Visit Date: January 3, 2024 I came here with my family after we ate breakfast at the diner for my dad's birthday. I looked around at all the offerings and finally chose one of my usual favorites a linzer tart. When I ate it later in the day it was good but kind of dry. I don't know if that's the bakery's fault though in general these pastries are on the dry side. I also ate it much later in the day when it was less fresh instead of eating it right away so that could have been it too. I would come back to this bakery again! read more

See all

Ran in here at the last moment for large cupcakes. I had to stop myself from ordering extra items because the turnovers were calling my name. The friendly young lady boxed up my order quickly. The bakery was smelling delicious and was fully stocked with cookies, pops, and cakes. read more

See all

Service is horrible which makes ambiance terrible also. Definitely not a place to go and have a sweet treat. Cake was okay

Mario's Bakery in Oceanside never disappoints. We ordered savoiardi cookies and a cake, and everything was incredibly fresh and absolutely delicious. The savoiardi cookies were light, perfectly textured, and tasted homemade, while the cake was moist, flavorful, and clearly made with quality ingredients. You can really tell they take pride in their baking. If you're looking for authentic, fresh baked goods in the area, Mario's is a must-stop. We'll definitely be back for more. read more

This is the only bakery in the area that has sourdough bread! Their goods are fresh and delicious and the place is impeccably clean. The cashiers are courteous. There's parking either on Merrick Rd or in a small lot between Mario's and the Convenience Store read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Great Desserts ! Thanks Lou For Your Help. Lemon Meringue Pie & Marble Crumb Cake Both Are Delicious read more

See all

As much as me and my family like this bakery , I think today was my last time visiting . The last 4 times I stopped by to get some goodies , the ladies who are working are very unpleasant and rude. I'm polite , I tip and I still can't get friendly, polite service . For the baked goods , everything is fresh and delicious , if you don't mind bad attitudes go for it read more

See all

I ordered my wedding cake from here. Whoever said wedding cakes never taste good never got one from Mario's. Ours was delicious. I had a pink two-tier cake with red velvet and cream cheese inside. It was perfect and very good. Delivery came an hour early. Everything was packaged perfectly. Price was reasonable. read more

See all

I just recently gave a review for Mario's Bakery and gave it a one star and that was not really deserved because I was only disappointed in their honey balls so and I love everything else I get there so I am changing my one star to a four star everything is delicious there and I have never been disappointed except this one time and I have been going there for years read more

Ordered a cake for my daughter in law's bridal shower this past weekend. They did an exceptional job. It was exactly what I was hoping it be. Not only was it beautiful it tasted amazing. read more

Mario's Bakery - Cherry Blossom cake - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Very satisfied with the fresh cakes that we bought. Cookies and cakes are all fresh and delicious. I have been going to Mario's for years and wouldn't go elsewhere owner Lou is very accommodating. read more

I been using this bakery for years. I get all my cakes here and they never disappoint ever. read more

Mario's Bakery - This was for my mother's birthday and they delivered it. Everyone enjoyed it. - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

I will say right off the bat, Mario's Bakery has the best corn muffins I've ever had in my life! (No exaggeration) lol, it's amazing. They also have a huge selection of sweets, everything is fresh, clean, and visually looks amazing! Staff is quick to get you in and out, wait times are never long, which I love. read more

Marios Bakery cookies on the right are terrible looking compared to the box on the left. read more

Mario's Bakery - Mario's bakery in Oceanside, NY to Tasty Pastry in Dyker Heights. The box on the right is from Mario's. - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Don't waste your money with this place, you could just make it at home for way better i promise. Everything is expensive and doesn't show on the quality at all! I ordered a cake and gave them specific instructions but the cake came out like they took 5 minutes to teach a kindergarten to do it. read more

