A friend and I stopped into Sergio's Pizza for lunch today and had a better-than-expected experience. While the pizza itself definitely hit the bready, greasy spot, what really stood out was the overall value and the extra touches. They have a great lunch special that was a nice surprise for my wallet and I liked that they provide chili oil alongside the standard parmesan and red pepper flakes. (So unique!) The restaurant was notably clean and the staff is friendly, which made for a pleasant atmosphere. I asked for the staff's two favorite flavors and tried those slices; pepperoni & mushroom and the Grandma. I loved them both! Although I didn't try any of them this time, the desserts looked super enticing and are definitely on my list for next time. For a slice, why wouldn't you give Sergio's a try? read more

See all

2nd time here. So far always good service. Ordered a made to order 16" half cheese and half white pizza. Amazing as last time. We tried Villag** and while they were good, my family thinks Sergio's is better. Thank you Sergio's. Oh forgot. Tried a garlic knot. Outside texture crispy and inside so soft. Yummy read more

See all

Walked in with hubs around 1:30pm. We were the only folks in the place. Lunch crowd left already? As you walk in, there's a display case with all different types of pizza. Hubs & I each ordered 2 slices. The slices go into the pizza oven to get warmed up. I know this is supposed to be "NY style" pizza, but for a person who lived in NY and lived above a pizza restaurant, in my opinion, it's not quite 100% NY pizza. I mean it's good pizza, but it doesn't quite hit the mark. Lovely people, nice and clean, serves Coke. Would I go back, probably not. I'm still in search of the "perfect" slice. read more

See all

This has become a regular spot for pizza. We love the Grandma's slice. The tomato sauce on it is fantastic and different from the regular sauce. We tried a sub and salad as well as our pizza. All of it was really good but the star for me is still that Grandma's pizza. read more

See all

None of us wanted to cook dinner after spending the day taking down Christmas trees and decorations (ugh), so we checked out what could be delivered by UberEats. We decided to give Sergio's a try, and what a great choice! The pizzas and garlic knots were absolutely delicious, so it's safe to say we're now fans. The pizzas are good sized, with delicious, thick cheese - well worth the price - and we highly recommend. Can't wait to try other offerings, especially given the extensive dessert menu! read more

See all

Ever since I moved to Utah I have been missing the pizza. You can typically fine a decent cheese style slice anywhere but what makes Sergio's stand out from the rest is their Grandma & Sicilian style slices. The Grandma slice was sweet & savory sauce paired with fresh mozzarella. The Sicilian tasted like it was made on focaccia bread. They truly make it feel like you're walking right into a NY slice shop because they have their variety of slices on display. There isn't too much seating so I would suggest taking pies to go. There are some tables but they're mostly for groups of 2-6. They also offer some dessert options like $2.00 soft serve (which is only 50¢ on Fridays). Plus they serve fountain coke products which is always a plus. There are some really great special to take advantage of so if you're craving pizza give Sergio's a try! read more

Sergio's Pizza - Grandma Pizza Cheese Pizza Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

See all

Amazing NY style pizza! We ate at their food truck. One of the best slices of Margherita I've had! The service was SO friendly and kind, and it was quick too. We each got one slice and then liked it so much we got another. Delicious! Can't wait to come back here! read more

See all

This pizza is great. We just happened upon it and are so happy we did. We tried four different types and they were all amazing. I cannot imagine that anything you try would be disappointing. Finally we gave the cheesecake a try and it was great as well. The staff were super helpful and had a lot of information about each pizza and good recommendations. read more

As a long time resident to our little pocket of the Salt Lake Valley, Sergio's is an underrated gem. NYC Style pies and slices, without having to travel too far to get the standards like a great Cheese or Pepperoni slice or delicious others to sample that look appealing to you. Sitting in South Jordan strip mall means not a real fun vibe but tasty pizza! read more

Best New York pizza you won't ever get a plain pizza after you've had the garlic knot crust 10/10 their lunch special is great as well read more

Sergio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

This place is over priced and the pizza is just not very good. Thick dough, huge slices that can't be eaten by hand, ingredients were so so. It was a pick up order to go but I just wasn't impressed. I love pizza, but maybe not from here read more

Great food, great service, and great price. Awesome spot, you have to check it out!! I've always had a great experience her, and I cannot recommend it enough!! read more

Pizza wasn't bad. Got two larges and ordered two large ranches as well and didn't get any ranch. Really irritating especially when you pay for the sauce. read more

Very solid, pizza. One of the better NY pizza places in the valley. Not life changing but very good, satisfying pizza.

