Katia, Xollit, and Jennifer are the best!! They are always nice, always attentive, and provide an excellent service every time I visit. read more

Great customer here. Good big variety and options of desserts and drinks ! And they have their own parking always a plus . My second time here . read more

See all

What a lovely little bakery with outdoor seating. It's got cheesecake, sweets and other yummy treats. It's different than the other American style bakeries. I loved the cheesecake with fruit in the middle. read more

See all

Nice coffee shop with some awesome, desserts, pastries, and donuts. Place is a casual coffee shop with wifi and a decent amount of seating, including outdoor seating. Service was fast and friendly. read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Got the birthday cake and Oreo cheesecake for MIL bday. Both disappointing. MIL said that I can just make a better cake and that this wasn't any good. We won't be going back. Service was slow even though it was one customer in front of us. They just seem to move slowly. read more

See all

The bakery goods are fantastic, love their brownies & double chocolate cake not to leave off the tiramisu, but their coffee needs to be hot read more

Sugarberry Bakery - A piece of artwork in the establishment..... - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Whoever the male at the front register is could benefit from some customer service training. I was asking questions about the large available cakes since they weren't labeled and he acted like he couldn't move from the cash register to answer my question. Telling me he can't see without his glasses, babe take two steps over. THANK YOU SOCHI for your hospitality, I was about to walk out and she was able to answer my quick question and decorated the cake nicely for a birthday. read more

They offer a variety of sweet treats--everything I've tried so far has been delicious. On my last visit, I went with the gelato, which was creamy and flavorful. They also serve a nice selection of beverages--the chai latte is a standout! Service is quick, and I didn't have to wait long after placing my order. Bonus: they have outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying your dessert on a nice day. Definitely a go-to spot when you're in the mood for something sweet! read more

See all

Ordered a fruit tart off from here off of doordash, it was poorly packaged, (the bag wasn't sealed so I didn't trust it). Opened my fruit tart container, the fruit looked a bit old. When i flipped over the raspberries and there was mold. read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Moldy berries on Fruit Tart - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Stopped in for a afternoon coffee. Couldn't find anything else open! So thank you for being open. Was surprised the spread of desserts they had. Nothing really special that made me get something though. Just the usual bakery stuff. Coffee was really good hit the spot. Staff was friendly and they had a decent amount of customers coming and going. Nice place. read more

I'm extremely disappointed with my experience. I paid $170 for a custom birthday cake, and the order was taken directly by the store manager. We clearly agreed that the cake would match a reference photo, including specific colors and Spiderman eye decorations. The manager reviewed the image with me and allowed me to take a photo of her phone showing the exact design we agreed upon. When my husband arrived to pick up the cake--after the promised pickup time--the cake was brought out, but the manager quickly asked for it to be returned to the kitchen because it was not ready. At that point, it was clear the cake was also missing the agreed‑upon decorations. I spoke directly with the manager, who then denied ever agreeing to include the Spiderman eyes, despite having reviewed and approved the design earlier. Most concerning, my husband later observed the manager alter the photo on her phone, removing the decorations we had discussed. Additional requested decorations were also not put on the cake. It has now been weeks, and no one has followed up, despite being told the owner would contact me. For the price and the importance of the occasion, this level of disorganization, lack of accountability, and dishonesty is unacceptable. I expected professionalism, transparency, and follow‑through--and received none. read more

I first had this cheesecake years ago at a barbecue and I remember being really impressed by it but I didn't know which bakery it came from as I am not from the South Shore. Well this year my family surprised me with it for my birthday and it was just as good as I remembered. Dare I say this might be the best cheesecake I've had in NY? I do like a lot of other places as well but Sugarberry just knocks them out of the water. I've never physically been to Sugarberry but would love to go one day. My family also brought me a tsoureki from there and it was also very fresh and delicious! Will definitely stop by there one day to try more! read more

I have nothing bad to say about Sugarberry. I have been in a while but I still get my cheesecake delivered vis grub hub so know there desserts are DELICIOUS. There services are great. They're packed with such care. read more

