I was impressed with how clean this restaurant was and the service is always amazing! This is a great place to meet up with a friend for lunch or bring the family for dinner. I need to come back for another pizza build! read more

See all

From out of town and decided to try this local my pie. Pickup was quick and counter service was great. Inside was nice and clean. I came for the pizza but the meatballs with ricotta won me over. Perfect combo and appreciated the pizza chips to pair with it. The garlic knots could use more garlic and were a little over drenched in an oil. I did like the texture and they were perfectly baked. The pep pizza was ok it was baked to my liking but not enough flavor. Back to the meatballs....they definitely stole the show. read more

See all

If you enjoy driving somewhere to have it close before the posted hours, I highly recommend this place. We were standing outside 10 minutes before closing, not for a pizza, just for pizza dough. We were ignored. We even called to be told they're not open, when they are supposed to be open. Horrible service. We used to come here every Friday but will definitely not be returning. read more

Usually, My Pie serves up some pretty tasty pizza and salads. Tonight, our pizzas were burnt all over the bottom. It seems like their oven needs to be cleaned out a bit before cooking pizzas. We had charred/black burnt old crust all over our fingers and the taste of the burnt areas made the pizza taste pretty unpleasant. Our Mediterranean salad was good, but the dressing seemed much more watery than usual. I wonder if there are new managers on board. We will definitely consider other local pizzerias before My Pie, as this was a pretty expensive disappointment tonight. read more

See all

Lately this pizza place has been our go-to. Each kid orders exactly what they want and we get a giant salad so everyone gets at least a few bites of vegetables. It's fast and fresh and no one walks away hungry! Their ranch is PERFECTION! They also have an open soda fountain so you never have to wait for a refill. The location is a little hard to find if you aren't looking for it but the food and the ambiance make it worth it. Think traditional pizza joint but clean and warm with soft benches. Easy pizza night out with kids or picky eaters? This is it. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Everyone happy with their choices - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Pizza was OK atmosphere so so not remarkable not terrible throwing a lot of options around it's one of the better ones

Whenever it's my partner's daughter's turn to pick where we go get food, My Pie is typically her go-to. They make personal pizzas and have a pretty wide variety of options including vegan options, gluten-free crust pizzas, and cauliflower crusts. It's a fast casual place where you order at the front and they bring you your pizza when it's done. I don't think I've ever gotten the same pizza here before because they have so many yummy options. You can also build your own pizza, but they have a lot of really yummy flavor combos so I've never built my own. I tend to go for their veggie-heavy options and yesterday I got the "My Greek Pie" with tons of veggies, feta, and a balsamic glaze. We also go one of their Reese's cookies which was perfectly gooey and delicious. The staff here is always so wonderful, the pizzas come out quickly, and they have great options. Although I'm not gluten free, I've gotten the gluten free crust a couple times and it's really delicious. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

I'm gonna go back! Fresh, real ingredients, perfect crisp on the crust. Bomb cookies! Chill vibe. Nice people. Tip: limit your toppings, cuz the crust is NY thin, & will only hold so much. Plus: red cream soda!! Wine: meh read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Build your own: ham, spicy sausage, gr peppers, carmelized onions, artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, xtra mozz - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

I ordered a pepperoni pizza from My Pie Pizza via Door Dash. Their pizzas are all 11" size, which makes for good consistency in cooking time. The crust was quite good, of medium density. The sauce was not overpowering in flavor, and there was a good amount of cheese. The failure point was the pepperoni: only seven slices of pepperoni for the whole pizza. And I didn't see any option online to increase the topping volume. Perfectly decent pizza but nothing to get excited about. read more

I've driven past this pizza shop dozens of times but never stopped. Tonight we were craving pizza and we're so glad we gave it a try. No lines, quick counter service, and a hot oven made for fast food that can't be beat. You can order off the menu or make it custom. Fresh toppings and plenty of them! Perfect for picky eaters or those with dietary restrictions, too. And let me just say that the warm cookies are not to be missed. Peanut butter heaven. We will definitely return to My Pie! read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Your Way - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

My Pie Pizza failed to deliver with below average pizzas and salads. The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were okay for the kids. My pizza was overloaded with toppings and a mess to consume. The dining area was nice, with large open windows and lots of natural light. The employees were friendly, and the service was prompt. With many alternative pizza restaurant options, I'd look elsewhere before returning to My Pie Pizza. read more

I called ahead to order a margherita pizza for lunch. It only took fifteen minutes for them to bake my pie (maybe shorter time since it was ready when I arrived). It was hot and delicious with fresh ingredients. It was juicier than the same pizza at pizzeria limone which is my usual pizza place. There was a parking lot nearby plus street spaces. read more