We came in for lunch and got the two slice special and added some garlic knots. It's set up like a typical New York City pizza joint, with a lot of variety of slices in which you could order. I tried grandma's pie, which has a garlic base to it. I really enjoyed it. I also tried the pepperoni and mushroom and thought it was good. I like that the crust had a nice crunch to it but still chewy enough. The garlic knots had a great flavor and were perfectly dough. The owner was very helpful and friendly to us. I definitely plan on coming back and trying some of the other variety of slices in the future. read more

I've thought about trying this place for about a year because I think that New York pizza is the best pizza and that Utah really struggles to make decent New York pizza. The poor reviews have kept me away until today and I really wish I had just stayed away. This is not New York style pizza. Maybe their locations in NY make the pizza differently. Maybe there's better quality control there. Maybe the person who made my pizza tonight was training? Idk, but I paid $23.63 for a pepperoni and seriously considered returning and asking for a refund. It was just a soggy terribly disaster loaded with way too much cheese and drowned in grease. I had to eat my "NY style" pizza with a fork lol. Look at my photos. read more

See all

Love their pizza! If I miss New York, this is where I come. By the slice pizza that serves large slices in different varieties. People are always nice when we go. Definitely recommend! read more

Great NY style pizza. We love the white and the BBQ chicken. I recommend ordering the whole pizza rather than by the slice.

This is the only pizza place we come to since we discovered it several months ago. Prompt friendly service, and you get perfect pizzas every time. I cannot over emphasize how happy I am (as a native New Yorker) to have found real quality pizza in South Jordan, at reasonable price. Simple tables and chairs are available to eat in, and the lobby and bathrooms are always clean. I only recommend this restaurant for all your Italian pizza and calzone needs. read more

Sergio's Pizza - A poster in the lobby of Sergio's Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

Great service, decent pricing, and good quality. I hadn't been here since they first opened and even with the change in ownership I had a good experience. read more

Stopped in around 12:30 on Monday. The guy behind the counter never said a word to me. He was way to busy watching a video on his phone. Left me standing there between 5-10 minutes before a girl emerged from the kitchen or back room. I was close to walking out. Tip for the restaurant: Greet your customers and if they can't assist train them to at least let the customer know someone will eventually help them. I won't be back. read more

See all

I'm giving this place 5 stars because it satisfies specific needs of the people. It's the only place around here that you can get a big single slice of pizza in minutes. This store front gives you fast access to great pizza. Sure there are the mall pizza places, miles away, but I dislike the mall experience. After thought, who goes to the mall for pizza? I arrived when they opened at 11am and they didn't have all the varieties ready. I kept seeing more delicious combinations coming out after I already ordered. I recommend going at 11:30am. Only recommendation: bring your own cutlery and plates. Their plates are flimsy and can't handle those serious slices. read more

Completely insane to charge $30 for a large buffalo chicken pizza. It would be one thing if the pizza was really good but it's so unbelievably average. Only reason I got it was because there was a buy one get one deal. The max I would pay is $20 read more

My friend is from NY and recommended Sergio's! I've been to NY about 5 years ago and will never forget the amazing NY pizza I had there. I was craving pizza and decided to finally give Sergio's a try. I'm not sure what was going on with the workers that day, but when we walked in we weren't greeted they just stared at us. We were looking at the different pizza by the slices until a couple of minutes later when one of the workers finally acknowledged us. We got 2 slices of the meat lovers pizza and garlic knots. They heated everything up for us so it was fresh and warm. Meat lovers pizza - BIG slices a little bigger than costco pizza slices. I love that they didn't cheap out on the toppings. The pizza is really thin and crispy, not the same NY style pizza I had in NY. ( was expecting the crust to be a bit more chewier/soft but it was really crunchy. Overall still a good pizza, but not exactly NY Garlic knots - ABSOLUTELY GET THIS!!! TO DIE FOR!!! I had low expectations for the garlic knots and these blew me away. They heated it up in foil with fresh minced garlic and it was so fragrant and tasty. The knots were soft and fluffy, not hard like other places. read more

