Delicious rainbow and butter cookies, great cakes. Cookies by the pound are my favorite - get a variety!

I've loved the cannolis and rainbow cookies from here since I used to hang out in Elmont 20 years ago and would stop here often. Recently I've gotten back into going here and I'm so glad I did. The staff is always very friendly. It's a small bakery but with a very good selection. I've gotten a few too good to go boxes from here within the last couple of months and they are extremely generous with the portions they give for those boxes. The first time they gave me a large box full of pastries, a box with four large cupcakes and two loaves of semolina. Went again last night and recieved a box with 8 large cannolis and a large apple crumb pie. The parking lot is very small and in front of the store, so if they're busy you may not be able to find a spot as there are definitely less than 10 parking spots. read more

See all

I ordered 1lb of rainbow cookies like I ordered the week before. I received way less cookies so I weighed it. They shorted me a good amount of cookies. When I called they argued with me and the employee told me they dont measure in ounces (although 16 oz is 1lb which I informed her of). The manager of store was very rude and told me to place a new order on Uber Eats and they would give me "free" cookies. They essentially shorted me, offered nothing and argued with me. WEIGH YOUR STUFF FOLKS. They can't don't know math read more

Sapienza Pastry - 13.4 oz for the cookies and box. Not 1lb. - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

This bakery has been around for eons. It is always busy with customers The service is fast and attentive. Great quality baking. Park on the side street, Hempstead turnpike is very busy. read more

My must buy items from this store are rainbow cookies and cannolis. Everything else is pretty solid but if you're going to Sapienza you have to try rainbow cookies. Soft and fresh every time I purchase. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Cannoli, Large Carrot cake cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Complaint is about the service, ordered some cookies and pasties and when paying the total was a lot more than I expected. When I returned home I realized there were a couple of items she doubled, I said one carrot cake but there were two. She put in cookies that I did not ask for and I was very specific like saying the long chocolate coated one with raspberry filling. Instead it was 3 huge tie dye shortbread cookies (that no one wanted or ate). I asked for 2 of a specific cookie and she put in 4. Same with the other cookies, she would put an extra in. I was very clear for each item, 2 of xyz, etc. No wonder why I spent double the amount than I was expecting. Truly disappointed, I feel like I was duped. I really wish I had paid attention to her packing but no way did I think I would have to. read more

Horrible customer service by the girls that works their . I was in their today there was a lady in their before me and no one at the counter to help when one of the girl came and I asked are you going to help us she ignored me when I asked for a manager she said no one is their asked the owners name they wouldn't give it to me . Than 2 other girl came from the back arguing with a customer front of the other customers she asked her name than she said I don't have to give you my name . Very bad experience it will b my last time going there bec of the employees. They should have a manager on duty for these girls to work professionally read more

We came on a whim and we were pleasantly surprised. The employees behind the counter were very nice and greeted us and allowed us time to look around. They made great suggestions and we actually left with more than we had in mind to get. We got some cannolis, turnovers and a cheese danish. The turnovers were huge, flaky and the filling tasted so fresh (not the normal gelatinous glob) I love that the shell of the cannolis continues to be crunchy the day after. Will definitely return for more of their other desserts next! read more

this is a great bakery , with delicious pastries BUT I ordered a football SHAPED cake for a super ball party and I was under the impression after repeating myself , having a clear conversation with the person who took my order and she even agreed and repeated football shaped ... to my surprise I received a rectangular cake with a football drawn on it..... so make sure if you're ordering a cake this doesn't happen to you. read more

Sapienza Pastry - cake - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Got to try a wonderful assortment of baked goods from Sapienza Pastry. Everything in the showcases looked wonderful. The croissants are HUGE, as are the danish. My husband devoured the croissant after making a sandwich on it. I made sure to get a taste. It was soft & flaky. The cannoli...the best I've had yet! The outside shell had a nice fresh crunch to it. Very light. The filling creamy & not too sweet. My family who staked their claim on the danish all loved them. The bakery is on a main road with parking spots on property right in front. There were 2 young ladies working when I picked up my goodies this evening. One immediately came over to assist and was very nice. I will certainly return to try more. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Cannoli, Large, Cannoli minis, variety of danish & a croissant. - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

