Great little personal pizzas. Prompt service, especially during the pandemic. I like that they have cauliflower crust. Greek Pie read more

In the 25 minutes I sat in this restaurant tonight I watched one persons order for pick up get messed up three times (which ended up taking as long as the time it took us to eat our whole meal), another guys two pizzas get made incorrectly that had to be remade, and I got a gluten free pizza that was more of a piece of charcoal covered in cheese. Attached is a picture of the gluten free pizza which is clearly burnt. I took it back and asked if it was usually that burnt for the GF crust, and they said they actually took it out sooner than it was supposed to be. They said it's made of rice and tapioca flour which just makes it burn. In my opinion, if something can't be made to look good or taste good then it shouldn't be sold. Pizza Studio has a tapioca flour crust that's much better and doesn't burn like this. Settebello also has a phenomenal gluten free crust. Aside from a really bad gluten free pizza, it's obvious that it's poorly managed and has a poor process. You tell the guy what you want, who tells another girl what you got, and then a person with a screen asks you what you ordered, and that screen gets sent to another screen where you pay, and the cashier asks you again what you got. There's so much room for error in the process. The amount of errors I saw in 25 minutes is the evidence of poor management, or maybe just poor staff training. Anyway. Wouldn't recommend it. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Always fast, SUPER friendly and delicious. The interior and exterior are always clean and the employees are more than happy to answer questions. My kids especially look forward to the play-dough. We have been eating here for years and it is always consistent. read more

I love the food here! and they are so good to me! I always get the garlic gnots here and mama meat! read more

See all

Excellent food. Excellent service. My husband and I shared a My Greek pie. It was nice that we were able to watch them make the pie which meant that we could ask for extra red sauce. We added a medium size Mediterranean Lover salad. It was big enough for 3-4 people to share if they also had pizza. Everything was fresh and high quality. Highly recommend. read more

We've had zero issues with our order. Each time has been fast and delicious. Owners are lovely. The garlic nots are a must as well. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Delicious pizza, great owners! Welcome to the neighborhood! - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

We wanted to try a new pizza place and this place hit the spot! Smelled and tasted amazing The garlic knots could be better but still tasty read more

Great service. Great pizza. Friendly staff took care of me even though I came in right before closing time without realizing they were closing at 8:30 not 9. Staff still took great care of me. Girl with short hair helped me. Excellent help read more

The cauliflower crust here is UNMATCHED!!! The best way to eat a pizza without all the carbs. Love this place so so much!

Ordered 6 pizza paid for 6 and two garlic knots. Went to pick up the order the employee said I ordered 5 pizza and one knot . Even after showing the receipt she still argued with me. Finally after another employee looked at the receipt and agreed with me. So finally she said they would make the pizza and garlic knots . she keep saying it was a big order and they missed some of the order like it was my fault for ordering. So I had 5 cold pizza's And one hot. No sorry .nothing .I wish I could take the tip back on the big order she complained so much about. I won't go back!!!!!! read more

Yum. Headed here after a lazy snow day with two of my girlfriends because after receiving a rewards text message that they were having a $5 cheese pizza deal for the day. We ordered 3 white crust cheese and one with wheat. I was very excited that they didn't charge extra for wheat dough. We were told our phone order would be ready in 30 minutes which made sense since they were having such a good deal going on. When we arrived, we still had quite a few people in front of us. When our pizzas finally came out after a bit of a wait, they had forgotten or left out the wheat crust. Without hesitating, the woman working told us to keep all four white crust cheese and she would bring a wheat one out soon if we wanted to wait a few more minutes. My girlfriends asked for ranch and they provided us four delicious sides of ranch at no cost. Talk about amazing customer service. I was very impressed. As a New Yorker I have very high standards for pizza and it was delicious. Crust was fresh, thin but bubbly, and cooked perfectly. The sauce was deliciously seasoned and there was plenty of it which I love. Thank you, My Pie! I'll definitely be back. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

I'm so happy a pizza place opened in Holladay village, we are in need of a really good pizza place around here. When I went to try with my family the staff was extremely generous and friendly. Order was accurate. The food is a step above the next "build your own" pizza place. You can taste the quality in the ingredients, we loved it! Well be back again. read more

Vegan options - quality ingredients. I eat here once a week (not counting secret garlic knots snack visits). Update: Please note that the cookies and gluten free crust or brownies are not vegan. I love this place but I don't want there to be any confusion based on the response promoting the gluten free options. Yes, My Pie has various accommodations for different dietary needs. I'm specifically here to help vegans find the vegan options. read more

Delicioso. Just got back from Italy and my hubs and I both agreed that the pie is as close as it gets. Grandmas pie. Greek salad. Reese's cookies?! What else can I say?? read more