Sergio's Pizza - All the meats - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

See all

Best pizza in the state of Utah! I would highly recommend it to everyone. Fantastic service and I love that you can order by the slice New York style! read more

Everyone talks about New York style pizza like it's incredibly superior to all other pizza-and they may be right. However, growing up in Utah, I've come to enjoy thick pizza that is a little less greasy. To each his own, right? So I won't fault Sergio's pizza for having a product that I don't particularly care for. I'll base my review on the entire experience, not just the pizza itself. There are several pizza options on display for you to select from. They look a little stale, but when you pick your slice, a staff member put it in the oven for a few minutes, reviving it to it's delectable glory. Slices are served on a modest paper plate-the slices are so large that most of the plate is covered. You'll find napkins, forks and seasoning at a counter nearby and you can order a soda and fill it (and refill it) yourself. There are also a few bottled options, if that's your preference. That's it. Simple concept-pizza by the slice, some garlic bread and a soda. I appreciate that they stick with what they do well and don't try to branch out into too many things. You can't be everything to everyone. The ambience here is a little odd. There's a giant screen TV on one wall and it was playing a TV gameshow when we dined in. There's no music playing, and it was really quiet-all we heard was the game show. A staff member was leaning against the counter watching the TV when there were no customers, making us feel like we were hanging at a friend's house. I think a little upbeat music would do wonders for the vibe here. read more

See all

Was very upset with the quality of pizza from this spot. Was expecting it to be a good traditional styled by slice. But it was not very good. The crisp of the pizza was decent, but the cheese tasted very fake and the sauce was essentially non existent. I ordered the cheese, pepperoni, and a meat lovers slice to try a little of each. They are well priced and a cheaper option for NY style pizza. But the quality was very poor. I ordered online and they gave me a time frame, but the time I got there the pizza was ready and when I opened it in the car to view it, the pizza was cold as if it had been sitting there for a while which does hurt the quality of the slices. I would try again to give it another try, maybe order and eat there, but this experience was very poor read more

See all

Came in 3 times fist two times they didn't have any pizza by the slice that we wanted to try only like Hawaiian and some artichoke one. Not for me I overheard the person in front of me ask the people working if they would put out more pizza they said since they were behind not now. So decided to leave. There was a really nice gentleman waiting for his pizza who told me to give them a chance. He was originally from New Jersey and said it was good pizza but they still needed to get the hang of the crowds. He also recommended I just order in advance instead of getting the slices since they didn't look as good as ordering one. Thanks for the tip' So instead of going in the 3rd time I decided to order and pick up a pie. We went with plain pepperoni. I will have to agree with other reviews the customer service is little on the need improvement side but it's okay. First slice tasted good crust was little crunchy but as it sat there it got softer. Cheese was good. I like the sauce not your normal pizza sauce you get. More fresh tomato flavor is how I could describe it. I felt like it was a little salty but maybe just my taste buds. I liked the edge crust a lot. I got 2 garlic knots to try since other reviews said they were delicious. Maybe I am KNOT a fan haha. They were ok. Noting to rave about for me. Could use more garlic flavor. Overall would I go back? Yea I liked it. It's different kind of pizza. Nothing out of the world but it's good pizza. But order ahead to make sure you get what you want. Don't go to eat there.. not a place to go and eat like the PIE just take it home and enjoy it without having people stand around you waiting for their pizza. read more

See all

FOOD: 3 1/2 stars. PIZZA : The pizza borders are excellent, light, crunchy and delicious but the dough under the pizza is a little of hit and miss here, not the same as Sergio's in NYC. The ingredients used are good, with exception of the broccoli and mushroom that seemed canned to me. They offer pizza by the slice which is getting rare in the area and one of the best I found, perfect for families. GARLIC KNOTS: very good, their dough when perfectly cook is unbeatable. CANOLLI: excellent, perfect dough and amount of filling. No pic as I eat too fast.CHICKEN PARMESAN PASTA: good, chicken was crispy inside, but pasta was too thick, but perfect for heavy eaters. ALFREDO PASTA: shrimp was undercooked and Alfredo sauce was not good, very weak. Not good at all. I trashed it. SERVICE: 3 stars. Good and friendly. Good for large groups and family. AMBIANCE: 3 stars. Clean and simple. Typical pizza by slice place. read more

