on a Friday night and sat at the bar. Maline was the best bartender ever :)-attentive and full of great food and drink suggestions. Th my have a great selection of wine and beers on tap. The cheese triangles were magical. Come here if you're craving some good Italian food or pizza. Great times! UPDATE: I've noticed that all the one-star reviews in here are from the same person or same party. Apparently they had a Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Pizza Party. But, don't let their copy-and-paste reviews fool you. This place rocks. read more

See all

This was a great place to stop after a long drive. I picked up 2 gf pizzas and a full dinner salad after a long day on the road. It was busy on a Friday night but the service was excellent. Bummed I didn't get pics of the food, but we were so hungry the food was gone before I even thought of it! Great gf option for pizza in the area! I was a little daunted by the "I GLUTEN" sign in the window, but I get it. If I could I would too. I'm glad I ordered the salad too, the pizza was deliciously crisp and thin. We had a med gf pepperoni and a med gf salami mushroom olive. Great sauce, super nice service. The salad was good too, yummy pickled beets! read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Cool spinning oven!! - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

My husband and I have date night here once a week and the service is always impeccable. The food tastes delicious and the staff is quick to get our order out. We got the garlic Formaggi add chicken yesterday and it was delicious. They add the right amount of garlic for it to blend well and not over power the rest of the flavors. Id recommend trying their Mac and cheese bites too! read more

Actually super unhappy with the service, my kid went in for a dance with a group of people. The server was extremely rude to them (while I know they are teens and can be annoying) this was a special night for them as well. Anyhow my son accidentally knocked the pizza off the stand and the pizza fell to the floor. They only had 1 slice of it. (Accidents happen) The server scolded them as if they little kids. Telling them she would not replace the pizza because the restaurant should not pay for their accident. My son had to pay for a new pizza, how much would it actually have cost for them to say no problem we'll take care of you? When the server brought the new paid for pizza she was again super rude and condescending. I was actually mad they tipped this lady 18% after being treated so rudely and condescending. It was a special night for them and they felt like they did something wrong by hitting that stand with an elbow. I will be telling every single person I know to not support a company who treats their customers so poorly. Shame on that server!!! read more

We've been to Wicked Peel several times to sit and for take out. We've always had a good experience and the pizza is really good. We've tried a variety of kinds and the cheese bread is always good. Service has been good as well as the ambience. We'll be back again for sure! read more

Food was bland and seemed leftover. Service was terrible. No check-in during our meal, no refills offered. Saw our waitress when she took the order, served us and when she came back to drop the bill on the table. In spite of my plate being pushed away and barely touched she didn't check on me. She disregarded it when she dropped the bill as well. read more

I got the cheese sticks because of the glowing reviews on here and they really are amazing! I recommend eating them cheese side down so you get maximum flavor. Cheesy, garlicky goodness. My friend said she tasted olive oil too which she thought gave it even more good flavor. I also got a Hawaiian pizza which was pretty good. Nice crust texture. And our waiter was good too. My one complaint.... Please get rid of the fake windowsills in the booths! I hit my head pretty hard twice and my friend did too! Not cool to have something sticking out of the wall right where your head goes! read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

See all

We were really hungry for pizza and picked this place because it allowed dogs!! It did not disappoint!! Everything was delicious and our waitress was so sweet...sat outside with the dog and it was wonderful! Great place wish we had one at home!! read more

Updating my review to give props to Malene. Already loved this place but she was so helpful with dealing with a horrible DoorDash situation (opened up the box and saw a slice was missing). She let me know how to deal with doordash customer service but also made sure i let her know if they weren't helpful. She remade the entire order as pick up. Definitely love this place - the food is great but I appreciate customer service over that. Will continue to keep coming back. Thank you; malene! read more