See all

What happened Sugarberry?? Did you stop caring? The lemon cheesecake I just had was atrocious! Absolutely stale and had an unrecognizable flavor to it. We've been coming here since it opened and never had a single complaint. I'm concerned. read more

Been going here for about 2ish years now and between the great lattes from (Kat,soshie,an princess) The sweet/kindness from all workers, An an excellent setting to relax an focus. An personality it set's the standard for me when I look for a place to get work done. I'm actually on my way there right now lol read more

We came here on a weekend after the Yelp Social Club event for some sweets afterwards. When we arrived in the bakery, we discovered that this was a small business bakery. Service was ok. There were only two people working behind the counter. There were a lot of Greek pastries and desserts. I ordered the Kataifi, Baklava, and Galactoboureko. The ambiance of the place indicated that it is owned by Greeks just by the products imported and desserts being sold. The place also offered free water for guests. When I received my orders, they felt massive. Portions were generous because it took us three days to finish everything. In hindsight, I definitely got my money's worth. read more

See all

Wonderful bakery with fresh, delicious cakes and excellent coffee. Everything tasted freshly made, and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. A great spot for a sweet treat and a quality cup of coffee. Highly recommended! read more

My first time coming to this bakery after reading a lot of the other reviews, I agree with what people are saying. The establishment is nice. I love the outdoor seating area. When you walk in, it is clean. The staff is friendly and helpful. I decided to purchase a slice of strawberry short cake. When I got home the cake looked good strawberries and whip cream was good but the cake is a little bland. The cake is not dry it's fluffy, but it's missing an ingredient. read more

See all

Heaven. An expensive heavenly experience. The deserts are delicious and cheesecake slices are huge. But you're going to pay. Service was good and the place was warm and inviting. Sweets were amazing. But we will save this for a once in a while place. Highly recommended. read more

I received a cake delivered to me for my birthday yesterday. I'm eating a strawberry and realized there is mold on almost every one of my berries on top of my berry cheesecake. read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Receipt, delivered yesterday - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

If I could give this place 1 star, I would. The service is terrible, they are always gossiping behind the counter or on their phones and not paying attention. I was waiting to be attended as the only customer for 5 minutes. I had to say "Hello! Hello!" for them to look up and attend me. When they finally did, they had a horrible attitude and left me waiting with cash in hand for 3 minutes while they did my order. And to top it off, my cake was stale and dry AND IT HAD A HAIR IN IT. So disgusting, I would never come here again. The only thing going for the place is that it's pretty to look at. Don't waste your time or your money on Sugarberry. read more

Frida, 10:30am, 07/31/2026, worse coffee Ive ever had. The employees behavior was not anywhere near welcoming, and facial expressions can speak very loudly. It was my first time coming in, and it looked really nice on social media but it is no where near what I expected In terms of food and drink quality. They do have nice decoration but whats the point of sitting somewhere that looks nice but tastes horrible. Whats even more upsetting is that I had drove 30 minutes to come here when I could have just went to a starbucks in the neighborhood. read more

Got a cake here for my friends birthday last month and came last night for a sweet treat! I love this place for its hours and all their pastries. The inside is cute as well. The service has also never disappointed, My friends and I love it here. read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Strawberry Tres Leches - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

I was shocked and pleasantly surprised when my fellow work from home colleagues ordered door dash for me on my birthday! It was so sinfully delicious and I enjoyed every morsel! I received a cappuccino and a birthday assortment of three different delicious pastries. I do not know the names of the different types, but I have a it pictured here. I definitely will try it on my own and see what other deliciousnesses they have! read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

At Sugarberry with friends and once again the music is blasting- and it is cold to the point the customers are complaining.staff says they are not allowed to lower the music or do anything about the heat. really? Good coffee, desserts, but last time we are coming here. read more

Got a sweet tooth - go here! Nice variety to choose from Comparable prices of other bakeries Seating & Street parking available read more

