I am a lover of good BBQ, and at first when we ate at Whole Hog Cafe (WHC) tonight, I had high hopes. I ordered their burnt ends dinner, which included 7 ounces of meat (according to their online menu), and 2 sides. I asked for and received a sample of their beans. Just like many other BBQ places in town, they include pulled pork and other off cuts of meat in their beans for flavor. I tasted no smokiness to them at all, so I'm sure they do not smoke their beans like Buckingham's.
As I did find the beans tasty, I ordered those and what they referred to as "natural cut fries" as the other side. When we received them, they were weird looking. Most were small triangle shaped pieces, and they were coated in a seasoning that wasn't exactly what I would call tasty. To make matters worse, they were also out of ketchup. My wife and I both thought they tasted a bit like baby red potatoes, but they weren't.
I asked one of the employees of the restaurant what kind of wood they used to smoke their meats. I was surprised to hear the response... pecan. I found it odd, because my wife works for a major market chain, and they smoke their own ribs in house, and the seasoning and flavor of my burnt ends tasted exactly the same as the ribs I could get for less than half of what I paid for a 7 ounce serving of burnt ends, and that would be a full rack of ribs.
I will say this, their burnt ends were very, very tender. They weren't dried out or overly salty, and they almost literally melted on my tongue. My wife agreed. Also, the store has a multi-function soda fountain that allows for you to have over 100 different drink combinations, including my favorite... Mello Yello Zero. As a person who suffers from Juvenile Diabetes (Type 1), I usually will only drink diet soda, un-sweet tea, coffee or water. Unless I feel my blood sugar tanking, I don't do sugared drinks.
I've had mixed reviews on WHC from different family members. One was very positive, and one was very negative. I'd put it right in between. The food was good (except for the potatoes), but the seasoning on their burnt ends tasting so much like what I could get for half the price (for ribs) at my wife's store makes me think I might give them a second chance to be sure before totally writing them off.
On a scale of `1 to 10, with 1 being the lowest possible and 10 being the highest, here's how I would rate them:
Price: A little high for the quality and quantity of the food. I'd give that a 6.
Flavor: The meal was definitely edible, except for the potatoes. Based only on the beans and meat, I'd rate my food as a 7.
Quality: Overall, I would give them a rating of 6.5. I would go higher, but the potatoes were horrible, and the meat was just not up to par with Buckingham's or Old City Butchers.
There is no excuse for a restaurant to run out of condiments, especially ketchup. They could have sent an employee to a store nearby to purchase ketchup (eventually they did, but not until after we were finished eating. Without ketchup, whatever the flavoring was that coated their potatoes made them almost inedible.
Overall score, definitely 2.5 out of 5 stars. I will give them another chance to see if they can impress me. Incidentally, with the exception of the fries, the rest of the meal was sufficiently seasoned I didn't need to use any of the 7 different BBQ sauces they had available.
I don't know, maybe I'm being too harsh. The burnt ends did have good flavor despite it tasting like i came from my wife's store. They were still good, and they did practically melt in my mouth. The beans were not bad. The potatoes... not good at all. They should not call them "natural" if they are coated in any kind of seasoning. I find this to be the same problem with Wendy's fries. At first, Wendy's natural cut fries were awesome, then they did something to add a seasoning to coat them, and it changed the tasted and texture enough to make them horrid.
I will write another review if we ever try them again. read more