Love this bar and I always have such a great time here !! My only complaint was that someone who works there started screaming at me and my family for literally eating grapes underneath the table claiming we were doing drugs.. Throwing the F bomb at us nonstop for our yearly tradition Left immediately after that. Will definitely go again tho ! Just will be avoiding that one guy LOL read more

One of the best burgers ever! Quite small but cozy. Excellent service. Look forward to returning.

My boyfriend says they make the best old fashioned he has had, so we will def be back! We had this maple bourbon glaze on our wings which was interesting, I was expecting more of a kick but it was good none the less. Wings were crispy and cooked to perfection. The burger we had was delicious as well! The beer cheese had so much flavor. It loses a star because we ordered pretzel bites and never received them. Also we ordered a chicken sandwich that was underwhelming. Place is small so be prepared to wait during peak times. read more

Great spot in Peekskill. We had gone to bear mountain for a short hike and we're looking for a nice town to have lunch at. While the town is not that special this place is! It's a very cute spot with great service and amazing drinks and food. We got the wings and the cod fish tacos and both were good. Definitely visit this spot if you are in the area read more

Whiskey River NY - a sign outside of a restaurant - Comfort Food Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Food, service and ambiance is great. Very relaxed atmosphere. Servers know what they are doing and make you feel like family. I love this place. read more

This place has the perfect local vibe. The staff are the best people and the food and drinks are really good!

I came to Whiskey River during the holiday season with my friend who lives in the area and it did not disappoint! We sat at the bar and the bartenders were super friendly and the holiday decor was amazing. We ordered the empanadas of the week, which were buffalo chicken, and the up the river burger, which you MUST order. It was the best burger I ever had - the combination of candied bacon, beer cheese, fried shallots, and siracha aioli was unbelievable - just be sure to have napkins! I need to come back to visit my friend so that I can have this burger again! read more

Whiskey River NY - Comfort Food Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Serious dive bar with smelly ambience! the owner is a horrible person and would rather have non-paying customers in there than paying customers !!! likes to dictate what the customers talk about and tell them they're not allowed to say whatever they want in the bar even when there's no other customers !!! he grabs their drinks out of their hand if he has a different opinion than anything you're speaking of! I have hired an attorney and started a lawsuit against the owner and the bar to get it shut down. I am going to community council meetings and doing whatever I can to get this establishment shut. he's insane and needs to be shut down. read more

One of my favorite places! Great service and atmosphere, and the Cali River Burger (bean patty) is one of the best burgers I've ever had (both meat and meatless!) read more

Went to Whiskey River for a nightcap of some Redbreast 15 year old Irish Whiskey. Only to be stopped at the door and told to turn around and leave because the "bar is too full and the Fire Marshal will have a problem with that". First time I've ever been told that the bar was "too full" and was denied entry. I guess people buying more expense whiskey are not welcome and local hipsters drinking draft beer are. A bad look and definitely not a welcoming experience. Would've loved to try some of the appetizers too but like I said, we never made it past the front door! I guess the Peekskill Fire Marshal sets the occupancy at no more than thirty people in an establishment at any given time or more likely, locals only welcome on a Friday night.... read more

My favorite local bar. Every from is super nice and great customer service. Highy recommend the burgers.

Best vegetarian burger!!!!! The service was great; I'll definitely be back. In love with the buffalo cauliflower read more

Great service! The waiter was very welcoming. A small place but all food was delicious and the atmosphere is casual and fun.