I'm taking off one star for my latest experience that shows that this place is not really great at customer service during a pandemic. I called and wanted to place an order and have someone else pick it up. Having done exactly that recently, I thought they would allow it again. Especially in a pandemic where people are ordering deliveries, I did not think it was an unusual request. However, the lady over the phone refused to allow me to place an order for someone else to pick up. I was having car trouble and had to walk in this freezing weather to go into the bakery when I had a friend who had a car and could have picked it up for me. I still like Mario's baked goods but this is not very good customer service during a pandemic! I felt uncomfortable having to wait in line with many people. They should really allow online and or phone ordering. read more

See all

We order all of our cakes from this amazing bakery! Our guests are always say this is amazing, where did you get it? Today they went above and beyond! I ordered a cake requesting a late pick up, due to it being transported and served the next day. Our plans changed and we needed to leave the morning of the day before. I messaged them on Facebook and their immediate response was to call when they opened at 8am. The staff could not have been more understanding and helpful. They had the cake ready 2 hours later (7 hours earlier than I originally expected). So grateful and cannot wait to enjoy it! read more

Not what it used to be. Won't go back. Bought a half pound of a special Italian cookie, plus others. they were hard as a rock. Too bad. wasted money. read more

Great cannolis, the lobster tail was delicious, staff very professional , sfigadell was a favorite

Came to get some pastries for my family, they had a great variety and all tasted amazing. Will definitely be back soon! read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

They made my sweet 15 cake come to true! I'm very happy about my cake. The service was amazing , the person who took my order was so patient and nice.The place was clean, it smelt amazing! 11 out of 10! read more

Mario's Bakery - a blue and white dessert table - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Really great corn muffins and danishes, bread tastes good too! Great price on the muffins.

I recently went to Mario's for both my Groom's cake for rehearsal dinner and my wedding cake and OMG both were AMAZING and so much more beautiful than we could have imagined. Not only that, but the cakes were sooooo delicious and tasty. The whole process was great--we went in for a tasting and then picked what flavors we wanted. We had originally went in with a different idea of a wedding cake in mind but the owner, Louie, was superrr helpful and Googled some photos for us on the big screen and helped us pick something out even more beautiful. Definitely go here!!! The cannoli cream and tres leches cakes are our favorites!!! read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Review written by my mother: I can't say enough about how beautiful my cake turned out for my daughters bridal shower. I wanted a naked cake & brought some pictures with me of what I was looking for. Lou helped me and knew exactly what I wanted. He showed me many pictures of what they could do. I ordered a two layer cake with some flowers. The cake was absolutely gorgeous. It was beyond expectation & was equally delicious with amazing chocolate mousse filling. Everyone is still talking about it. Many thanks to Lou and his team for making our day so special. Janice read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

The absolute best!!! Have been getting their cakes for all my friends and families special occasions since I was 20 years old in college. Had them do my 25th birthday cake this year and everyone still talks about how yummy it was. Had a minor issue and Lou handled it incredibly. Just picked up my moms 60th birthday cake and it came out beautifully- I am in awe. Definitely recommend especially their cannoli cake and strawberry shortcake. read more

We was recommended here for our wedding cake. I was a little nervous because of some bad reviews but we were not disappointed at all. The cake was so moist and delicious! Every layer of cake was perfectly balanced. There was no overpowering taste of sugar between the buttercream and fillings. We did a different filling each layer with chocolate and vanilla cake. I would say we got a 4 tiered wedding cake for 100 people and we had plenty of leftovers. I probably should've done 3 tiers. I definitely recommend this bakery. read more

Mario's Bakery - Beautiful cake - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Still getting calls on how delicious my cake was!!! They did such an AMAZING job on my wedding cake (& grooms cake!!) Met w/ Lou over the summer... My wedding was the end of Nov.. it was perfect just like the picture I gave him. Lou even took the ride with the delivery truck to make sure the cake got to the venue ok!! read more