This is my new go-to pizza restaurant. The pizza reminds me of authentic Italian cuisine that uses the perfect blend of cheeses and fresh ingredients. The caprese salad and garlic knots are ideal for dinner side dishes or enjoy them as stand- alones. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur I once wrote a college essay on what constitutes a harmonious, delicious pizza. I received an A+ on the paper, not necessarily because of my excellent writing skills, but because the integrity of the content merited an outstanding mark. Unless you are gluten free the My Pie pizzas won't disappoint your taste buds. So much so, that after indulging in their food you might bid farewell to franchised pizza chains! Enjoy. read more

Ordered My Pie through DoorDash today, first time ordering out from here. Pizza was burnt. Bottom was pretty black and made essentially the whole pie taste like charred dough. Garlic knots were pretty good so it wasn't a total loss. Will order again if they can figure out how to not burn it, kind of important for a pizza place! read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Super great pizza! We love the personalized sized pizzas because we can each pick out what we want. You can tell it's real brick oven pizza too! The quality is always consistent delicious as well! Staff so far has seemed to be friendly and easy to order from. One thing that other people might now care about is how good the ranch is! I'm a pizza dipper and I always need something to dip my pizza in, and their ranch is incredibly flavorful! read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Mr. White is my favorite! - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

See all

You guys really need to get your online ordering system figured out! Three times in a row I got really screwed up!

So the pizza is good. Not mind blowing, but good. The wait is always atrocious - plan on at least an hour dining experience. Tonight is especially awful. I called in an order for take out at 6:50 pm. They told me 25 minutes. Seemed reasonable. I arrived at 7:20. They told me "5-7" more minutes. Here I am at 8:00 still waiting. The only reason I'm even writing a review is to entertain myself while I wait. Noting there are a total of 10 people here; it's not exactly a busy night. Update: my pizzas were just sitting there and had been for 40 minutes. They said they didn't have a name on them. No apology and they still tried to sell them to me. Walked out. Very sad, but I won't be back. I met the owner when this place first opened. He's a really nice guy. With so many good restaurants in a 1000 foot radius, his people are going to have to up their game - and shorten their wait times. read more

Tried My Pie for the first time and it was a 5 star experience. In a time where it is tough to find help at all (let alone good help), I walked in during dinner time and there was no line and about 5 employees ready and waiting to help. Every one of them was kind and friendly and helped to explain the process and all of the different options. I tried the Angry Bird pizza and it was excellent! I had never tried a pizza with a spicy buffalo sauce and I'm glad I went for it. All of the toppings looked fresh and the pizza is baked right there in a wood fire oven while you wait. It's tough to have even a "decent" experience at fast casual restaurants these days due to the worker shortage and my experience at My Pie definitely warranted this review. read more

We love all of the unusual sauces and toppings and we enjoy customizing our family's pizzas. The crust is delicious and the cauliflower crust is a great gluten-free option! read more

I didn't have very high expectations for this place, but I was pleasantly surprised. It is a fast casual pizza place, where you place your order, watch them make your pizza, and they cook it in the oven for just a few minutes. The pizza is very good, the garlic knots are very garlicky, with large garlic cloves, so be prepared if you order those. They also were delicious. They have specials, which I highly recommend you take advantage of. The cookies are also delicious, but in my opinion, a bit overpriced. The atmosphere is a little echoey, but fun and trendy. All in all, a 4.5 star experience that I rounded up. read more

Came here for the first time a week ago after attending a Yelp party. I ordered my husband a calzone and I got a salad. Salad was very good. I just wish they had a berry salad option. I really like their neopolitan pizza dough. Very unique and delicious. Finally, I finished my to-go meal with a delicious red velvet cookie. Will most certainly be back. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by My Pie tonight. I happened to see it when I was in Holiday and thought I'd try it out. The crust is perfect, it's a good thickness and cooked well. The toppings were fresh and so yummy! My only complaint is the garlic knots almost have too much garlic and butter on them, the flavor is still good though. Overall a great dinner, I think I found a new favorite pizza place! read more

See all

Nice little place for pizza. Prices are reasonable & staff is quite friendly. They have GF crust options & the cauliflower crust is a great option! I recommend & have always gotten pizza to go for an easy dinner. Salads are large & quite good too! read more

Really great artisan pizzas. We got the Greek and the Palermo. They were both so good!! And the hot Hawaiian was fantastic too. It looked like they grilled their pineapple before putting it on which made it was better. Way better than pizzeria limone or mod. read more

Super fast and super tasty. We've been doing take out and delivery throughout the pandemic. The gluten free crust is actually wuite good!