Went with a good friend to lunch today. He's been raving about the quality of the food at Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen. We were the first customers through the door today. The atmosphere is casual; perhaps a few too many beer advertisements than I like, but it does highlight that they've got options, if you're into that sort of thing. Our hostess got to us quickly and seated us in a comfortable booth. A brief moment with the menu told me exactly what I wanted: The Smokey - a BBQ chicken pizza with a really fabulous, tangy BBQ sauce. First to arrive at our table were the cheesy breadsticks my friend ordered. They looked delicious and tasted even better. It's hard to pull off a good breadstick pizza without it either tasting like cardboard or dripping with grease. These breadsticks were superb! A flatbread-style appetizer, they were so good with or without the marinara dipping sauce. I ended up eating 8 pieces. When The Smokey pizza arrived, I knew I was in for a treat even before my first bite. After the first bite, I knew I'd found a new favorite BBQ pizza which, for me, is a go to at any specialty pizza place. Even when I was full, I enjoyed another piece. The tangy BBQ sauce was so good, and was meted out perfectly so as not to overwhelm the other flavors. We had an opportunity to chat with our hostess for a minute at the end of the meal. Like the rest of the restaurant world, they're short-staffed, but you wouldn't know it by the way she treated the guests. She was attentive to everyone, and everyone we saw was really pleased with their food. Her efforts are commendable and made the lunch really enjoyable. For a specialty pizza place, they've also got salads and pasta dishes if you're not feeling the pizza. Our hostess told us they spend an incredible amount of time each day prepping salads so you're always guaranteed something fresh and delicious. I should mention that for a specialty pizza place, the prices were completely reasonable. Officially, I've found my new favorite pizza place. Do yourself a favor: go enjoy yourself some Wicked Peel pizza (or salad or pasta, if that's more your speed). read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - The remainder of The Smokey and Cheesy Breadsticks. - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

From the road, I thought this was a tattoo parlor, based on the font of the sign. I had pulled in to the parking lot to turn around and head elsewhere and realized this was a restaurant. Yippee!! I found a spot and took my hungry family inside for dinner. We were immediately greeted and taken to a booth near the door. Our server was friendly and took our drink order quickly. I requested the wine flight and asked for his recommendation, which he said he'd get some input on from the back. After placing my food order, he went back to the manager and asked what wine would pair well. They brought me three different whites, which surprised me with pizza, but it worked! It was a fun way to try different wines. The food came out fairly quickly-just the right amount of time I'd expect to wait for made-from-scratch food. One bite of my pizza and I knew I was hooked. The flavors of the pepperoni, mushroom and ground sausage danced in my mouth-making each bite a pleasure! (I hate cheese, so ordered my 'za cheeseless, which is how I got it. I'm sure for more traditional pizza lovers, you'd prefer the cheese. But this was perfect for me!) My son ordered some wings, which he reported were very good. My wife stayed true to her diet and ordered a salad-and she loved it! She did mention that she'd likely try the raspberry or strawberry vinaigrette next time, rather than the plain one. I'm already craving it again-will be back very soon! read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Create your own pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

See all

The pizza is so good. I also love their house salad. I have tried their pasta as well. The wait staff is very attentive and friendly. I also like the seating, each booth is personal and you don't feel like you are listening to everyone else's conversations. read more

Mmm mmm mmm. Jerry's spot has been hit once again. This thin crust pizza was crispy, flavorful, and delicious. We got the old world pizza, the vodka one, buffalo chicken, and chicken Alfredo. The wings were also delicious. The owner was also quite the jokester. I think he came by every 3 minutes with a new joke. I'm not sure if he was googling them in the back room or if these were off the dome. Great food and atmosphere. Jerry approved for sure. Best, Jerry read more

We got two pizzas to go. The pizzas were soggy and floppy, which isn't good for Napoletana pizza. The description of the pizzas sounded promising, but the flavor on both was poor. They both were full of bland and unappetizingly soggy veggies and meats. I can't judge the ambiance or service because it was takeout. read more

We absolutely love this pizza! We live 2.5 hrs away and will always try and fit this in when we are traveling south. We've been to both locations and have to say the Riverton pizza and breadsticks are a bit better. Staff and customer service have always been great. read more

Omg this is the best pizza, sausage Alfredo, garlic bread/cheese sticks. If you get a chance come try it. Every time we come here, it never disappoints. read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - The Brooklyn Pizza and pepperoni, olives, and mushroom pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

NEVER GO HERE! We went to this place with my friends and the service was terrible, his name is Timothy! First of all he splash water to one of my friend and messed up all our orders. The manager came and was very rude and disrespectful. I have never seen so much disrespectful in my life especially in a restaurant. Timothy and Sebastian you guys needs to rethink your professions. You guys are not meant to be in a service industry. Have your parents teach you some manners!!! Oh by the way, you cannot just add your own gratuity when your service sucks! read more

The food here is absolutely delicious. The owners are super friendly. The menu is so diverse. It's rare I want to try multiple things on the menu but there's so many good options here. Outside or inside seating. read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Detroit style pizza. Pepperoni and artichoke. Pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

See all

I brought a whole swarm of ladies here for GNO and everyone was so accommodating! I know it can be tricky to manage a large group especially on a Friday night, but despite having to wait (as we expected), we all had a great time! The Buffalo pizza was fantastic! The cheese breadsticks were to die for!! I wish the wicked vodka would have had more flavor but it was still pretty good. Definitely check out Wicked Peel. read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

The pizza was great. Staff was attentive. Really enjoyed our evening there. It's a great place to go as a family.