One of my family members lives close to Sugarberry and is often here, so she decided to bring red velvet cupcakes from here for Thanksgiving. They were packaged great, and neatly. Upon first glance, there was a lot of icing (which I appreciated because I am an icing person). Biting into the icing (cream cheese), it was very good and rich and was my favorite part of the cupcake. I bit into the cake itself and it was a little dry. It was a bit disappointing because the container was sealed shut and my family member was very excited about these cupcakes. Biting into the cupcake and the icing together helped the dryness. I wouldn't mind trying here again just to draw any conclusions. I would buy a tub of the icing though!! read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Red Velvet Cupcake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

My daughter's visited this location 11/1/25 and was having an iced coffee. As she is sipping her beverage she notices a bug in her drink. I have filled a complaint with the county. One of my daughters that happens to be there is a elementary school teacher in the neighborhood and definitely will be advising her peers and parents to not visit this establishment. The daughter that happened to is a high school student in the neighborhood and as well will advocate to her fellow classmates not to visit. To make matters worst the staff was not even apologetic about the matter. read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Close up of bug - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

European bakery in Long Island with a cool 1920s vibe, hard to choose just one dessert! read more

See all

I enjoyed their iced latte. The brownie was very good. However the cake slices weren't the best I've had. It is open until midnight which is good for late night cravings. read more

If you have a sweet tooth then you'll like this place. They have a descent amount of options. I usually go for their cheese cake or carrot cake. read more

This bakery is wonderful. The caramel cheesecake is now my new favorite cheesecake. It even beats out Cheesecake Factory cheesecake for me. All of the baked goods I tried were soft and fresh. Next time I am in the neighborhood I will be back. read more

Stopped by the Sugarberry Cafe and it was wonderful! They have lots of outdoor and indoor seating. It's such a cute walk to the cafe. Staff was super friendly and can recommend things because they have so many options. I got the Oreo cheesecake and I would recommend it! 8/10! It was a lighter chew cake but you get a really large piece for $7.50. Check them out if you're in the area. read more

See all

Nice bakery. They have a lot of different options. Place is pretty busy and hard to find a table at times. read more

See all

This cake was filthy greasy, sour, and honestly hard to swallow. Absolutely awful. The smell alone was unbearable. I regret every bite. Would never recommend this to anyone. read more

This bakery has very good cakes and has seating to have a hot or cold beverage and dessert but unfortunately the music level is a bit elevated and when asked if it can be lowered even slightly the staff informs you that it is set at this level and the owner does not permit for it to be changed. Also although the temperature outside was in the 40's the air conditioner was intermittently on and also could not be changed when asked. read more

I struggled with the rating on this one. I almost gave it 2 stars, but they have the best red velvet cake I've ever had. The ambiance is fantastic, love the look of this shop. The desserts look great and there was thought behind placement and the look of the desserts. The service is good. However, this is the second time in a year or two that I've found hair in my dessert. As much as all of the above is great, hair in food is gross. Someone back there needs to figure it out. I've never experienced this at another bakery. I gave them a pass the first time, it was in the Sugarberry dessert (napolean). The second time it's under the Portokalopita. Come on... not sure if I can go back. Pretty turned off. read more

Muy Bien Servicio de parte Rosa Gracias! el pastel estuvo muy rico y sabroso!! Rosa fue muy servicial.

The girls at the counter are very unknowlegeble about the desserts.I asked for a cheese pie and got a bougatsa.The coffee is always cold.Told the owner repeatedly but he does not care.Also the cakes and desserts are stale and old.They are being brought over from another bakery, the leftovers. I would not recommend this place to my worst enemy. read more

Their deserts are amazing. The coffee was better when they first opened. I ordered a cake for my mom's birthday as she loves the cannoli cake from suga berry. When I called to order I explained what I wanted and that it would be for about 8 people and I needed a very small cake as not everyone would be eating it. She suggested the 10 inch. I wasn't even thinking as I worked in a bakery when I was younger and our 8-10 ppl box was 9 by 9.75 but that was so long ago I had a 50 hour work week was putting together a birthday Xmas eve dinner and my mom is on hospice so I was not thinking when it was $65!!!! The cake was sort of damaged from the box on the sides which is fine but it just had writing no flowers or no thought put into it. We couldn't take it out of the box because under the board was soaking wet. I ordered it in advance and my mom still loved it but I am disappointed read more

Sugarberry Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York