If my parents don't get me a PLAIN whistlestop cheesecake for my birthday I am in a bad mood for a long time. I am 25 and live in boston. One time, this-happened. Last year they got it with dolce leche on top. I was immediately pissed, though it was phenomenal and everyone was obsessed. It's not that toppings ruin it at all; it's just that I almost don't want anything in the way of that plain wonderful cheesecake. read more

Recommended for: Cheesecake... delicious cheesecake, oh, and other baked goods. Service 5, Selection 5, Quality 6. Oh Cheesecake, how do I *heart* thee. Of all my travels around the globe I must say, that this place ranks among the top 5 for best Cheesecake. I mean, you just can't compare to this place. In fact, they are so good, that their main business is wholesale to restaurants around the tri-state area; they only have a small retail shop in the front. Drive up to the storefront and your thinking immediately 'uh, what is this place?', and you know what, I had the same reaction. This is the industrial part of Oceanside and again, this is their production facility; but that just lends itself for the immense freshness that you will have. When ordering a cake, ask for one in the back (not a display) and they are happy to accommodate. Want extras like cherries on a plain cake, no problem; want to write a message to someone in frosting, no problem. Aside from the basic cheesecake they have a variety of other types of cheesecake (think variety along the line of cheesecake factory). If you're in the area stop by, or, if you're a really really good friend, ask, and I just might bring one the next time I see you ^_~ Sean Approved: Absolutely YES!!! read more

This bakery is the best. The cannolis are fresh. The napoleon is yummy. Everything here is fresh. I've never been disappointed.

I've been coming here since they opened (about 20 years?) and this is by far THE BEST bakery to get occasion cakes and cheesecakes from. Even the sugar-free cheesecake is amazing. I really have no idea why I waited all these years to review this amazing bakery! Our favorite cake to order is their Tres Leches cake and every time we order it for any party or birthday, people always ask where it came from. We have even picked this cake up many times to bring to other friend's parties who do not live in our area. The cakes are consistently perfect and delicious and their raspberry crumb cake is to die from! Their pies are great too! If you like yellow cake with the best chocolate fudge anywhere, try their Chocolate Heaven. read more

Really, really really good cheesecake : moist, not too sweet, not too thick, not too airy, very creamy The peanut butter cake was exceptional as well. A perfect balance of pb and chocolate The cheese crumb cake has the best crumb top - it's not too thick where the sweetness overwhelms you. I bought a whole one for myself, cut it into squares and froze them. They were still delicious thawed out with my morning coffee weeks later read more

Here's how serious it is... My Dad had to fly me back one of their cheesecakes from NY to CA. If this isn't the definition of a New York Cheesecake than i don't know what is, lol. I can honestly sit here and tell you this is the best cheesecake I've ever tasted. I don't even know what to say! It was outstanding. read more

I was sadden today. Bought a large plain cheesecake, brought it home and discovered it was previous frozen. I expect better from them. For the record I went to school with the owner's brother 45 years ago, I have been around and can buy a frozen cake at the supermarket. read more

Wow. and I mean wow. So glad was told about this place by someone as having the best cheesecake. She was right on! read more

You would never suspect that a gem like Whistle Stop would be hidden in the trenches of the industrial area of Oceanside. Ah, but alas, a great cheesecake! I've been eating their cakes all my life, our little secret it used to be. But good food is hard to come by, so I shall divulge the wonders of whistle stop. Creamy, rich and sinful! You want quality, come here. read more

I've only gotten their regular cheesecakes, so that's all I can speak for. However, I can confirm that their regular cheesecake is 100% the single best cheesecake that I have ever had! Texture, taste, everything is spot on. If you don't want to eat loads of cheesecake all at once it freezes well at home, just slice it, stick some parchment paper between the slices and toss it in a container to freeze in. Then you can just pull out a slice at a time to eat. read more

It's overrated. It used to have a good reputation. Don't know if that's true anymore. I just don't think it's worth stopping there. Staff isn't very friendly either. read more

This is a family tradition. Every year I am in NY for a holiday I get the pies from Whistle Stop. Get there early because they do run out. Nothing gets you in the dog house faster then telling the family you got the desert and showing up on Thanksgiving without Pumpkin Pie! read more