Great food, it's always fresh and delicious! The service is fast and always so friendly! We love this place! They have great pizzas and pasta with fabulous drinks too! read more

first time at this restaurant and I was not impressed. we did not have good service or food. We got there at 5:30 didn't get our drinks until 6 and never received refills after asking multiple times. then we didn't get food until 7:30 the pizza was cold and soggy. We asked for the check right when we got our food and that took another 45 min. read more

Oh my goodness...honestly, the best pizza I have had in Utah! Cannot wait to go back! Staff friendly and fun! read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - The Smokey Pizza Medium - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

See all

Best margarita pizza "old world " in Utah ! The Detroit is also top tier pizza ! Bread sticks beyond delicious! Great atmosphere and fun place to eat read more

NEVER GO HERE! The staff is absolutely HORRIBLE! One of the bartenders is the owners daughter. One of our friends politely asked her to get some wine for them, she flew off the handle and told him to get the (f word) out of there. The owner then Proceeded to throw him out with him not doing anything else. They are expensive and the biggest jerks out there! STAY AWAY! read more

I might be hungry writing this review. But it was my first time to wicked peel. I ordered a triple meat (I forget the name) for takeout- 10 minutes not so bad but I'm half way home and take a peak- it's burnt. I saw it, they saw it, and I made the mistake of leaving a tip before I had "the full experience". The staff that I talked to were nice but for 18, 21 with tip- I shouldn't get a bunt pizza with staff hoping I wouldn't notice. Treat your takeout orders better guys- it was going to my family read more

The Old World is the best pizza I've had! We are regulars here! A little pricey but worth it.

Walked in at a NOT busy time, and were seen and then directly ignored while the guy counted out a TON of change (for what we do not know). No "hello", no "be with you in a moment", nothing. We were patient and waited for at least five minutes and eventually just left. Super unpleasant experience. It's too bad. We were hungry! read more

First timer and I won't be back. We ordered two pizzas. Both lacked flavor and toppings.

I had the "GF ten-inch" pizza at Wicked Peel and not only did it come burnt to a crisp, but they tried to tell me that's how GF crust comes! They were super RUDE and aggressive and wouldn't make it again or give me a discount or anything. NEVER going back there! read more

See all

This is a hidden gem in Riverton! It's a cozy spot with some of the best food we've ever had. It's so hard to find a restaurant we can all agree on, but WP is the one place we can all go and enjoy as a family. We've had the same server every time we go and our kids love Mike. He's attentive and makes sure we have what we need often. The pizza is outstanding - we've tried all the pies and our favorites are Quattro Formaggi and The Brooklyn. But we come for the cheese bread sticks and dipping sauce. You know the cheese they use is high quality because even the smell is almost satisfying enough. The food fairly priced for the quality - it's worth every penny! You won't regret whatever you order. read more

Wicked Peel Pizza Kitchen - The New Yorker - Pizza Near Me - Riverton, Utah

The food at wicked peel is amazing! From their pizzas to any of their appetizers! The service is always quick and everyone is super friendly! The bar in the back area adds to the vibe! Its super nice with a lot of options! read more

Holy Shite Balls! First time eating at this establishment and it did not disappoint! Got the Detroit Style Pizza and it was a glorious slab of cheesy gluten. Loved it! To top it off this Santa Claus looking dude who works there came by with the coolest jokes and weird ass laugh. I want to recruit this guy as my next Dungeon Master when I nerd out at on some D&D! #pizzageniouses read more

We brought our kids for an early dinner on Saturday....the service was excellent, the food and drinks amazing and everything was very clean. I found the restaurant through a Facebook ad of all things and now it is going to be a restaurant we go back to regularly. Our 4 year old and 1 year old both LOVED the Cheese Bread Sticks. My husband loved the Garlic Formaggi Pizza and I really liked the Wicked Pasta. My husband and I moved to Utah from Brooklyn, NY 6 years ago and we are always trying to find a good pizza and pasta place and we found it! Thanks guys! read more