What a great place! Visited with my best friend for my b-day and we had a blast. Tried several whiskeys, recommendation from the bar tender, and they were all great. He was very knowledgeable in the products he offered. Paired the whisky based on our personal preferences. The owners, husband and wife team, visited with us for a few minutes to see how we were enjoying our drinks and food, and to get to know a bit about us. The food was very good too and they frequently offer new items on their menus so you'll always have something new to try. Give them a try! read more

This little gem is one of the best restaurants in Peekskill. What I love the most is their menu changes every two weeks and it gets more and more interesting and delicious. I love their empanadas and I highly recommend them. Give it a try you will be so happy! Awesome staff friendly professional and knowledgeable. read more

Whiskey River NY - The crabrangoon empanadas were delicious! They change the filling weekly. - Comfort Food Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

This is our second visit to WR and it's already become "our bar" as gleeful empty nesters. The bartenders are knowledgeable, service-smart, and truly enjoyable; the food and ambiance is is great, and the Irish accent is legit The Irish whiskey, bourbon, and Scotch selections are high quality and thoughtfully chosen. Highly recommend!! read more

This place was so good! The Up The River burger was one of the best burgers I've ever had. I'm from Maryland and would drive back just to get the burger. read more

The picture I posted of their Up burger doesn't do it justice. This so far it's the runner up for best burger in this area. The place is clean, The service was outstanding, the owners and staff have done a great job. They have a good selection of beer, and I honestly can't wait to go back. read more

Whiskey River NY - The Up burger - Comfort Food Near Me - Peekskill, New York

This was my first time coming here, We were greeted by a gentleman named "Jack". Jack made us feel like family and seated you right away. The drinks came out fast and on point. We ask for his recommendations, since we were never there. He told us the best sellers and we went off of that. We ordered the habanero wings and the empanadas for the appetizers and the Whiskey River burger. The burger was out of this world and probably one of the best burgers in peekskill along side the peekskill public bar and grill. The empanadas are the best in town. Our food came out fast and piping hot. The flavor profile was unique the food was Flavorful, sweet, and spicy making it a mouth-watering experience. I highly recommend this establishment right away, and for a better experience go on a Friday or Saturday night sit outside and enjoy the live music at the sametime!!! read more

Fantastic chicken sandwich. Decent tap list. Staff quick but a bit gruff. They use plastic utensils which is weird and wasteful. But whatever. I'll be back. read more

They come out with a new menu almost every week and every time the have bangers. I come here way more often than I should. Not only is the food really good but the drinks ?! Don't even get me started. All the bartenders are extremely skilled and professional. This is hands down my favorite place in Peekskill. read more

My wife and I ordered from a Whiskey River tonight for the first time and were absolutely BLOWN AWAY! Although the menu is rather limited, they have certainly mastered it. My wife and I ordered the following: 1) Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich 2) Up the River Burger 3) Blueberry BBQ Wings I must say, if you're looking for great pub food, Whiskey River should be number one on your list. Although it tends to be difficult to rate a restaurant on its take out; we did not have that issue here. I'm excited to have Whiskey River in our town and I can't wait to sit at the bar, have a drink and another fantastic meal. More importantly, I can't wait to meet the owners to thank them in person (I didn't pick the food up). Congrats Whiskey River and thank you for providing us with not only a great meal, but a place that will look forward to frequenting weekly. read more

food was soooo delicious. atmosphere was nice. bar tender was also very nice with great service.

The foods always great and the service is fantastic too:):) I always get the same thing to eat. It's always juicy and tastes fresh!!

Great little place with awesome cocktails, burger, chicken sandwiches and pretzel bites. Really good! The bartender was very nice as were the people dining/drinking there. Great experience!! read more

Absolutly fantastic. The food was very good (I had the burger) and the drinks even better. The smoked old fashioned was something I will be going back for again and again. The bartender might have been the nicest person Iv ever met as well. All around great experience! read more

I have been going to Whiskey River weekly for about 3 months now, I have never once been disappointed. It is humbling to see how passionate the owners, chef and staff are about their customers. Their ingredients are fresh, local and always surprising my taste buds with new flavor. My absolute favorite to date was the Banana Pudding & Rhubarb desserts. They have a different menu every week with new and exciting dishes. This week I had the Shishito Peppers after a looooong day at work and they were BOMB. I even ended up bringing them for lunch the next day. Hands down, one of the best restaurants in Peekskill. Even if there is not something on the menu you feel like interests you, I promise, try something and they will change your mind. My absolute favorite restaurant in the 914. read more