The pizza is always great at My Pie but the delivery was awful! Awfully expensive, awfully slow and by the time we got the pizza (an hour later) it was awfully cold. The boxes were ice cold and so was the pizza! Won't do that again! read more

Just what I needed on a cold evening .. the in-line ordering was a breeze and excellent value for money .. pizza was fresh and the crust was done just right .. not too thin and not too thick .. my second order from them in 3 days and it was great read more

I used to give MY Pie Pizza 5 stars. However, I have to take down 2 stars recently. My pizza was neither burnt nor under cooked. Sometimes, I got the wrong pizzas from ordering online. Be sure to check your pizza after picking up in the restaurant especially if you have more than 2 pizzas. read more

Came here the first night they were open. Even with first night jitters, the pizza was fantastic. I used to like Pizzeria Limone but had been getting tired of their dwindling care about customer service and product. My Pie is my new go-to pizzeria for sure. Starting with the crust, this is great pizza. They have at least 6 sauces to choose from - regular pizza sauce, spicy pizza sauce and a marinara (thicker than pizza sauce) as well as Alfredo, pesto and a garlic/olive oil swipe. Their toppings are top notch, and more interesting than at the other 'fast casual' pizza places popping up. I especially liked their thinly sliced spicy sausage, and I'll try their spicy chicken sometime. They also have some finishing sauces to put on your pizza at the end. I made my own pizza with spicy sausage, bacon and roasted red peppers, and it was outstanding. Give them your business, you won't be sorry. This is a great addition to all of the food options in this popular block in Holladay. UPDATE : I have been back 3 times since they opened, and every time the pizza has been spot on! Great product, great owners, great business! read more

First time here and probably last. Man who appears to be the owner was very rude and on his phone while making orders. In between grabbing his phone he neglected to change his gloves and wash his hands. For a company that features allergen friendly menu options, more co side ration should be taken. Girl as register could care less about customer service. When my pies came up, they were not prepared as I had ordered. The napkins they gave me were covered in grease and trash. Probably from someone not changing their gloves again. For this to be a new establishment, I was highly disappointed in their food safety protocols. Stay away if you value sanitation. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Inside of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

The staff is amazing! There is one young lady in particular who has always remembered what I like, right down to the extra balsamic. So, the other day I went in and ordered a lunch special, not my usual. It came with a salad so I ordered the Caesar as it was one of the listed salads. When she came out of the back and saw my order, she had the young man who took my order clarify if I wanted the Caesar salad or the Greek salad, because she remembered that I always get the Greek salad. I did, in fact, want the Greek salad, but didn't ask as it wasn't a listed option. This young lady is amazing, and I so appreciate her attentiveness!!! read more

This little pizza joint has quickly become my family's favorite pizza place! We love the variety, quality fresh ingredients, gluten free options for celiac. The staff is always friendly, upbeat, and helpful. We order pizza here almost every week! This last time our delicious Mr. White on cauliflower was burned around the crust, making the outer 2" inedible... which was a total bummer because I really enjoy devouring every crumb of this delicious pizza! Didn't realize it until I got it home and opened the box. This won't deter us from frequenting this establishment. read more

My Pie - Holladay, UT - Pizza Near Me - Holladay, Utah

Yup definitely worth trying. The garlic knots were good. A little too much fresh garlic, but won't detour us from going back.

It's always a good thing when a good promo code is sent by the business especially in these COVID times. Pizza was ready in 20 min and my kids love them read more

I really love this place for a quick inexpensive PIZZA. QUICK, easy, affordable. The crust is thin and just a little chewy in a good way. Sauce is great. Always had a great experience here. Love the curbside pick up! My only wish is they had some carrots and celery with ranch as a side. Lol read more

I am updating my review. Since my first review we have eaten there about 4 times and without fail, EVERY SINGLE TIME they mess up the order. The last time we went, they had to give us two free pizza coupons because it took ONE HOUR for us to get our order TO GO. They gave us the wrong pizza, they burnt our pizza so then they had to remake it. THIS TIME we ordered a NY RONI pizza and a power pie. The NY RONI was made without pepperoni...... its seriously a pepperoni pizza... how are you going to forget the pepperoni? And the power pie was like eating char it was so burnt. The pizza, when done well taste really good... but at this point, it is not worth the hassle of ordering food here, which sucks because the place really has potential. read more

See all

Delivery was very fast and the driver was wearing a mask and respected all covid measures. The pizzas I ordered as well as the garlic knots were all great, best pizza I've had in Utah! read more

My pie was great! I liked the sauce options and everything looked and tasted really fresh. The service was great. My favorite was the Garlic knots...they were tasty!!!! And the cookies were good too! I am going back for sure! read more