This place is awesome! Great go-to pizza joint for a quick and yummy pizza to go. Very affordable as well! read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Got take-out via the app. The app had not transmitted our order, so we had to wait around for the pizzas to be made. The Good: Place is very clean, very helpful staff. Got our order right out as we waited. The Bad: I do not order take out pizza to enjoy the cleanliness of the tables, etc nor the staff. I want good pizza. This was not it. Crust - boring, bland tastes like ready-made - really, zero flavor Sauce - little flavor, store bought would be better Toppings - Margherita - a few small pieces of mozz and some sad basil NY Roni - 7 pieces of pepperoni, also very little flavor If you are looking for pizza to fill up the kiddies this is probably an OK place. For anyone else looking for tasty pizza - look elsewhere. read more

Great food and service!! Would eat here again!! Got the Reece's cookie which was really good too! read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Prosciutto Arugula - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

Good tasting pizza. I ordered the San Gennaro The portions are good. If you're super hungry you can finish a whole pizza. If you order salads or other sides with the pizza, it would be large enough to feed 2. The sauce was good, not over spicy and was generous. I look for pizza with save all the way to the edge. The crust was cooked just right. The crust is thick enough that it doesn't crumble on itself when you eat it. The pizza combos were plentiful so finding something you crave shouldn't be hard. Toppings were tastey and covered the entire pizza. The pizza came out fast and was cooked well. I'd recommend this place for a quick pizza lunch. Update... I came back again the next day because I liked the pizza so much the previous day. The pizzas took a bit longer today, however the manager (on his own) came out and handed out free garlic knots to the customeds to say sorry for delay. Very top notch service!!! I just updated my rating to 5 stars. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

Recently I wrote a 2-star review for a nearby pizzeria, a stone's throw from My Pie, which we chose because the MP online order site wasn't working. We should have just drove to My Pie instead as they have always been "on" every single time we've ordered them. My Pie has been our go-to pizza delivery place for quite some time now...simply stated, every single time we order, each pizza that we get has never missed the mark for flavor, quality, and consistency. I think we have tried every single pizza on their menu at one time or another, with and without guests. It's always been fantastic and high quality. Highly recommend! read more

Hot pizza tip: Want to make pizza at home but don't want to like, maaaaaake all that pizza at home? My Pie has pizza kits! That's right, you can pop in to get a dough ball, sauce, cheese, toppings, and then get on your way. Go home, have a pizza party, roll out your dough, and go for it. https://www.pizzayourway.com/introducing-my-pie-pizza-take-bake-kits/ I mean, yes--you can also do the go-down-the-line thing in store to make a pizza your way, and have them bake it. That's always an option. But I've been here a couple of times and I've got to say that the dough is really good and translates really well to the take home method, so that's what I've done. In fact, you can just get a dough ball. For $2, you get a very easy to stretch dough ball, with just the right rise, and then you can spread your own toppings. The staff here has always been friendly and even though they were a bit confused when I came in to buy just a dough ball (the manager knew exactly what I was after, but the first person I spoke to was a little unsure) they definitely got it handled and got me on my way. read more

Ordered our pies to go, and from the outset it was a good experience. I was greeted on the phone with a proper "Hello, this is __________, welcome to My Pie. How may I help you." That was refreshing. My order was taken promptly by someone who actually seemed to be paying attention and cared to get the order right. On arriving at the restaurant to pick up my order, I was glad to have called ahead so I could skip the Friday night line (there were about 8 people in line, so not too busy, and business remained steady as I waited, briefly, for my order). The cashier was quick and quite nice, and once I was handed my order at least four of the staff members thanked me for coming in--certainly nothing like the poor service reported by another Yelper (maybe they were just having some opening week jitters when that patron visited). My Pie makes only 11" pizzas, made to order, so we ordered three different pies and a couple orders of garlic knots (they come 6 knots per order). Both kids and adults alike in our family really liked the pizzas, and the garlic knots were great. In all, our three pizzas and a dozen garlic knots rang up to $36, so it's a good bargain to boot. My Pie is most certainly worth a visit--it's great to have a pizza joint back in downtown Holladay. read more

See all

They did a super cool Yelp event where you purchased the ingredients, went home and then they showed you how to make one of their delicious pizzas your way, from home. It came in a really co hell tote and Yelp water bottle. The directions were easy to follow and their ingredients were really good. The most fun was I. Rolling the dough out, spinning it and then putting your twist on it. Then of course eating it. What a cool event. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Make your own pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Found hair in my pizza and lost my appetite. The bite that I did take was pretty good so that was a let down. Ordered through Uber eats and Uber refused to give me a refund. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

I used to love this place but it has gone downhill. The service is so slow. I waited 20 minutes over the estimated finishing time and left with the wrong pizza and the wrong salad dressing. The large Caesar salad is $10.50 and used to fill the container and today it wasn't even halfway full. I sadly will not be going back. It's not worth a $45 dinner for 2 pizzas and basically a $10.50 side salad. read more

Delicious!!! Friendly service and very clean. We will be back again! Tell your friends to check this place out!