See all

I stopped by here for the first time today. Cute looking building and the parking lot in front was nice. My son and I were pretty excited to enter the bakery. However unfortunately the customer service was not that great. No greeting or no smiles. One girl who took care of my order had to ask me what I was saying because she had earbuds in her ears. All items I bought tasted great. Really really good. I would give five stars for that but this place needs better customer service. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Apple Strudel on the beautifully decorated cannoli.... - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Unfortunately, I found this wonderful bakery on the way to a funeral in Elmont New York. My friends and I stopped to pick up pastries to bring to the bereaved after funeral. This bakery specializes in custom cakes, biscotti, cookies, cheesecakes and much more. We walked in and admired the display case of pastries: elephant ears, sfingi, tri-colored cookies and other delectables. The server was on the phone placing a phone order, thus our wait time was a few minutes. This is, surprisingly, a Kosher bakery except for the desserts that contain strawberries. Everything looked scrumptious especially the Creme filled cannolis: the Creme looked as if it was just freshly prepared. We also ordered coffees to go. The coffee was delicious and piping hot. They should think about offering specialty coffees like cappuccino. I've reviewed the reviews that were posted on Yelp. Could the service improve.. yes.. there was only one server to assist us. There were 2 customers who entered as we were paying that were placing sizable orders. But, we are still dealing with a pandemic, so I can only imagine it is hard for the owner or any owner to gauge demand and how to hire in these still difficult times. I can only imagine at this location, reassessing, payroll needs. Thus, I would love to give Sapienza a 5 star but the service needs to be relooked at. The 4* are for the quality and delicious pastries. read more

Sapienza Pastry - a business card on a table - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Went in to get chocolate cake and ended up giving me like butter cream cake were the whole cake was just cream no sponge in side for cake texture and charged me $47 for cake that's wasn't even good very disappointing read more

Over the years I've always passed this shop taking the bus in route to my college in Manhattan from home. My aunt always brought classic Italian cookies and their chocolate crème pie over for the holidays. I stopped here the other week with my husband since he was interested seeing the shop in person. It's located on the main road of Hempstead Turnpike which is super busy. There is limited parking in front of the shop, but it is easier to park within the neighborhood on the local roads since it can be difficult to pull out of the lot. The bakery is small, so covid restrictions limit them to having two parties at a time in the bakery. The girls are very helpful and package all the desserts in an efficient manner. I felt sorry for them for some rude customers that were yelling at the girls because they didn't give themselves enough time in case there was a line to wait on. No fault to the employees at all. Shame on those customers for their poor timing. This visit we got a quarter pound of assorted cookies and some small pastries (cream puff, cannolis, st. Joseph's pastry and rainbow cake). Their rainbow cake was light and airy. The st. Joseph's pastry and cannolis were also very good with a pretty decent cannoli creme. The cookies are always an easy go to for a small bite. Although they are not the best Italian bakery I have been to, they are definitely worth checking out. read more

Sapienza Pastry - St. Joseph's Pastry, rainbow cake, cream puff, mini cannolis - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

My cannoli cravings brought me here! Parking is limited and backs up to the busy Hempstead Turnpike. Good thing we went when it wasn't a busy time which allowed us to maneuver the car and avoid the hassle. I enjoyed my cannoli and the cream puffs that I got! It's not the best I've had, but it's high up there in my book because the filling is on point. However, my husband did not feel the same joy with his carrot cake. It was dry. He didn't finish it and threw half of it away. Such a shame, I thought. read more

See all

This was the first time I've had a cake made by your bakery .. Not only was my 50th birthday cake absolutely beautiful, the cannoli cream inside was so delicious. The sponge was so moist and the fondant had a great marshmallow taste!!! thank you so much .. it was AM read more

Sapienza Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Asked for Pignoli cookies and was told they no longer sell them because they're to expensive, I take that to say they can't afford my business anymore, good bye Sapienza read more

My strawberry pineapple birthday cake was delicious Sapienza never disappoints Cakes are always fresh and the staff are friendly My go to spot for fantastic bake goods read more

The biscotti doesn't have a lot of flavor and the primary taste is sugar. The sesame cookies were great. Cannoli's not bad. I came here on a Wednesday and some of the pastries (and the florentine cookies) were stale. Wondering why everyone loves this place -maybe better to go on a weekend with higher turnover?? Disappointing to spend so much money and not be mostly satisfied. read more