See all

I'm obsessed with this place. It's hard to find a decent slice in Utah. It is even harder to find a place with good spaghetti and meat sauce. The price is reasonable. The staff is super friendly. I found out today that they also do catering, so I'm excited to have a go-to place for large orders for work. I'm so glad we have this gem in our neighborhood! read more

Sergio's Pizza - Spaghetti with meat sause - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

See all

We got two large pizzas from Sergio's and as always, it was great! Service isn't always the most attentive but the cheese pizza reminds me so much of New York that I can't help but go get it. We also got a large double pepperoni and sausage and my kids loved that. Definitely would recommend Sergio if you like New York style pizza because it's the closest thing I've had in Utah. read more

We love trying pizza from everywhere! I don't pay attention to most reviews because everyone has bad days and good days. The inside was clean, smelled good, and the staff was friendly. We ordered the Margarita Pizza, Fresh Mozzarella & Basil salad, and Garlic Knots. Everything had just the right amount of seasoning and tasted very fresh. Their Mozzarella was amazingly tasty! For dessert my wife requested something they did not offer. Garlic knots, without the garlic, add powdered sugar, and blueberry jelly. It took them a few extra minutes to make, but the staff was very accommodating and the finished product looked and tasted FANTASTIC! Before we left, we even noticed one of the staff enjoying this newly discovered treat that may even find its way onto the menu. If not then ask for it in person, you'll definitely enjoy them. read more

Sergio's Pizza - Non-Garlic Knots with Powdered Sugar and Blueberry Jelly - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

Absolute WORST tasting Philly Cheese Steak I've ever tasted. Made with Kraft Cheese Singles and greasy roast beef. Waste of money, threw it in the garbage after one bite. read more

Ordered two pies to be delivered (we live 5 min or less from Sergio's) and one of the pies was just a pile of mush. You couldn't even make out a pizza shape! Undercooked, greasy and tasteless. Tried numerous times to get refund no luck. Spent over 25 bucks and it went straight into the trash. Awful. read more

Sergio's Pizza - Margarita pizza...did they throw this pie around like a football??? What did you do?? - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

Wow. Ordered delivery. How can you make pizza so disgusting. Thick, wet , like huge sandwich melts. Does this pile of raw vegetables and cold cuts look like a pizza? read more

Sergio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

I already want to go back!l, that is a great sign of great pizza. It's the perfect New York slice. This is a franchise of a true New York pizza place. The owner of the brand is actually spending the next 4 months here in South Jordan making sure the flavors are his. I hope he trains the staff well, because we're committed to coming back. Walking in, it's clean and well organized. There are several tables around, but nothing for large parties. This is the perfect order ahead, and pick up location. In the future I'll order a whole pie to go. For our first trip though we wanted to order as many slices as we could. We stayed away from the pasta and sandwiches, but want to try them next time. We ordered the cheese, meat lover, buffalo, combination, the white pizza, and a slice of the grandma. They were all proper slices. Nice and crispy. Perfect fold. The perfect cheese drip. And the best flavors. All the flavors were spot on. It took me back to good New York City pizzas. The grandma was truly something special. Great simple flavors but quality. The buffalo was perfectly spicy. The meat lovers had the best sausage. The cheese was simple and delicious. It was all really great. We will be back. read more

My order consisted of 2 Calzones & 2 Fries. I didn't get the 2nd fry and we didn't get any marinara sauce to dip the calzone. So check your order before leaving. Calzone I've had the calzones here before and they were so yummy. Today, they were just so light on toppings and the dough was rolled out paper thin in most areas so I could not pick it up and eat it. Tasted like nothing more than melted cheese and ricotta. Thanks for being so generous with the cheese and ricotta but too much can kill the calzone experience. Probably just a one-off so I'll try again in the future:) read more

Sergio's Pizza - Sausage & pineapple calzone - Pizza Near Me - South Jordan, Utah

Ok. Real NY style pizza. I would get a whole pie next time, well done. Little bit of a flop. Pizza is best ate fresh, with that crisp. Haven't found a better pizza in Utah. read more

Delicious crust and good cheese! They had an Uber eats deal, buy one get one free and it was worth it!

Great pizza by the slice. Huge pieces and a great variety. People are helpful and friendly. Pop in, get a slice and take off.