I've been eating here for years. Always fast, always good service, always delicious pizza. I've gotten many of their pizza options, including calzones. Highly recommend! read more

We placed a pickup order for 11:30 and when we got there at 11:35 they were "just starting it now" so we waited until 11:50 and they gave it to us (to go). We came back and sat down to eat and the bread sticks were alright. The salad had brown and yuck lettuce. The pizza had so much powder caked on the bottom it was horrible to eat. ‍ read more

See all

Great location, poor execution. Our pizzas were not pretty. Flavor was "ok", but everything from the crust to the service was just mediocre at best. Lose the gimmicks and just make a damn good pizza. The bar is low in Holladay, so why not do it right?? read more

See all

This has become my go to place for personal pizzas. I prefer the Fra Diavolo sauce over the pizza sauce for the extra punch of heat and garlic. The staff is likable and always quick with a "welcome back". My cautions are that if you order anything with garlic as an ingredient, be prepared for raw garlic. It's not to my liking, but friends of mine absolutely love it. ymmv switching to Pepsi Aug 5th, 2022 read more

We had the best pizza in a long time from here tonight!! It was so amazing! We got several different pizzas and they were all great! The garlic knots were out of this world!! They use fresh garlic and were the perfect texture! I would highly recommend My Pie Pizza!! The pesto drizzle was perfect too!! The restaurant was very clean and the staff was helpful and nice! read more

Well made pizza with plenty of toppings, catered for vegetarian diet, family oriented.

I had the calzone with my own ingredient choices. Delicious, made to order on line and on time!

Great pizza at a great price! Definitely recommend adding the fig drizzle and don't forget a side of garlic knots!

We came pretty late in the evening. We were in the area and decided pizza is what we wanted. You order and pay before sitting down. I was in the mood for a meatball sandwich however they only serve calzones and pizza. I choose a meatball calzone. It was made in front of us and they use a ricotta type cheese in them with very little mozzarella. I personally didn't like it. The service was spectacular and attentive. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

great seevice. great pizza. great cookies. honestly couldn't ask for much more. I'm a big fan of pizza, and this is some of the best I've had in Utah. it's thin crust, which may not be everyone's favorite, but it's GOOD thin crust. i will be back read more

Our order was ready in under 20 minutes and, as always, was delicious and exactly what we wanted. We love my pie!

This place is a safe zone for us monsters who enjoy pineapple on pizza. You won't get judged for it either. The service her was great. They explained their process. Pizza was a good size. Tasted delicious and fresh. All the toppings I wanted. Definitely recommend this place. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

Pizza was rather disappointing. Very pedestrian crust and the overall pizza lacked any zing. I cannot recommend this pizza house.

In the 25 minutes I sat in this restaurant tonight I watched one persons order for pick up get messed up three times (which ended up taking as long as the time it took us to eat our whole meal), another guys two pizzas get made incorrectly that had to be remade, and I got a gluten free pizza that was more of a piece of charcoal covered in cheese. Attached is a picture of the gluten free pizza which is clearly burnt. I took it back and asked if it was usually that burnt for the GF crust, and they said they actually took it out sooner than it was supposed to be. They said it's made of rice and tapioca flour which just makes it burn. In my opinion, if something can't be made to look good or taste good then it shouldn't be sold. Pizza Studio has a tapioca flour crust that's much better and doesn't burn like this. Settebello also has a phenomenal gluten free crust. Aside from a really bad gluten free pizza, it's obvious that it's poorly managed and has a poor process. You tell the guy what you want, who tells another girl what you got, and then a person with a screen asks you what you ordered, and that screen gets sent to another screen where you pay, and the cashier asks you again what you got. There's so much room for error in the process. The amount of errors I saw in 25 minutes is the evidence of poor management, or maybe just poor staff training. Anyway. Wouldn't recommend it. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Great little personal pizzas. Prompt service, especially during the pandemic. I like that they have cauliflower crust. Greek Pie read more

Pizza was delicious! Customer service was subpar, when I walked in there was one other customer who had already ordered. There were several employees, but no one had acknowledged me for several minutes. Finally someone came up and I told her I was here for a pickup and gave her my name. She handed me my pizza and turned around without saying a word. I'm not a heavy critic of every restaurant I go to, but I do train my employees to acknowledge a customer immediately when they walk in, if nothing else, but to say "I'll be with you in a minute". Sadly, stellar service is few and far between these days. read more

I ordered and jumped into my car for a 8 minute trip. 3 minutes into the ride I got a text that my order was ready. Never going to waste my money at any other pizza place. This is it. This is the only pizza I'll ever want. So good. Tasted fresh and was hot! So sooo yummy and very affordable. Can't wait to try the other options. Thanks for a great pizza! read more