This review is for the Hempstead Tpke address. Don't go to Meacham Ave. I Mecham is the bakery that makes only BREAD. This review is for Sapienza Pastry. Apologies Pinoli cookies, canolis, pies, caked, blondies and brownies. You want it, Sapieza's got it! Located in eastern Elmont on Hempstead Tpk, this long time family owned establishment excels in Quality with a capital Q. The kids working there attend to customers with a greeting and a smile. I used to go here so frequently but never really appreciated how delicious everything is here. I bought a lattice apple pie yesterday, and all 15 guests (including those who don't usually like apple) wanted more. Convenient parking right in front, moderately priced, one can't go wrong here. read more

See all

Thank you for a delicious bday cake and home made biscotti ! great service. Excellent suggestions.

I've ordered a few cakes from here and they are always very good. Tasty and beautiful! Pastries usually good , but occasionally I'll get something that tastes a bit stale and not as fresh. Despite that I always come back. Cannolis consistently good Napoleons hit or miss on the freshness scale- but when they are fresh they are VERY good. I'm always sad when I get a stale one lol Tiramisu I would skip- all cream and not enough cookie/coffee layer Lobster tails- my parents favorite! Reasonably priced and staff helpful! read more

Nice bakery. The young ladies who work on Sunday afternoon are very sweet. Prices are pretty good. Chocolate mousse is tasty. Lobster tails could be crispier. They have a good selection of cookies and pastries. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

See all

Cute little spot not too far from my house. It's a bit pricey but everything tastes pretty good. Parking is annoying in the sense that there are only a few spots. They do take cards here which is also a plus. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

I liked a cake that my friend had for her son and that is how I learned about this place. Well, I was so disappointed! I provided the logo and the school logo does not have the color pink. Well, my cake did and the writing on the cake was crooked as well. I called and they asked me to text a picture of the cake as she needed to speak to the owner. When she called me back her response was that the owner said he printed it twice, this was the best he could do and that he would only refund me $15 for the editable image. That response was completely unacceptable. If there was an issue, they should have called me and explain the situation. I also found it very upsetting that the owner knew it was not right and was just going to leave it at that. Very unprofessional. I will add, I did not take the refund. I was told I would have to drive back which I was not going to do and then the girl offered to take my credit card into. That was definitely out of the question. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Dessert - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

At this point I think they've adopted my daughter's. Lol. We used them again for my daughters 3rd bday. That's 2 babyshowers and 1 daughters bday 1 to 3yr old. Always great work and great taste. Never have a custom design they couldn't do. We did a Toy Story themed cake and cup cakes. It was red velvet. Soft and you drool before it hits your mouth. Lol. THE BEST. I've sent numerous friends and family. If you don't use them, you're missing out. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Red velvet toy story. AWESOME - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

I'm a huge fan of older styled bakeries.. Seeing Sapienza for years in my friends former local paper, I made a note of it.. obviously Italian. Have stopped in twice though not nearby and both times very pleased to find some of the traditional Italian bakery items.. St. Joseph, cannoli cake, but what was really appreciated was a Napoleon like pastry with a layer of chocolate cake, and custard and some good cookies/biscuits to go with coffee/ tea. This is a reliable place reminiscent of old fashioned bakeries. I appreciate these small town non chain places... read more

Sapienza Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

My birthday cake was beautiful!!!! & delicious!!!! It was filled with cannoli cream! Yummmmmm is definitely recommend this place to my friends & family. read more

Sapienza Pastry - Cannoli cake - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

Our relationship started with Sapienza 5 yrs ago when they did my wedding cake. I said that I would write a review. I kept putting if off and forgetting. This time I had to make time. Every event from my wedding day until now the top question is " where do you get that cake from"? Every event I find a cake design and I email Andrew the idea and it's even better then what I ask for. Then when we actually take a bite, it's complete heaven. This last cake I was a bit nervous to order because I had to take it on a 2hour drive. Andrew told me to freeze it so I did. When my guest and I took that 1st bit it was by far the best cake I had in my life! They don't know that I'm writing a review but, It was time! Thank you so much Sapienza family and Andrew! You continue to make great looking and tasting cakes which is hard to Do, you remain patience with me and my 100 emails, and the customer service by far is the best me and my family thanks you! read more