Simply put: the best cheesecake. The best. Their other items are fantastic, too! (My best friend and his (now) wife had Whistle Stop bake their wedding cake. If you grew up on LI's South Shore you grew up on this cheesecake. A few years ago I sent one of these cheesecakes to my in-laws. They loved it. I ruined all other cheesecake for them. They made me ship one the next year....then Hurricane Sandy struck shutting down the bakery's production temporarily and, seemingly more permanently, their shipping capabilities. I'm so glad that WS is up and running -- I got to have some of the cheesecake over Thanksgiving while visiting family friends on LI -- but very sad that I can't have the cake shipped to my in-laws. We managed last year, and will manage again this year, with Junior's cheesecake. It's good. It's very good. But it's no Whistle Stop. None-the-less, I'm glad that I got to introduce some people to WS cheesecake who otherwise never would have had the best cheesecake there's to be had. read more

One of my favorite bakeries, especially the cheesecake selections. Gluten free cakes are delicious also. Stopped by today to buy dessert for Easter dinner. Was shocked to hear that they now charge customers 3% for using credit cards. Very tacky business practice. Would have given 5 stars if not for this. This is how you treat your loyal customers, shame on you! read more

The...absolute...best...Macaroons...in...all...the...Land! Possibly life changing macaroons. They are sweet, creamy, coconutty and covered in delicious chocolate. You might be tempted to share one because they are so large but trust me, don't. Be selfish and indulge! read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - To die for Macaroons! - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

They now charge a 3.5% surcharge on all credit and debit card purchases. No notice on the wall.

If you grew up on the South Shore, you probably know this beloved family owned bakery on an industrial stretch of Lawson Boulevard. Everyone in my family goes crazy for their cheesecake: we usually get the one with quadrants of pineapple, cherry, blueberry, and strawberry toppings so everyone gets a flavor choice. Their pies are also very good, but the assortment of butter (Italian) cookies is my absolute favorite. Umm num num! read more

Love love love the cheese cake, the carrot cake and the pican pies here. A bit upset that they charge and extra 3% for using a credit card!!! read more

My favorite bakery in Long Island #1 cheesecake. The best Tiramisu for my birthday every year Crumb cake is also a big hit read more

So, I just discovered this place last year, I've been here a few times since and I can tell you that I'll be coming by here for their plain cheesecake slice for years. The cheesecake sampler is pretty good, but their plain cheesecake is absolutely the best! I definitely recommend it! I can't wait for my next trip here. Mmmm I can really go for another cheesecake slice. read more

Really nice, light raspberry crumb cake. read more

Whistle Stop Desserts - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Very good. Lots of variety. Excellent cakes. Quick and easy. Parking right in front of the establishment. Reasonably priced baked goods.

Someone brought a cheesecake into work the well I started calorie counting. I declined but they said try a bite... I did and it was over! Totally worth every calorie! Fluffy and decadent, yum! read more

Nasty owner. My wife ordered a cheesecake. Had to wait over an hour after when it was supposed to be ready. So of course she's upset. The owner comes out with a nasty attitude. I've seen many businesses fall from grace because they think they are big enough to have a attitude. I'm waiting for this one to fall. Until then Ill knock his business down one dessert at a time read more

I tried their cheesecake and it was amazing!!! Better than any cheesecake in NY. I think i paid like $17-$20 for it but it was soooo good.

We've been coming here for years. Best cheesecake on Long Island the Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake is to die for, but I love all! Every time we serve to our guests they rave about it. I've had Junior's in Brooklyn and it doesn't even come close. If you're buying right before a holiday be ready to stand on line. read more

This place is amazing. i drive 40 minutes just to buy their cheesecake. Everything is amazing at this bakery and inexpensive

Although they're known for their cheesecake, Whistle Stop goes way over that. Mousse cakes, cookies, pound cakes, the list is endless!!! They also bake the most delicious specialty cakes for any occasion. They'll make the cake in any size, flavor, and decorate it to your specifications. Their cheesecakes and other cakes definitely are worth the trip if you don't live nearby. I give Whistle Stop 5 Big WHISTLES!!!!! read more

I have been a customer for years, ordered cakes here for years. I ordered a cake for my daughters 30th birthday here. I asked for them to put macaroons and dress up the cake with gold foil, they told me they can get either and therefore could not put them on the cake. I ordered macaroons and got the gold foil myself. When i brought them there to have them put on the cake I was told "NO because we do not put anything on our cakes that are not from our bakery". After spending $150 on a cake and being a customer for years this completely turned me off! Here I spent additional money on the gold foil and macaroons because they as a bakery could not provide them or get them only to be told they "will not" put them on the cake for me. My family and I will no longer be coming back here. read more

