This place is an absolute must-have in Eagle River! For our family night out we all decided this…read morewas our unanimous option! The Cheese Curds were absolutely fantastic, we killed 3 plates with no issue (there were 9 of us). Most people got the pan fried Walleye, i would say it's a specialty of the restaurant and NOONE WAS DISAPPOINTED!!! Our waitress forgot to bring out our salads but there was so much food no one even cared! Each dish came out perfectly hot and delicious. When you're in the North Woods you absolute have to stop here! They've got a great ambiance and the food was fantastic, stop in and enjoy the best meal you'll have all week!!

This is a perfect little up north spot. The wait for a table was about 30 min. The service was ok-…read morethe waitress seemed to get flustered and confused when we asked for separate checks (but ended up doing it anyway)- she just kept repeating there's an atm. The food was pretty solid. My only complaint/concern was one of my daughter's chicken strips were not cooked- thankfully I was cutting them when I found out. Everything else seemed to be normal be type food.

Love Craftsman American Tavern in Eagle River WI. Today was a flight of beer from Blueberry Train…read moreTribute Brewing in Eagle River, Hughes crawler Stout from Fox River Oshkosh & a Campfire Old Fashioned with Smoked Maple Knob Creek Bourbon with toasted marshmallow and cinnamon. Fish tacos and Mint Smash burger with tots were both excellent as well as our attentive server Susan. Fun & delicious visit

We keep trying .. have been here a half dozen times as we are local. But we are out…read more A few weeks back we entered a bit before 7pm The look on the greeters face was like "oh not more people" .. but there were only 3 active tables with one other finished. Turned out sour lady was also the server. Very unwelcoming The food was so bad I sent it back. The "smothered" pulled pork (the menu's description) had a squirt of sauce and was not hot - not warm even. As my husband was eating I just cancelled. The robotic manager said he wouldn't charge me !! ... seriously I didn't even bite into the sandwich. I joked he could reuse the bun. He offered a dessert. I'm not going to eat a dessert for dinner. I declined. Such a beautiful remodel of an old bar. A shame the food and service just don't hold up.

The restaurant was very busy being Sunday night on the last day of the Cranberry Festival. We sat…read morein the bar for one drink before being seated . The Brandy Alexander was delicious. The waitress was very friendly and prompt . We ordered a combo pizza and it was very good. Lots of toppings and the sausage was especially tasty. We would go again.

Great little north woods bar. We sat at the bar while we waited for our pizzas. The bartenders…read moreare great and even though the place was packed, they were very attentive. Of course, I had a brandy old-fashioned sweet. You have to. We ordered pizza to go. The pizza is great. I've been told they use the recipe from the old Tijan's Twelve Pines, which closed a couple years ago.

Really enjoyed our dinner here. The building, location and ambiance is great. They are located on…read morethe water of the Eagle River chain so the view out of the entire wall of windows is stunning. Decor is undated rustic Northwoods. The light fixture above the bar is stunningly made from a huge tree trunk and has to be seen to be understood but trust me. It is beautiful. The dining room is spacious and welcoming. Our waitress was right on the ball. Arrived to our table promptly, was attentive but gave us space and time to visit and decide. Eventually, she came back with a warning of an upcoming big party so we ordered right away then and our meals came out in perfect timing. The lobster bisque was a very tasty starter for me and was a nice side option for my friend. No chunks of lobster but the seasoning and taste was just right, so no need for salting. I had the Kimchee ribs special. Wow! So tender and juicy. They slid right off the bone, and the wild rice side with avocado was tasty. My daughter had a "spicy" chicken wrap that they happily modified to not be as spicy and she loved it. My friend tried the mushroom Swiss burger that her husband had the previous time and it did not disappoint. My other friend had the brisket sandwich. The meat was tasty but a little dry. Could have used a little more sauce or juice. HOWEVER, he said that the yummy coleslaw on top served as a perfect "moistener". Overall a delicious meal was had by all.

Worst "fish fry" we've had. Looked like bloated fish sticks obviously Sysko or other frozen fare…read morejust fried. Fries were bland. Nothing was hit. Wait staff never checked on us (maybe another cocktail) but busy chatting with a table of friends. Arely ate anything and my husband noted she picked up your plate without comment ! Such a shame the view is the best thing here.

Food real good, had an patty melt that was perfect. Very good service, large parking lot if you…read morehave a trailer. Would go again.

First the food was fantastic . My smoked Ham and cheese sandwich on a pretzel bun was outstanding,…read more wife had these hand sized king prawns in thier beer batter dip.she could not stop talking about them . Service was quick , Wife loved her old fashion and the beers we ice cold.I love the Ambiance of this place was like a cabin in the woods . If your up in Northern Wisconsin around Eagle River you got to check them out.

Everything went well. Lots of fresh vegetables on the pasta, and so delicious…read more There was live music which was a perfect accompaniment to sitting outside on a beautiful night. I will be back.

My wife and I really enjoyed our meal. The food was great, the room is very nice and the service…read morewas excellent. Friendly, professional and efficient. The live entertainment is a perfect addition to the experience. The Northwoods can be challenging restaurant-wise but this place stacks up nicely with any urban spot.

Checked this place out after hearing good things from a few neighbors. Came on a Monday night, but…read moreit was still moderately busy, which we felt was a good sign. Service was friendly and quick. Never waited too long for a drink or for food to come out. All in all, very pleased with the meal. Reuben was one of the best I can recall in recent years. Crispy bread, good corned beef, plenty of sauerkraut and dressing. And I found it interesting they added smoked gouda as well. Overall, excellent, excellent sandwich! One of our party members ordered the broasted chicken, which looked and smelled amazing. She said it was excellent. Great portion size and I may try that next time. Another had the bacon Gouda burger and said it was good but messy. And he wasnt the biggest fan of the garlic bread instead of a bun, but said it was still tasty. Messy, but tasty! Other than that, drinks were not bad and were comparably priced to other places in the area. We had brandy old fashioneds for the most part. Have had better but they were still good enough to have multiple! Soup of the day was beer cheese chicken chowder, which was light and flavorful and surprisingly good (I am not a beer cheese person usually but would have this again if given the chance). Fiesta poppers for the appetizer were quick to come out and a great start before entrees rolled out. No sitting and waiting around at all between courses. Overall, very good experience and we will be coming back again to try more of the menu!

Fun local vibe type bar. We were in town visiting for Christmas. Hungry after a long drive, we…read morewere able to get right in, plenty of seating at 5 but it was filling up fast. I tried the chili, it was good. The bacon ranch chicken was good, great sweet potato fries. My daughter was not a fan of the burger too greasy for her liking and did not like the bun. The service was fast and friendly

Really great food and service at this truly hometown cafe/diner style restaurant!! Absolutely…read morerecommend highly!

This place has some really good food. They have a lunchbox collection with some very eclectic…read more brands and characters adorning the faces of the boxes. Our server was busy and thoughtful. The biscuits and gravy were from scratch and very good. The Eagle River skillet was perfectly prepared. The corned beef hash was made from scratch and very meaty, no extra onions and potatos or skimping on the meat. The pancakes were again from scratch and delicious. I can tell when an owner and chef care about what comes out of their kitchen and this place does.

Aeillo's in Eagle River is a must-visit! The sandwiches were absolutely excellent--fresh,…read moreflavorful, and so tasty. Every bite was packed with quality ingredients, and the portions were generous.

The BEST, let me repeat, the BEST Italian Sandwich I have ever had! The Godfather is its name and…read morebam, I wish I could east this every day! The service was great. They brought food out to us while we sat in the outdoor seating. Gonna try their pizza next time!