See all

mande hacer un pastel Napoleón con fruta fresca no es primera vez que compro aca y usualmente e sorprendido a las personas q lo han probado ayer pase la vergüenza mas grande de mi vida cuando cortamos el pastel no tenia mas q whip cream por dentro como por fuera fruta fueron contados los pedacitos parecía q estaban aprendiendo hacer un pastel lo ordene para 6 personas por lo tanto me vendieron el más pequeño me costó casi $60 lo que pague para pasar una gran vergüenza recomende muchas personas anteriormente pero hoy ni loca les recomendaría Mejoren la calidad de sus productos !!! read more

Nice servers but can't say the napoleons were very good. Not crispy at all, rather soft and the icing on top is way to sweet. Wouldn't bother coming back as there are many more bakeries to try. read more

On a stressful day, there's no dilemma! Haha got my cannoli fix today. Thank you sapienza! You never dissapoint. ;) next time I'll even get a coffee ;) Inquired about some cakes today. The girls behind counter were very patient, pleasant and helpful ;) read more

See all

Recently I ordered $100 worth of cupcakes for my child's birthday through Ubereats and the cupcakes never got delivered. I tried reaching the delivery person right away with no luck so I called the bakery and was provided with 10 out of 10 customer service as Andrew did everything right that cold night to make my child's birthday a special one. I will be ordering all work cakes from this bakery based on this exemplary customer service alone !!!!! read more

Used to be good. Service now is terrible. Placed an order for a cake over a week in advance. Girl half-distracted on the phone. Takes the order. Day of pick up and no cake. "bakers all gone home." Unbelievable. read more

I been a long time customer of Sapienza Pastry. This use to be our go to spot for cakes for every single occasion. A few years or more we stopped going there because the cake started to taste like a literal sponge in texture, they would forget to use fresh strawberries or forget to put them at all as ordered. So we stopped going. Then recently we were desperate for a quick cake and picked one up from this very bakery. It was amazing so we decided for my sons 4th birthday we would give them another shot. When we got there to pick up the preordered cake the younger opened the box and looked at the cake. She said Oooo Noo then without showing us took the cake too the back and brought it back out. The name on the cake and the image were damaged. Her response was that they spelled my sons name with an O instead of an A but it wasn't that they spelled it with an O, they spelled it with a cursive a. She should have shown us the cake before trying to fix it and she didn't fix it she messed it up. The cake was good thank God but the presentation was not what I was expecting for a bakery that has been here for decades read more

See all

Worst cake experience ever.. there is a problem if a bakery opens up at 10am on a weekend and STILL doesn't have your cake or the other 25 cake orders from other customers ready.. line out the door and down the block, missing ones hosted event because there isn't a system in place where they do pickups only. Several Customers running into the store demanding refunds for cakes that aren't ready. Would rather take my chances with a supermarket cake then do this again !! They have lost me as a customer. It could be the best tasting cake but when this happens and you fall the customers and they have huge events you take you business elsewhere . I'm sure this will not be the only negative review. read more

Sapienza Pastry - This cost $175, not cut evenly, lettering off center, ugly flowers. This is a disgrace. No more Sapienza ever again. We were promised more. - Bakeries Near Me - Elmont, New York

I love this place they did my wedding cake when I got married on my last review. This cake was made to perfection. Sapienza cakes are always moist and delicious. I definitely recommend I am going to them to do my son next birthday cake. Roseanne and Andrew always take care of me tell them I sent you. read more

Top 5 bakeries on Long Island? I think so. It's a good thing I don't live closer, because if I did, I'd be half a ton by now. Every time I am in the area I make a trip here, no exceptions. This is a must try place. Everything is made fresh, and tastes great. Also, being open later then most bakeries, I was able to stop in one night and grab over 2lbs of stuff before going to a family event. It was a huge hit, and price wasn't bad either. Can't wait to come back! read more

Never got a bad dessert from here. Quality is super high but can use work on there appearance. The inside looks old and could use a renovation. That's not even why I didn't give it 5 stars. It lost a star due to there parking. The parking lot is super small and super dangerous to get out of. read more

So I ordered a pound of cookies and a cake for my brother. The cookies were absolutely delicious and the cake was great but the lemon filling was not a crowd favorite though some folks did like it. The decoration was also very pretty and exactly what I asked for. My biggest problem was that I had the cake delivered (I scheduled it the day before) and the delivery was a full hour past the delivery time. So just be aware of that. Very nice staff though and I would love to stop in for some cookies again! read more