I came all the way here from Farmingdale, I heard that these were the best cheesecakes and that the chocolate raspberry was the best. I asked for a chocolate raspberry cheesecake and a peach crumb pie. I get all the way home, hours later decide to have a piece and cut into it. It's NOT a Cheesecake. It's s chocolate layer cake with raspberry. I'm so disappointed. I was totally looking forward to Cheesecake. Now I have to go all the way back another day. Got to go back 5 days later, bought a plain cheesecake and it was amazing! Went back to get the Apple crumb cheesecake and a pineapple for friends, both were amazing!! read more

Best Red Velvet Cake in EVER!!!! My job ordered a red velvet sheet cake through a vendor and it happened to be from this shop. OMG, the best cake I have ever had!!!! I made them get the contact information for me and I will definitely be stopping by to get more of this awesome cake. read more

Awesome!!!!!!!!!! Always get the sampler when I have to celebrate someone's birthday (including my own). Then I proceed to have one of every slice as everyone picks at the cheesecake, because it's probably super caloric. I don't mind the calories though, the cake is sooooooooooooooooooo worth it. I've also tried their carrot cake, which was surprisingly good as well. It was rich though, and had to cut their "mini" cake into four servings. That's easier to do with a cake that I'm not as fond of... cheesecake I eat the full slice and dream about the next slice, which awaits the following day. I really need some now... Prices are moderate to pricey ($30 for the sampler), but I think that's comparable to Cheesecake Factory, which I don't think is as good. read more

The shop is small but the baked goods are terrific. We have had cakes, cheese cake and brownies. Everything is very good.

Great cheese cake have been coming here for many years things have changed,a lot of there products and seems too be very commmercial I have gotten frozen product here twice I would be very cautious but they have the nerve too charge manhattan bakery prices and above they should wake up and realize they are in LI . There are better bakeries in the area. read more

Stumbled upon this place when I happen to be in long beach and needed to pick up a kid friendly dessert for a dinner party. Got a tray of blondies and brownies. Was curious to try something else, so got a mini chocolate mousse cake and mini PB explosion. The brownies were okay, but holy moly those minis were outrageous. Will be back to try the cheesecake. read more

Whenever I hear the word "pie" or "cake", I think Whistle Stop. I mean, it doesn't even cross my mind to get a pie or cake anywhere else. And by the lines they tend to have, I'm not the only one. My childhood birthdays were ALWAYS topped off with their chocolate mousse cake. Little get togethers are usually complimented with several choices of cheesecake, and the winter holidays are ALWAYS celebrated with their pumpkin pie. read more

Seriously we should not be giving this place such great reviews....then the lines will be even longer to get these desserts. Can't say enough good things about the store or the people. The Missippi Mud is my favorite but you simply can't go wrong with any selection at this place. Brooklyn eat your heart out. read more

Best cheesecake you can get. I have had cheesecake from a lot of bakeries and I have made my own, but, in my opinion it's one of the best, better than Juniors of Brooklyn. read more

Words are not even created to describe my 1st taste of cheesecake from Whistle Stop. My friend gave me a slice to go home with last Sunday. His words were "just take it & tell me about it later". WOW! I was watching TV & decided to see what was in the wrapped foil. My 1st first bite brought a great smile. I mean REALLY REALLY GREAT SMILE! It was so good so AMAZING so UNBELIEVABLE! That I had to pause the TV to make sure I was really awake & not dreaming. This cheesecake is hands down the best I ever had from West to East coast. Junior's can't hold a torch to it. Not even close & I'm not saying it because I don't like Junior's. I always thought Junior's was overrated & I've had better cheesecake at other places specifically Luigi's bakery in Brooklyn. The next day I get off before 6pm I will be buying my own whole cake for sure! One slice isn't enough. read more

I'm not a big cheesecake person, but I had the pleasure of enjoying a Whistle Stop cheesecake after having dinner with BF's parents (ok, it was a day long eating extravaganza). I heard the stories before of these fabulous cheesecakes, and they did live up to my expectations!! His mom picked up a plain cheesecake with cherries on top. The texture was perfect - smooth and creamy, but not too heavy. The cherries gave just the right amount of tartness. Every bite was bliss. She sent me home (back to Chicago) with a quarter of the cheesecake and a box of cookies! Everything is fantastic, but the cheesecake is their gold medal! read more