See all

I heard this place had a great burger so I had to check it out. It did not disappoint. It was one of those menu items you will remember for a long time. Everything is super fresh and un-bar-like. The beers I tried were all well chosen too. read more

Drinks are great but dont eat here food is overpriced and subpar .I wish yelp would allow a part rating system for bar/ food places. Bar gets 5 and food a 3. read more

Very fun pub for a drink and a bite to eat. Will visit it once again The bartender was very entertaining. read more

Hit and miss. First time we went food was great but it was a slow night months ago in the middle of winter. Went back a week ago and it was a busy Sunday evening. Sat at a street table with our friends which was nice. Food and drinks came within reasonable time for them being short staffed. Hopefully they can find the extra staff they need to work their busy nights. Our wing appetizers had good flavor but skimpy chicken wings (I know this is a National problem). Husband had the up the river burger and loved it. I had the enchiladas and they were ok. Soggy tortillas, dry shredded or "pulled" chicken, bland white rice on the side and the whole thing was covered in in lettuce. read more

Best spot in the greater Peekskill area BY FAR! Bartenders are friendly, so professional and very knowledgeable. Drinks are high quality and creative! Food is the same - must try the black bean burger!! This remains my number one spot to eat and drink. Super clean and safe. read more

Maybe I'm missing something. Craft beer list was B+. Fiddlehead IPA and Sloop Juice Bomb IPA being the only notables. Whiskey selection had nice depth. Had the wings and empanadas and decided not to decided not to expand. Wings were rubbery bathed in garlic parm sauce. No actual garlic or parm anywhere in sight for $14. The 2 empanadas were okay, but at $5 a piece I was underwhelmed. Very much enjoyed hanging out in the closed street though. Beautiful night to do so, and the service was excellent. Didn't love it, but didn't hate it. read more

I'm a vegetarian with celiacs disease, unfortunately I did not look at the menu before going in but Nate was beyond accommodating and friendly! My fiancé snd his family have eaten here many times and love the food! Nate said they change the menus ever 2 weeks and I can't wait to go in and try something that fits my difficult dietary restrictions. Highly reccomend trying this place just based off the customer service, ambiance and reccomendations from so many other people! read more

Taking a trip up to Peekskill for a day trip, my fiancée and I wanted to find a place for lunch, specifically a burger. Looking over the reviews, we decided to take a chance on Whiskey River and we were not disappointed. Considering that we are in a time of mask wearing and social distancing, we considered ourselves very safe to eat here. Everyone was wearing masks and hand sanitizer was plentiful. We ordered Michter's Bourbon (for me), Harvest Collons (for her), the Up the River Burger and the empanadas. Everything was very tasty. We told our server Nate that we were splitting everything and we loved the fact that the Burgers were already cut in half when it came out without even asking. Cutting it ourselves would definitely be problematic. Adding the fact that it had double patty's that were perfectly medium rare combined with candied bacon. All in all it was amazing!!! With that said, we will be back when we are in the area. And we highly recommend you all to come as well if you are thinking about it. read more

I really want to give this place 5 stars because the food is some of the best I've had, but the service is the worst I've had. All credit to the chefs. The location is awesome, but unfortunately it's not enjoyable to eat here because the only server I'd count on would be the younger girl. The drinks are inconsistent and are small for the price. Recommend going here for take-out only! read more

Amazing pierogies, burger, beer and fish tacos were also great. Excellent service - they took our number and texted when the next table was ready so we could walk around while we waited. My husband and I came here after hiking Bear Mountain today. We'll definitely be back! read more

Great outdoor dining setup and love the live music on the weekends. The food was amazing and while I loved my burger, I fell in love with my friend's korean tofu dish. Dish offerings change weekly which is exciting and only makes me wish I lived closer so that I could visit more often! read more

great burger and terrific service. good wine selection and terrific beer and whiskey selection as well. small place but outside seating available when weather is good. I recommend you trying this place read more

The food, the staff, and the atmosphere are all incredible. Definitely my favorite place to drink/eat in Peekskill