See all

This happened a couple of months ago, but today i had time. This cake was orginally for my boyfriends birthday. I was really excited because he never celebrates his birthday and i wanted to really make it special for him. Upon consultation i left feeling confident that the cake would come out perfect.. as the employees did make recommondations and such which at the moment was appreciated. This cake wasnt cheap.. well over 135 dollars. That pug is made of fondant.. the said yes that it should hold up fine with the buttercream cake. A week later i go and pick it up and i immediately noticed how huge that fondant was and how heavy it looked but.. they were the "professionals" and i left thinking it would be ok. I live 3 minutes from the bakery.. by the time i get to the house the end result is viewed in the pictures below.. i was DEVASTATED. It literally looked like it just fell apart. This was in march too so it was still cold out. I immediately call and express my concern... and whoeverrrr i spoke to on the phone was so rude and inconsiderate. "Well you left so there is nothing we can do" "yea idk what to tell you" "its not our responsibility after u leave with the cake". With such a rude attitude. Consultations before ordering a cake are MEANT to what happened to me wont happen. As professionals they should have known sticking a heavy fondant on a butter cream based cake was NOT going to hold up...how is that not their responsibility? I didnt get offered a reinbursement.. or even a free or discounted cake for my troubles. She said "you can come pick up a cake you have to pay for it" i then asked what time they close and she said "ok we are already closed". USELESS. Absolutely USELESS. I had to end up running to a supermarket and getting a cake there... i felt so bad for my boyfriend.. he always goes out of his way for me and due to the lack of professionalism while making the cake and aftercare of the cake he had to suffer from this. Safe yourself the trouble and dont even bother with this place!!!! read more

See all

I ordered the key lime pie. It has a mucus like consistency. The inside tasted like chemical jello. I could've done It better. And the crust tasted like old freezer burn. read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

I've been going to Mario's for many years and purchased cannolis for Easter. Every single cannoli was empty inside except for the very tips where there was a small dollop of filling! Sooo embarrassing serving those to my guests having them crunching on empty shells! For the price you pay for pastries I was very disappointed! read more

Went in to pick up a Tres Leches cake for my father's birthday. The line moved quickly and the people behind the counter were nice. I didn't preorder because of the size of the cake I wanted was small. The cake was a bit dry, but I was okay with that (the flavors were okay too) . What I wasn't okay with was the penmanship on the cake, it was messy. Granted the store was busy, so I get it... however this doesn't mean rush the writing to the point that it is sloppy. What do you say when people ask you what is written on the cake ?! It's supposed to say happy birthday Dad, which you can make out if you look at it for some time.. 2 stars for ease, taste, and friendliness read more

Mario's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

We live in Florida and were in Oceanside for a small outdoor family wedding. The grooms favorite cake is carrot cake so we ordered that. It was beautifully decorated. The cake itself was moist and delicious. Definitely recommend! read more

Mario's Bakery - Wedding carrot cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

They make sugar-free apple turnovers, which my husband adores, and I'm a fan of the rainbow layer cookies.

My family and I have been ordering cakes from Mario's Bakery for over 10 years. THEY NEVER DISAPPOINT! It is by far my favorite bakery to order from on Long Island, NY. I highly recommend it read more

See all

Stopped by this bakery to pick up a platter for a New Year's Eve party. Complete waste of $50! Worse cookies ever!! Absolutely no flavor. Would have been better off throwing store bought pre-packaged cookies on a platter. read more

The best cake in Mario's of Oceanside is the strawberry shortcake. We checked with the owner and the cake is safe for people with tree nut allergies. They will deliver . read more

Mario's Bakery - Cakes from Mario's Bakery in Oceanside - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Great cakes especially at short notice . I was very impressed. I will continue to purchase cakes and recommend highly !

Ordered a cake for my daughters Bridal Shower from Mario's. Not only was it beautiful and just what we were looking for, this was one of the freshest most delicious cakes I have ever had. If I could give ten stars I would. read more

Mario's Bakery - Mario's bakery- French cream filling with strawberries and butter cream ombre icing with silver pearls. - Bakeries Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

My sister picked up a tiramisu for my bday recently. It was the strangest tiramisu I've ever had. It tasted like maple syrup. It was almost like someone mixed up the espresso extract with maple. It was disappointing as it was my bday and tiramisu is my favorite. Would not recommend. read more

Great selection, great prices and great service. They have a bunch of cakes so you can definitely find one on short notice!